Rock lobster pots removed from Granites beach despite 'no evidence' of shark risk mitigation
Following the death of 28-year-old Lance Appleby, who was taken by a shark at Granites in January, the local council and Surf Life Saving South Australia (SLSSA) released a report with 28 recommendations for shark mitigation.
Among the community's concerns was that activities such as rock lobster fishing could be "conditioning" sharks to associate humans with species that form part of their diet.
Streaky Bay community members subsequently called for the removal of lobster pots from surf breaks, which the SA government brought into effect last week out of respect for community sentiment.
However, the decision has drawn opposition from fishers who say there is no scientific evidence that removing lobster pots will reduce the risk of shark attacks for surfers at the beach.
The SA government also acknowledged there was "no evidence that this is effective as shark mitigation" in its statement announcing the decision, adding that the exclusion site for rock lobster pots at Granites was not being considered for any other location.
South Australian Northern Zone Rock Lobster Association executive officer Kyri Toumazos said fishers' fundamental concern was that the actual risks from shark attacks were not being mitigated.
While less than ten rock lobster fishers, mostly recreational, would be directly impacted by the exclusion zone around Granites, Mr Toumazos was concerned what kind of precedent would be set by a government policy that was made without scientific evidence.
"Obviously it impacts those fishers involved, although it's not many fishers, but there's a concern that this could be something that happens more often," he said.
"Our fundamental concern for this decision, with no scientific backing … is to see it actually be rolled out in other areas.
"That's our fundamental concern that it goes across the board … [to] all sectors, not just the rock lobster sector."
The toxic algal bloom that has wreaked havoc on parts of the state's coast has so far not spread to the Streaky Bay area.
The Department of Primary Industries and Regions (PIRSA) implemented the 12-month closure on July 25 for the immediate area around Granites, prohibiting the setting of commercial and recreational rock lobster pots.
The rock lobster season does not begin until November.
Streaky Bay Mayor Travis Barber acknowledged the removal of the pots from the popular surf break was "not going to be a silver bullet, but anything helps".
"This was a really community-led thing from the Mid-West Coast Surf Riders Association. They came to council with a proposal, which we supported," he said.
Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development Claire Scriven said the state government had acted on calls from the community in the aftermath of January's fatal attack.
"I visited Streaky Bay in the weeks that followed the tragic loss of surfer Lance Appleby and the community sentiment about the immediate area around Granites was understandably very strong," Ms Scriven said.
"We have taken this measure out of respect and recognition of the tragedy that occurred."
Mr Barber said the Shark Task Force had been set up prior to Mr Appleby's tragic death — the second person to be taken by a shark at Granites since October 2023.
After deliberating for about 12 months the mayor said he was pleased to see progress being made towards implementing the recommendations of the shark mitigation report.
"They came up with the 28 recommendations … since the unfortunate tragedy of Lance. I've been hot on it with the council and community groups," Mr Barber said.
"It's August and we've already had four things put in place. So I can't thank the government and the minister enough for how fast they've acted."
Previous community-led mitigation efforts had included cardboard warning signs at beaches, a $24 air horn and a flag pole system to alert beachgoers of shark sightings.
Other changes to soon take effect will include drones for shark surveillance purposes and a new rescue boat for the Streaky Bay SES.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
3 days ago
- ABC News
One in five calls to SA domestic violence crisis line go unanswered despite extra funding
About 20 per cent of calls to South Australia's domestic violence crisis line are going unanswered, despite a recent boost in government funding to address demand, the state's peak body for domestic violence services says. Embolden CEO Mary Leaker told ABC News Stateline the state's crisis domestic violence services were this year experiencing "unprecedented" demand, amid heightened community awareness, media attention, and a royal commission into domestic, family and sexual violence. "Despite an injection of funding from the state government last mid-year budget review, we're still seeing one in five calls to that crisis line go unanswered because of the increase in demand," she said. "Where there's that kind of pressure on the system, we do run the risk that people are discouraged from seeking help and that they don't actually get the help that they need in that moment." The crisis line is operated by Women's Safety Services SA and provides counselling, support and accommodation referrals to people experiencing domestic and family violence. In December, the state government announced it would increase funding for the service by an additional $880,000 each year, to "boost staffing levels and enhance the helpline's capacity to respond to calls outside business hours". The funding allocation was made one month after Women's Safety Services SA CEO Maria Haggias told the state's royal commission into domestic, family and sexual violence that only 70 per cent of calls to the crisis line were answered, leaving one in three callers without immediate support. Ms Leaker said there was also an increase in the number of families escaping family and domestic violence, who were being placed in emergency accommodation such as hotels and motels. If you need help immediately call emergency services on triple-0 She said for some months of the year, the numbers had increased by more than two thirds compared to the same time last year. "At times, there have been close to 100 families in emergency accommodation," she said. "The lack of appropriate housing options means that families are staying longer in emergency accommodation, with significant negative impacts for their health and wellbeing." The SA government allocated $3.5 million in its June state budget to coordinate its response to the domestic violence royal commission findings, ahead of a final report being handed down later this month. Ms Leaker said that money would go towards public sector