Next Guernsey States likely to revisit plans for GST-plus
The outgoing President of Policies and Resources Committee (P&R) Lyndon Trott previously announced the States spent £44m more than it brought in last year.In this context, candidates' views on taxation and the economy were of critical importance to many voters deciding where to cast their votes for last week's general election.Should deputies stick to their promises, the next mandate for government could see GST-Plus – which was agreed in November - scrapped altogether.The GST-Plus package of tax reforms includes a 5% GST, lower income tax rates for earnings under £30,000 and social security reform, to start in 2027.Most candidates said in their manifestos they wanted a "fairer tax system" for the island, but lacked detail as to how they would approach tackling the financial deficit.
Half of Guernsey's next assembly - 19 in total - said they were firmly against GST or GST-Plus. Some of them indicated they had opposed the policy in the past and were hopeful it would be reconsidered.A further eight said they wanted to explore other options before ratifying the last States' decision to introduce the new tax, but would consider GST-Plus as a last resort.Four prominent GST-supporting politicians were voted out.Out of the 38 elected candidates, only 11 pledged to back GST-Plus in upcoming votes the new States is expected to hold early on.Other ways to tackle expenditure included closing corporate tax loopholes, improving tax administration, reforming the zero-10 corporation tax model and slashing public spending.
Former States economist and incoming deputy, Dr Andy Sloan said the new government had a mandate to "turn over every stone" before introducing GST-Plus.He said he would like to see a three-pronged approach to "introduce a consumption tax, reform corporate tax and restraining expenditure" to balance the public accounts, but stressed that the introduction of a GST should be the last resort.He said: "The message from the electorate was they wanted no stone left unturned before GST being introduced and they don't believe that's been done yet."The States has to follow the will of the electorate and listen to that message and focus on restraining expenditure."He said when he first came to Guernsey over a decade ago spending was about £296m and it has now "ballooned" to £700m."I think the public really want to see expenditure restraint first. The majority of those who topped the poll were elected on that message," he said."We can't keep spending at twice the rate that we have income coming in, which we have been doing for 10 years."
Returning Deputy Gavin St Pier, the leader of Forward Guernsey, is among those not supportive of GST-Plus "in its current form".He said: "We don't oppose a consumption tax but before it hits the streets it does need reform to make it fairer. It's really important to get the community behind this kind of tax change."It is so fundamental - it will affect everyone on the island for generations to come."At the first States meeting where business will be discussed - on 15 July - members will debate the accounts for 2024.With public finances set to become a major theme next term, all eyes will be on what the States does next.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
24 minutes ago
- ITV News
Vivergo bioethanol plant near Hull faces closure after government rejects funding plea
A bioethanol plant near Hull is facing closure after the government said it would not be providing grant funding to keep it afloat. Vivergo Fuels, which employs 160 workers at the site, says it is facing closure within weeks following the decision to end the 19% tariff on American bioethanol imports as part of the recent UK-US trade deal. It had been in talks with the government to secure financial support but the Department for Business and Trade said on Friday it had taken the "difficult decision" not to offer funding as it would not provide value for money for the taxpayer. A spokesperson said: "We recognise this is a difficult time for the workers and their families and we will work with trade unions, local partners and the companies to support them through this process. "We also continue to work up proposals that ensure the resilience of our CO2 supply in the long-term in consultation with the sector." The owners of the plant said they were disappointed the media was told the decision before they were. A spokesperson for parent company ABF said: "It is deeply regrettable that the Government has chosen not to support a key national asset. "We have been fighting for months to keep this plant open. We initiated and led talks with Government in good faith. We presented a clear plan to restore Vivergo to profitability within two years under policy levers already aligned with the Government's own green industrial strategy. "In making this decision, the Government has thrown away billions in potential growth in the Humber and a sovereign capability in clean fuels that had the chance to lead the world."
