SA politicians with clouds hanging over their heads
A look at politicians dogged by controversy, including Ramaphosa, Mashatile, Simelane, Mantashe and others.
Pictures: The Citizen and Gallo
Here are some prominent politicians who are under a cloud:
President Cyril Ramaphosa
He has faced scrutiny over his business dealings, most notably the Phala Phala farm scandal, where $580 000 (about R10 million) in cash was stolen from his Limpopo game farm in 2020.
The incident was concealed until June 2022.
He was later accused of money laundering, tax evasion and violating foreign currency regulations.
However, the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) declined to prosecute.
ALSO READ: Phadi to serve MK party, despite removal as provincial convener [VIDEO]
Paul Mashatile – deputy president
He has long been haunted by corruption allegations, including the R1.3 billion Alexandra renewal project.
More recently, questions have emerged about his lavish lifestyle, allegedly funded by government contractors.
The DA has laid criminal charges, leaving the NPA to decide on prosecution.
John Steenhuisen – minister of agriculture and DA leader
Steenhuisen was implicated in allegations of misusing DA funds during his 2020 campaign for party leadership.
ALSO READ: WATCH: Floyd Shivambu 'a total failure as a politician' – analyst
The accusations were made by expelled member Tsepo Mhlongo, who also implicated Manny de Freitas.
While De Freitas was found guilty and expelled, no action was taken against Steenhuisen.
Kgosientsho Ramokgopa – minister of electricity and energy
As former mayor of Tshwane (2010-2016), Ramokgopa was linked to a controversial contract awarded to PEU Capital Partners.
The irregular contract was set aside by the courts.
Thembi Simelane – minister of human settlements
ALSO READ: Police close to breakthrough in IFP deputy chief whip's 'assassination'
Simelane has been accused of taking questionable loans from companies connected to the looted VBS Bank while serving as Polokwane mayor.
Additionally, she faces DA-laid charges for allegedly defrauding Eskom of R700 000 during her time at consulting firm Vitrovian.
Nobuhle Nkabane – minister of higher education and training
Nkabane stands accused of ignoring corruption allegations in the Construction Education and Training Authority, despite whistle-blower evidence.
She was also accused of misleading parliament regarding Sector Education and Training Authority appointments.
Aaron Motsoaledi – minister of health
ALSO READ: ANC denies it approached Zuma and MK party to join GNU [VOICE NOTE]
Motsoaledi was implicated in a 2019 bribery scandal involving the murder of businessman Louis Siemens, with claims he received R150 000 to fast-track a hospital licence.
He has denied the allegations.
Gwede Mantashe – minister of mineral and petroleum resources
Mantashe is linked to the Bosasa corruption scandal, accused of accepting home security upgrades.
The Zondo commission recommended further investigation.
Blade Nzimande – minister of science, technology and innovation
ALSO READ: Late ANC stalwart Solomon Mahlangu's niece joins Zuma's MK party
Nzimande was accused of accepting kickbacks from National Student Financial Aid Scheme service providers when he was higher education minister.
He denied the claims, calling them a politically motivated smear campaign.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
New by-law aims to loosen building regulations for 'micro housing developers'
Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis Image: Supplied The City of Cape Town yesterday passed a major amendment to its Municipal Planning By-law, aimed at unlocking affordable rental housing in informal and lower-income neighbourhoods — a move Mayor Geordin Hill-Lewis described as 'a watershed moment.' The amendment introduces a new land-use right that allows homeowners in 194 designated communities to legally build affordable rental units on their properties. These areas have seen rapid densification over the past decade, particularly through backyarder dwellings and informal structures. While the Democratic Alliance (DA), which holds a majority in Council, voted in support of the amendment, it faced opposition from several parties, including the EFF, Al Jama-ah, the National Coloured Congress (NCC), GOOD, Cape Exit, the PAC, and the Freedom Front Plus. The ANC abstained. In his address to Council, Hill-Lewis stressed the scale of the challenge: '1.2 million of our fellow residents live in informal structures in Cape Town,' he said. 'For those of us who did not grow up in townships, or in a backyard, it is hard to imagine what that means. To live with bitter cold and constant damp in winter, and scorching heat and constant threat of fire in summer.' Hill-Lewis criticised the national government's free housing programme, known as Breaking New Ground, for failing to meet rising demand. 'Budgets are simply too small, the need too vast. Only a lucky few thousand per year, those waiting the very longest, will get a totally free house, while hundreds of thousands remain on the list. It is important that the public understand that.' While acknowledging that economic growth and job creation remain the only sustainable long-term solution, Hill-Lewis emphasised the need for action now: 'We also can't wait for a faster growing economy. While that is undoubtedly the only sustainable long term solution, we also need a plan now.' That plan, he said, is the by-law amendment. