Nehru's Vision of Foreign Policy Assumes Greater Relevance in Wake of the Modi Regime's Abject Failures
Menu
हिंदी తెలుగు اردو
Home Politics Economy World Security Law Science Society Culture Editor's Pick Opinion
Support independent journalism. Donate Now
World
Nehru's Vision of Foreign Policy Assumes Greater Relevance in Wake of the Modi Regime's Abject Failures
S.N. Sahu
18 minutes ago
The dehyphenation of India with Pakistan so arduously achieved before 2014 has been reversed by the utter failure of our foreign policy under Modi regime.
Illustration: Pariplab Chakraborty
Real journalism holds power accountable
Since 2015, The Wire has done just that.
But we can continue only with your support.
Contribute now
The abject failure of India's foreign policy and its collapse under the Modi regime, especially after the launch of Operation Sindoor against Pakistan, has been a cause of national concern. Such disastrous performance was never witnessed during the tenure of any other Prime Minister of our country.
While Operation Sindoor's military success in targeting Pak bases following the brutal killing of tourists by terrorists in Pahalgam in Kashmir has been acknowledged, its devastating fallout in the diplomatic and foreign policy front is very embarrassing.
Trump announcing ceasefire
Instead of India first announcing the ceasefire, it was US President Donald Trump who did so and repeated that claim several times on different occasions. He asserted that it was he who brokered it and claimed that both the countries ceased fire after he threatened to stop trade and commercial engagements with them.
Its denial by the spokesperson of External Affairs Ministry and Prime Minister Modi's deafening silence on it unambiguously affirms that Trump's claims are credible. A few days back Russian President Putin's aide Ushakov corroborated Trumps claim saying that that the armed conflict between India and Pakistan was halted with the personal involvement of the American President.
Indira Gandhi's Leadership
It is tragic that the country is witnessing such a sorry spectacle when India is reckoned with as a major player in international affairs and its military and economic might is globally acclaimed. Way back in 1971, neither the economic and military strength of India was anywhere near what we have in 2025.
And yet, under the leadership of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi, country's foreign policy and diplomatic orientation formed a crucial part of formidable military strategy in the war of 1971 when Pakistan was dismembered, its soldiers surrendered before Indian Army and Bangladesh emerged as a new country.
She set an example of a remarkable leader providing leadership to India in shaping her own independent path by defying the intimidations and pressures from the then US President Richard Nixon who despatched seventh fleet to the Indian Ocean to threaten India.
In 2025, no country with the exception of Israel supported Operation Sindoor even as China, Turkey and Azerbaijan stood in solidarity with Pakistan.
Nehru's vision
In 1927, when India's independence was a distant goal and freedom struggle was gaining momentum under the leadership of Mahatma Gandhi, thirty-eight-year old Jawaharlal Nehru, while attending an anti-imperialism conference in Brussels wrote for the first time an article titled 'A Foreign Policy for India.'
He outlined in it the crucial necessity of safeguarding our autonomy and independence to formulate and implement such a policy.
'We,' he thoughtfully wrote, 'must understand world movements and politics and fashion our own movement accordingly'. 'This cannot,' Nehru forcefully asserted, 'mean that we have to subordinate our interests or our methods of work to those of any other country or organisation'.
'Nor does it,' he added, 'mean that we should expect any help from outside or slacken our efforts at home'. 'It simply means that we must educate ourselves in problems of world polity so that we may be able to serve our country better,' he stated.
Those words uttered ninety-eight years back deeply resonate when India's foreign policy is in tatters and there is deafening silence of Modi regime on this grave issue.
It is educative that nineteen years after Nehru wrote that aforementioned article on India's foreign policy, he very presciently talked about the capability of India to frame an independent foreign policy in his book, Discovery of India, published in 1946.
Also Read: Gandhi's and Modi's Reflections on 'Sindoor' Are Poles Apart
He wrote that in the future, India along with USA, erstwhile Soviet Union and China would matter in world affairs. With rare far sightedness, he could foresee the rise of India, in his words, '… as a strong united state, a federation of free units, intimately connected with her neighbours and playing an important part in world affairs'.
He then remarked with emphasis, 'She is one of the very few countries which have the resources and capacity to stand on their own feet.'
