Air India captain's eerie words to his first officer before doomed jet crashed killing 260 'are revealed in black box recording'
'The plane is in your hands,' Captain Sumeet Sabharwal allegedly told First Officer Clive Kunder, two Western sources familiar with the contents of the recordings told Corriere della Sera.
The sources said it was not unusual for the captain of a flight to yield the controls to a first officer during takeoff. The plane left the ground at 1:38:39pm and remained airborne for about 30 seconds before losing power and crashing into a residential area.
Mr Kunder was at the controls of the Boeing 787 and asked the captain why he moved the fuel switches into a position that starved the engines of fuel, a source briefed on U.S. officials' early assessment told Reuters. He was said to have requested that he restore the fuel flow before the crash.
'Why did you shut off the engines?' Mr Kunder asked the senior pilot, according to Corriere's sources. Another microphone recorded a 'vague' denial: 'I didn't do it'.
The outlet reports that Mr Kunder was 'unconvinced' and asked the same question 'several more times' over a further six seconds.
A preliminary report released by India's Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau (AAIB) on Saturday confirmed that the fuel switches had switched from 'run' to 'cutoff' just after takeoff -- but did not say how they were moved.
The report also said one pilot was heard on the cockpit voice recorder asking the other why he cut off the fuel and 'the other pilot responded that he did not do so.'
Investigators did not identify which remarks were made by Captain Sumeet Sabharwal and which by First Officer Clive Kunder, who had total flying experience of 15,638 hours and 3,403 hours, respectively.
There was no cockpit video recording definitively showing which pilot flipped the switches, but the weight of evidence from the conversation points to the captain, according to the early assessment by U.S. officials.
The plane momentarily disappeared from view behind trees and buildings before a massive fireball erupted on the horizon in this horrifying clip
The Wall Street Journal first reported similar information on Wednesday about the world's deadliest aviation accident in a decade.
Citing U.S. pilots familiar with the AAIB report, the outlet reported that 'as the pilot actively flying, [First Officer] Kunder likely would have had his hands full pulling back on the Dreamliner's controls at that stage of the flight'.
'Sabharwal, as the pilot monitoring, would have been more likely to have had his hands free as he oversaw the operation.'
According to the report, the switches were apparently moved in succession, one second apart, before both were turned back on about 10 seconds later.
The movement of the fuel control switches allows and cuts fuel flow to the plane's engines.
The report did not say how the switches could have flipped to the cutoff position during the flight.
The switches' 'locking feature' meant pilots had to lift them up before changing their position - they are not simple push buttons that can be accidentally turned off.
Almost immediately after the plane lifted off the ground, closed-circuit TV footage showed a backup energy source called a ram air turbine (RAT) had deployed, indicating a loss of power from the engines.
The London-bound plane began to lose thrust, and after reaching a height of 650 feet, the jet started to sink.
The fuel switches for both engines were indeed turned back to 'run', and the airplane automatically tried restarting the engines, the report said.
But the plane could not gain power quickly enough to stop its descent. The report stated: 'One of the pilots transmitted "MAYDAY MAYDAY MAYDAY"'.
The plane clipped some trees and a chimney before crashing in a fireball into a building on a nearby medical college campus, the report said, killing 19 people on the ground and 241 of the 242 on board.
Both fuel switches were found in the run position at the crash site.
Aviation expert and former airline pilot Terry Tozer said the engine cutoff switches being switched to off only seconds after takeoff was 'absolutely bizarre.'
'Unfortunately, the altitude was so low that the engines were only beginning to recover and they didn´t have enough time,' Tozer told Sky News.
India 's civil aviation minister, Kinjarapu Ram Mohan Naidu, said the report´s findings were preliminary and one should not 'jump into any conclusions on this.'
'Let us wait for the final report,' Naidu told reporters.
Investigators are said to be looking at the medical records of the pilots as part of their probe.
Captain Mohan Ranganathan, a leading aviation safety expert in India, claimed that one of the pilots had suffered with their mental health, citing other Air India pilots.
Speaking to The Daily Telegraph, he claimed: 'He had taken time off from flying in the last three to four years. He had taken medical leave for that.'
Captain Sabharwal is also understood to have taken bereavement leave after the death of his mother, though Mr Ranganathan understands that he had been 'medically cleared' by Air India prior to the fatal crash last month.
Air India, in a statement, said it is fully cooperating with authorities investigating the crash.
A final report is expected within a year.
In an internal memo on Monday, Air India CEO Campbell Wilson said the preliminary report found no mechanical or maintenance faults and that all required maintenance had been carried out.
