John Swinney urged not to drop Scotland's ban on cash for weapons in face of Russia threat
John Swinney is under pressure not to drop the Scottish Government ban on sending public cash to weapons manufacturing projects.
The First Minister last week revealed he could "reconsider" the longstanding policy due to the threat from Russia.
It follows an internal review by its business quango, Scottish Enterprise, into its funding of arms companies.
Scottish taxpayers have shelled out £8million in grants since 2019 to arms dealers like Leonardo, Raytheon and BAE Systems.
The money is not currently allowed to go towards the direct manufacture of munitions, but critics describe the current system of human rights checks as "inadequate".
The Scottish Greens and Amnesty International say cash has been awarded to firms involved in manufacture of F-35s and other military tech in Gaza.
Greens MSP Patrick Harvie said: 'Scottish tax payers' money should never go towards companies arming regimes that commit war crimes.
"In recent years the UK has armed Israel as it engaged in genocide, Saudi Arabia as it pursued a brutal war in Yemen, and Hong Kong and Egypt as they attacked pro-democracy protests.
'The SNP generally falls back on the 'no manufacture of munitions' line to defend the fact that they still fund companies complicit in such crimes.
'Far from retreating from their policy, they should strengthen it by applying human rights checks that actually mean something, instead of the rubber stamp currently applied."
He added: 'There are hundreds of projects across the country that provide jobs and positive, productive outcomes for Scotland that would welcome financial support from the government.
"There's simply no need to give it to arms dealers and war profiteers.'
Swinney had previously said the government's stance against directly funding munitions would remain, with his Cabinet minister Mairi Gougeon previously saying it was based on the party's "principles".
But speaking to the Holyrood Sources podcast last week, the SNP chief said: "I'm conscious we are living in a very different context today. The Russian threat is very real. We have to consider these questions."
Join the Daily Record WhatsApp community!
Get the latest news sent straight to your messages by joining our WhatsApp community today.
You'll receive daily updates on breaking news as well as the top headlines across Scotland.
No one will be able to see who is signed up and no one can send messages except the Daily Record team.
All you have to do is click here if you're on mobile, select 'Join Community' and you're in!
If you're on a desktop, simply scan the QR code above with your phone and click 'Join Community'.
We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like.
To leave our community click on the name at the top of your screen and choose 'exit group'.
If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice.
Deputy first minister Kate Forbes revealed this week a tighter regime of human rights checks for Scottish Enterprise funding of arms firms following a review, but opponents said it would effectively allow the status quo to continue.
Neil Cowan, Scotland director at Amnesty International, said: 'The Scottish public must be assured that this review has not simply swept the issues under the carpet.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
42 minutes ago
- NBC News
Trump says call with Putin yielded no progress on a Russia-Ukraine ceasefire
President Donald Trump said Thursday that he "didn't make any progress" on a potential ceasefire in the Russia-Ukraine war when he spoke by phone with Russian President Vladimir Putin. "No, I didn't make any progress with him today at all," Trump told reporters when asked about any movement toward an agreement between the two countries during his call with Putin earlier in the day. "We had a call. It was a pretty long call. We talked about a lot of things, including Iran, and we also talked about, as you know, the war with Ukraine. And I'm not happy about that, I'm not happy," Trump said. Putin aide Yury Ushakov said in a readout of the call that the two leaders held a 'frank and substantive' and that Trump raised the possibility of an immediate ceasefire in Russia's war with Ukraine but that Putin did not agree. Putin said Russia "will pursue its stated objectives" in the conflict, and continues to look for a political resolution to the conflict through negotiations, Ushakov added. The last publicly known call between Putin and Trump took place last month in a discussion that involved the Israel-Iran conflict, according to a Truth Social post by Trump. They also spoke in May about the Ukraine-Russia war. Representatives from Russia and Ukraine held direct talks in Istanbul in May, but there weren't any breakthroughs. Trump and some of his allies on Capitol Hill are seeking to secure a permanent ceasefire. Trump repeatedly said on the campaign trail that he would bring an end to the conflict within the first 24 hours of his second term. During a presidential debate in September, he said he could resolve the conflict "before I even become president." Speaking to reporters Thursday, Trump was also asked about a U.S. pause in shipping missiles and ammunition to Ukraine. Trump denied there was a pause. "We haven't, we're giving weapons because we've given so many weapons, but we are giving weapons, and we're working with them and trying to help them," Trump said. "But we haven't, you know, Biden emptied our whole country giving 'em weapons, and we have to make sure that we have enough for ourselves." NBC News reported this week that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth had ordered a shipment pause over concerns about the U.S. military's stockpiles, according to two congressional officials and two sources with knowledge of the decision.
