Salesman 'deceived by false promises' over unpaid wages wins €27,000 at WRC
A tech firm has been ordered to pay over €27,000 in wages illegally withheld from a salesman who told a tribunal he was 'consistently deceived by false promises' to pay him.
In a decision published on Monday the
Workplace Relations Commission
(WRC) decided to redact the identity of the video company to 'encourage' it to 'bring the matter to a close without adverse publicity'.
It follows a statutory complaint under the Payment of Wages Act 1991 by the salesman, who resigned last year with the company owing him some five months' salary and commission.
The salesman joined the company in April 2023 on a contract which paid a base salary of €75,000 and commission of up to €55,000 annually.
READ MORE
The tribunal heard difficulties first arose when his wages were not paid in November 2023, but that this was rectified the following month.
There was further non-payment in January and February 2024, the salesman told a hearing earlier this month, and in March, that he had 'less than half' his normal salary payment. His salary did come in April that year, but went unpaid in May and June 2024, he told the WRC.
Bobby Healy on why Manna drone delivery could be the 'biggest technology company in the world for its space'
Listen |
67:08
In July 2024, the salesman handed in notice of resignation effective 30 August, 2024. When he left on that date, he was owed €19,450 in salary and €7,979 in commission, net of tax and statutory deductions, the tribunal heard.
The salesman presented the WRC with emails and WhatsApp messages he exchanged with senior executives in the company, all of whom had confirmed to him that he was owed the money, he said.
The company had been able to pay him two months' wages prior to his resignation after applying for a loan in August 2024, the tribunal noted.
Around 10 weeks after the claimant left, he had an email from the CEO confirming that half of the outstanding sum would be 'available by the end of the week' and that the rest would be 'available in December [2024]'.
WRC adjudicator Catherine Byrne noted that when the case was first called on in April 2025, the salesman 'agreed to an adjournment when his former employer indicated that they would shortly be in funds'.
When the salesman's case was heard earlier this month, he showed Ms Byrne correspondence from May 2025 in which an executive at the firm stated that the company was about to draw down funds which would allow it to pay him.
'However, no money was transferred to the complainant,' she said.
The salesman told the WRC in a submission that he had suffered 'stress and inconvenience' because of the failure to pay the wages he was owed. He had spent an 'inordinate amount of time writing to various managers' and had been 'consistently deceived by false promises', he added.
Adjudication officer Catherine Byrne decided to anonymise her decision on the case 'to encourage the [company] to bring the matter to a close without adverse publicity'.
Ms Byrne wrote in her decision: 'It is extremely regrettable that the complainant had to spend so much time and energy trying to exert his basic entitlement to be paid his wages, an issue about which there is no dispute.'
The company had made an 'illegal deduction' from the claimant's wages by failing to pay him the €27,429 owed to him when he resigned on 30 August last year, she found.
Upholding the complaint, Ms Byrne directed the company to pay the salesman the sum as compensation under the Payment of Wages Act 1991.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Mother who convinced man to pretend he fathered child gets three-year suspended sentence
A woman who manipulated a vulnerable man into pretending he was the father of her fourth child and attaining rights of citizenship for her family arising out of the deception has received a three-year suspended sentence. Cork Circuit Criminal Court heard the 45-year-old obtained citizenship for herself, her husband and her children after she provided false information to the State. Det Sgt Keith Cleary, of the Garda National Immigration Bureau , previously told the court that the woman moved to Ireland in March 2008 on a student visa. Her husband arrived at the same time. He was also studying in Ireland. Dt Sgt Cleary said the woman gave birth to a child later that year and put pressure on an Irish man 'with certain vulnerabilities' to put his name down on the birth certificate as the father of the child. READ MORE No name was recorded for the father when the child was born in hospital. However, on July 29th, 2009, the accused presented at the civil registration office in Cork to register the birth. An Irish birth certificate was obtained for the child after the woman persuaded the man to attend at his local Garda station to make a false passport application for the boy. Det Sgt Cleary said the man was 'out of his depth' and 'felt obliged' to help her. For his role in the offence, the 64-year-old received an eight-month suspended sentence last year and a €500 fine. . At the sentencing hearing defence barrister William Bulman told the court his client was a 'vulnerable' man who had acted out of a misplaced sense of kindness. The