Palestinian grandmother detained after Australia cancels visa on security grounds
Maha Almassri was taken into custody in the early hours of Thursday following a pre-dawn raid by a contingent of nearly 15 Border Force officers at her son's home in Punchbowl in the southwest of the city.
She was held at the Bankstown police station and then transferred to the Villawood Immigration Detention Centre.
According to documents seen by The Guardian and SBS News, Ms Almassri's visa was 'personally' cancelled by the assistant minister for citizenship and multicultural affairs Julian Hill following an assessment by the Security Intelligence Organisation that deemed her to be 'directly or indirectly a risk to security'.
The decision stated the elderly woman failed Australia 's 'character test' and her removal was 'in the national interest' under the Migration Act.
Ms Almassri arrived in Australia on a tourist visa in February 2024, having escaped the Israeli assault on Gaza through the Rafah border crossing.
She was living with her son in Sydney and had applied for a protection visa. While her application was being processed, she had reportedly been granted a bridging visa.
Her relatives insisted Ms Almassri posed no threat, citing her poor health, trauma, and the fact she had undergone security checks by both Israeli and Australian authorities before being granted a visa.
'She's an old lady, what can she do?' her cousin Mohammed Almassri told The Guardian, adding that there was ' no country, no house, nothing' for her to go back to in Gaza.
She was left terrified during the raid and was unable to speak through tears when he contacted her at Villawood later in the day, Mr Almassri said.
'She was sleeping when the raid happened. She couldn't walk, she was so scared.'
Mr Almassri's brother told SBS News the family initially feared that Israeli soldiers had landed at their door. 'They just came like a bunch of police officers and some federal police, and they terrorised everyone inside the house,' Soliman Almassri said in a video message.
He described the experience as 'traumatic' and claimed that they had been provided no clear explanation for her detention.
The Department of Home Affairs declined to comment on individual cases, citing privacy. However, a spokesperson told The Guardian it would 'continue to act decisively to protect the community from the risk of harm posed by individuals', including 'visa cancellation or refusal where appropriate'.
The minister for home affairs also declined to comment directly. 'Any information in the public domain is being supplied by the individual and isn't necessarily consistent with the information supplied by our intelligence and security agencies,' Tony Burke was quoted as saying by SBS News.
'Our security checks never stop and this cancellation is proof the system is working.'
The Refugee Advice and Casework Service, representing Ms Almassri, said that it had 'nothing to comment on at this time'.
Human rights lawyer Alison Battisson criticised the Australian government's handling of the situation, pointing to a lack of transparency and the practice of early-morning raids.
'It's a Palestinian grandma. I would be very interested to understand the decisionmaking process behind it,' she told The Guardian.
She also questioned how authorities expected to remove someone to Gaza, given the ongoing humanitarian catastrophe. 'Individuals can only be detained if there are reasonable prospects of their removal in the foreseeable future,' she said.
Ms Almassri's isn't an isolated case. In November 2024, Australian officials confirmed that a Palestinian person's visa had been cancelled onshore on character grounds.
Amnesty International previously accused Australia of rejecting over 7,000 Palestinian visa applications since Israel started bombarding Gaza in October 2023.
A protest led by Ms Almassri's family was held outside Mr Burke's office on Thursday, with signs reading 'Bloody Burke' and calls for her immediate release.
'She's traumatised, she's sick and this is the treatment she gets from the Australian government,' said Soliman Almassri. 'We demand that she be released tonight.'
Ms Almassri's family said she had more than 100 relatives living across Australia. They traced their origin to a town near present-day Tel Aviv, from which they were displaced during the 1948 Nakba, the mass expulsion of more than 750,000 Palestinians following the establishment of the state of Israel.
Her family also reported another relative's visa had been cancelled last week, although this could not be independently verified.
The timing of Ms Almassri's detention coincides with the Australian government's release of a new report on combating antisemitism, which includes stricter screening of visa applicants for antisemitic views.