Western Telegraph
an hour ago
- Western Telegraph
Ministers reveal plan to nearly double onshore wind across England by 2030
Ministers want to expand the country's onshore wind capacity from 14.8GW to 27-29GW by the end of the decade. It comes as part of wider Government ambitions to transition towards a clean power system by 2030, with the hope of boosting economic growth, creating jobs, reducing bills, decarbonising the grid and strengthening energy security. Last year, Labour axed the de facto ban on building onshore wind farms introduced by the Conservatives under David Cameron. Energy Security and Net Zero Secretary Ed Miliband arrives at Lancaster House, London. File photo. (Toby Melville/PA) The Government's move put onshore wind on an equal planning footing to offshore wind and nuclear, paving the way for projects to be rolled out faster in the coming years. The Conservatives criticised the strategy, accusing Energy Secretary Ed Miliband of making the country's energy 'unreliable and expensive' through his 'obsession with climate targets'. As part of the plan, the Government set out 40 actions for ministers and industry to take to hit the 2030 onshore wind ambitions. These include planning reforms, building supply chains and skilled workforces, resolving issues over how onshore turbines and aerospace infrastructure can co-exist, repowering old turbines, and exploring plans to expand the clean industry bonus for onshore wind. The Government claimed the strategy will support the creation of up to 45,000 skilled jobs by the end of the decade. In the foreword, Mr Miliband said: 'As one of the cheapest and fastest-to-build sources of power we have, onshore wind will play a critical role in boosting our energy independence with clean power by 2030. 'The reality is that every turbine we build helps protect families, businesses and the public finances from future fossil fuel shocks.' 'The reality is that every turbine we build helps protect families, businesses and the public finances from future fossil fuel shocks.' Matthieu Hue, co-chairman of the Onshore Wind Taskforce and chief executive of EDF Power Solutions UK and Ireland, said: 'This strategy is focusing on overcoming barriers and challenges we face across the industry in the deployment of onshore wind while capturing the major socio-economic benefits it can bring to the environment and to local economies. 'This is a critical part of making Britain a clean energy superpower and delivering energy security.' The Government said communities that host wind farms will benefit from money for community initiatives, such as new football pitches or libraries, or even bill discount schemes. A typical 25MW wind farm paying the industry standard of £5,000 per MW of installed capacity per year could deliver £3.75 million of funding to be redistributed among the community on local initiatives of their choosing over a 30-year operating life, according to the strategy document. A general view of Europe's biggest onshore wind farm, Whitelee Windfarm on the outskirts of Glasgow. (Danny Lawson/PA) In a statement, shadow energy secretary Claire Coutinho said: '(The Energy Secretary) is shutting down the North Sea, concreting our gas wells and he's downgraded our plans for nuclear. 'All this means is that families' energy bills are going to go through the roof, and we'll just end up importing more from coal-powered China. 'The US security services have already warned us that Chinese wind turbines could pose serious risks to our national security, but he won't do a China audit. Ed wants to hit Net Zero targets no matter the cost to the British public.' Elsewhere, the Government recently completed a process to de-risk offshore wind developments, led by the Marine Spatial Prioritisation Programme. It said this will inform the Crown Estate's marine delivery route map on strategic use of the seabed so that more offshore wind farms can be built in a way that considers all marine sectors, including fisheries, and protects the environment. James Robottom, RenewableUK's head of onshore wind delivery, said: 'Overturning the unpopular onshore wind ban, which deprived us of one of the quickest and cheapest technologies to build for a decade, was just the start. 'The hard work to make the most of this great opportunity to grow our economy and strengthen the UK's energy security is now in full swing.' Sue Ferns, senior deputy general secretary of trade union Prospect, said: 'The lost years resulting from the last government's inexplicable ban have resulted in significant workforce and skills-related challenges that urgently need to be addressed, which hopefully they will be in the forthcoming clean energy workforce plan.'
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
South West Wales to pilot new bus franchising scheme
Transport for Wales (TfW) is inviting the public to share their views on proposed changes under the scheme, which forms part of a wider effort to improve bus services across Wales. The changes are being proposed as part of the Welsh Government's bus reform bill, which is currently under consideration in the Senedd. Lee Robinson, executive director for regional transport and integration at TfW, said: "Bus franchising in Wales will allow us to shape an improved bus network that really works for people, and we're doing this in partnership with local authorities and bus operators. "We are now at the start and South West Wales will be the first region to see changes in 2027. "It's fundamental that we involve the public and listen to their feedback on our proposed improvements. "We'd encourage people to take part in the online survey or attend the organised events." TfW and local authorities in South West Wales are developing a Proposed Base Network, outlining possible routes and service frequencies for 2027. The changes will build on the current network and focus on using existing resources to deliver improvements. The new model will be introduced through a franchising approach, giving TfW and local authorities greater control over service planning and delivery. The public can share their views through an online survey at In-person engagement events are also being organised across the region. The feedback gathered will help shape the final network design and ensure that services meet the needs of communities. TfW said it will continue working with local authorities, bus operators and the public to refine and improve the network over time.
