A recipe for repeated failure
Indeed, any positive shift in macroeconomic indicators should be welcomed but only if it stems from meaningful, sustainable reforms. Unfortunately, that's not the case. We are walking a precarious path, chasing the illusion of economic stabilization while ignoring the deep-seated flaws in our system. It's a dangerous approach, one that treats the symptoms, not the disease, and sets us up for future failures.
Take agriculture, not just a sector, but Pakistan's lifeline. Nearly 70 percent of our population relies on it, directly or indirectly.
Yet, it continues to be sidelined. According to official data, major crop production declined by 13 percent this year, which is not a marginal slip, but a clear warning sign. The wheat crisis illustrates how political considerations repeatedly trump national interest.
A failure to ensure fair pricing, combined with rising input costs like electricity and urea, has pushed farmers to the brink. With each planting season, they face higher risks and fewer rewards, definitely crushed by policy neglect dressed in populist slogans. If we cannot protect the very people who feed the nation, what kind of economic growth are we aiming for?
The government's GDP growth target of 3.56 percent, already modest compared to our historical average of 4.5 percent%, wasn't even met. Blaming global headwinds masks a more uncomfortable truth: internal mismanagement and misplaced priorities. We keep pumping money into politically motivated but economically unproductive ventures, while high-return sectors like SMEs, technology, and export industries are left gasping for support.
Our national budget is a reflection of this short-termism. Political optics consistently take precedence over long-term planning. As a result, the engines of real growth are being starved of fuel, while flashy but unsustainable projects grab headlines.
Another fundamental weakness lies in our ever-expanding informal economy. Rather than integrating it into the formal structure, our policies encourage its continued existence. It's no secret that countless businesses operate without paying taxes or following regulations.
Meanwhile, those who try to play by the rules are penalized burdened by audits, red tape, and higher taxes. In time, many either shut down or are forced to go underground just to survive. Unfortunately, budget 2025 followed by this Economic Survey has the fewest initiatives to increase the tax base.
The policy is taxing the already taxed. What's worse is that the very institutions tasked with revenue collection often enable this dysfunction. Whether through neglect or collusion, their inaction erodes faith in the system and entrenches the culture of non-compliance.
The services sector fares no better. Consider Pakistan's fast-growing freelance and remote work industry, driven by one of the youngest populations in the world. These digital workers require no subsidies and free laptops but just a clear, supportive policy environment. Yet they are met with uncertainty over payment gateways, taxation, and regulatory hurdles. Frustrated by the culture, many route their financial operations through Gulf countries, depriving Pakistan of valuable foreign exchange and economic potential.
This is a tragic missed opportunity. With minimal effort, the government could unleash the power of this low-cost, high-yield export sector, generating jobs boosting foreign earnings, and empowering the youth.
Instead, what we see is over-regulation, lack of trust, and a bureaucratic mindset that scares away innovation. Gen Z, inherently comfortable with digital finance, is a natural ally in our effort to document the economy. But rather than incentivizing their participation, the state often treats their financial activity with suspicion. The result? Fear, not confidence. Disengagement, not inclusion.
If we're serious about formalizing the economy, we must start by winning public trust, simplifying compliance, and offering incentives rather than penalties.
We've spent far too long lurching from crisis to crisis, mistaking temporary stability for genuine progress. What we need is structural transformation: bold reforms in agriculture, taxation, regulation, and service sector development. We need to stop punishing those who follow the rules and stop rewarding those who don't.
We must shift our mindset from election cycles to generational thinking. Because the truth is: Pakistan has immense potential. We have the land, the talent, the youth, and a strategic location. But unless we address the foundational issues, surface-level improvements will do little to prevent long-term decline.
Our economic managers must rise above the habit of number-polishing and narrative-spinning. The real challenge is not to lower inflation for a quarter, but to build a fair, inclusive, and future-ready economy.
We don't need miracles. We need meaningful change and the courage to pursue it.
