Only ‘minimal force' used, says Taiping prison officer
KUALA LUMPUR : A Taiping prison officer testifying in the Human Rights Commission of Malaysia's (Suhakam) inquiry into alleged rights abuse, described 'minimal force' as an action that does not lead to death.
Hairie Jumri, who was shown CCTV footage of him repeatedly hitting inmates in an incident on Jan 17, claimed that he was emotionally unstable at the time, but insisted his actions fell within what he considered 'minimal force'.
He said the action he and his fellow officers took had been triggered by the inmates who hurled profanities at them and threatened to harm their families.
Questioned on whether repeated blows could still be considered minimal force, Hairie said the term was 'subjective'.
Suhakam inquiry officer Simon Karunagaram asked the prisons enforcement assistant to define minimal force.
Simon: Could you define what is 'minimal force'?
Hairie: Not dead.
Simon: Let's say I punch your eyes and they swell, your vision becomes blurry three days later, would that be minimal force?
Hairie: Yes.
Simon: In an image (from the CCTV footage), there was an inmate with blood on his head. Would you say that it was due to minimal action?
Hairie: Maybe. Maybe he hit a pole. Maybe it was blood from someone else who knocked his head against a pole.
Hairie also disagreed that excessive force had been inflicted on one of the inmates who died during the incident.
Asked by Suhakam chairman Hishamudin Yunus why he kicked an inmate who already appeared weak, Hairie admitted that he was not in the right state of mind at the time.
Hishamudin: Let's say you were stable and 'sane', you wouldn't do that?
Hairie: Yes.
Hishamudin: So your action was an action of someone who's not sane?
Hairie: Yes.
The inquiry into the alleged abuse of more than 100 inmates by about 60 wardens in the Jan 17 incident is scheduled to resume on Aug 6.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
5 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Police detain doctor's wife and sons, seize RM420,000 worth of cannabis at Kelantan home
KOTA BHARU, Aug 10 — Two men, the sons of a doctor, and their mother have been detained in connection with the seizure of 35 kilogrammes of compressed cannabis and a pistol in a raid at a house in Kampung But, Ketereh here yesterday. Kelantan Police chief Datuk Mohd Yusoff Mamat said the stepbrothers, aged 24 and 34, who work as assistants at their father's clinic, and the 46-year-old housewife were picked up at 4.30am. 'Checks at the house found six boxes containing compressed blocks of dried plant material suspected to be cannabis and two bags containing the same drug weighing 35kg, worth about RM299,590. 'Also seized was a Glock pistol with 16 bullets and a casing, estimated to be worth RM5,000,' he told a press conference at the Kelantan Police Contingent headquarters here today. Mohd Yusoff said four vehicles — a BMW 523i, a Mercedes-Benz C200, a Perodua Bezza and a Naza Ria — worth a total of RM116,000 were also confiscated, bringing the total estimated value of the seizures to RM420,000. Mohd Yusoff said the syndicate is believed to have been active since 2023, using the house as storage before distributing the drugs via courier services. The quantity seized could supply about 35,000 addicts. 'The men tested positive for methamphetamine and ketamine while their mother tested negative,' he said, adding that all suspects have been remanded for seven days starting August 6 for investigation under Section 39B of the Dangerous Drugs Act 1952. In a separate case, Mohd Yusoff said the General Operations Force Battalion 7 seized a revolver, 30 live bullets and a casing from a Thai couple at a house in Pengkalan Kubor on July 25. The married couple, aged 40 and 30, did not possess a valid firearms licence and had entered Malaysia illegally. He said they were detained for investigation under the Firearms (Increased Penalties) Act 1971 and the Immigration Act 1959/63.— Bernama
Malay Mail
6 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Penang cops book Kepala Batas hardware trader under three laws after upside-down Jalur Gemilang uproar
KEPALA BATAS, Aug 10 — Police detained the owner of a hardware store in Jalan Bertam Perdana here, following a flap over the Jalur Gemilang being flown upside down in front of his premises yesterday. Acting Penang police chief Datuk Mohd Alwi Zainal Abidin said the arrest of the 59-year-old man was made last night in the Kepala Batas area. 'The case is being investigated under Section 5 of the Emblems and Names (Prevention of Improper Use) Act 1963, Section 14 of the Minor Offences Act 1955, and Section 233 of the Communications and Multimedia Act 1988. 'The investigation papers will be referred to the Penang deputy public prosecutor's office tomorrow with a proposed charge,' he said in a statement today. Mohd Alwi stated that so far, police have received 16 reports regarding the incident, 12 of which were lodged in the state, while the other four were reported outside the Penang contingent. He said the police view such acts seriously and reminded the public to respect the Jalur Gemilang as a symbol of national sovereignty. Yesterday, a 21-second video went viral on social media showing two men at a hardware store here, who appeared to have deliberately installed and hoisted the Jalur Gemilang upside down, earning the wrath of netizens. Following this, several non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and Bertam assemblyman Datuk Seri Reezal Merican Naina Merican filed a police report. — Bernama
Malay Mail
6 hours ago
- Malay Mail
Penang supermarket baby-snatching suspect under police remand till Aug 13
BUTTERWORTH, Aug 10 — A Vietnamese man who allegedly tried to snatch an 11-month-old baby while fleeing after being caught stealing from a supermarket in Telaga Air yesterday has been remanded for four days. Seberang Perai Utara police chief ACP Anuar Abd Rahman said the 36-year-old security guard was remanded until Aug 13 to facilitate investigations under Section 380 of the Penal Code for theft, Section 324 for causing hurt, and Section 506 for criminal intimidation. 'The suspect tested negative for drugs, and he has no prior record,' Anuar told Bernama. A video of the incident has gone viral, showing the suspect holding a plastic bag and a knife, trying to pull the baby from a woman's arms. The incident happened at 12.45 pm when a supermarket supervisor caught the man trying to leave with some weighed seafood without paying. As the supervisor intervened, the suspect broke free and grabbed the baby while brandishing a knife. Staff and shoppers quickly overpowered and handed him over to the police when they arrived at the scene. — Bernama