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ 'The amendments to the Municipal Planning By-law that we will vote on today will do more than any other programme, in any city, to help many more people make the leap from informal housing to dignified, affordable homes.' The by-law now enables homeowners in selected communities to build rental units legally and safely, with connections to municipal water, sanitation, and electricity. These developments will also need to meet National Building Regulations. Hill-Lewis acknowledged that micro-developers in townships have already been meeting housing demand at a scale the State cannot match: 'The fact is that micro-developers in lower-income communities are already getting on with meeting housing demand by building many thousands more units every year than the State could ever possibly hope to deliver.' He described the City's role not as one of obstruction, but of enablement: 'Now we are playing our proper role – not standing in the way, but enabling this form of housing delivery, driven by people's own enterprise, ingenuity, and investment.' The by-law also includes support measures, such as: Pre-approved building plans and development charge discounts; A pipeline of 12,000 affordable housing units on well-located land; South Africa's first Land Discount Guidelines, allowing for discounted city-owned land to be used for social housing; Utility discounts for approved social housing projects. While praising the amendment's potential, Hill-Lewis also raised a broader point about transformation in the housing market: 'For so long, property development has been an industry dominated by wealthy established developers who mainly develop in expensive suburbs… but today we are also blowing open the property development industry for thousands of new entrants – new property developers in the townships and in so many other areas.' He also committed to streamlining approval processes and clamping down on unlawful construction. 'This amendment also empowers communities, by greatly improving public participation in planning applications, and giving the City real teeth for the first time to stop illegal building work.'
IOL News
3 hours ago
- IOL News
DA threathens to walk as Ramaphosa sparks GNU crisis with Whitfield firing
Former DTIC Deputy minister Andrew Whitfield warns the DA may exit the GNU if Ramaphosa fails to act on compromised ministers, calling the president's approach provocative, confusing, and damaging to political cooperation. Image: DTIC/X Former Deputy Minister of Trade, Industry and Competition, Andrew Whitfield, says the Democratic Alliance (DA) may reconsider its role in the Government of National Unity (GNU) if President Cyril Ramaphosa fails to act against ministers the party deems compromised. This comes after DA leader John Steenhuisen issued an ultimatum to the president, demanding that Ministers Thembi Simelane, Minister Nkabane, Deputy Minister David Mahlobo, and others be removed within 48 hours. Whitfield also says Ramaphosa's decision to fire him is inconsistent, disproportionate, and could destabilise the GNU. In an interview on Face the Nation, Whitfield confirmed that the president gave no formal reason for his removal except to cite Section 93(1) of the Constitution, which gives him the prerogative to appoint and dismiss members of the executive. 'At no stage leading up to this letter that I received or up until this evening have I received any formal explanation as to what the reason may be,' Whitfield said. The DA believes Whitfield's removal was linked to his decision to travel to the United States in February as part of a DA delegation without receiving written presidential approval. Whitfield said he followed protocol by submitting a formal request 10 days before departure, as required by the ministerial handbook. Despite multiple follow-ups, he received no response from the Presidency. 'I decided to abide by the request of my party to travel abroad under the circumstances where no response was received. I simply took silence as consent,' he said. 'Perhaps that was an error in judgment on my part, but at the same time, I don't think the sanction, which appears quite dramatic, was proportionate.' He added that he had sent a written apology to the president after the trip, but never received a reply. 'I think there were other ways to deal with this,' he said, adding that the president later declined other travel requests, including a personal study programme at Harvard University on inclusive economic growth, ironically, the apex priority of the GNU. Whitfield further warned that the president's actions, or lack thereof, could jeopardise the GNU. ''The leader of the DA has made it very clear that a line has been crosse,d which is going to be difficult to turn back from. 'I just don't see a situation in which the DA can continue to operate in the GNU in the way that they have,' he said. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Whitfield said the federal executive of the DA is expected to meet and decide on the next steps if the ultimatum is ignored. 'I think that there are a number of options at our disposal, leaving the GNU is one of them, and I think that the president believes that he, for whatever reason, that he thinks that the DA is perhaps not going to take that decision or perhaps the president simply doesn't want the GNU to work and has decided to provoke a reaction on something like this.' Whitfield expressed frustration over the timing of the decision, suggesting it was politically motivated: 'If there was another way to sanction me, if he'd raised this a month ago, three months ago , it's been four months. I don't know why the timing is now and potentially putting the budget in jeopardy, which luckily didn't happen today.' He also revealed that some ANC colleagues had privately expressed support and confusion over the president's decision. 'I've had some calls from colleagues in the ANC who have been perplexed; they've been supportive. They've reached out, and I've had a conversation or two. I think there's a bit of confusion inside the ANC around this as well.' Whitfield noted that while the GNU presented an opportunity for political maturity and collaboration, the president had taken 'a different route entirely,' calling the move 'premature and deeply unfortunate.' Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel. IOL Politics
