Directorship bans imposed on brothers behind Starbucks franchise in Ireland
Two brothers behind various Irish franchises, including several Starbucks cafes, TGI Fridays, Mao, and Hardrock Café, have been banned from acting as company directors of any company for five years.
A High Court judge imposed the restriction after finding Colm and Ciaran Butler failed to prove they acted responsibly in their operation of one of their companies, Downtul Ltd, which leased a premises at St Stephen's Green, Dublin, that operated as a Starbucks.
In a judgment published on Wednesday, Ms Justice Nessa Cahill noted the brothers are directors of more than 130 companies each.
'It is plain from this fact — and from the vigour with which this application was opposed — that the declarations of restriction sought in the particular circumstances of this case would have significant implications for them, beyond the symbolic or reputational,' she said.
Her orders followed an application from the liquidator of Downtul, Patrick O'Connell.
Downtul was placed into voluntary liquidation in November 2022.
Mr O'Connell later raised concerns that the brothers did not act honestly and responsibly 'with regard to their duties, responsibilities, and actions' as directors of Downtul.
Arising from this, Mr O'Connell sought an order for the brothers to be restricted from acting as company directors or secretaries for five years unless the company meets certain requirements set out in the Companies Act 2014.
The Butlers opposed Mr O'Connell's application.
A hearing of the case lasted five days, with both sides calling expert witnesses.
Acceding to the liquidator's request, Ms Justice Cahill said she was not satisfied the brothers acted responsibly in relation to Downtul's affairs, but they showed they acted honestly.
Ms Justice Cahill said her findings arose primarily from the brothers' operation of Downtul, and a related company they controlled: Atercin Liffey Unlimited Company.
Downtul's function was to lease a premises at Stephen Court, St Stephen's Green, and it did not trade or carry on a business.
It entered into a lease agreement for the premises in December 2013, its sole transaction.
Atercin operated a Starbucks cafe out of the Stephen's Green premises.
The judge noted that Atercin operated from the premises rent-free for two-and-a-half years and obtained government supports to deal with the impacts of the covid-19 pandemic.
In effect, Downtul bore the liability and cost of the lease, while Atercin occupied the leased premises and earned revenue from its trade there.
The judge said Downtul received no contribution from Atercin towards rent due on the Stephen Court premises 'and, consequently, was unable to pay its debts as they fell due'.
'In allowing the company to enter and maintain these arrangements, and in failing to ensure an enforceable mechanism by which the company could obtain the funds necessary to discharge its liabilities as they fell due or otherwise protect its position, the respondents [the Butlers] failed to demonstrate responsible conduct with regard to the interests of the company,' the judge said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Dublin Live
3 hours ago
- Dublin Live
Penneys to slash 100 jobs at Dublin headquarters
Our community members are treated to special offers, promotions and adverts from us and our partners. You can check out at any time. More info Penneys is to cut around 150 jobs in Ireland, the UK and the US, the company has confirmed. Around 100 redundancies will be at its international headquarters in Dublin. It means around 7% of the company's 1,500 staff in the Irish capital will be impacted. The planned 150 job cuts are in people and culture, finance and procurement. The move is connected to a decision to outsource some of its support activities to a third party, and it is understood the third party is Accenture in Mumbai. As is required by law, the Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke and Alan Dillon, Minister of State for Small Business and Retail, have been notified of the company's collective redundancy plan. A Primark spokesperson said: "As we continue to grow internationally, we need to evolve our operating model to best support this ambition. "We're exploring how resourcing via external partners could help support our operations so that we can focus our own resources on what we do best. As part of this, we are now proposing that a number of support function activities move to a third party and we are beginning a collective consultation. "This unfortunately will impact a number of Primark colleagues primarily in our head office operations. While this is all about setting us up for future success and continuing to offer great products at great prices to our customers, these are not decisions we take lightly. "We understand how difficult this news is for those colleagues affected and we'll be working to support them as best we can." Join our Dublin Live breaking news service on WhatsApp. Click this link to receive your daily dose of Dublin Live content. We also treat our community members to special offers, promotions, and adverts from us and our partners. If you don't like our community, you can check out any time you like. If you're curious, you can read our Privacy Notice . For all the latest news from Dublin and surrounding areas visit our homepage .