Wilson also urged the airline's staff to avoid drawing premature conclusions about the crash.
The AAIB's preliminary report had no safety recommendations for Boeing or engine manufacturer GE.
The AAIB, which is leading the investigation, said in a statement on Thursday that 'certain sections of the international media are repeatedly attempting to draw conclusions through selective and unverified reporting.'
It added the investigation was ongoing and it remained too early to draw definitive conclusions.
Most air crashes are caused by multiple factors, and under international rules, a final report is expected within a year of an accident.
The plane´s black boxes - combined cockpit voice recorders and flight data recorders - were recovered in the days following the crash and later downloaded in India.
Indian authorities had also ordered deeper checks of Air India´s entire Boeing 787 Dreamliner fleet to prevent future incidents. Air India has 33 Dreamliners in its fleet.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Bihar: The witchcraft murders that shook an Indian village
Warning: This story contains details that some may find weeks after five members of a family in India were brutally killed and allegedly burned alive amid accusations of the practice of witchcraft, the survivors are still trying to come to terms with the tragedy. For Manisha Devi (name changed) of Tetgama village in Bihar state, the night of 6 July has been the darkest in her around 10pm, a belligerent mob gathered outside their relatives' home - by dawn, five people, including a 71-year-old widow Kato Oraon, were incident in Bihar is not an isolated one. According to the National Crime Records Bureau, more than 2,500 people, mostly women, were killed in India on suspicion of witchcraft between 2000 and 2016. But the Tetgama murders stand out, as five members of a family were killed say superstition and belief in witchcraft remain widespread among many of India's disadvantaged tribal communities, including those involved in the recent Bihar alleged murderers and victims all belong to the Oraon tribe and have lived together for generations. But what transpired on the night of 6 July has opened a chasm that is unlikely to be bridged anytime streets now echo with silence - all the residents, except four of Kato Devi's sons and their families, have fled the village. Some homes are locked, while others appear to have been abandoned in a BBC spoke to the victims' relatives, police and officials to piece together what happened on the night of the killings. Manisha Devi says she heard a commotion and found a large crowd outside the home of Babulal Oraon, the eldest of Kato's five sons who lived Oraon, his wife Sita Devi, the couple's son Manjit and daughter-in-law Rani Devi were among those killed. His youngest son, a teenager, is the only in their first information report (FIR), which is available online, have named a villager - Ramdev Oraon - as the main accused. They said Ramdev's son had died about 10 days back after falling sick, but he had allegedly accused Kato Devi and her family of killing his child through witchcraft. It's not clear what the belief was based on. Police say Ramdev is absconding and that they are looking for the night of the killings, Ramdev had allegedly brought his nephew, who appeared seriously unwell, to the victims' house. Manisha Devi said she saw the teenager lying on the ground and the village exorcist performing some rituals and reciting mantras. Manisha Devi, another relative and the survivor in his police complaint have alleged that the exorcist "pronounced Kato Devi and Babulal's wife Sita Devi as witches, blaming them for the death and illness in Ramdev's family". "Kato was dragged out and given half-an-hour to heal the sick teenager. Sita Devi, who was away visiting her mother in a neighbouring village, was called and asked to return if she wanted to see her family alive," she second relative who also witnessed the alleged murders says Kato pleaded with the villagers to see reason, but the mob kept getting angrier. "When Babulal and Manjit tried to intervene, the mob attacked them too. Rani Devi was also assaulted when she attempted to shield her husband," she adds. "When Sita Devi returned with her son, the survivor, they too were assaulted." The teenager later told the police that he somehow managed to run away, hide in the darkness and watch as his family was lynched and police complaint names 23 men and women from the village and "150 to 200 unnamed people who made up the mob"."The mob was armed with sticks, rods and sharp weapons. They tied all the five victims with a rope and dragged them to the village pond, assaulting and abusing them all the way," it complaint adds that the victims were "half-dead" when they were doused with petrol and set on fire, their bodies were packed in sacks and taken away on a tractor.A senior police official told reporters the next day that the victims were burned alive and their charred bodies had been recovered from a pond near the Magistrate Anshul Kumar also initially said the five were burned alive. But he recently told the BBC that the post-mortem report was inconclusive on the issue."The report indicates evidence of burn injuries and assault; however, it does not clearly articulate the precise cause of death, whether it was due to burning or whether that occurred post-murder."Shockingly, the night-long violence occurred not very far from the Mufassil police station, located just 7km (4.5 miles) away. Mr Kumar said the police heard about the incident 11 hours after the mob gathered, and acknowledged that it