While there is no suggestion Ms Almassri holds such views, her supporters fear the increasingly hostile climate towards Palestinians may be influencing immigration decisions.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
29 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Christian patriarchs in rare visit to Gaza after deadly Israeli strike on church
Top church leaders have visited Gaza a day after its only Catholic church was struck by an Israeli shell. The attack killed three people and wounded 10, including a priest who had developed a close friendship with the late Pope Francis. Advertisement The strike drew condemnation from the Pope and US President Donald Trump, and prompted a statement of regret from Israel, which said it was a mistake. Since ending a ceasefire in March, Israel has regularly launched far deadlier strikes across Gaza against what it says are Hamas militants, frequently killing women and children. Strikes killed 18 people overnight, health officials said on Friday. Benjamin Netanyahu released a statement saying Israel 'deeply regrets that a stray ammunition hit Gaza's Holy Family Church' (Manuel Balce Ceneta/AP) Pope Leo meanwhile renewed his call for negotiations to bring an end to the 21-month war in a phone call on Friday with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, the Vatican said. The religious delegation to Gaza included two patriarchs from Jerusalem — Latin Patriarch Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa and Greek Orthodox Patriarch Theophilos III. The rare visit aimed to express the 'shared pastoral solicitude of the churches of the Holy Land', a statement said. Advertisement Israel has heavily restricted access to Gaza since the start of the war, though church leaders have entered on previous occasions, usually to mark major holidays. They visited the Holy Family Catholic Church, whose compound was damaged in the shelling. They were also organising convoys carrying hundreds of tons of food, medical supplies and other equipment to the territory — which experts say has been pushed to the brink of famine by Israel's war and military offensive — and the evacuation of those wounded in the church strike. In his call with Mr Netanyahu, Pope Leo 'expressed again his concern over the dramatic humanitarian situation for the population in Gaza, with children, the elderly and the sick paying the most heartbreaking price', the Vatican said in a statement. An Israeli official confirmed that Mr Netanyahu had placed the call and said that the Vatican's account was accurate. Advertisement Pope Leo expressed his concern over 'the dramatic humanitarian situation' (AP) In an earlier statement, the Pope had 'repeated his intentions to do everything possible to stop the useless slaughter of innocent people', and condemned 'the unjustifiable attack' on the church. The Vatican said the Pope had also received an update on the condition of Rev Gabriel Romanelli, the resident priest at the church, who was lightly wounded. The priest had regularly spoken by phone with Pope Francis, who died in April, telling the pontiff about the struggles faced by civilians in Gaza. Mr Netanyahu released a statement on Thursday saying Israel 'deeply regrets that a stray ammunition hit Gaza's Holy Family Church'. The Israeli military said it was still investigating. Israel has repeatedly struck schools, shelters, hospitals and other civilian buildings, accusing Hamas militants of sheltering inside and blaming them for civilian deaths. Palestinians say nowhere has felt safe since Israel launched its offensive in response to Hamas's attack on October 7 2023. Advertisement Israeli strikes killed at least 18 Palestinians overnight and into Friday, including a strike on a home in the southern city of Khan Younis that killed four members of the same family, according to morgue records at Nasser Hospital, which received the bodies. Associated Press footage of the aftermath of the strike showed people digging through the rubble in search of remains. Palestinians say nowhere has felt safe since Israel launched its offensive in response to Hamas's attack in 2023 (Ohad Zwigenberg/AP) Israel's military said it was 'operating to dismantle Hamas military capabilities' and that it takes 'feasible precautions to mitigate civilian harm'. Nasser Hospital said another three people were killed while heading towards an aid site run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), an Israeli-backed American contractor. A spokesperson for the foundation said there was no violence at its sites overnight and that crowds were 'docile'. Advertisement Since the group's operations began in late May, hundreds of Palestinians have been killed in shootings by Israeli soldiers while on roads heading to the sites, according to witnesses and health officials. GHF's four sites are all in military-controlled zones, and the Israeli military has said its troops have only fired warning shots to control crowds. There was no comment from the military on the latest deaths. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in the October 7 attack and abducted 251 people, most of whom have since been released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Fifty hostages are still being held, less than half of them believed to be alive. Israel's retaliatory offensive has killed more than 58,600 Palestinians, according to Gaza's Health Ministry, which has said women and children make up more than half of the dead. It does not distinguish between civilians and militants in its tally. The ministry is part of the Hamas-run government but is led by medical professionals. The United Nations and other international organisations consider its figures to be the most reliable count of war casualties.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Ken Henry is right to be a bit worked up – he has a solid reform plan ready to go for an emboldened Labor
