
Inside the nasty private club fight tearing one of America's richest ZIP codes apart — even a supermodel has been kicked out
Fisher Island – once home to Oprah Winfrey and favored by tennis greats including Boris Becker and Caroline Wozniacki – is one of America's most exclusive ZIP codes and can only be accessed by helicopter or boat, but the drama on-island matches the size of resident's bank accounts.
The 216-acre enclave, located just south of Miami Beach, boasts its own private school, medical clinic, and gourmet market. Apartments go for $4 million, while houses range from $6 million all the way up to $85 million for a top penthouse.
Advertisement
10 Victoria's Secret model Karolina Kurkova and property broker husband Archie Drury have been expelled from the Fisher Island Club, igniting a nasty legal battle.
Getty Images
10 The exclusive island is just south of Miami beach and comes with a hefty price tag — condos start at $4m.
Getty Images
Access to this elite world hinges on membership in the Fisher Island Club, a non-profit which sources say owns nearly every amenity: golf, tennis courts, restaurants, a spa and gym, and a beach club.
Advertisement
Equity membership costs $350,000 plus $38,000 in annual dues and without membership,
residents effectively can't even shop for groceries.
Sources tell The Post the club also keeps a tight rein on its members.
Various WhatsApp group chats discuss the club, but we hear since December, the club has suspended or expelled members after accusing some of creating 'disharmony' with their comments.
Advertisement
A member of several years told The Post, 'It's different from revoking your club membership at La Gorce [another exclusive club on Miami Beach] or something.
'You can golf somewhere else. Here, you literally have to pack up your home and leave.'
In response, the club told The Post: 'Discussion and debate is not uncommon among Club members and is encouraged, not discouraged. Not a single member has been expelled for speaking out against the Board.'
However, one email in December accused members of 'sowing discord'.
Advertisement
10 Kurkova and her husband own multiple properties on the island and were members of the club until 2023. In their lawsuit they claim the club retaliated againsst them because Archie started his own property company.
Getty Images
10 Fisher Island, with the southern tip of Miami Beach in the background. The only ways onto the island are via boat or helicopter.
Getty Images
'We strongly urge Members to cease any attempts to undermine and disrupt the Club's
capital projects,' the board wrote, 'and also to end aggressive attacks on Club leadership — or risk a 30-day Membership suspension.'
Some called the message 'threatening' and 'frightening' in the 'Let's Renovate Fisher' WhatsApp group.
Another member, who asked not to be IDed, added: 'If you lose your membership here, you're cut off from your entire social life, your entire town.'
In March the board sent another email warning: 'While free speech is a right, the use of free speech as a tool to incite disharmony is not.'
'If you ask too many questions, you're going to be suspended,' the longtime member alleged.
Advertisement
10 Tennis legend Boris Becker has a vacation apartment on the island, and is one of its celebrity residents.
EPA
10 Danish tennis star Caroline Wozniacki and her former NBA player husband David Lee put their $43 million home on the island up for sale in 2024.
Getty Images
The club denies this, saying: 'The Club has neither silenced nor retaliated against any Club member for voicing an opinion.'
The warnings come in the wake of an increasingly nasty legal suit filed by Victoria's Secret supermodel Karolina Kurkova, 41, and her husband, Archie Drury, 54 – which has been the talk of the island ever since.
Advertisement
In January, the club's board voted to expel the couple, alleging they tried to defraud them by trying to transfer one of their memberships to a tenant.
They filed suit a month later alleging unlawful expulsion and retaliation against Drury – once one of the island's top real estate agents at Douglas Elliman – for starting his own real estate firm.
Their lawsuit accuses the club of 'threats and coercion,' claiming one of the couple's employees was allegedly asked to provide false testimony against them, or risk losing their apartment and privileges on the island.
The lawsuit states the couple had lived for more than a decade as members of the club on Fisher Island, where they have bought multiple properties, until 2023 when Drury formed his real estate company.
Advertisement
The lawsuit states: 'The Defendants' conduct has and continues to cause [Kurkov and Drury] substantial harm both personally and professionally, including by preventing Plaintiff Drury from engaging in his trade as a real estate broker on Fisher Island.'
10 Fisher Island Country Club maintains they kicked Kurkova and Drury out for good reason, and they had been warned of their conduct for years.
10 A penthouse in one Fisher Island's condos would set you back a cool $85 million.
However, since the lawsuit has been filed, the club has defended its position and filed to strike and dismiss what it calls a 'sham pleading'.
Advertisement
In their motion to strike the suit, the Fisher Island Club maintain the couple were properly expelled 'after years of misconduct' and had ignored multiple warnings about their behavior.
One of the more bizarre incidents cited in court papers is that Drury allegedly stole another member's white Range Rover in Nov. 2023 – while he claims he simply mistook it for another car he was allowed to drive. The club disputes that, and claims he changed his story about what happened.