showed "there were shortcomings somewhere" and that "this was our failure". But the delay, he added, was "since the entire community was involved".In the aftermath, the officer-in-charge was suspended. His replacement Sudin Ram told the BBC that four people, including the exorcist, have been arrested. The others are absconding, he said."We have invoked laws related to unlawful assembly, rioting, causing grievous hurt by dangerous weapons, wrongful restrain, mob lynching and disappearance of evidence of offence," Mr Ram said, adding that the guilty could face life imprisonment or the death penalty. The BBC has not been able to speak to the exorcist, who is in custody, or to Ramdev, whose whereabouts are unknown. The survivor is in protective custody at a safe location and receiving counselling, police official Mr Kumar said, adding that he is "gradually recovering."His brothers, who were away working when the attack occurred, are receiving free food and support, he added. They're currently staying with relatives in a nearby village.A special investigation team is probing the lynchings, but Mr Kumar said superstition-fuelled hysteria drove the crowd to commit the say this is the area's first such incident, with no prior witchcraft cases ever Mira Devi, a local social worker, told the BBC that tribal villages lack education and rely more on exorcists than on doctors or council head Santosh Singh says most children skip school to work at nearby brick kilns with their parents. A local teacher, Indranand Chaudhary, confirmed only three are enrolled - and none attend. Tetgama, a tribal village 11km from Purnea town, is home to 22 paddy fields, a villager points to burnt maize stalks - the site of the 6 July mud paths lead to the victims' homes. At Babulal Oraon's two-room hut, built from corn stalks, bamboo, and mud, time feels the room where Manjit and his newlywed wife Rani Devi slept, the bed is neatly made, with a clean sheet and the mosquito net tucked Devi sits outside her home, haunted by the senseless murders she and others witnessed that night."We stood helplessly, watching the victims desperately trying to save themselves. That scene still haunts us," one man said.
BBC News
a day ago
- BBC News
Should teen sex be a crime? Indian woman lawyer mounts challenge
In late July, lawyer Indira Jaising mounted a challenge against the legal age for having sex in India - which is 18 years - in the Supreme Court, renewing conversations around the criminalisation of teen Jaising argued that consensual sex between 16 and 18-year-olds is neither exploitative nor abusive and urged the court to exempt it from criminal prosecution."The purpose of age-based laws is to prevent abuse, not to criminalise consensual, age-appropriate intimacy," Ms Jaising has said in her written submissions to the the federal government has opposed this, saying that introducing such an exemption would jeopardise the safety and protection of children (persons under the age of 18, according to Indian laws), opening them up to abuse and case has re-ignited debate around consent and whether Indian laws, especially the country's main law against child sexual abuse - Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 or Pocso - should be altered to introduce a provision exempting 16 to 18 year-olds having consensual sex from their rights activists say exempting teens protects their autonomy, while opponents warn it could fuel crimes like trafficking and child question whether teens can bear the burden of proof if abused. More importantly, who decides the age of consent laws - and whose interests do they truly serve? Like many countries, India has struggled to set its age of sexual consent. Unlike the US, where it varies by state, India enforces a uniform age legal age for having sex is also much higher than most European countries, or places like UK and Canada, where it is was 10 years when India's criminal code was enacted in 1860 and was increased to 16 in 1940 when the code was introduced the next major change, pushing the "age of consent" to 18 years in 2012. A year later, India's criminal laws were amended to reflect this change and the country's new criminal code, introduced in 2024, has adhered to this revised is consensual teen sex a crime in India?But over the past decade or so, many child rights activists and even courts have taken a critical view of the country's legal age to have sex and have called for it to be lowered to 16 years. They say the law criminalises consensual teen relationships and is often misused by adults to control or block relationships - especially those of remains a taboo topic in the country even though studies have shown that millions of Indian teenagers are sexually active."As a society, we're also divided along caste, class and religious lines, which makes the [age of consent] law even more susceptible to misuse," says Sharmila Raje, co-founder of Foundation for Child Protection-Muskaan, a non-profit working to prevent child sexual abuse for over two decades. In 2022, the Karnataka High court directed India's Law Commission - an executive panel that advices the government on legal reform - to rethink the age of consent under Pocso, "so as to take into consideration the ground realities".It noted several cases where girls over 16 fell in love, eloped, and had sex, only for the boy to be charged with rape and abduction under Pocso and criminal its report the following year, the Law Commission ruled out lowering the age of consent, but recommended "guided judicial discretion" during sentencing in cases involving "tacit approval" from children aged 16 to 18 