Ken Henry, the former Treasury boss, slipped up during his address to the National Press Club this week. Speaking in his capacity as chair of the Australian Climate and Biodiversity Foundation, Henry was asked about his landmark review of the nation's tax system, handed to the Rudd government back in 2010. Its official title was Australia's Future Tax System Review. Famously, Labor sat on the report and most of its 140 recommendations for bringing the taxation system into the 21st century, with a 40% mining super profits tax the only major element taken up by the government. It sparked a huge lobbying backlash and was quickly consumed by Labor's bitter civil war. But, with tax reform back on the agenda ahead of next month's productivity roundtable, the more than 1,070-page report has returned to the headlines. 'Every recommendation of the Henry review remains valid,' the reform campaigner said, giving a thumbs up to the crowded club, before catching himself. 'Actually, that's the first time I've ever called it the Henry review. You must have got me excited.' Henry clarified some of the ideas could benefit from 'sharpening up' but said the suite of measures he recommended then was broadly ready to go for any government prepared to match his excitement for making the system better. Henry was right to be a bit worked up. He has a lot of the answers to the biggest challenges facing the emboldened Labor government this term. Since he handed his tax report to then treasurer, Wayne Swan, Henry faced criticism in the banking royal commission. He was forced to quit as chairman of National Australia Bank after the commission's report said he and the then chief executive had not learned the lessons from past failures at the bank, including $100m in fees charged to customers without any service being provided. Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email Years later, Henry is fed up with the delay on overhauling Australia's broken environmental laws. Known for his advocacy for threatened species – especially the northern hairy-nosed wombat – he used his speech to endorse Graeme Samuel's review of the Environment Protection and Biodiversity Conservation (EPBC) Act. At stake is the foundation of all life on earth, Henry warned, pointing to threats to food systems, clean air and water, and vulnerable animal and plant species. 'We have turned nature against us,' Henry said. 'Our destruction of the natural environment now poses an existential threat to everything we value.' He said Labor should consider the inclusion of a climate trigger in its looming redesign of the nature positive package, requiring approvals for major projects to at least consider any effect on global warming. He suggested Labor should make the case for a new carbon tax, exasperated that the policy had ever been ditched by Tony Abbott's Coalition and describing it as 'the world's best carbon policy'. Less helpful to the government was Henry's blunt words about the toxic algal bloom now wreaking havoc with the waters off South Australia, an ecological disaster being fuelled by ocean warming. For Henry, the massive destruction of marine life washing up on Adelaide's beaches does not represent an early signal of things to come. He said it was a 'late warning' on the threat to oceans from the actions of humans on land. Federal Labor is under increasing pressure to act, amid concerns beaches will have to be closed over summer and permanent damage wrought to sea life. Some kind of federal intervention is looking likely in the next few days, potentially from the top levels of the government. Henry cast changes to the EPBC Act as critical to boosting productivity. The creation of a federal environmental protection agency was delayed before the election over fears of a backlash in resource-rich Western Australia, with Albanese moving to scuttle a deal with the Greens and push the issue into the new term. Sign up to Breaking News Australia Get the most important news as it breaks after newsletter promotion The calibre of the audience for the speech was a strong indication of how important the reforms will be. Among those served Lancashire hotpot was the former Reserve Bank deputy governor, Guy Debelle, now a board member of the Clean Energy Finance Corporation. A few seats away was David Parker, the chair of the Clean Energy Regulator, and a senior member of environment minister Murray Watt's staff. A table of parliamentarians nearby included the independent David Pocock, the Greens' Sarah Hanson-Young, and Labor MPs Alicia Payne and Karen Grogan, the chair of the Senate environment committee. Henry will have a seat at the table at Jim Chalmers' cabinet room summit in August, as well as at an unofficial preview to the talks set to be hosted by the Wentworth MP, Allegra Spender, next week. That meeting follows the independent's work on tax reform in the last parliament. Henry noted Australian workers have forfeited as much as $500,000 in lost earnings in the past quarter of a century because of policy paralysis and shoddy productivity. He put road user levies on electric vehicles and moves to scale back the cost of franking credits to shareholders as ideas to help fund a cut to the corporate tax rate. It's not yet clear just how far Labor is prepared to go on fixing the outdated environmental laws or changing the tax system. The answer could lie somewhere between the politically cautious Albanese and the more ambitious Chalmers. Treasurers and prime ministers can have different objectives, but an effective pairing is a prerequisite for lasting change. Albanese and Watt look eager to involve business in the redesign of the environmental