staffing. "We know that we need a well-resourced public sector, but what we didn't see in this state budget was a really substantial allocation of funding that will enable our state to drive on the ground urgent royal commission recommendations," she said. "We know that for some time in South Australia we have been underinvesting in our domestic, family and sexual violence services relative to other jurisdictions. "We have some catching up to do, even before we look at driving really transformative system change." A state government spokesperson said the government was "committed to preventing, domestic family and sexual violence" and was awaiting the findings of the "landmark" royal commission report. The spokesperson said the report would "present an opportunity for generational change", but they did not respond to questions asking if the government was considering increasing funding for the domestic violence crisis line, or whether it would increase funding to respond to the royal commission recommendations. Ms Leaker was one of a number of South Australians who called for the royal commission into domestic violence, following the deaths of six South Australians from alleged family and domestic violence at the end of 2023. She said royal commissioner Natasha Stott Despoja had a "lean team" and was working towards "fairly ambitious timeframes", but the sector was confident that she would hand down "well-grounded" recommendations later this month. "There's always that concern around implementation and that's really where the metaphorical rubber hits the road," she said. "We know that it will be really, really critical that people who have lived experience of our systems and also the specialist domestic, family and sexual violence sector [are[ around the table when it comes to designing how we implement the recommendations." Ms Leaker said domestic violence services were also calling for "independent monitoring" of the royal commission recommendations. "We see that as absolutely vital in terms of building accountability to how our state government, how our services system more broadly is actually responding to those recommendations to ensure that the royal commission lives up to its promise to the South Australian community," she said. The royal commission has received more than 360 submissions and more than 800 survey responses. It has also heard from 64 people at 10 public hearings.
ABC News
4 days ago
- ABC News
Coroner calls on SA government to make hospitals safer amid ramping death findings
A South Australian coroner has called on the state government to "formally acknowledge" ramping is "a reality" and focus on making it safer for those who will "inevitably" experience it. On Thursday, Acting Deputy State Coroner Ian White — who was recently appointed as a judge in South Australia's District Court — handed down his findings following the months-long inquest into the deaths of 76-year-old Anna Vincenza Panella in April 2019, 89-year-old Bernard Anthony Skeffington in September 2021, and 64-year-old Graham Henry Jessett in March 2022. All three people died after they were ramped at either the Royal Adelaide Hospital (RAH) or Flinders Medical Centre (FMC). In his published findings, Acting Deputy Coroner White concluded Mr Skeffington's death was preventable and Mr Jessett's was "potentially preventable", but said Mrs Panella's was not. He said while her "death was not preventable, the circumstances in which it occurred were far less dignified than Mrs Panella deserved". Acting Deputy Coroner White made a total of 18 recommendations he encouraged the state government to adopt as it continues to address the systemic issues associated with ramping. "The tragedy lies in being so close to the help needed, but being unable to access it," he wrote. "In order to commence the process of cultural change and change in the community's attitude to ramping, I make a recommendation directed to the Minister for Health and Wellbeing … that the South Australian government formally acknowledge that ramping is a reality that all modern healthcare systems encounter. "While efforts to reduce the levels of ramping remain extremely important, efforts must also be made to make the process of ramping safer for those patients who will inevitably experience it." Acting Deputy State Coroner White said he took into consideration the evidence of all witnesses, including that of the chief executive of SA Health Dr Robyn Lawrence who "agreed that it is reasonable to act on ramping as a reality but also continue to maintain a focus on strategies to end it". "If that fundamental policy was adopted, the health system can stop pulling itself apart each month as ramping figures roll in," he wrote. "It can instead focus on doing health the best way it can. The state of South Australia indicated that more recently there has been some level of recognition of this reality." He also said another key issue explored in the inquest was the understanding of medical professionals as to who "is responsible for the care of patients on the ramp". "I am not permitted and do not wish to make any findings or suggestions as to liability in respect of the deaths of Mrs Panella, Mr Skeffington and Mr Jessett," he said. Acting Deputy State Coroner White highlighted that numerous statewide policies should be introduced for the safety of patients including "mandating the use of a structured oral handover between paramedics and triage nurses". He said another statewide policy should be introduced "requiring visualisation of patients arriving for triage, regardless of their manner of arrival". Acting Deputy State Coroner White said he hoped his recommendations were adopted by the health system "and improves the manner in which people wait for entry to emergency departments during times of extreme demand". "In this way, the loss may have meaning for the families in that something positive has developed from the death of their loved ones," he wrote. "Mrs Panella, Mr Skeffington and Mr Jessett were each important and productive South Australians. In a written statement, Mr Skeffington's son Martin said he and his family were "very pleased" that his death was "deemed preventable". "As healthcare workers, we are very aware of the consequences of delays to medical care and realise the problems cannot be fixed overnight and it involves many moving parts, involving emergency departments, hospital beds and staffing, which are all in need of an overhaul to fix the many problems," he wrote. "We wish not to blame any single person but hope that this inquest will bring about positive change so no other families have to go through this ordeal." SA Health and SA Ambulance Service have been contacted for comment.