years, meaning where the relationship has been this is yet to be implemented, courts across the country have been using this principle to allow for appeals, grant bail, make acquittals and even quash cases after taking into consideration the facts of the case and the victim's testimony. Many child rights activists, including Ms Raje, urge this provision be codified to standardise enforcement; left as a suggestion, courts may ignore April, the Madras High Court overturned the acquittal in a case where the 17-year-old victim was in a relationship with the 23-year-old accused and the two eloped after the victim's parents arranged her marriage to another man. The accused was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment."The court adopted a literal interpretation of the Pocso Act," Shruthi Ramakrishnan, a researcher at Enfold Proactive Health Trust - a child rights charity - noted in her column in The Indian Express newspaper, calling it a "grave miscarriage of justice". Ms Jaising argues that judicial discretion at sentencing isn't enough, as the accused still faces lengthy investigations and judicial system is infamously slow with millions of cases pending across all court levels. A research paper by India Child Protection Fund found that as of January 2023, nearly 250,000 Pocso cases were pending in special courts set up to try these cases."The process is the punishment for many," Ms Jaising notes. "A case-by-case approach leaving it to the discretion of judges is also not the best solution as it can result in uneven results and does not take into account the possibility of bias," she urges the court to add a "close-in-age exception" for consensual sex between 16- and 18-year-olds in Pocso and related laws. This "close-in-age exception" would prevent consensual acts between peers in that age group from being treated as and child rights activist Bhuwan Ribhu warns that a blanket exception could be misused in cases of kidnapping, trafficking, and child marriage. He advocates judicial discretion paired with a justice system overhaul."We need faster processes so that cases are disposed off in a time-bound manner. We also need better rehabilitation facilities and compensation for victims," he Ganguly, co-founder of HAQ: Centre for Child Rights, however, agrees with Ms Jaising. "We can't shy away from making changes because we're afraid of the law being misused," she says, adding that Ms Jaising's argument is not new as over the years, many activists and experts have made similar recommendations."Laws need to keep pace with changes in society if they are to remain effective and relevant," she BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, Twitter and Facebook.
The Sun
a day ago
- The Sun
Horrifying moment ‘rich kid' driver knocks over scooter rider & then reverses 4×4 truck into him in road rage
THIS is the horrifying moment a wealthy businessman's son mowed down an elderly scooter rider before deliberately reversing his 4x4 into him in a shocking road rage attack. Sickening CCTV footage shows Manan Anand – dubbed a 'rich kid' locally – speeding on the wrong side of the road in Kashmir, India. 4 4 4 4 The 20-year-old then slams into Kamalkant Dutta, 68, at around 1.30pm on Sunday. The pensioner is seen being flung to the ground as Anand, son of prominent businessman Rajinder Anand, overtakes at high speed. But instead of rushing to help, the driver coldly throws his vehicle into reverse and smashes into the OAP a second time, knocking him onto his back where he cracks his head on the tarmac. Anand then casually steps out of the 4WD alongside a passenger, walks over to the injured Dutta. But moments later, he climbs back into the car and drives off, leaving the pensioner fighting for his life. Horrified bystanders rushed Dutta to GMC Jammu hospital, where he remains in critical condition. Police confirmed they have since seized the vehicle and detained Anand's father for questioning. But despite multiple raids over the past couple of days, Anand himself has gone on the run. Police said the crash happened near Allora Textiles in Jammu, when a Mahindra Thar being "driven in a rash and negligent manner" hit a scooter coming from the opposite direction. A spokesperson added: "The scooty, which was coming from the opposite direction, was struck by the Thar, resulting in injuries to the rider. Dramatic moment idiot driver speeds off road, spins out of control and crashes into police car "The injured individual was shifted to GMC Jammu by passers-by, while the Thar driver fled from the spot." Cops have launched a manhunt to track down the fugitive driver. It comes after a young comedian died in a horror crash after a retired judge allegedly mowed her down while drunk — with a naked woman sitting on his lap. Thaís Bonatti, 30, was riding her bicycle to work at a restaurant in Araçatuba, Brazil, when Fernando Augusto Fontes Rodrigues Júnior, 61, allegedly slammed his Ford Ranger pickup into her. The impact left Bonatti with devastating injuries, including a fractured pelvis and a traumatic brain injury, last Thursday morning. She was rushed to hospital, but medics were unable to save her. According to a police report, Rodrigues — a former civil court judge now working as a lawyer — had left a nightclub shortly before the crash with a woman believed to be a sex worker. Surveillance footage allegedly showed the woman naked and trying to climb off his lap as the vehicle stopped near a supermarket. He was taken into custody and charged with manslaughter, but was released the following day after posting bail of 40,000 Brazilian reais (around $7,150).