plan, making sure to have broad buy-in for the changes and force the opposition to the fringes. That approach could guide future work as Albanese seeks to marginalise Sussan Ley and the Coalition to deliver at last the Labor government he has spent decades imagining. On Friday, speaking from the G20 finance ministers meeting in South Africa, Chalmers endorsed Henry's message and said he viewed proper environmental law reform as part of the solution to Australia's productivity challenge. It is good the government, MPs across the parliament, the bureaucracy and decision-makers in the community are prepared to listen to informed voices like Henry. Even if he is is reluctant to use his own name in the branding, he has a solid reform plan ready to go for Albanese, just in the period where his legacy will made or broken. Tom McIlroy is Guardian Australia's chief political correspondent
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Liberal party hardliners are on the back foot – but while Tony Abbott is around, the right will fight
Four days on from the Liberal party's worst federal election defeat in its 80-year history, Tony Abbott sought to explain the wreckage. Peter Dutton, Abbott argued, put the Coalition in the 'box seat' to beat Labor with his opposition to the Indigenous voice to parliament, nuclear power ambitions, refusal to stand in front of the Aboriginal flag and warnings about 'indoctrination' in schools. That was at the end of 2024. Then something changed. 'This year, really from January on, we failed to pick fights,' the former Liberal prime minister told a podcast by the Institute of Public Affairs (IPA), the rightwing thinktank of which he is a distinguished fellow. 'And when we did pick fights on, for argument's sake, trying to get public servants back into the office, as soon as we came under a bit of pressure, we pulled back. We kind of lost our mojo a bit; we lost direction a bit.' The explanation from Abbott – who was close to Dutton – reflected a popular counter-narrative pushed by hardline conservatives in the election postmortem. The Coalition didn't lose, and lose badly, because Dutton had dragged it too far to the right, as most commentators concluded. It lost, Abbott was suggesting, because Dutton pulled back. As Sussan Ley tries to reposition the Liberals to the political centre in response to Dutton's catastrophic defeat, the new leader will face resistance from conservatives, inside and outside the party, who are adamant it must remain on the right. This latest chapter in the party's enduring internal conflict is expected to flare during debates over whether to dump the target of net zero emissions by 2050, adopt gender quotas and embrace or shun culture wars. Sign up for a weekly email featuring our best reads Conversations with Liberal MPs and insiders suggest that more than six years after losing his seat in federal parliament, Abbott remains arguably the most powerful conservative in Australian politics. One senior Liberal source said Abbott was as influential as he has been since he was dumped as prime minister in 2015. The 67-year-old is entrenched in the ecosystem of rightwing media, thinktanks and lobby groups that shape conservative thinking. He sits on the board in charge of Fox News (Donald Trump's favoured cable news channel), appears regularly on Sky News, often with his former chief-of-staff Peta Credlin, and has ties to the IPA and the rightwing campaign group Advance. Overseas, Abbott advises the rightwing political forum Alliance for Responsible Citizenship and is a senior visiting fellow at the Danube Institute, a Hungary-based thinktank supportive of the country's far-right prime minister, Viktor Orbán. In a revealing insight into his worldview, Abbott used a recent speech to the Hungarian Conservative Political Action Conference to urge western countries to have the 'cultural self-confidence' to resist the 'the politics of climate and identity' and the 'false doctrine of multiculturalism'. One Liberal source suggested Abbott's endgame was to transform the Liberals – the supposed 'broad church' accomodating moderates and conservatives – into a rightwing party. 'He [Abbott] wants to be the major power behind the throne. He's not driven by money; he's driven by power,' a Liberal source said. Abbott helped orchestrate Jacinta Nampijinpa Price's post-election defection from the Nationals to the Liberals to run as Angus Taylor's deputy, two sources familiar with the covert plot confirmed. He actively campaigned for fellow anti-voice campaigner Warren Mundine in his preselection tilt for Bradfield. He publicly put pressure on Ley to extend the Dutton-backed intervention into the troubled NSW Liberal division. The three cases are evidence of Abbott as an active player internally. But they are instructive for another reason: in each, he failed to achieve his ultimate outcome. The Taylor-Price leadership team never materialised while Mundine lost preselection in Bradfield to Gisele Kapterian. The NSW intervention was ultimately extended but in a vastly different form after Ley secured support for an all-NSW administrative committee to run the branch, effectively sacking the two controversial Victorian figures installed under Dutton with Abbott's support. An 11th-hour push from right faction powerbrokers to secure Abbott a seat on the new committee failed. Some Liberals view the sequence of setbacks, each at the hands of Ley and her allies, as signs of the waning influence of Abbott and the conservatives over the party. Others aren't so sure. Under Dutton, the conservatives ruled the Liberal party in Canberra. After the teal independents all but wiped out the Liberal moderates in 2022 and Scott Morrison's exit diminished the centre-right group that had expanded around him, Dutton and