After Nehru, successive Prime Ministers right up to Manmohan Singh – which of course include the tenure of BJP's Atal Bihari Vajpayee – conducted India's foreign policy in a manner affirming India's capacity to stand on its own feet.
Nehru and Austria
In the middle of 1950s, eight years after India's independence, with hardly any economic and military capability, India under the leadership of Prime Minister Nehru was requested by Austria to restore its freedom and sovereignty from the subjugation of the erstwhile occupation forces of the Soviet Union, Britain, France and the US, following the defeat of Germany in World War II.
Nehru took up the matter with the authorities of the erstwhile Soviet Union and requested them to sign the treaty so that all occupation forces would withdraw from Austria and it could get back its status as a free country. Indeed, Austria could recover its dignity as an independent nation wedded to the ideal of neutrality which remained central to Nehru's non-aligned foreign policy eschewing alliances with military blocks and pursuing active engagement with all countries with a spirit of friendship, equality and reciprocity.
Vajpayee and Kargil Conflict
During the Kargil conflict, even Vajpayee did not visit the USA when President Clinton asked him to join the then Pak Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif in Washington to discuss the military disengagement and put an end to the ongoing conflict. Pakistan eventually withdrew from the Kargil heights occupied by its army personnel.
Failure of India's Foreign Policy Under Modi
Tragically, now in 2025, after Operation Sindoor, the Modi regime's approach to India's foreign policy is demolishing its very foundation anchored in the ideals of independence.
As stated earlier, it was sadly reflected in the announcement of ceasefire by President Trump even before India did so.
Additionally, the dehyphenation of India with Pakistan so arduously achieved before 2014 has been reversed by the utter failure of our foreign policy under Modi regime and rest of the world has rehyphenated both the countries.
Failure of the all paty delegation to meet top functionaries of the 30 odd countries they visited to explain our position vis-a-vis Pakistan is yet again proves the sorry state of affairs of our foreign policy establishment.
Pakistan continues to get loans from the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and Asian Development Bank in spite of indulging in cross boarder terrorism against India, while the Modi administration is failing to get global public opinion mobilised against that country.
Besides, it is now set to chair the United Nations Security Council's Taliban Sanctions Committee in 2025, and will also be a vice-chair of the Council's Counter-Terrorism Committee. All such developments taking place in the backdrop of cease fire following Operation Sindoor is reflective of the failure of foreign policy architecture set by Modi Government to isolate Pakistan.
Nehru's Legacy Endures
Modi, who boosted up his image domestically on the strength of his much hyped narrative that India's stature has been considerably heightened globally under his leadership needs to introspect and assess the dismal failure of the foreign policy followed by his regime.
He should be mindful that during Nehru and Indira Gandhi's period, the stature of India at the global level was very high because of the excellent personality traits and attributes of those leaders even as India was not militarily and economically all that strong. It is in this context that Nehru's vision articulated in 1927 and in 1946 assumes greater significance to restore India's credibility at the national and global level.
S N Sahu served as Officer on Special Duty to President of India K R Narayanan.
The Wire is now on WhatsApp. Follow our channel for sharp analysis and opinions on the latest developments.
Make a contribution to Independent Journalism
Related News
Eight Days, Nine Rallies, Six States: Tracking PM Modi and Operation Sindoor as Campaign Ammunition
Gandhi's and Modi's Reflections on 'Sindoor' Are Poles Apart
Facing Pushback, Derision and Anger, BJP Says News of Sindoor Distribution Plans 'Fake'
Four Times Narendra Modi Showed That Criticising the Union Government on National Security is Okay
Operation Sindoor and Supernatural Times Under the Modi Regime
Why a Special Session of the Parliament is Critical to Discuss the Disclosure Made by CDS Chauhan
Mamata Accuses Modi of 'Political Holi' with Op Sindoor, Asks 'Why Not Give Sindoor to Your Mrs?'
Modi's Search for Global Solidarity Rings Hollow Amid Rising Domestic Intolerance in India
From Flowers to Sarees, A Story of PM Modi's Communication Imagery Post-Operation Sindoor
View in Desktop Mode
About Us
Contact Us
Support Us
© Copyright. All Rights Reserved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Deccan Herald
32 minutes ago
- Deccan Herald
Dalit youth murdered over ration dispute; Rahul says Bahujan people facing violence under Modi govt
He alleged that 11 years of the Modi government have been full of humiliation, violence and discrimination against Dalits, tribals, backward classes, and minorities.
