Only RM50,000 ‘nominal damages' for hotelier after MBPP wins appeal
PUTRAJAYA : The Court of Appeal has awarded RM50,000 in nominal damages to a hotel operator that succeeded in a lawsuit against a Penang local authority for revoking its temporary permit six months before its expiry in 2016.
A three-member panel chaired by Justice Ruzima Ghazali said the High Court had assessed damages based on a promotional brochure and drew an adverse inference against the Penang City Council (MBPP).
'We also find that the formula used was speculative, and the hotel is only eligible for nominal damages,' Ruzima said in allowing the council's appeal.
The panel substituted the RM865,000 in general and exemplary damages previously awarded by the High Court to Maritime Waterfront Suites Sdn Bhd (MWS) and its owner, Noorzaina Mat Zain, with RM50,000 in nominal damages.
It also set aside the RM100,000 in costs awarded by the High Court and exercised its discretion for both parties to bear their own legal expenses in the appeal.
Four years ago, the Federal Court ruled that MBPP had acted illegally by revoking the temporary permit issued to MWS and its proprietor.
In the judicial review, the bench chaired by Justice Vernon Ong declared the council's decision to revoke the permit as 'illegal, irrational, unreasonable, and disproportionate'.
The apex court then remitted the matter to the High Court to assess the amount of damages and compensation to be paid.
MWS had operated a hotel at Karpal Singh Drive in Jelutong, having obtained a temporary operating permit valid from Nov 1, 2015 to Oct 31, 2016.
The temporary permit was granted under a Penang government moratorium programme for unlicensed hotels aimed at legalising them.
Applicants were required to apply for the relevant approvals from local authorities during this transition period.
Jelutong Development Sdn Bhd, the land and building owner where the hotel was located, applied to MBPP to rezone the building from 'commercial-offices' to 'commercial-hotel' to enable MWS to operate legally.
However, MBPP rejected the rezoning request, and on April 22, 2016, decided to revoke the previously granted permit to MWS.
The hotel operators later sued MBPP, seeking compensation and reinstatement of the permit.
Karin Lim, M Murgan and Clifford Ong represented the council, while Ong Yu Shin and Lim Wooi Ying acted for MWS and Noorzaina.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
7 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Najib gave conflicting answers over source of funds, court told
SRC International is suing Najib Razak and former CEO Nik Faisal Ariff Kamil for wrongfully receiving company property, and dishonestly and wrongfully conspiring to convert company property for their own use. KUALA LUMPUR : A lawyer for SRC International Sdn Bhd told the High Court today that former prime minister Najib Razak gave conflicting answers when confronted about the source of money that entered into his accounts more than 10 years ago. Lead counsel Lim Chee Wee said Najib had, in his testimony under oath, given various versions of the source of funds that entered his accounts when cross-examined. Submitting at the close of the SRC International trial, Lim said Najib had, in an affidavit affirmed in 2015, claimed that a 'personal donation' of US$700 million and another sum of RM42 million originating from SRC International had been channelled into his account by Gandingan Mentari Sdn Bhd and Ihsan Perdana Sdn Bhd without his knowledge. 'He first said the affidavit was 'very badly drafted', and then he said the admission was based on 'allegations at that time'. 'He later said that he was 'misled' and backtracked to say it was the information he received. And another version was that he was misled by media reporting,' Lim said after the defence had closed its case. SRC International is suing Najib and former CEO Nik Faisal Ariff Kamil for wrongfully receiving company property, and dishonestly and wrongfully conspiring to convert company property for their own use. A judgment in default of appearance has been entered against Nik Faisal. The suit originally included former chairman Ismee Ismail, as well as former directors Suboh Yasin, Shahrol Azral Ibrahim Halmi, Azhar Osman Khairuddin and Che Abdullah @ Rashidi Che Omar, as co-defendants. SRC International later dropped the case against them. However, they were added as third parties by Najib. Lim also said Najib never informed his Cabinet about the RM42 million he allegedly received, and that he continued to helm decisions involving SRC International. 'It cannot be said that he was acting in the country's interest, or that his actions can be downplayed to mere recklessness,' he said. The hearing continues before Justice Ahmad Fairuz Zainol Abidin on Tuesday, with Najib's lawyer, Shafee Abdullah, submitting in his defence, followed by lawyers appearing for the various third parties.