The incident caused the club to suspend Drury, which was extended after he allegedly violated the terms of suspension.
The rebuttal papers further accuse Drury of 'inappropriate conduct towards Club members (such as physically threatening another member and giving him the middle finger) [and] 'screaming' at a Club employee.'
Regarding Drury's suspension, the club claims in its court papers: 'Drury did not object to his suspension after it was imposed, nor did he timely institute an action challenging it.'
The couple maintain in their filing they bought a second membership to the club and should be allowed under its rules to designate that membership to a tenant.
The papers also claim that as a result of Drury's 'disruptive behavior' the Club even hired armed security and issued him a cease-and-desist letter for trespassing, after he had been expelled in January.
10 Kurkova and Drury. He told The Post their lawsuit is about more than his family's expulsion, saying: ''I want to make people feel safe to speak up.'
Getty Images for EJAF
10 Kurkova, who was born in the Czech Republic, has two children with Drury. They say they have since relocated from the island.
Getty Images
The scathing rebuttal to the lawsuit accuses Drury and Kurkova of 'Piling one defective claim on top of another … a transparent attempt to seek to strong-arm the Club into reinstating Plaintiffs' appropriately cancelled memberships … and garner public support of Plaintiffs' false narrative against the Club, and in effect steal from the Club's members by seeking damages from the Club.'
A judge has yet to rule on what will happen with the suit, which currently remains active.
In an interview with the Post, Drury said the conflict has hurt his family's livelihood and
forced them to uproot their kids and move.
But for him, the lawsuit is bigger than his family. 'I want to make people feel safe to speak up,' he said.
Kurkova's spokesperson, Melanie Bonvicino, called Fisher Island a community under siege in a statement to The Post.
The Fisher Island Club also isn't the only private club accused of cracking down on dissent. In June, a couple sued a club in the Keys, saying it expelled them after they challenged its leadership.
Such clubs' 'rampant abuses of power' have led to 'autocratic control over residents' daily lives,' Jennifer Altman, Kurkova and Drury's lawyer, claimed.
In its response to The Post, the Fisher Island Club expressed confidence in its pending court motion and said it believes Drury and Kurkova's suit 'remains deficient and is also subject to dismissal.'
Meanwhile, the island's millionaires looking on are chugging their way through plenty of popcorn as they await the result.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New York Post
19 minutes ago
- New York Post
Vanessa Hudgens pregnant, expecting 2nd baby with Cole Tucker
We're soarin', flyin' over this baby news. On Saturday, Vanessa Hudgens announced that she and her husband, Cole Tucker, are expecting their second child together. The two welcomed their first child in July 2024. 'Round two!!!!,' the 'High School Musical' alum, 36, wrote on Instagram beneath a carousel of maternity pictures. Advertisement 7 Vanessa Hudgens pregnant with her first child. Instagram/vanessahudgens In the snaps, Hudgens and Tucker, 29, donned matching white outfits as they posed outdoors. One photo showed the baseball star pointing to the singer's stomach, while another shot had the couple holding hands and smiling. Friends immediately flocked to the comments section to share their excitement. Advertisement 7 Vanessa Hudgens poses while expecting her first child. Instagram/vanessahudgens Fellow Disney Channel alum Aly Michalka wrote, 'Omg!!!!!!!! Congrats,' while Jenna Dewan chimed in, 'Ohhhhh congratulations my love!!' Corey Cott, who Hudgens starred in the Broadway show 'Gigi' with, penned, 'Congrats V!' Advertisement Days before the baby announcement, the 'Spring Breakers' actress shouted out the athlete in a sweet social media post. 7 Vanessa Hudgens attends the 96th Annual Academy Awards on March 10, 2024. FilmMagic 'Happy birthday to my best friend/lover/partner in life,' Hudgens gushed. '@cotuck you're everything to meeeeeee. No one does it better. 🥳🎂😘.' Tucker replied, 'You're the best mama thank you ❤️.' Advertisement The pair first met in 2020 on a Zoom meditation group. 7 Vanessa Hudgens and Cole Tucker. Getty Images for Thomas Ashbourne A year later, Tucker opened up about Hudgens for the first time during an MLB spring training interview. 'I got a girlfriend and she's cool. She's awesome, I love her,' he said, according to KDKA. 'But I don't want it to be, 'Oh, Cole's dating Vanessa … '' 'I don't want it to be treated any differently than Mitch [Keller] having his wife down, or Ke'Bryan [Hayes] having his girlfriend come down,' noted Tucker. 'She's great. She'll be around. You will see her, but you saw the headline, it is what it is.' 7 Vanessa Hudgens and Cole Tucker poses with their dog. Instagram/Cole Tucker Months later, Hudgens echoed her partner's sentiments. 'He's just kind of perfect for me,' she explained to Entertainment Tonight. 'I am [happy]. I really am. I think that it's also so important to stay grateful for everything that you have in life. I've been making that a priority, and I feel like it's just been making magic happen all the more.' Advertisement Hudgens and Tucker went on to tie the knot in 2023 in Tulum, Mexico. 'I felt like I was transported to some kind of utopia, unlike anything I had ever been to before,' she told Vogue about their nuptials in 2023. 'It was whimsical and magical, and I just fell in love.' 7 Cole Tucker and Vanessa Hudgens at the 2025 Vanity Fair Oscar Party. Getty Images Last July, TMZ was the first to report the news that Hudgens had given birth. Advertisement 'We're disappointed that our family's privacy was disrespected and exploited during this very special time due to the greed of a long lens camera feeding the media,' the 'Princess Switch' alum wrote on her Instagram Stories on July 4. Hudgens added, 'Despite all of that, mom dad and baby are happy and healthy.' 7 Vanessa Hudgens and Cole Tucker smile together. Advertisement The husband and wife recently enjoyed a date night out in March while at the Vanity Fair Oscar Party in Beverly Hills. Tucker and Hudgens were photographed kissing on the carpet before heading into the star-studded bash.