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
7 days ago
- Express Tribune
Victory celebration and reality check
Listen to article Pakistani luck is flying these days. It has been blessed with massive success, one after the other. First, Pakistan successfully and comprehensively defeated India in the military conflict. It was an enormous triumph, which laid the foundation for a regional reset. India, which had portrayed itself as the regional power, a rising market and economy in Asia, and a leader of the Global South, had to face a checkmate at the hands of Pakistan. Second, on the diplomatic front, Pakistan achieved many accomplishments. After the war, India sent a delegation to the world to launch a propaganda campaign. It wanted to tag Pakistan with terrorism. Pakistan analysed the situation and sent its own delegation, which outperformed the Indian delegation. The world did not buy the Indian argument, and the Pakistani point of view had wider acceptance. Pakistan maintains a balanced relationship with the world's major powers, including China, the United States, and Russia. There is no need to discuss the China-Pakistan relationship, as everyone is aware that both countries share a deep and enduring brotherhood. However, the recent shift in the Pakistan-US relationship is the talk of the town. The US played a prominent role in halting the war between India and Pakistan. After the truce, President Trump praised Pakistan for its sensible and rational behaviour. He also invited Army Chief General Asim Munir for a meeting at the White House. Both sides reportedly discussed enhancing the relationship in multiple fields. On the other hand, Pakistan and Russia intensified efforts to further enhance and strengthen their bilateral relationship. Russia has shown interest in investing more than $2 billion in reviving and expanding Pakistan Steel Mills. It is a good omen, as Pakistan was looking for opportunities to revive the mill. Also, a breakthrough happened at the SCO defence ministers' meeting, where Russia supported Pakistan's stance on terrorism. Simultaneously, Pakistan played a prominent and leading role in ending the Iran-Israel war. It diligently convinced the US administration that the war in the region had no justification. Therefore, all efforts must be made to end the war and work for peace. These examples collectively indicate that Pakistan has achieved significant success in recent months. However, the country needs to be cognizant that these achievements cannot be sustained without solving domestic challenges. Pakistan continues to face multiple challenges. The economic and governance system is in shambles. The government claims that the economy is improving and that the budget will provide a foundation for accelerated economic growth and development, as promised the previous year. But the Economic Survey 2024-25 and the budget for 2025-26 present a bleak picture. The Economic Survey shows that the national GDP grew at a 2.7% rate. However, independent sources are not willing to accept government claims and instead raise questions. They question that, during the first three quarters of FY25, the economy grew at an average annual rate of 1.7%. To achieve a yearly rate of 2.7%, the economy would have had to grow at 5.3% during the last quarter, which is not possible. Apart from that, agriculture, which had provided a significant boost to economic growth in FY24, presented a dismal picture in FY25. A booming sector experienced a sharp decline in production and market share. The growth rate fell to 0.56% in FY25 from 6.25% in FY24, driven by a steep fall in the growth of major crops. Major crops' growth rate fell to -13.26% in 2025, from 11.3% in 2024. Similarly, the large-scale industry is struggling to enter a positive growth trajectory, having demonstrated a negative growth of -1.7%. Social indicators too are pretty disturbing. The World Bank estimates that 44.7% of the population lives below the poverty line, and 16.5% of the population resides in extreme poverty. Poverty is increasing, despite the government's assertions of investing in poverty reduction such as the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP). This raises questions about the effectiveness and sustainability of the BISP. Food insecurity is another constant irritant, and a 2013 study estimated that 58.8% of the population in Pakistan was food insecure. Unfortunately, we have to rely on old data because the government has not updated it. There are fears that food insecurity has increased over the years due to multiple factors. Poor economic conditions and the devaluation of the PKR have substantially impacted people's purchasing power, resulting in fewer resources available to afford healthy food. Additionally, inadequate governance and management of the agricultural sector have led to lower production and reduced availability of quality food. Bad governance is further complicating the situation. The elite class has designed the institutions to ensure the exclusion of common citizens from the governance system without explicitly mentioning it. The system encourages wealth accumulation, and there is no system in place for redistributing wealth or resources. It is deepening the divide between the haves and have-nots. A few influential individuals have all the resources, while millions struggle to make a decent living. Furthermore, the elite have devised an extremely complex business system and environment to strengthen their control over the economic system and resources. This system has given birth to rampant corruption and deep-rooted rent-seeking behaviour. It only works for the powerful or those who can afford to offer bribes. Environmental degradation, particularly climate change, is another issue that is worsening over time. Climate change-related disasters, such as floods and droughts, are regular visitors. Pakistan is still struggling to recover from the impacts of the 2022 floods, and there is a prediction that Pakistan will again face floods. On the other hand, climate change is severely impacting agriculture, which is threatening Pakistan's food security and economy. Farmers are bearing the brunt of climate change. Poor governance and attitude of the government have left farmers vulnerable to the impacts of climate change. In conclusion, Pakistan needs to be mindful that its heyday can be limited if it does not address these issues. The writer is a political economist and a visiting research fellow at Hebei University, China
Express Tribune
13-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Non-formal education enrolment rises 20 per cent
A 20% increase has been recorded in enrollments in Pakistan's non-formal education sector, according to the 2023-24 National Non-Formal Education (NFE) Statistical Report. The document has been released by the Pakistan Institute of Education (PIE). Non-formal education has been described as a "second-chance model" that is cost-effective, flexible, and community-based. The monthly cost per child ranges between Rs 1,000 to Rs1,500, considerably lower than the expenses of formal education systems. The annual report, presented a detailed snapshot of the country's non-formal learning landscape, spotlighting both achievements and persistent gaps. The number of non-formal education centers across the country has reached 35,427, serving over 1.29 million learners, reflecting a 20% increase in enrollment compared to the previous year. The report notes that in 2023-24, enrollments in non-formal education centers grew by 20%, with 57% of learners being girls, marking a promising step toward gender parity. Female teachers make up 82% of the workforce, demonstrating strong female participation in the non-formal education system. A total of 3,382 adult literacy centers are currently operational, serving 80,093 learners, indicating an increasing focus on youth and adult literacy. Additionally, 10,181 refugee children, mostly from Afghanistan, are enrolled in NFE programs. Innovative models like ALP (Middle-Tech) have been introduced, integrating both academic and vocational skills to improve retention and outcomes. Despite the progress, the report highlights substantial regional disparities, particularly in enrollment rates across remote and underserved areas. According to the Pakistan Economic Survey, female literacy remains significantly lower than male literacy, especially in rural Balochistan, where only 31% of women are literate. The latest UN report ranks Pakistan 164th out of 193 countries on the Human Development Index (HDI), and 144th out of 173 on the Human Capital Index (HCI), with education being a key contributing factor. Among the report's key recommendations is the expansion of ALP programs, particularly the Middle-Tech model, which boasts a 70% completion rate.
