Lawyer's bid to prosecute journalist over Sophie Toscan du Plantier case dismissed
Robert Sheehan, who worked with the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP) in 2001, sought to bring a case against journalist and author Senan Molony, alleging professional vilification through comments made in Sophie: The Final Verdict , a book published in 2024.
Mr Sheehan also alleged that comments made by Taoiseach Micheál Martin at the book's launch had damaged his reputation. During the event, Mr Martin reportedly questioned aspects of the Irish justice system's handling of the Bailey case.
This week, Judge Ann Watkin of the Dún Laoghaire District Court declined to issue a summons against Mr Molony. The judge found that the journalist's criticisms were directed at the legal process more broadly and did not provide grounds for a criminal prosecution.
The DPP had previously determined that the material submitted by Mr Sheehan did not disclose any offence that could be prosecuted in the courts.
Mr Sheehan has indicated that he may appeal the decision to the Circuit Court or to the European Court of Human Rights.
His complaint centred on remarks in the book and at the launch event that he believes called into question his actions and conclusions while working on the Bailey case.
Speaking at the launch in September 2023, Mr Martin is understood to have expressed concern at how the case was handled, saying it was difficult to understand why authorities had not pursued a prosecution.
Sophie Toscan du Plantier, a French film producer who was found dead outside her holiday home in West Cork in December 1996.
Ian Bailey, a journalist who was long considered the main suspect by gardaí, was never charged in Ireland despite being arrested and questioned twice. In 2019, a French court convicted him in absentia and sentenced him to 25 years in prison. The Irish State declined to extradite him.
Mr Bailey died in January 2024 in Co. Cork, at the age of 66. He always totally denied any involvement in the case.
More recently, director Jim Sheridan premiered a dramatised film based on the case— Re-Creation —at the Tribeca Film Festival. Mr Sheridan has publicly expressed supreme doubt over Mr Bailey's guilt, describing the situation as a 'double injustice' in which both families had suffered. While acknowledging Mr Bailey's history of domestic violence, Mr Sheridan maintained that this should not be conflated with responsibility for the murder.
The murder of Sophie Toscan du Plantier, a French film producer found bludgeoned outside her holiday home in West Cork in December 1996, remains one of Ireland's most infamous unsolved crimes.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
10 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Two Irish teens, 18, arrested over ‘unprovoked' street attack on grandfather, 71, & grandson in popular tourist hotspot
The pair have since paid €2,000 bail and have been freed BRUTAL ASSAULT Two Irish teens, 18, arrested over 'unprovoked' street attack on grandfather, 71, & grandson in popular tourist hotspot TWO teenagers have been arrested over a brutal street attack on an Irish grandfather and his grandson in a popular Majorcan holiday resort. The 18-year-olds, who are also from Ireland, were held after witnesses told police they had seen them kicking and punching their compatriots following an earlier row in a tattoo parlour. Advertisement The violent incident occurred in Santa Ponsa near Magaluf. The 71-year-old victim and his 20-year-old grandson were taken to hospital, with the elder of the two men needing an emergency operation after suffering several facial fractures. The two tourists held were remanded to a local jail after appearing before a judge in court, although they have since paid €2,000 bail and have been freed while a judicial investigation continues. The Civil Guard has yet to make any official comment about the incident. Advertisement READ MORE IRISH NEWS DO NOT EAT Full list of every herb sold in Dunnes, Lidl, Aldi & Tesco after listeria recall Local paper Diario de Mallorca described the early-hours attack at the end of last month as 'unprovoked'. It said it occurred after the Irish teenagers were kicked out of a tattoo parlour in the resort's Ramon de Montcada Street after starting to insult and threaten staff and customers. They are said to have told the men they allegedly went on to physically attack: 'What are you looking at? Do you want a fight?' They reportedly waited outside with six other friends for 40 minutes and ambushed their alleged victims as they walked back to their hotel. Advertisement It has been reported that the the teenagers continued to kick and punch them after knocking them to the ground. The assault is said to have occurred outside an unnamed fast food restaurant where witnesses afterwards gave police a description of what had happened. The teenagers, who are still being investigated although they are thought to have been given permission to return to Ireland, spent only a few hours behind bars before managing to stump up their bail bond. SANTA PONSA FATAL CRASH Separately, at the weekend it emerged an Irish tourist had been involved in a fatal crash in Santa Ponsa. Advertisement The 38-year-old was at the wheel of a rental car which collided head-on with a 51-year-old German cyclist in the town on July 31. Police spent nearly half an hour trying to save the man knocked off his bike. Paramedics arrived a short time later and confirmed he was deceased. No arrests are believed to have been made although a local judge has opened an investigation into the accident. Advertisement It happened just before 5pm on July 31 at the intersection of Ramon de Moncada Street and Bartomeu Rossello Planas Street.
Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Irish family shocked by message from assisted dying clinic
An Irish family has been left reeling after allegedly receiving a text message from a suicide clinic in Switzerland informing them that their mother was dead, and her ashes would be arriving in the post. 58-year-old Maureen Slough, based in Co Cavan, travelled to the Pegasos clinic on July 8, telling her family she was going to Lithuania with a friend, according to the Irish Independent. However, the woman's daughter, Megan, says she was shocked when she received a WhatsApp message saying her mother had died listening to gospel music sung by Elvis Presley, while her family believed she was holidaying in Lithuania. Maureen Slough, a 58-year-old mother from Cavan who reportedly took her own life at the Pegasos clinic, and her daughter Megan Royal. Pic: Facebook Now her family is demanding answers to find out why their mother, who they say attempted suicide a year earlier following the deaths of her two sisters, was able to seek assisted dying without the family being informed. Her daughter Megan told the Irish Independent that she had to track her mother's ashes through the postal system. It's reported that after the shock of finding out Ms Slough had travelled alone to Switzerland and paid a reported £13,000 to the Pegasos Swiss Association to facilitate her death two days later, the family began investigating how this could have happened They were shocked to find that Pegasos accepted their mother's application, considering her long history of mental illness, and claimed the clinic did not inform the family of her plan. Ms Slough allegedly travelled alone to Switzerland and paid £13,000 to the Pegasos Swiss Association to facilitate her death two days later. Pic: Facebook But the Pegasos group has allegedly said that it received a letter from Ms Slough's daughter, Megan, saying she was aware of her mother's desire to die and that she had accepted her decision, something Megan has denied. The clinic also claimed it verified the authenticity of the letter through an email response to Ms Royal, using an email address supplied by her mother, but Megan insists she never wrote such a letter or verified any contact from the clinic, and the family claim their mother may have forged the letter and then verified it using an email address she created herself. This is not the first time the non-profit assisted dying clinic Pegasos has attracted controversy. Alistair Hamilton with his mother Judith. Pic: ITV In 2023, Alistair Hamilton, a 47-year-old teacher from the UK, with no diagnosed illness, took his own life at the Swiss clinic, without the knowledge of his family, and after that case, Pegasos reportedly promised it would always contact a person's relatives before carrying out assisted death. His mother, Judith, later visited the clinic where her son had died to look for answers. Since 1942, under Swiss Law, people have been allowed to help others to die, as long as their motives are not for personal gain, such as an inheritance or other form of monetary gain. The law states that the person wishing to die must be of sound mind, but they do not need to be terminally ill or have any medical conditions. The country's assisted suicide clinics are non-profit organisations. Earlier this year, British MPs voted to change the suicide law in the UK and allow terminally ill people in England and Wales the choice to end their lives.
Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Outrage as man lights cigarette at Arc de Triomphe war memorial
A Moroccan man is facing deportation from France after sparking national outrage by lighting a cigarette using the Eternal Flame at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier beneath the Arc de Triomphe in Paris. The incident, which took place on Tuesday morning, was caught on camera and quickly circulated across social media platforms. The 47-year-old suspect can be seen climbing over a chain barrier and leaning over the flame to ignite his cigarette – an act widely condemned as deeply disrespectful. The famous Arc de Triomphe in Paris. Pic: Getty Images The move triggered swift backlash from French officials, with the country's interior minister, Bruno Retailleau, declaring on X: 'This unworthy and deplorable act undermines the memory of those who died for France.' L'homme qui a profané la tombe du Soldat inconnu en allumant une cigarette avec la flamme du souvenir a été interpellé à Paris pour violation de sépulture, tombeau, urne ou monument édifié à la mémoire des morts. Il a été placé en garde à vue et a reconnu les faits. À la suite du… — Bruno Retailleau (@BrunoRetailleau) August 5, 2025 Patricia Miralles, Minister for War Veterans, also condemned the act in the strongest terms: 'What happened is not a mere misstep, but a desecration. 'France will never tolerate the tarnishing of the memory of those who died for her. Never.' Arc de Triomphe war memorial. Pic: Getty According to Le Figaro, the man is a homeless Moroccan national whose residence permit will now be revoked. Initially denying responsibility, he later admitted to being the man seen in the viral footage. Police have charged him with 'violating a burial site, tomb, cinerary urn, or monument erected in memory of the dead' – an offence in France that carries a potential sentence of up to one year in prison and a €15,000 fine. Local media reports reveal that the man is well known to police, with 21 prior entries in France's criminal record processing file, including offences such as car theft, vandalism, violence, and public insults motivated by race.