ABC News
6 days ago
- ABC News
Rock lobster pots removed from Granites beach despite 'no evidence' of shark risk mitigation
Rock lobster fishers have questioned the South Australian government's decision to remove rock lobster pots from a popular western Eyre Peninsula surf beach in response to two fatal shark attacks despite a lack of scientific evidence. Following the death of 28-year-old Lance Appleby, who was taken by a shark at Granites in January, the local council and Surf Life Saving South Australia (SLSSA) released a report with 28 recommendations for shark mitigation. Among the community's concerns was that activities such as rock lobster fishing could be "conditioning" sharks to associate humans with species that form part of their diet. Streaky Bay community members subsequently called for the removal of lobster pots from surf breaks, which the SA government brought into effect last week out of respect for community sentiment. However, the decision has drawn opposition from fishers who say there is no scientific evidence that removing lobster pots will reduce the risk of shark attacks for surfers at the beach. The SA government also acknowledged there was "no evidence that this is effective as shark mitigation" in its statement announcing the decision, adding that the exclusion site for rock lobster pots at Granites was not being considered for any other location. South Australian Northern Zone Rock Lobster Association executive officer Kyri Toumazos said fishers' fundamental concern was that the actual risks from shark attacks were not being mitigated. While less than ten rock lobster fishers, mostly recreational, would be directly impacted by the exclusion zone around Granites, Mr Toumazos was concerned what kind of precedent would be set by a government policy that was made without scientific evidence. "Obviously it impacts those fishers involved, although it's not many fishers, but there's a concern that this could be something that happens more often," he said. "Our fundamental concern for this decision, with no scientific backing … is to see it actually be rolled out in other areas. "That's our fundamental concern that it goes across the board … [to] all sectors, not just the rock lobster sector." The toxic algal bloom that has wreaked havoc on parts of the state's coast has so far not spread to the Streaky Bay area. The Department of Primary Industries and Regions (PIRSA) implemented the 12-month closure on July 25 for the immediate area around Granites, prohibiting the setting of commercial and recreational rock lobster pots. The rock lobster season does not begin until November. Streaky Bay Mayor Travis Barber acknowledged the removal of the pots from the popular surf break was "not going to be a silver bullet, but anything helps". "This was a really community-led thing from the Mid-West Coast Surf Riders Association. They came to council with a proposal, which we supported," he said. Minister for Primary Industries and Regional Development Claire Scriven said the state government had acted on calls from the community in the aftermath of January's fatal attack. "I visited Streaky Bay in the weeks that followed the tragic loss of surfer Lance Appleby and the community sentiment about the immediate area around Granites was understandably very strong," Ms Scriven said. "We have taken this measure out of respect and recognition of the tragedy that occurred." Mr Barber said the Shark Task Force had been set up prior to Mr Appleby's tragic death — the second person to be taken by a shark at Granites since October 2023. After deliberating for about 12 months the mayor said he was pleased to see progress being made towards implementing the recommendations of the shark mitigation report. "They came up with the 28 recommendations … since the unfortunate tragedy of Lance. I've been hot on it with the council and community groups," Mr Barber said. "It's August and we've already had four things put in place. So I can't thank the government and the minister enough for how fast they've acted." Previous community-led mitigation efforts had included cardboard warning signs at beaches, a $24 air horn and a flag pole system to alert beachgoers of shark sightings. Other changes to soon take effect will include drones for shark surveillance purposes and a new rescue boat for the Streaky Bay SES.