court heard there was no suggestion of the man being in receipt of money or sexual promises arising out of his actions. The woman, who cannot be named as it would identify her child, pleaded guilty to falsely claiming that the Irish man was the father of her child and to three counts of providing false information in passport applications in 2009, 2012 and 2017. Dt Sgt Cleary said obtaining the false Irish passport for the child gave the woman an immigration advantage. She was subsequently able to apply for an Irish passport for herself and her other children. The woman obtained Irish citizenship 10 years ago while her husband was 'last across the line' in the family being naturalised in 2017. Dt Sgt Cleary said when the woman was arrested in 2023 she claimed it was all 'a big mistake' and that she simply had 'wanted to name him [the Irish man] as a guardian.' He said the actions of the woman had called into question the integrity of both the Irish birth certificate registration system and the Irish passport system. The court heard that the real father of the child had applied for a change of name on the birth certificate. A DNA test was submitted to prove he was the biological father. Defence barrister Jane Hyland, SC, appealed for leniency in the case as her client is the main carer of her children. One of her children has additional needs and requires extra support. Ms Hyland spoke of the history of mental health difficulties experienced by her client. The difficulties cited including suicidal ideation and deliberate self harm. She said the woman had suffered a difficult childhood and had undergone gender discrimination and bullying in her home country. Ms Hyland stressed that the woman had engaged with the community in Ireland and was known for reaching out to assist others in difficult situations. References were handed in to the court which spoke of her 'kindness' in helping others. Ms Hyland said the guilty plea had saved the State the time and expense of a trial. She added that her client had been deemed as being of 'low risk of reoffending.' Judge Dermot Sheehan said the woman was in her 20s and an 'adult' when she carried out the offence. He stated that the accused had 'manipulated' a man into pretending he was the biological father of her children having met him when she 'befriended' a group of people. The judge said the woman had given the man the impression that she was 'in fear' of having to return to her home country and he felt 'pressure' to fill in documentation. He noted the engagement of the woman in Irish life and described her as a 'very productive member' of the community. He also factored in her care of her children, her guilty plea and her poor mental health into his decision-making when sentencing. The judge said it was a 'very serious offence' and the woman had 'time to consider what she was doing but didn't turn back'. He imposed a three-year prison sentence and suspended it in its entirety.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Gang-related intimidation and exploitation of children are key Irish policing challenges
The Garda has fallen short on many of its policing performance goals with 'only four of 18 targets fully achieved', according to a report from a new independent oversight body. The Policing and Community Safety Authority (PCSA) found nine of the 18 targets for the force were 'partially met and five were not achieved'. While efforts were being made to address the Garda's recruitment and retention challenges, the report says the issue is not likely to be resolved in the short term and there will be a dependency on overtime spending 'to ensure enough gardaí and garda staff are available for work'. The report says the Garda made progress in tackling organised crime, but drug-related intimidation remained a cause for concern, as did the grooming and exploitation of children by gangs. READ MORE The force also continued to 'lag behind' other comparable organisations in terms of the technology used to run functions such as finance and human resources. PCSA chair Elaine Byrne said the authority 'acknowledges the progress made' by An Garda Síochána in key areas last year and the 'commitment shown' by members and staff. 'At the same time, the report reflects the complexity of modern policing and the importance of ensuring that the right supports, whether in staffing, technology or training, are in place to meet public needs.' The assessment focuses on the Garda's performance last year based on the force's annual policing plan and policing priorities set out at the start of 2024. The report was compiled by the Policing Authority but has been published by its successor, the PCSA. It says the Garda's 'operating model' – meaning the amalgamation of Garda divisions, creating fewer but much larger divisions across the country – had been completed in 19 of the 21 divisions by the end of last year. The process has been fully completed since then. The Garda staff associations have criticised the model, which is the biggest restructuring of the force in its history, saying the geographic area of many divisions, spanning several counties, is so big it poses policing challenges. They believe resources were being drawn into urban centres in these larger divisions at the expense of the policing service available in rural areas. The PCSA said personnel shortages across the Garda were cited by some members of the force as 'detrimental' to the success of the operating policing model. 