Mid-air collision draws attention to military helicopter training, previous accidents

Associated Press

30-01-2025

To learn to fly a military helicopter is to take a master class in multitasking.
You need both hands and both feet to control the aircraft while keeping a close eye on the horizon and your altitude. If it's nighttime and you're flying low, you may be scanning the ground for familiar landmarks using night-vision goggles while also checking GPS instruments.
'You have six to seven radios to mess with,' said retired U.S. Army Lt. Col. Darin Gaub, who flew Black Hawk helicopters for 22 years. 'You're using everything. And by the way, you're also supposed to fly the aircraft, which is why most military aircraft are crewed by a minimum of two pilots.'
The training for U.S. military helicopter pilots is getting heightened attention in the wake of Wednesday night's fatal mid-air collision between an Army Black Hawk helicopter and a passenger jet in the skies above Washington.
The accident follows a dozen fatal crashes during Army Black Hawk training missions since January 2014 that have claimed the lives of 47 service members.
But former military helicopter pilots and experts stood by the nation's rigorous military training Thursday, insisting that it's the world's best.
Intense training in the classroom and sky
The education includes intense classroom training about aerodynamics, aircraft systems and the many things that can go wrong, said Mark Miller, an associate professor at the College of Aviation at Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University on its Honolulu campus, and a former Marine helicopter pilot.
'There are real idiosyncrasies on just landing the helicopter,' he said. 'You can actually flip over a helicopter really easily if you don't know what you're doing. But you become very well-versed in that stuff. And then you learn as you go. And you can actually see these things happen and know what to do.'
Pilots are trained to fly visually by looking out of the windows and to fly using their instruments in bad weather and at night. The instruments can include an attitude indicator that informs the pilot of the helicopter's orientation in relation to the horizon as well GPS instruments and night vision goggles.
'You get that instrument scan down right away, sometimes painfully so,' Miller said of the training. 'It's not that easy. And then you get it to the point where you're proficient at it. And at night, you use those instruments all the time.'
Challenges of flying near Ronald Reagan National Airport
Pilots operating around Reagan National Airport face unique challenges and must have a 'heightened level of awareness' when navigating the area, said Clint Balog, an associate professor at Embry-Riddle.
The Washington-area airport, known to pilots by its abbreviation DCA, is relatively small and doused in light pollution from the surrounding metropolitan area, said Balog, who has flown dozens of corporate flights in and out of the airport.
'In DCA, whenever I've flown in there, I found that the light pollution there is among the worst I've flown into,' he said. It's always pretty bad, especially early at night.'
Balog said pilots have to be precise, especially when landing, because that light can distort the surroundings. He said other cities also have light pollution but the compactness of Reagan Airport intensifies the potential confusion.
'All the lighting starts to look the same,' he said.
Gaub, the retired Black Hawk pilot, said there have been thousands of military helicopter flights over many years in that particularly dense airspace.
'And this is one that didn't go right out of all those thousands,' he said. 'So it's a testimony to the great procedures that are there, to the pilots that train there and how they operate on a daily basis. It's basically a highly choreographed dance with very little room for maneuver.'
Army concerns over helicopter crashes
Army leaders sounded the alarm over a rash of helicopter crashes last year, and in April they ordered extra measures including added training.
In a briefing with Pentagon reporters after the crash on Thursday, Army aviation chief of staff Jonathan Koziol said there was 'a spike in incidents' last year that prompted the Army to do a safety stand-down, in which units pause flight operations to evaluate safety procedures 'to not allow these types of incidents to happen,' Koziol said.
At the time of the stand-down, there were about a dozen Army helicopter accidents that caused 14 deaths in a six-month period, about twice the rate of the previous 10 years, according to Army officials. The Black Hawk helicopter involved in Wednesday's crash is one of many helicopter types used by the military.
Maj. Gen. Walter Rugen, director of Army aviation, told reporters last year that 'spatial disorientation' was a trend in the spike in accidents. Rugen said training must reinforce that pilots know 'where you are and where your aircraft is with respect to the ground.'
Twelve crashes of the Army Black Hawk helicopter since 2014 have killed 47 service members, according to data provided by the military.
One of the crashes was a nighttime mid-air collision of two Black Hawk helicopters near Fort Campbell, Kentucky, in 2023 that killed nine service members. The pilots were wearing night vision goggles during the training exercise, army officials said.
The most recent crash was on Nov. 10, 2023, when five Army soldiers were killed during aerial refueling training in the Mediterranean Sea.