the right faction assumed both numerical and ideological control of the federal party. Dutton's dramatic downfall at the 3 May federal election set in train a realignment of the internal power dynamics. With more than 20 members, the right is still clearly the largest faction in the 52-member federal Liberal party room. Yet it was unable to install Taylor as Dutton's successor after surviving moderates, centre-right and unaligned MPs combined to make Ley the federal party's first female leader. Taylor and senior rightwingers Michaelia Cash, James Paterson and Andrew Hastie have retained senior roles, but other conservatives were dumped or demoted, including Sarah Henderson, Claire Chandler, Tony Pasin and Price, who abandoned plans to run for deputy leader after Taylor lost the ballot. The right was surprised and concerned at how far Ley went in rewarding backers and punishing internal rivals in her shadow ministry, particularly given she won the leadership by just 29 votes to 25. 'She overextended in the reshuffle and that could come back to haunt her,' one Liberal insider says. For now, senior conservatives are supporting Ley after a tumultuous first two months in the role, which included navigating the brief split with the Nationals while grieving over her mother's death. Taylor, now the shadow defence minister, has not been agitating behind the scenes and has been dissuading others from doing so, sources say. The open hostilities in the run-up to the leadership vote, which included the distribution of a scorecard mocking Ley's closeness to centre-right numbers man Alex Hawke, her past support for Palestine and her alleged faith in 'numerology', have stopped. There is a widely held view among Liberal MPs that Ley's fledging leadership is not under threat and undermining her serves no one's interest. Sign up to Five Great Reads Each week our editors select five of the most interesting, entertaining and thoughtful reads published by Guardian Australia and our international colleagues. Sign up to receive it in your inbox every Saturday morning after newsletter promotion Conservatives are wary, though, of the new leader's early, deliberate steps to distance herself from Dutton, such as opening her speech to the National Press Club with an acknowledgment of country to traditional owners. '[Sussan] is a completely different leader to Dutton and that is a good thing,' a senior Liberal source says. 'She does need to be careful in navigating her way. Her acknowledgment to country at the Press Club and standing in front of three flags during her press conference did not go down well with the base. 'The Liberal party is the main centre-right party in Australia and we cannot forget that. If we do, we will lose our base.' The right secured a small win ahead of parliament's return, with the faction's pick, Slade Brockman, defeating the Ley-backed candidate, Andrew McLachlan, in an internal ballot for the role of deputy Senate president. Liberal MPs acknowledge conflict is inevitable and even necessary after internal contest was sacrificed for discipline under Dutton, a trade-off many MPs blame for the threadbare agenda it offered on 3 May. But some fights are expected to extend well beyond the bounds of robust debate, descending instead into open political warfare. 'Everyone will behave themselves in the short term, but whenever something comes up, people will seek to use that to litigate their personal grievances,' one MP said. 'Things like net zero, for example, will really ramp up.' Climate change is ground zero for the Liberal party's internecine conflicts. The latest battle – whether to abandon a commitment to net zero emissions by 2050 – shapes as a defining contest for Ley's leadership and the future of the Liberal-National Coalition. The hard-won but fragile consensus that allowed Morrison to sign up the Coalition to the emissions target in 2021 has fractured, exposing deep divisions over what has become a totemic issue for the political right. Ley immediately put net zero up for debate after agreeing to review the opposition's entire policy agenda. The shadow energy minister, Dan Tehan, is leading an internal policy working group that will report to Ley and the Nationals leader, David Littleproud. The Nationals will conduct a separate review, to be jointly led by parliament's loudest net zero critic, Matt Canavan. Liberal MPs are not optimistic a consensus position can be achieved as they brace for a divisive and damaging brawl. 'I'm a bit worried about it,' one says. 'The issue was settled at enormous cost [under Morrison]. No person in their right mind should open it up again.' One option discussed among some Liberal MPs would involve abandoning 2030 and 2035 targets – a position that would be incompatible with the Paris agreement – but retaining the 2050 ambition. Even that compromise would struggle to placate a growing number of sceptical colleagues, who believe net zero proponents have failed to explain the case for climate targets to rightwing voters. 'The mods say we need net zero to win,' one such MP says. 'That is the most facile, self-serving reason – it's exactly why people hate politicians.' Pressure to dump net zero is also coming from the party's state branches and grassroots members. Alex Antic's SA Liberal division, Price's NT Country Liberal party and the NSW Nationals division have all passed motions since the federal election rejecting net zero. The branch members, who are responsible for selecting election candidates, tend to skew older and more conservative than the average Liberal supporter. They tend to get their news and opinions from Sky News, Liberals say, making the conservative figures who appear on the channel's evening programs hugely influential over the 'base'. Figures such as Tony Abbott.
