Prosecutors want 19-year and 10-year sentences for men convicted after family froze at Manitoba border
U.S. attorneys have filed sentencing submissions for two men convicted after a family froze to death while trying to walk across the Canada-U.S. border in Manitoba.
A Minnesota jury found Steve Shand and Harshkumar Patel guilty of human-smuggling charges after the parents and two children from India were found in the snow in January 2022.
The attorneys say in court documents that Patel is not remorseful and they're requesting he be sentenced to a little more than 19 years in prison.
They also say Shand should be handed 10 years for conspiring with Patel to smuggle migrants into the United States at least five times through brutal winter conditions.
Shand's lawyer, Aaron Morrison, says in a document that proposed sentence is "unduly punitive" and he's requesting a little more than two years in prison.
A defence lawyer did not provide a document outlining a recommendation for Patel.
They were convicted last November in the January 2022 deaths of the Patel family (who were not related to Harshkumar Patel).
The frozen bodies of Jagdish Patel, 39, his wife, Vaishali, 37, their 11-year-old daughter, Vihangi, and their three-year-old son, Dharmik, were found in a snow-drifted Manitoba field just 12 metres from the U.S. border later on the morning of Jan. 19, 2022.
The temperature that day was –23 C, but the wind chill made it feel like the –35 to –38 range.
Shand was arrested near the border around the same time with other Indian nationals in the van he was driving. Harshkumar Patel was arrested in Chicago in February 2024 on charges of co-ordinating the smuggling and hiring Shand.
The men are set to be sentenced May 28.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
22 minutes ago
- CBC
Wildfire evacuee numbers climb to more than 17,000 in Manitoba, premier says
Social Sharing The number of wildfire evacuees in Manitoba has increased, with more likely as a handful of communities remain on alert. "The numbers have continued to grow. We were saying 17,000. I think we can safely assume it's north of that number now," Premier Wab Kinew said on CBC Manitoba's Information Radio on Thursday morning. He didn't have an estimate on the total but said about 16,800 people are now registered with the Canadian Red Cross. "And keep in mind, not everyone registers with us. Some folks, they just make the decision they're going to stay with family," Kinew said. It's been eight days since he declared a provincewide state of emergency due to rapidly spreading wildfires and extreme fire conditions in northern and eastern Manitoba. Since then, the northwestern part of the province has also become a danger zone. There are 15 communities under mandatory evacuation orders and another three under voluntary evacuation. Three others — Snow Lake, Norway House and Chemawawin Cree Nation (Easterville) — are under evacuation alerts or notices, with people ordered to be ready to leave with short notice. "We are in a new reality when it comes to wildfires. Typically, we would have one part of the province dealing with challenges and … there'd be, like, maybe two communities on evacuation in other summers. This year, it's every region at the same time," Kinew said. "So that's one thing that we need to plan for in the future." The pace at which everything has been happening has also opened an unfortunate door to misinformation on social media, Kinew said. To combat that, the province is launching a digital information portal later on Thursday. "It is striking during a state of emergency how quickly false claims can make their way around social media that actually pull away time and resources from people who would otherwise be co-ordinating an evacuation effort or responding to the actual wildfires themselves," Kinew said. Watch as the northern Manitoba wildfires grow 20 hours ago Duration 1:11 Wildfires have been burning in northern Manitoba since late May, when a province-wide emergency was declared. Watch as CBC Weather Specialist Riley Laychuk tracks the fires threatening the communities of Flin Flon, Sherridon and Pukatawagan. Three days after last week's evacuation of the city of Flin Flon, rumours sprouted on social media about firefighters being killed while battling the blaze. "I realize people are driven by stress in some cases, and in other cases by a compassionate response to try and get information out there, but … to have the added stress of some false information being shared on social media was counterproductive," Kinew said. The province's info portal "will be a trusted source of information on fires, where to find evacuation supports, how [people] can help in the response," he said. The province will also begin holding regular, but not necessarily daily, news briefings. The first of those is scheduled for 12:45 p.m. Thursday. As of Wednesday (the most recent data available), a total of 513,803 hectares had burned in the province. Last year at this time, 43,141 hectares had been impacted. Manitoba's fire situation report shows there are 27 active wildfires and a total of 111 fires to date, which is well above the average of 91 for this time of year. Kinew on Thursday also defended the province's decision to send evacuees to Ontario, addressing criticisms that suggested Manitoba was unprepared to respond to the demand. "That is the Manitoba response, just to be clear," he said. The province hired a private firm to manage the evacuee response, "and they found rooms in Niagara." "Earlier in this same wildfire season, Ontario didn't have rooms and we housed more than 1,000 Ontario evacuees here. I think one of the things that we're seeing this year is that we have to have a pan-provincial — a national — response, just given the scale of the emergency we're facing." The ability to get people, within a week, out of harm's way and into shelters and provide wraparound supports is a testament to the emergency management team in Manitoba and partners like Manitoba