Malay Mail
7 hours ago
- Malay Mail
‘Don't be sad', father tells daughter in dream following family's tragic death when Iswara sank into Kedah river
ALOR SETAR, July 7 — 'I dreamt my late father told me not to be sad,' said Putri Qisya Nur Izzat, 12, the eldest child of a family of six who perished after their car plunged into Sungai Korok in Jitra last Saturday. Putri Qisya was the sole survivor of her immediate family, having stayed behind at her grandmother's home in Jerlun, while her parents and younger siblings travelled without her on the day of the incident. Her parents, Muhammad Azim Izat Ishak, 32, and Nurul Hidayah Khadijah Razman Efendi, 31, along with their children, Putra Rayyan Nur Izzat, 9, Hawa Adriana Nur Izzat, 8, Annayla Humaira Nur Izzat, 7, and six-month-old Tuah Haydar, were reported missing after their vehicle veered off the road and into the river. The bodies were recovered today, bringing a tragic end to the search. Speaking at the Forensic Department of Sultanah Bahiyah Hospital here, Putri Qisya said the family had planned to visit an aunt in Taman Seri Aman, Jitra, as part of a regular weekend routine. However, she chose not to join them this time. 'At first, I wanted to go, but at the last minute, I felt tired and decided not to. One of my siblings even tried to persuade me, but I still said no,' she said, holding back tears. Upon learning that her family had gone missing, she joined others in searching the area along the river, but her efforts ended in heartbreak. Grief overwhelms family and friends at the site of the incident in Sungai Korok, near Jitra. — Bernama pic Describing a dream she had early this morning, Putri Qisya said her father appeared to her wearing the same jersey he had worn the day he left. 'I was lying on his lap. He told me not to be sad because he couldn't take care of me anymore. My mother and siblings were also there in the dream,' she said. 'At around 8 am, I woke up suddenly and went to the front of the house. My grandmother and aunt tried to comfort me, saying they would look after me and that I wouldn't be alone.' She also recalled a moment earlier this year when her youngest sibling, Jebat Haydar, died in February. 'Back then, my mother told me not to be sad because it was only my baby brother who had left, not her. She even said, 'If we are meant to go, we'll all go together so that we won't trouble anyone',' said Putri Qisya. — Bernama
Malay Mail
8 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Ringgit drops to 4.23 against US dollar as Trump's tariff remarks stir market anxiety
KUALA LUMPUR, July 7 — The ringgit closed weaker against the US dollar on Monday but traded better against major currencies, as traders and investors are observing the United States (US) tariff situation, an analyst said. At 6pm, the local note depreciated to 4.2310/2400 against the greenback from last Friday's close of 4.2180/2260. Bank Muamalat Malaysia Bhd chief economist Dr Mohd Afzanizam Abdul Rashid stated that the latest remark by US President Donald Trump on an additional 10 per cent tariff for countries aligning themselves with Brics has taken centre stage. On Sunday, US President Donald Trump was reported saying that any country aligning with Brics' 'anti-American policies' will face an additional 10 per cent tariff. 'This goes to show that the tariff fear seems to make a comeback as the 90-day pause period is coming to an end this week. 'The US Dollar Index (DXY) gained 0.03 per cent to 97.208 points (at time of writing). It seems to be risk-off mode at the moment,' Mohd Afzanizam told Bernama. At the close, the ringgit traded higher against a basket of major currencies. It rose against the euro to 4.9647/9752 from 4.9675/9770 on Friday, appreciated against the Japanese yen to 2.9091/9155 from 2.9225/9282, and slightly advanced versus the British pound to 5.7563/7685 from 5.7601/7710 previously. The local note traded mostly higher against its Asean counterparts. It improved vis-à-vis the Singapore dollar to 3.3096/3172 from 3.3114/3182 Friday, and marginally higher against the Philippine peso to 7.46/7.48 from 7.47/7.49 previously. However, it strengthened against the Thai baht to 12.9837/13.0173 from 13.0302/0609, and was flat against the Indonesian rupiah to 260.5/261.2 from 260.6/261.2 on Friday. — Bernama