Hans India
34 minutes ago
- Hans India
Assam CM slams Rahul Gandhi for ‘betraying' nation; praises Owaisi, Tharoor
Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma on Monday praised several opposition leaders for defending India's stance on international platforms following the country's retaliation to the Pahalgam terror attack, while launching a scathing attack on Congress leader Rahul Gandhi, accusing him of undermining national interests. Speaking during a discussion in the Assam Assembly about the successful 'Operation Sindoor', CM Sarma acknowledged the efforts of opposition figures like Shashi Tharoor, Asaduddin Owaisi and Supriya Sule, commending them for standing up for India on foreign soil. 'I am thankful to Congress and other opposition leaders, especially Shashi Tharoor, who have strongly defended India's position abroad. Leaders like Asaduddin Owaisi and Supriya Sule also upheld the nation's honour outside the country,' CM Sarma said. However, the Chief Minister drew a sharp contrast with Rahul Gandhi, accusing the Leader of the Opposition in the Lok Sabha of betraying both the nation and the armed forces. 'Rahul Gandhi did not stand with the country. He betrayed the nation. He betrayed our armed forces,' the Assam CM alleged, criticising Rahul Gandhi for raising questions about India's military losses during the conflict. CM Sarma claimed that while Gandhi repeatedly sought details on India's casualties during the operation, he showed no concern about the damage inflicted on Pakistan. 'There's a difference between questioning losses after a military operation and doing so while it's ongoing. Rahul Gandhi chose the latter — and never once asked what losses Pakistan suffered,' the Chief Minister asserted. Operation Sindoor was launched in response to the deadly Pahalgam terror attack, and the resolution in the Assembly marked a unified acknowledgment of the Indian armed forces' role in the counter-offensive. Earlier on Monday, CM Sarma asserted that the government would speed up the process of deporting illegal immigrants from the state to safeguard the indigenous community. While speaking at the Assembly, CM Sarma said: "The state government is set to use the 1950 law to expel the illegal immigrants here. The apex court of the country has also given a nod regarding this. The administrative machinery will work accordingly to make Assam free from illegal immigrants.' The Chief Minister also pressed for safeguarding the interests of Assamese people. He said, 'I am an Assamese first and a Chief Minister later.' The Assam government has decided to invoke a little-known law from 1950 -- the Immigrants (Expulsion from Assam) Order -- to fast-track the deportation of undocumented immigrants, bypassing the usual judicial process.
Time of India
38 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Ink of dictatorship ...': Opposition slams 11 years of Modi govt; Cong releases report card for 'detailed expose'
NEW DELHI: While the Bharatiya Janata Party ( BJP ) on Monday lauded 11 years of Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government, describing it as a period marked by a "remarkable transformation" in Indian politics, the opposition parties sharply criticised the Centre shortcomings across multiple key areas, accusing it of failing to deliver on several important fronts. Leader of Opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi latched on the Mumbai railway accident to attack the government and accused it of "selling dreams of 2047." "11 years of Modi government = no accountability, no change, only propaganda. The government has stopped talking about 2025 and is now selling dreams of 2047. Who will see what the country is facing today?" Rahul wrote on X. He added in another post: "The 11 years of the Modi government have been full of humiliation, violence, and discrimination against Dalits, Adivasis, backward classes, and minorities. The conspiracy to institutionally make them second-class citizens and keep them away from the mainstream is continuing." 'Wasted 11 years rubbing the ink of dictatorship' Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge claimed that the "Modi government has wasted the last 11 years rubbing the ink of dictatorship on every page of the Constitution." "In the last 11 years, the Modi government has caused severe damage to Indian democracy, the economy, and the social fabric," Kharge said. "BJP-RSS weakened every constitutional institution and attacked their autonomy—whether by stealing public opinion and toppling governments through the back door or by forcibly imposing one-party rule. During this period, the rights of the states were ignored and the federal structure was weakened. There have been continuous efforts to spread hatred, threats, and fear in society. Exploitation