State bar council issues notices to 16 lawyers over alleged ‘bench hunting'
The council issued the notice following a suo motu inquiry initiated by the Privilege Committee after media reports and court observations hinted at attempts to manipulate the bench allocation process of the Punjab and Haryana High Court.
The Privilege Committee, chaired by Raj Kumar Chauhan, convened on August 7 to examine records in CRM-M-19843-2025 (Roop Bansal vs State of Haryana), along with related high court orders and news reports.
The committee observed that the allegations, if proven, amount to a grave attack on the dignity and ethics of the legal profession.
'Any attempt to subvert the Temple of Justice, motivated by greed or manipulation, must be addressed with utmost seriousness,' the order stated, invoking historical and moral analogies from the Mahabharata and quotes from figures like Mahatma Gandhi, B.R. Ambedkar, Lord Denning, and Justice Brandeis.
The order was released on Friday late evening.
The lawyers who have been asked to file a response to the issue are J K Singla, Sidharth Bhardwaj, Aditya Aggarwal, Gagandeep Singh, Anmol Chandan, Baljeet Beniwal, Harsh Sharma, Sauhard Singh, Rupender Singh, Ankit Yadav, Ashim Singla, Aakash Sharma, Bindu, APS Shergil, Senior Advocate Rakesh Nehra, and Senior Advocate Puneet Bali.
All are alleged to have appeared or acted on behalf of Roop Bansal in the matter.
The committee noted that records prima facie suggest Advocate J K Singla may have played a 'key role' in orchestrating the strategy, but stressed that such actions were likely carried out 'in an organised manner' with involvement from other 'ingenious minds' yet to be identified.
The order also called for responses from prominent Senior Advocates Abhishek Manu Singhvi and Mukul Rohatgi to ensure a comprehensive adjudication.
The lawyers have been asked to appear before the Privilege Committee on August 16 at 3 pm, either in person or through counsel, and to submit written replies.
The committee likened the alleged practice of bench hunting—seeking a particular bench perceived to be favourable—to 'rotten apples in the basket' and stressed the need to remove them before the entire profession's integrity is compromised. It also appealed for information or complaints from advocates or affected persons, to be sent via the committee's email or official WhatsApp number.
'The legal profession is not merely a career—it is a calling that demands unshakable integrity, moral courage, and devotion to the cause of justice,' the order concluded, warning that ethical breaches by even a few can corrode public faith in the entire system.
Importantly, the matter came into the limelight after a complaint was received by Chief Justice Sheel Nagu of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, and the matter was de-listed from the bench of Justice Mahabir Singh Sandhu, who reserved its verdict after hearing the matter.
The Chief Justice, in its order, hinted at bench hunting by the lawyers in this matter. Prior to referring the matter to Justice Sandhu, several benches recused themselves from hearing.
Interestingly, even after taking the matter from Justice Sandhu, several other judges of the HC recused themselves from hearing this case.
Stay updated with the latest local news from your
city
on
Times of India
(TOI). Check upcoming
bank holidays
,
public holidays
, and current
gold rates
and
silver prices
in your area.
Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with
Raksha Bandhan wishes
,
messages
and
quotes
!
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
an hour ago
- Hindustan Times
Mahabharata metaphor for India's ‘missile shield' in Modi address
New Delhi Prime Minister Narendra Modi addresses the nation from the ramparts of Red Fort on 79th Independence Day, in New Delhi on Friday. (ANI) Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday vowed to provide a 'complete shield of protection' to the nation's most vital locations, from strategic installations to civilian spaces such as hospitals and faith centres, by 2035. Drawing from the epic Mahabharata, he invoked Lord Krishna's divine discus to announce the Sudarshan Chakra Mission, a sweeping initiative aimed at strengthening India's security architecture. 'During the war of the Mahabharat, Lord Krishna's Sudarshan Chakra obstructed the sunlight helped Arjuna to fulfil his oath to kill Jayadratha. Drawing inspiration from that, the country will now launch Sudarshan Chakra Mission,' PM Modi declared in his Independence Day address. Modi said the mission would fuse advanced surveillance, interception and counter-attack capabilities to swiftly neutralise threats. 'It will have a system which will function a step ahead of all possible attacks in the future,' he said, adding that the entire programme, from research and development to manufacturing, would be fully indigenous. According to Modi, the mission will also focus on developing a system for targeted and precise action, integrating cutting-edge technologies to create a powerful, multi-layered defence shield around critical points across the country. This 'complete security' push can be drawn parallels between the upcoming system and Israel's famed Iron Dome, the multi-layered defence network credited with intercepting thousands of rockets from Hamas and Hezbollah since its deployment in the 2010s. India already has a Integrated Air Command and Control System that acted as a shield against Pakistan's missiles during Operation Sindoor.
