HSE paid supplier €723k twice and has not clawed back overpayment
The Comptroller and Auditor General Seamus McCarthy said the HSE disclosed the payment and set out actions to avoid such a situation in the future.
"The HSE acknowledges there were weaknesses in controls, particularly, in relation to appropriate goods receipting protocols," Mr McCarthy said in an assessment attached to the HSE's annual report and financial statements for 2024.
"The statement on internal control sets out the actions taken by the Health Service Executive to avoid similar circumstances recurring in the future."
He said a single integrated financial system, which was due to go live at the start of this month, would "significantly reduce the risk of this kind of overpayment occurring in the future".
Mr McCarthy also highlighted that €4.1m euro due to the HSE was lost last year by missing deadlines by which it could claim charges for patients covered by a health insurer.
A memorandum of agreement with the health insurer in 2016 sees the HSE paid 70pc of its charges for a patient stay, on account, if it makes its submission and validation within a 12-month period of a fully completed claim.
If it does not meet that deadline, it must pay for all of the costs.
"For a sample of eight hospitals examined on audit, it was noted that losses incurred in 2024 as a result of delays in submitting completed claims amounted to two million euro," Mr McCarthy said.
"The Executive estimates that losses for the remaining hospitals it manages were €2.1m, resulting in an estimated total loss of €4.1m for 2024."
The HSE's annual report indicated there was a 10pc reduction in the number of people waiting on trolleys in emergency departments last year.
Over 108,000 people were recorded on trolleys in emergency departments last year, amid an 8pc increase in the total number of people attending and a rise of 7pc in admissions to emergency departments.
HSE chief executive Bernard Gloster said one of the most "challenging" aspects for the HSE was wait times for healthcare, and said tackling "unacceptably long" waits in emergency departments was an area of focus.
The HSE annual report for 2024 analyses the health service's performance and health trends among Irish people.
"Addressing waiting lists for scheduled care and unacceptably long waits in emergency departments (EDs) remains a priority focus area, especially for older people and those with complex needs," Mr Gloster said in the foreword.
"My plan for 2025 is to continue to bring trolley numbers down and to improve how our health and social care system works across seven days to allow consistent access to care."
Requests for assessments of need for children spiked by 26pc last year compared to a year previous, and were 33pc above expected demand in 2024.
There were 8,400 such requests in 2023 and more than 10,600 in 2024, in figures which had previously been shared by Children's Minister Norma Foley in the Dail.
Although there was a slight uptake on the measles, mumps, rubella (MMR) vaccine compared to the previous year, the 89.9% figure was below the target for 2024.
The chairman of the HSE's board, Ciaran Devane, said in an introductory statement to the report that Ireland's population is ageing "faster than that of any other country in the EU".
Since 2015, the number of people aged 65 years and over has increased by 37pc.
Although life expectancy in Ireland, at 82.6 years, is ahead of the EU average, the burden of cancer is higher and accounts for a quarter of all deaths of those aged over 65.
Mr Gloster, who is to step down from his role in March 2026, said 2024 was a year of "real progress".
"We reduced the number of people waiting on trolleys by over 10pc, expanded community services and improved access to scheduled care with an additional 24,000 patients seen within target timeframes.
"Our focus in 2025 will be to build on this momentum, improve patient flow and continue to reform how care is delivered across seven days."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
3 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Two more reviews completed on Portiuncula maternity unit
In response to a parliamentary question from TD Claire Kerrane, Health Minister stated that the hospital and the safety of maternity patients are of 'critical importance'. While the response acknowledged the completion of two additional reviews and the increased number of recommendations, it merely stated that implementation would proceed 'over the coming months'. To date, Deputy Kerrane has received no further updates from the HSE or Health Minister. The direction for the hospital's future, according to the ministerial response, will require an 'extensive evidence base, of which an extensive review of the implementation of the current National Maternity Strategy will form part'. Deputy Kerrane expressed concern about the ongoing lack of clarity around future plans for PUH, particularly regarding efforts 'to ensure a full return of maternity services'. 'This roadmap is essential to ensuring the current reduction in services is not seen as a permanent solution and the hospital can continue to serve our community. This prolonged uncertainty is completely unacceptable, especially for pregnant women, who, as long as this situation continues, will have to travel further to have their babies.' The Irish Independent reported recently on the Galway County councillors call to the HSE and the health minister requesting a 'fully independent, external review' of the hospital. The councillors urged a broader evaluation of the hospital, placing it within a 'contextual service' framework alongside other maternity services nationwide. Initial recommendations in the first five reviews suggested diverting high-risk pregnancies to other hospitals, such as University Hospital Galway (UHG). This has raised concerns among local residents and councillors, as PUH serves communities across counties Tipperary, Offaly, and Clare. Questions have since been raised about the infrastructure and readiness of the hospitals expected to take on these patients, along with safety risks for women facing emergencies during labour. Deputy Kerrane is calling on the HSE to use the meeting to present a clear 'roadmap' and offer 'much needed assurances' that the diversion of high-risk pregnancies is only a temporary measure. Additionally, a petition to preserve and enhance existing maternity services at PUH has already gathered over 3,000 signatures. Funded by the Local Democracy Reporting Scheme.