New York Post
19 minutes ago
- New York Post
‘Superman' flies into first place on its opening day, obliterating any competition
'Superman' didn't just fly — the film almost destroyed the competition. The movie was the superhero of Friday's box office with The Man of Steel rocketing to the top spot. On its opening day, it raked in a heroic $56.5 million, according to The Numbers. The Post called the film — 'entertaining,' and its star David Corenswet 'an instantly likable upgrade,' but said its director, James Gunn, 'goes overboard with silliness at times.' It had the second largest opening day in 2025 behind 'A Minecraft Movie,' and is slated to earn up to a total of $120 million this weekend. 3 'Superman' star David Corenswet graduated from Juilliard in 2016. ©Warner Bros/Courtesy Everett Collection 'Jurassic World Rebirth' came in second, taking in $11.37 million on Friday, its second in theaters. The prehistoric flick, the seventh installment in the 'Jurassic Park' franchise, had a reported production budget of $180 million. 3 'Jurassic World Rebirth' is Scarlett Johansson's first film in the 'Jurassic Park' franchise. ©Universal/Courtesy Everett Collection Landing in third place was 'F1: The Movie,' with sales of $3.7 million. The Brad Pitt-driven film has already become Apple's highest-grossing ever, dethroning 2023's 'Napoleon' by earning $293 million globally in just 10 days. 3 'F1: The Movie,' starring Brad Pitt as a Formula One driver, is Apple's highest grossing film. AP 'How to Train Your Dragon' moved down a spot to fourth, with $2.3 million in revenue on its fifth Friday in theaters. Disney and Pixar's 'Elio' also fell a notch to fifth, but still with a healthy $1.2 million-dollar take.


New York Post
39 minutes ago
- New York Post
Melissa Gilbert reveals moment her birth father ‘knew' she was his child
After Melissa Gilbert's biological father saw her on television, he knew that the young actress was his child. The former child star, who played Laura Ingalls Wilder in 'Little House on the Prairie,' recently appeared on her co-star Patrick Labyorteaux's podcast, 'The Patrick LabyorSheaux.' She described what it was like getting in contact with her birth father after she welcomed her son Dakota in 1989. 'I didn't tell him who I was, and then he asked me, 'Well, who are you? What do you do?'' Gilbert recalled. 'And I said, 'Well, here's the thing… Did you ever watch 'Little House on the Prairie?' And he said, 'You're Laura, aren't you? I knew it.' He knew it.' 'He could see,' the 61-year-old shared. 'And when I met my half-siblings, we all looked alike. So you could definitely see it… It's pretty clear.' Labyorteaux, who was also adopted, said he had a similar experience. Like Gilbert, his birth mother died before he was able to find her. 'I never met her, but I met her family, who was a stepfamily,' the actor explained. 'She had three kids that she had inherited from the husband that she married. So, she had three kids, but they weren't her biological kids. She only had one biological kid… They would watch 'Little House' and when I would show up… because of my eyes, they would go, 'Oh, that's probably your kid.' And they would make fun of her like that… They were right.' 6 'Little House on the Prairie' actress Melissa Gilbert said her biological father saw her on television and knew she was his child. Getty Images for BAM 6 'He said, 'You're Laura, aren't you? I knew it.' He knew it,' Gilbert said about her dad. Courtesy Everett Collection Gilbert was adopted by actors Barbara Cowan and Paul Gilbert. Her biological parents were also in entertainment. According to the star, her birth mother was an exotic dancer and her father was a stock car racer and musician. 6 Melissa Gilbert in 'Little House on the Prairie' in 1974. Courtesy Everett Collection 'It was pretty clear that it was in me,' said Gilbert on pursuing showbiz. '… All the kids are performers on both sides of that family. So it was genetic and environmental.' 'They were each married to other people and had three children each and ran off together and conceived me on a motorcycle trip in the desert,' she said. 'Explains a lot. And then they left their spouses for each other and got married after [getting] pregnant with me and moved all the kids in, so I was number seven. So, the decision was made to put me up for adoption.' As Gilbert got older, she yearned to discover her roots. 