The Citizen
4 hours ago
- The Citizen
Eight MPs fined R10,000 for failing to disclose financial interests
Didiza clarified that while the members had missed the deadline, they remained obligated to submit their declarations. Eight members of parliament have been reprimanded and fined R10 000 each after failing to meet the deadline for disclosing their financial interests in 2024, with parliament's speaker warning that their actions had the potential to undermine public trust. The National Assembly adopted the joint committee on ethics and members' interests report during its plenary sitting, finding the legislators in breach of the Code of Ethical Conduct and Disclosure of Members' Interests for missing the 14 October 2024 deadline. Members found in breach The eight members sanctioned include Mluleki Dlelanga (ANC), Mkhuleko Hlengwa (IFP), Nhlamulo Ndhlela (MK), Mzoleli Mrara (ANC), Masetsego Mofokeng (ANC), Maropene Ramokgopa (ANC), Sihle Zikalala (ANC) and Andries Nel (ANC). Speaking during the reprimand, parliament sleaker Thoko Didiza emphasised the seriousness of the breach. 'Honourable members, I just want to say this is unacceptable. It's also objectionable and deserving of serious consequences as it has already been determined by the committee in terms of the fine that you have been given,' Didiza said. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa announces 'Eminent Persons Group' to guide national dialogue – These are the people appointed Disclosure requirements and deadlines During 2024, which was an election year, members were required to disclose their registrable interests within 60 working days after the opening of parliament. The disclosure system operates on an annual cycle, with the main period running from 1 April to 30 June each year during the first quarter of the financial year. Didiza clarified that while the members had missed the deadline, they remained obligated to submit their declarations. 'I just want to advise members that if a member has missed the date you are still equally obliged to tender your interest. So it doesn't mean that these members have not declared for 2024, but they were late in terms of the deadline,' she said. ALSO READ: Floyd Shivambu not on list of MK party members going to parliament Importance of financial disclosure The Code of Ethical Conduct serves as a crucial mechanism for maintaining public trust and ensuring parliamentary accountability. Mandatory disclosure of members' financial and other interests forms a cornerstone of ethical governance, helping to prevent conflicts of interest and safeguarding parliament's integrity against undue influence or personal enrichment. The disclosure requirements are comprehensive, covering employment details, assets, gifts, interests held by immediate family members and travel arrangements. Even members with no interests to declare must submit a 'nil' return and all submissions must be made electronically. Didiza stressed the fundamental importance of these obligations during her address. 'Would all appreciate that the Court of Ethical Conduct and Disclosure of Members' Interest provides a set of values for members. Among other requirements, the Court obligates members to annually declare their financial interest in a public register. 'This allows the public to confirm that no member may have been exposed to any conflict of interest,' she said. ALSO READ: 'We are not xenophobic': No justification to favour foreign academics over South Africans, says ANC MP Committee process and penalties The joint committee on ethics and members' interests found that the affected members had been given adequate opportunity to present their records and explain their failures but had not done so satisfactorily. The committee determined that their actions warranted both public reprimand and financial penalties. 'It is apparent from the committee report that you were provided fair opportunity to present your records and not having done so, to adequately explain your failings. Your actions had the potential to erode public interest in parliament,' Didiza told the members during the formal reprimand. Administrative framework The Registrar of Members' Interests plays a central role in administering the disclosure process, maintaining the register, overseeing timely submissions, and handling complaints and preliminary investigations into code breaches. The 2024 Public Register has been published on Parliament's website. When members fail to disclose their interests or submit false information, matters are referred to the joint committee on ethics and members' interests. Depending on the severity of breaches, penalties can range from reprimands and fines to suspension or other corrective actions. ALSO READ: 'A lying minister in Cabinet': Why has Ramaphosa not fired Nkabane? Implementation of penalties The speaker confirmed that the financial penalties would be implemented immediately. 'I also notice as indicated above that financial penalties have been imposed. These penalties will be implemented without delay. I trust therefore that this reprimand sends a message to all of us as members to live up to our obligations and ensure that we comply with the code,' Didiza said. The disclosure system continues to operate with quarterly updates required whenever there are changes to members' registrable or financial interests throughout the year. READ NEXT: DA threatens to exit GNU over Whitfield's firing