Irish Daily Mirror
9 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Chikungunya virus symptoms, spread and what to know as 7,000 infected in China
A mosquito-borne virus that has infected more than 7,000 people across 13 cities in southern China is prompting measures similar to those taken during the Covid pandemic - despite not being contagious between humans. The chikungunya virus, which causes fever, joint pain, headaches and muscle aches, is spreading rapidly across Guangdong province, just north of Hong Kong. Chikungunya is typically uncommon in China, but infections soared after an imported case was detected in Foshan city on July 8, which has since become the worst-affected area, reports New York Times. In Foshan city patients diagnosed with chikungunya are required to remain in hospital under mosquito net protection and can only be discharged after testing negative or completing a mandatory week-long stay, according to a translation of Chinese news outlet NF News. Authorities in Guangdong are doing door-to-door inspections checking for stagnant water - where mosquitos breed - and warning that those who fail to comply can be fined or face criminal charges for "obstructing the prevention of infectious diseases", as outlined in a government flyer translated by the Times. A drone sprays insecticide on August 1, 2025 in Guangzhou, Guangdong Province of China (Image: China News Service via Getty Images) Other measures include releasing mosquito-eating fish into ponds, spraying pesticides, deploying drones to spot breeding sites and even introducing giant "elephant mosquitoes" whose larvae devour the virus-carrying kind. While the current outbreak is centred in Asia, Ireland has recorded a travel-related case of the virus in the past. According to the Health Protection Surveillance Centre (HPSC), the most recent known Irish case was in 2016, involving a person who had recently returned from Kenya. Chikungunya is classed as a notifiable disease in Ireland - meaning health officials must report suspected cases to authorities. While it cannot be transmitted person-to-person, the virus can be passed to humans through the bite of an infected Aedes mosquito, which are usually found in the warmer parts of the world, especially Asia, the US and the Mediterranean Basin. What is Chikungunya? The HPSC said: "Chikungunya is a viral infection caused by the Chikungunya virus, an Alphavirus and member of the Togaviridae family. Chikungunya fever is a notifiable disease in Ireland." What are the symptoms ? The HPSC said: "The time between being bitten by an infected mosquito and developing symptoms ranges from 1 to 12 days, with an average of three to seven days. "The main symptoms are fever, joint pain, muscle pain and headache. Joint pains are a characteristic symptom. Bleeding from the nose or gums may happen, particularly in children. "While most cases recover without complications, some people may develop a more chronic phase with persistent joint pains. Recovery may take several weeks for these patients, coinciding with extreme tiredness. Younger people tend to recover in a matter of a one or two weeks while middle-aged and elderly tend to take one to three months for full recovery." How is it spread? The HPSC said: "Chikungunya fever is transmitted to humans by biting Aedes mosquitoes, such as A. aegypti, A. albopictus and A. polynesiensis. These are tropical and subtropical mosquitoes found in the warmer parts of the world, especially Asia, the United States and the Mediterranean Basin. " Where does it occur? The HPSC said: "Chikungunya is commonly found in East Africa, Southeast Asia and in the Indian sub-continent. In summer 2007, an outbreak was reported in the Emilia-Romagna region of North-East Italy, and this region is now considered an area where Chikungunya virus transmission takes place. The most recent cases of Chikungunya in Italy have occurred between June and October 2017 in Rome, the coastal region of Anzio and Latina. "One case of chikungunya was reported in Ireland during 2016, with a recent travel history to Kenya." What do I need to do if I visit an area with Chikungunya? The HPSC said: "Travellers to affected areas are advised to prevent mosquito bites. Pregnant women, immunosuppressed people and people suffering from a severe chronic illness should consult their physicians prior to the travel in order to assess their risk and get recommendations on personal preventive measures. "All travellers to countries where Chikungunya occurs should take the following steps to prevent mosquito bites: Use of anti-mosquito devices (insecticide-treated bed nets, spray, repellents) Mosquito repellent based on a 30% DEET concentration is recommended. Pregnant women and children under the age of 12 years should consult a physician or pharmacist before use. For newborn children under three months, repellents are not recommended and insecticide-treated bed nets and protective clothing should be used instead. Wear long sleeves and trousers." .Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here.