Business Recorder
09-07-2025
- Business Recorder
Unemployment
EDITORIAL: Unemployment is as high as 22 percent, according to academician Dr Hafiz A Pasha, citing the first-ever digitally-held seventh Population and Housing Census 2023 — higher for males at around 30 percent and 17 to 18 percent amongst women. The discrepancy in the unemployment rate between males and females requires clarification as perhaps the lower unemployment rate for women is limited to those actively seeking a job, which is difficult to assess, given the fact that women's contribution to the GDP is undervalued in most economies as their output in the home and the agriculture sector is not quantified. Be that as it may, Dr Pasha proceeded to challenge the Labour Force Survey by stating that it consisted of a sample, which was less than one percent that led him to conclude that the higher unemployment rate reflected the increased unemployment amongst the youth — a source of concern that perhaps reflects the increase in crime rates throughout the country in recent months. The high unemployment rate is partly on the back of a low Gross Domestic Product growth for the past three years, lower than the regional average, which is attributable to the tight monetary and fiscal policy conditions set by the International Monetary Fund and agreed by the economic team leaders. In 2022-23, growth was negative 0.2 percent (against 6.2 percent the year before) followed by 2.5 percent in 2023-24 (on the back of a low base the year before) and 2.8 percent in 2024-25 — a growth rate that does not reflect (i) a rise in revenue collections, given the decline from 12.6 percent of GDP in 2023-24 to 11.7 percent in 2024-25 as per the recent Economic Survey or (ii) a decline in negativity in large-scale manufacturing sector, which registered negative 1.52 percent July-April 2025 against 0.26 percent in the comparable period the year before. The unemployment statistic as well as other quality of life indices require an urgent focus by the economic team leaders who disturbingly appear to be focused entirely on incurring debt — be it from friendly countries or from multilaterals — to contain the budget deficit while raising revenue targets each year to be achieved through raising taxes mainly on existing taxpayers and bringing more items under the sales tax net (an indirect tax whose incidence on the poor is greater than on the rich). The bravado displayed by previous finance ministers as well as chair of the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), including the incumbents, that they would ensure enforcement of tax measures to generate higher revenue is misplaced as it belies an obvious fact: the ongoing heavy reliance on indirect taxes for revenue generation (inclusive of withholding taxes in the sales tax mode and dishonestly crediting them under direct taxes as well as the high petroleum levy payable by the common man though not collected by the FBR and placed under other taxes) is crippling the capacity of the common man to sustain his quality of life. The current Chairman of the FBR threatened tax evaders (illegal) and avoiders (an outcome of the lacunae provided by the tax system) that he would not let anyone off the hook must be appreciated though unfortunately he then proceeded to give the example of indirect taxes payable by the sugar millers who, he claimed, were evading taxes which, one may assume, were passed onto the end consumers that no doubt account for the 40 percent increase in sugar prices since November 2024. What is urgently required is a shift away from reliance on indirect taxes and on direct taxes. And what must be a further source of concern for the cabinet is the rise in poverty levels to a very disturbing 44.2 percent as determined by the World Bank. It is imperative for the government to look holistically at the economy rather than at the rate of inflation (which has certainly come down) and the debt-based foreign exchange reserves. At present, the latest macroeconomic data indicates a recession that the general public is too hard-pressed to withstand. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