of Dalits, tribals, backward classes, minorities, and weaker sections has increased. The conspiracy to deprive them of reservation and equal rights continues. The unending violence in Manipur is the biggest proof of the BJP's administrative failure," he added. "BJP-RSS made the country's GDP growth rate accustomed to 5–6%, compared to 8% on average during the UPA era. Instead of the promise of 2 crore jobs every year, crores of jobs have been lost. Due to inflation, public savings are at their lowest in 50 years, and economic inequality is at a 100-year high. Demonetisation, flawed GST implementation, unplanned lockdown, and the blow to the unorganised sector have ruined the future of crores of people. Make in India, Startup India , Stand Up India, Digital India, Namami Gange, and 100 Smart Cities—all have failed. Railways have been ruined. The Modi government is only cutting ribbons of infrastructure built by the Congress-UPA," he said. '11 Saal, Jhoothe Vikas ke Vaade' Congress also presented a report card of PM Modi's tenure by releasing two sets of documents to "expose the BJP's broken promises." At a press conference, AICC research department head Rajeev Gowda, who prepared the booklet, alleged, "This government is very good at fake news and propaganda. It is our job as the Opposition to let people know the grim reality." The booklet 'Ek Aur Baar Jumla Sarkar ', he said, focuses on promises made by the BJP in its 2024 manifesto. The second, '11 Saal Jhoothe Vikas Ke Vaade'*, is a "detailed exposé" of the BJP's hollow claims. "In the 11-Saal document, one of the first themes they (BJP) highlight is care for the poor and marginalised. They boast that 81 crore people are getting free food grains under PMGKAY. But the basic problem of hunger is a much larger crisis in India, which ranks 105th out of 127 countries on the World Hunger Index. "Its implications: malnutrition is affecting our children terribly. Stunting is at 35.5%, wasting at 19.3%, and underweight children at 32.1%," Gowda said. Congress also accused PM Modi of failing to protect the country, claiming that "52 terrorist attacks" had occurred in the last year. "In one year of the Modi government: 52 terrorist attacks; 36 soldiers martyred; 53 soldiers injured; 56 civilians killed; 82 civilians injured," the party stated. "Narendra Modi has failed in protecting the country," it added. 'People of the BJP are working against each other' Meanwhile, Samajwadi Party chief Akhilesh Yadav also raised questions about the Centre's performance in education, employment, and economic activity. He alleged a lack of coordination between the BJP-led central and Uttar Pradesh governments, citing their ongoing schemes. Speaking to reporters, Yadav said, "There's a phrase in Hindi—'Ek pe ek gyarah' and the other 'Nau Do Gyarah'. This might be their 11 years. If we add 11 years of the Central government and 9 years of the Uttar Pradesh government, that totals 20 years. The government must give an account of these 20 years. What have they done for the people? How far have we progressed in education? How successful have we been in providing employment or attracting investment?" "The people of Uttar Pradesh will analyse this more closely, since the Prime Minister himself is an MP from the state. There is no coordination between Delhi and Lucknow—it's evident in the schemes. If even the adopted villages haven't changed, it raises serious questions. The BJP leaders are working against each other. There are many unanswered questions on both achievements and failures. The people will evaluate. There is large-scale unemployment and inflation in Uttar Pradesh." 'This is Amrit Kaal' In contrast, addressing a press conference in the national capital, BJP president JP Nadda said the past 11 years had seen a decisive shift from politics based on "appeasement" to one driven by "performance, accountability, and responsible governance." 'It should be written in golden letters that under the leadership of PM Shri Narendra Modi, a remarkable transformation has taken place over the past 11 years. PM Modi has reshaped Indian political culture. In the past, politics was driven by appeasement strategies aimed at preserving power. Now, under PM Modi, the focus is on performance, accountability, and responsible governance. This has become the new normal,' Nadda said. Calling the NDA a 'people-led government,' Nadda claimed that the Modi administration had created a forward-looking, transparent, and futuristic model of governance. "Modi government is a people-led government. Over the past years, we have brought transparency and built a future-ready administration. That is why we talk about Viksit Bharat. This is Amrit Kaal. The past 11 years have laid a strong foundation for a truly developed and self-reliant India."