Keewatinowi Okimakanak, the Manitoba Métis Federation and municipal leaders across northern Manitoba, Kinew said. One of the other challenges the province has had to address is ensuring thousands of evacuees, especially those in major centres like Winnipeg, are kept safe from exploitation. "It is one of the very disturbing things about this, that even in the midst of the vast, vast majority of Manitobans stepping up and donating or volunteering, that there is a small group of people who are also trying to show up and prey on evacuees," Kinew said. "You can let your mind wander to some of the really bad behaviours that this might encompass." To counter that, security guards and other resources have been installed around evacuation centres, and police are working with First Nations safety officers, he said. "If there's a criminal act going on, there's going to be accountability. Somebody's going to get arrested," Kinew said. And then there's what he calls "a fourth layer of response," meaning help from community groups in Winnipeg like the Downtown Community Safety Partnership, the Bear Clan and Ogijiita Pimatiswin Kinamatwin (OPK), an Indigenous-led organization that supports at-risk youth affected by gangs, poverty and violence. "We've been working with them to ensure that they're, in some cases, that insulating security layer around people to protect them from bad actors," Kinew said. "In other cases, this is about somebody struggling, and we do have crisis stabilization unit, public health nurses and, you know, the medical professionals at each of these shelter sites and reception centres." Mandatory evacuations are in place for: Bakers Narrows. Big Island Lake. Bissett. Cranberry Portage. Flin Flon. Little Athapapuskow cottage area. Lynn Lake. Marcel Colomb First Nation (Black Sturgeon). Nopiming Provincial Park. Parts of Whiteshell Provincial Park. Pimicikamak Cree Nation (Cross Lake). Pukatawagan (Mathias Colomb Cree Nation). Schist Lake. Sherridon. Tataskweyak Cree Nation (Split Lake). Voluntary evacuation orders are in place for: Opaskwayak Cree Nation. Snow Lake. Wanless. Are you an evacuee who needs assistance? Contact Manitoba 211 by calling 211 from anywhere in Manitoba or email 211mb@
National Post
31 minutes ago
- National Post
Fan hit by concrete at Dodgers game claims he was discriminated against
A New York Yankees fan who was hit by a piece of falling concrete at Dodger Stadium says that he felt 'discriminated against' after the incident. Article content Luis Ricardo Aquino was in his seat during a game last week between the Yankees and Dodgers in L.A. when a softball-sized chunk of concrete hit him in the back. Article content Article content The Mexico City resident said that he initially thought it had been thrown at him by a fan rival – the Yankees and Dodgers met in the World Series last year — however, it was later found to have fallen from the deck above him. Article content Article content Aquino was treated at the stadium for his injuries – which he has now revealed to be a broken rib – and is now speaking out about the incident and what he claims was the initial question he was asked by first responders. Article content Article content 'The first question the police asked me if I had papers, and I said, 'Yes, I am on my visa.' I had to give them my visa and they took it from me. I am angry because I felt discriminated against,' he told KTLA, noting he was fearful of the line of questioning. Article content Aquino also explained why he refused further medical help at the time. Article content 'The paramedics did treat me and checked my vitals, but everything seemed OK,' he said. 'They asked if I wanted to go to a hospital, but this is not my country, so I did not feel comfortable.' Article content While this type of incident at a major league ballpark could invite lawsuits, Aquino said he agreed to not file a complaint over it – in return for some souvenirs. Article content After he returned to his seat following his treatment, Aquino was brought a jersey, some bracelets and a Max Muncy bobblehead. He also said that no one from the team or stadium followed up with him or offered an apology. Article content The Dodgers did take action in one regard – a small section of protective netting was installed under the top deck where the piece of concrete fell from, located between home plate and first base. Article content
CTV News
33 minutes ago
- CTV News
Barrie man among 35 others charged in large scale child exploitation investigation
A Barrie man has been charged along with 35 other individuals in connection with a large-scale, province-wide child sexual exploitation investigation resulting in a total of 128 charges laid. Provincial police say members from more than 20 police services, including the Barrie Police Service, posed as children in online chatrooms and social media apps during the two-week course of the investigation to identify and locate individuals seeking to sexually exploit children. "Although this was a luring investigation in which officers posed as children online and waited for offenders to make contact, nine real victims were identified," provincial police stated. 'One of the accused arrived at the meeting location with snacks and one arrived with sexual paraphernalia (lubricant and condoms). One of the arrested was listed on the National Sex Offender Registry.' Those accused are all men between 18 and 73 years of age, including a 55-year-old Barrie man, who is charged with three counts of luring a person under 16 and making sexually explicit material available to a child. He has since been released from custody with a court appearance scheduled for next week. 'These results highlight a sobering reality: predators can easily reach children in online spaces. We urge parents and guardians to remain vigilant and to talk to your children about staying safe online. Just as you wouldn't leave your child alone in a city, don't let them navigate the online world alone," stated OPP Det. Staff Sgt. Tim Brown.