'In some areas there are geographical challenges reported, as the area to be covered within the division means that travelling – for example for detectives – takes up considerable time on a shift across more than one county,' it said. Elsewhere in its review, the PCSA concludes there is 'a need to examine the investment still needed in areas such as technology to assist in the identification of child sexual abuse material'. Though 'some progress has been made' more 'investment is necessary to fully realise the full benefits from the initial investment'. More investment in ICT was also required 'to support internal processes, such as anti-corruption, discipline and performance management'. Furthermore, 'no progress was made in 2024 in implementing performance management' even though it was 'critical in supporting a culture of robust and supportive supervision'. This resulted in poor performance either not being tackled or an over reliance on the disciplinary process. 'Using discipline instead of good supervision and performance management inappropriately introduces fear and risk aversion to making mistakes,' it said. In the areas of roads policing and public order policing, significant progress was noted. This included the direction from Garda Headquarters last year that all frontline gardaí must complete 30 minutes of roads policing during their shifts. Public-order policing has been marked by significant investment in equipment and training, especially since the Dublin riots in November 2023. The PCSA notes some recommendations from a 2019 Garda Inspectorate report remained outstanding, 'good progress' has been made.
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Sky Ireland tells court it is not obliged to give end of contract notice
The communications regulator. ComReg, is seeking High Court orders requiring Sky Ireland Ltd to end its practice of automatically renewing customers' contracts without first informing them their contracts are about to end and of alternative tariffs. ComReg claims Sky is in breach of 2022 European Union regulations requiring communications service providers to inform consumers in a prominent and timely manner of the end of the contractual commitment and means by which to terminate the contract. It says Sky is also contravening the regulations by failing to provide consumers with 'best tariff advice' before the contract is automatically prolonged. Sky is the only one of the five big providers refusing to do so, ComReg says. Sky disputes ComReg's interpretation of the relevant legal provisions and says they only apply to contracts with a fixed duration. Its customers' contracts are subscription contracts of indeterminate duration, it says. READ MORE The regulations, Sky argues, are designed to address the potential harm of consumers getting automatically prolonged in the contract for a second term without their knowledge. This harm does not arise in relation to Sky customers as its contracts do not follow this type of model in Ireland, it argues. It also says the ultimate interpretation of the regulations is for the courts to decide. On Monday, Mr Justice Mark Sanfey admitted Comreg's proceedings against Sky to the fast track Commercial Court on the application of Eoin McCullough SC, for the regulator, and on consent from Andrew Fitzpatrick SC, for Sky. The case was adjourned to December. In an affidavit seeking entry of the case to the commercial list, Miriam Kilraine, ComReg compliance operations manager, said the purpose of end of contract information and best tariff advice, when a contract is nearing end and about to be 'auto-prolonged', is that customers are afforded an opportunity of making an informed decision to stay with their current provider on the same or different package or to switch to a new provider. This is important particularly as customers may be losing discounts and therefore incurring higher prices and, in the case of Sky customers, this could include bundled TV, broadband and telephone services, she said. As part of its review and enforcement functions, ComReg began an investigation last September and Virgin Media, Eircom, Three and Vodafone all confirmed they are in compliance but Sky said it did not do so. Further investigations into Sky followed and in December Sky said it would not be complying because of its interpretation of the regulations. Ms Kilraine said it is clear there is a fundamental disagreement between the parties regarding the interpretation of the relevant legal provisions in this case. It is ComReg's position that Sky has failed and continues to fail to comply with its obligations under the 2022 regulations, she said. She also said Sky's UK arm, Sky UK Ltd, has taken a different position to its Irish counterpart and provides best tariff information to its customers. Th followed enforcement action against Sky UK by the UK watchdog, Ofcom, in 2021 which concluded in Ofcom's favour last December, Ms Kilraine said.