6 'I realized there's got to be more,' the actress said about connecting to her roots after giving birth to her son. GC Images 'When I saw [my son Dakota] for the first time, I went, 'Oh my God, he had my eyebrows, and he had my lips, and I've never seen anyone that looked like me,'' said Gilbert. 'And then I realized there's got to be more.' Her family background wasn't the only thing that Gilbert faced after 'Little House' came to an end. In the podcast, she described how, as an adult, many fans still expected her to be Laura Ingalls. 'It was weird,' Gilbert admitted. 'I think people still, almost into my 40s, always kind of half expected a 12-year-old to come in with a fishing pole [and in] gingham. And that, at that time, to me, felt like a weakness.' Gilbert said it was a 'shock factor' when people realized that she was 'a full-grown adult with opinions and ideas that are smart and work.' For her, it was important to have an identity outside of Hollywood. 6 'I think people still, almost into my 40s, always kind of half expected a 12-year-old to come in with a fishing pole [and in] gingham,' Gilbert said about people wanting her to be Laura Ingalls. Courtesy Everett Collection '[As child actors] we either grow up super sheltered and don't know how to do things like wash dishes, or [be] super overexposed and exploited,' she said. Gilbert added that the second group are the ones that end up struggling with 'the big problems.' Keep up with today's most important news Stay up on the very latest with Evening Update. Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters So at age 22, she moved to New York City to appear in an Off-Broadway play. 'There I was at 22, living on my own with my cat and my dog in New York City, and completely unprepared to live on my own entirely. Completely,' she said. '… I had to figure out how to do so much stuff that I had no clue about,' she shared. 'Like, I didn't realize that you could break a $100 bill at a bodega, and you didn't have to go to a bank. It's little things like that… At one point, [I] let the dishes pile up in my sink so bad, and I didn't have a dishwasher, so I threw them out and bought new dishes. On my $700 a week salary at that point.' Still, Gilbert had fond memories of growing up on the set of 'Little House.' 'Our set was as kid-friendly as a set could be at that time,' she said. 'Even with all the adult shenanigans going on, we were sort of protected from a lot of that. I didn't know half the stuff that the grown-ups were doing until they started writing books about it.' Back in 2024, Gilbert told Fox News Digital she had to eventually leave Los Angeles to age gracefully. 6 'Our set was as kid-friendly as a set could be at that time,' Gilbert said about her time on 'Little House.' Courtesy Everett Collection 'I looked at myself in the mirror several years back,' the 61-year-old recalled at the time. 'I was living in Los Angeles, and I did not recognize who I was. I had overfilled my face and my lips. My forehead didn't move. I was still dyeing my hair red. I was driving a Mustang convertible. I was a size two in an unhealthy way. I looked like a frozen version of my younger self, and that's not who I was.' Every morning, the NY POSTcast offers a deep dive into the headlines with the Post's signature mix of politics, business, pop culture, true crime and everything in between. Subscribe here! 'I was stuck,' Gilbert admitted. 'I could feel myself fighting it. And I said to myself, 'It's time to age.' I had to leave Los Angeles to do that – not Hollywood – Los Angeles specifically.' Gilbert said she and her husband, actor Timothy Busfield, moved to his home state of Michigan following their wedding in 2013. They lived there for five years. She felt free to finally age. 'I stopped coloring my hair,' she explained. 'I had [my] breast implants removed. I decided to just be the best, healthiest version of myself without this pressure to look a certain way, and it paid off in a huge way.' 'I finally found my feet as a woman, fully, 100 percent strong in my own knowledge, in my own accomplishments. Everything got easier. And a bonus? I have a lot more free time not staring in a mirror, sitting in a dermatologist's chair, or sitting in a hair chair.' In 2019, Gilbert and Busfield purchased a rustic cottage on 14 acres in the Catskill Mountains. Life today is 'incredibly fulfilling,' she said. 'It's remarkable,' Gilbert gushed. 'I love being this age. There are things about it that are not a lot of fun. I don't like it when my ankles ache in the morning or my skin's drier. Aging is not for sissies, but it is certainly better than the alternative. And I've never felt better in my skin.'