The Journal
14 hours ago
- The Journal
Daughter of Waterford woman who died from bowel cancer calls for lower screening age
NOELLE DROHAN WAS never really one to complain, or even draw attention to herself. She was a trained accounts technician, and she worked in the garage across the road from her family home in Dungarvan, Co. Waterford, but her daughters say that her main occupation 'was as a always mam'. 'She put myself and my sister first, always, and I suppose she was like a lot of Irish women in that sense,' Niamh Drohan said. Niamh is 34, and just over a year ago, her mother died with colorectal cancer. Throughout her mum's cancer journey, from the first GP visit over worrying symptoms, to after the diagnosis point, Niamh always had the sense that Noelle was holding information back; that the outlook was much worse than what she was saying. Noelle was 55 when she died on 21 July 2024, she was 53 when she first went to the GP. 'My mam was a really private person, she probably suffered in silence for a really long time before she sought out medical attention. She was incredibly unlucky with her health; I was living in Cork and my sister was living in Dublin for the last few years, and it seemed like every time we were back home, she wasn't well in some way,' Niamh said. Niamh said that when she went home to visit she would notice digestive aids around the house, and that her mother's health seemed to have visibly deteriorated. 'Afterwards, when the reality of the situation was clear, she told me that at that time, it was taking her an hour to get dressed in the mornings. She'd put her leggings on and then have to lie down for half an hour, before she could put her t-shirt on,' Niamh said. In February 2023, after several GP visits, Noelle was sent for a full blood panel test. 'They found that her white blood cell count was on the floor, and she was sent to the hospital immediately,' Niamh said. Noelle underwent chemotherapy treatment and appeared to respond well to it during that year, but when Niamh went home for Christmas, she noticed that her condition had seriously deteriorated. 'At that time, she wasn't fully telling me what was going on, but at that time I was crying on the phone to my friends saying, 'I swear to god I think she's dying,' and they didn't know what to say. Noelle's condition worsened to the point that it was clear to her family that her cancer was terminal. 'She came home for the last time in June, and she had a walker to help her get around. At that stage the cancer had spread extensively, even to her spine,' Niamh said. Advertisement Her mam's passing in July 2024 was devastating to her. 'Of course, she was my mam, so I'd say this, but she really was so maternal with everyone,' Niamh said. Afterwards, Niamh started putting together a picture of their family's health history. Her grandmother had passed away with colorectal cancer at the age of 63, so she realised that there was potentially a genetic factor at play. 'I started looking into the latest reports around colorectal cancer in Ireland and in the world, and I saw that there is an increasing prevalence of colorectal cancer cases in people who are well under the screening age, so it made me start to think that the screening age itself in Ireland should be lowered from 59 to 50, because that is what it is the UK, and in other countries around the world,' Niamh said. Niamh is encouraging people to participate in HIQA's consultation programme for increasing the age range for colorectal screening in Ireland. It's understood that currently, the uptake for the colorectal cancer screening programme is at 46%, which is well below the participation for the other national cancer screening services. Just last week, the Health Information and Quality Authority launched a public consultation assessment as it is in the process of looking into lowering the age of the BowelScreen programme to people aged 50-54 in Ireland. Colorectal cancer, which is also referred to as bowel cancer, refers to cancer that occurs in the colon and rectum. It is the second most common cancer in men and the third most common cancer in women in Ireland It is the third leading cause of cancer-related deaths in Ireland. The screening process is fairly simple, at first it involves an at-home test which is intended to detect hidden blood in a person's stool, and if that is detected, they are sent for a colonoscopy. Similar to the cervical cancer screening programme, it can detect early health indicators and early intervention can prevent a person's cancer from developing to a more serious stage. Dr Máirin Ryan, the deputy CEO of HIQA, said that the HSE already has a commitment in place to expand colorectal cancer screening to people aged 55-74, as currently the service is only totally in place for people aged 59 to 69, although the expansion of the age range is already underway. 'The services required for screening are under pressure to meet existing demands. Significant investment and planning would be required to ensure the necessary resources are in place to support a potential future extension of the BowelScreen programme,' Dr Ryan said. To participate in the public consultation, visit the HIQA site here. *Bowel cancer and colorectal cancer are interchangeable terms. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