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
House of Lords does not need ‘Putin apologists like Farage', cabinet minister says
A cabinet minister has dismissed Nigel Farage 's call for the prime minister to allow him to nominate peers to the House of Lords, saying Parliament will not benefit from more 'Putin apologists'. Defence secretary John Healey said the Reform UK leader wanted to fill the upper chamber with 'his cronies', and accused his party of being 'conspicuously absent' from debate on the Ukraine war. In a letter to Sir Keir Starmer, Mr Farage had said that a 'democratic disparity' in the Lords needed to be addressed. Reform has four MPs and controls 10 councils in England. When asked about the party leader's demands, Mr Healey said: 'The same Nigel Farage who called for the abolition of the Lords… now wants to fill it with his cronies. 'I'm not sure that Parliament's going to benefit from more Putin apologists like Nigel Farage, to be honest.' Asked whether that accusation was 'a bit strong', Mr Healey told LBC: 'Look at what he's said about Russia, look at what he's said about Putin in the past. 'At this point, when maximum pressure needs to be put on Putin to support Ukraine in negotiations, when the maximum condemnation of Putin is required from someone who is sitting down with Trump in Alaska but turning up the attacks on Ukraine, it needs all voices. 'And I have to say, the voice of Reform is conspicuously absent in any of our discussions and any of our defence debates about Ukraine and about Russia.' The minister urged Mr Farage, the MP for Clacton, to start 'weighing in alongside us and the other parties in the House of Commons' in condemning the Russian president. Reform's deputy leader Richard Tice accused the Defence Secretary of 'an absurd smear'. 'Is Mr Healey suffering from a touch of August sunstroke?' he said. During the general election campaign last year, Mr Farage was criticised by leaders from across the political spectrum for suggesting the West provoked the Ukraine war. He also said he disliked the Russian president but 'admired' him as a political operator because 'he managed to take control of running Russia', in a BBC interview. Mr Farage has repeatedly denied that he supports Mr Putin and said he is clear that the Russian leader is to blame for the war. The Reform leader has previously called for Lords reform, writing in an article for the Telegraph in February that 'a smaller chamber is needed'. In his letter to the Prime Minister, first reported by the Times, Mr Farage said: ' Reform UK wishes to appoint life peers to the upper house at the earliest possible opportunity.' In what he described as a 'modest request', he said it was time that Reform was represented in the unelected second chamber. 'My party received over 4.1 million votes at the general election in July 2024. We have since won a large number of seats in local government, led in the national opinion polls for many months and won the only by-election of this parliament,' he said. Political appointments to the Lords are made at the discretion of the Prime Minister, who is under no constitutional obligation to elevate opposition figures but will sometimes ask other leaders to nominate individuals. In December, Sir Keir appointed 30 new Labour peers, including his former chief of staff Sue Gray – which Mr Farage said at the time showed the ruling party's 'lofty ambition' to abolish the Lords had 'fallen by the wayside'. The Conservatives appointed six new peers, while the Liberal Democrats appointed two.
The Independent
24 minutes ago
- The Independent
Cashback concerns raised when people are considering transferring their pension
Concerns that some consumers may be deciding to transfer their pension based only on the prospect of rewards such as cashback have been raised by the City regulator. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said some people may be focusing on an immediate or near-term reward, such as cashback on signing up to a consolidation service. This means they may not be considering the full financial implications of their decision, the regulator said. It added that it recognises the efforts firms already make to flag up to customers the often valuable benefits of their existing scheme. The regulator said that pensions dashboards, which will eventually allow people to see all their pension pots in one place, will make it easier for consumers to track their pensions. This may also drive higher demand to consolidate pension pots, the regulator said. The research was published as part of the regulator's findings from its multi-firm review of life insurers' pension transfer processes. The FCA said on its website: 'We expect firms to be resourced with sufficient, well-trained staff to service the products they have sold or acquired and be able to respond to foreseeable spikes in demand.' Under the Consumer Duty, which requires firms to put customers at the heart of what they do, the FCA said it expects firms to support consumers in making informed decisions. This means they should ensure their communications meet their customers' information needs, it said. The FCA's website said: 'Our findings suggest that firms are well-intentioned and seek to ensure consumers receive good outcomes when transferring their pensions.' Jon Greer, head of retirement policy at wealth manager Quilter, said: 'The FCA has said it is concerned that consumers are transferring their pension provider simply to take advantage of an immediate or near-term reward or incentive.' He said cashback for pension transfers 'could be a very tempting offer' for many people. He continued: 'However, many consumers will be unaware of the benefits their existing pension arrangements may have, and that by transferring you automatically give these up. This can include a higher tax-free lump sums or the earliest age you can access benefits – it all depends on the terms of the scheme. 'The FCA suggests that firms are rightly doing what they can to provide that information to a customer looking to transfer, but given where pension engagement is in this country, it is an uphill battle. 'The upcoming pensions dashboard is going to provide a lot more visibility to people of their various pensions, and thus there could be increased demand for consolidation services.'