India Today
3 hours ago
- India Today
In 2025 Red Fort address, PM highlights Bharat, youth, and self-reliance
Prime Minister Narendra Modi's Independence Day addresses have consistently outlined the government's priorities, each year marked by certain keywords that define the India's 79th Independence Day, his Red Fort speech — lasting a total of 103 minutes — underscored self-reliance, defence preparedness, and youth empowerment, signalling a forward-looking vision for India@ topped the tally with 48 mentions, followed by youth (28). Atmanirbhar emerged as the central theme with 26 mentions. Women and women-centric schemes also received substantial focus, appearing 26 times in his address. Other recurring terms included reforms, capability, national security, sports, and technology. advertisementSUDARSHAN CHAKARA & DEFENCE PUSH PM Modi referenced Sudarshan Chakra 15 times, drawing from the Mahabharata to highlight India's strategic initiatives. He announced the development of an advanced Sudarshan Chakra defence system to protect critical national also recalled the success of Operation Sindoor earlier this year, when India's S-400 Sudarshan Chakra missile shields successfully intercepted multiple drones and missiles coming from the enemy's side, averting large-scale damage. Praising the armed forces, whom he mentioned nearly 13 times, the PM said he had given them full operational freedom during the mission. He lauded their courage and efficiency, noting the nation's pride in their services. He also mentioned Pakistan and the enemy five times SCHEMESKey announcements included the Pradhan Mantri Viksit Bharat Rozgar Yojana, a Rs 1 lakh crore initiative to boost youth employment, offering first-time jobseekers Rs 15,000 in direct support. He promised GST reforms, describing them as a Diwali gift, aimed at easing compliance for taxpayers and businesses. Other highlights included a push for domestic semiconductor production by year-end, critical mineral development, and plans for India's own space SECURITY & CULTUREThe speech made repeated references to threats from terrorism, Naxals/Maoists, and intruders, underscoring security concerns. Economic priorities were reflected in mentions of startups, manufacturing, and critical minerals. Cultural and historical touchpoints added yet another year's Independence Day address centred on Desh, and Bharat and mentioned Bangladesh, crimes against women, and dynastic 2025, the focus shifted to Atmanirbhar, defence capability, and strategic industries such as semiconductors and critical minerals.- EndsTune InMust Watch IN THIS STORY#Narendra Modi#Independence Day 2025
NDTV
7 hours ago
- NDTV
"Every Citizen Must Feel Protected": PM Modi Announces 'Mission Sudarshan Chakra'
New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in his Independence Day address from the Red Fort, unveiled an ambitious national security initiative titled 'Mission Sudarshan Chakra', aimed at protecting India's critical establishments over the next decade through indigenous technological development within the coming ten years. "Every citizen must feel protected," PM Modi said. "This mission will be research-based and developed entirely with indigenous technology," PM Modi declared, emphasising self-reliance in strategic innovation. The initiative is expected to encompass a multi-layered security framework, integrating advanced surveillance, cyber protection, and physical infrastructure safeguards tailored to India's evolving threat landscape. Drawing inspiration from the Mahabharata, PM Modi invoked the moment when Lord Krishna shielded the sun to enable Arjun to defeat Jayadrath. "We are taking inspiration from Lord Krishna, who once barred sunlight from reaching Earth. That divine intervention changed the course of battle. Today, we must similarly shield our vital institutions from emerging threats," he said, blending mythology with modern strategic vision. Though specific details of Mission Sudarshan Chakra remain under wraps, sources suggest it will involve collaboration between India's premier research agencies, defence establishments, and private innovators. The mission aligns with the government's broader push for Aatmanirbhar Bharat (self-reliant India), especially in defence and critical infrastructure. The announcement comes amid heightened global concerns over cyber warfare, hybrid threats, and sabotage of strategic assets. PM Modi's emphasis on indigenous technology signals a move away from dependency on foreign systems, reinforcing national sovereignty in security architecture. The Prime Minister's speech also touched on India's historical vulnerabilities, including the 2008 Mumbai attacks, underscoring the need for proactive and integrated security planning. "We cannot afford to be reactive. We must anticipate and prepare," he said. As India celebrates its 79th year of independence, Mission Sudarshan Chakra stands as a symbolic and strategic commitment to safeguarding the nation's future. It reflects a fusion of cultural ethos and cutting-edge innovation, positioning India to meet the challenges of the next decade with resilience and technological prowess. (Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)