RTÉ News
3 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Workers seeking new jobs for better commuting options
More than a third of all commuters in Ireland are looking for a new job in order to have better commuting options according to a new survey. For workers in the 18 to 34-year-old age group the proportion looking to move job for shorter commutes was even higher, at 42%. The survey was conducted by KINTO Join, a digital mobility platform focused on sustainable commuting solutions. The KINTO 'Ireland on the Move' survey found that 65% of workers are more likely to stay in a job with more favourable commuting options. It also found that 71% would prioritise employers or universities offering free or low-cost shuttle bus service. More than 60% of commuters believe workplaces and universities should be more involved in supporting commuting experience. Almost one in three think employers and universities should incentivise sustainable travel. More flexible working hours and reward programmes were among top incentives suggested. One thousand Irish commuters comprising university students and employees were surveyed for the research. Two-thirds said they consider commuting options when selecting a new job while 68% said they would refuse a job if the commute was too long. Almost half of respondents said more flexible working hours would encourage them to change their means of commuting to a more communal or sustainable method of travel. KINTO Chief Executive Patrizia Niehaus, said: "Commuters in Ireland clearly care about how they travel to work, with many making career decisions with this in mind. However, they lack choice and support. In turn, organisations are potentially missing out on the best talent and undermining their own sustainability objectives. "They might not realise it yet, but business leaders have the power to facilitate more sustainable journeys for both their people and their companies. From shuttle buses to staff rewards, these micro-level actions can have macro-level impact."
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Letters to the Editor: Climate action — we need to move from rhetoric to action
We're going to be hearing a lot about 'just transition' in the coming months. At week two of the UN Bonn climate talks, which will shape the road to the Cop30 climate summit in Brazil, governments are starting to engage with the idea of a just transition. This is to be welcomed. The climate crisis is no longer a distant threat, but a burning reality for millions. Yet, the climate burden continues to fall unfairly on the world's poorest communities and those who have contributed least to global emissions and climate change. A just transition will ensure that the shift to a low carbon economy is fair, inclusive, and delivers job security and affordable food and energy access to the most vulnerable. But it also means rich nations stepping up with grants-based finance to support communities and countries most affected by climate meltdown, countries burdened by debt and denied climate finance. It also means a commitment to a serious shift away from fossil fuels. While the level of fossil fuel finance had been declining since 2021, last year saw two thirds of banks increasing their financing by a combined $162bn — a period when the world experienced its hottest year since records began. Ireland is shamefully playing its part in fossil fuel financing. A recent report by ActionAid Ireland and Trócaire revealed that, as of June 2024, an astonishing €3bn in fossil fuel investments were held by Irish-based financial institutions. Even more disturbing, 91% of that investment is tied to companies actively expanding fossil fuel operations in direct defiance of international scientific consensus on the need to limit global warming to 1.5C. Without a clear agreement on just transition at Cop30, the energy transition risks deepening inequality and further destabilising fragile economies. But a just transition framework, backed by funding, strong labour protections, and international co-operation, can turn this challenge into an opportunity for shared prosperity and resilience. It was encouraging to read Ali Sheridan, the chair of Ireland's Just Transition Commission, an independent advisory body established by the Government last year, affirm recently that it's essential any climate action must be fair for all. The world must move beyond rhetoric to action. A fair climate future must work for everyone, not just the privileged few. Karol Balfe, CEO, ActionAid Ireland, Dublin Criticism towards IHCA unwarranted Sarah Harte asserted in her piece ('The Gaza catastrophe is testing Ireland's conscience – and its credibility', June 11) that the Irish Hospital Consultants Association (IHCA) has taken a position of 'deafening silence in calling out genocide' in relation to Israel's systematic campaign of violence in Gaza. Such criticism is completely unwarranted. The IHCA has issued five statements since the beginning of 2024, condemning the unlawful destruction of hospital infrastructure and subsequent targeting of healthcare practitioners by the Israeli military. We are unequivocal in stating that the actions of the Netanyahu government and Israeli Defence Forces equate to crimes that contravene international law; accordingly, the International Criminal Court has issued an arrest warrant. We agree with the Government's assessment that these crimes against humanity include a genocide against the Palestinian people. In tandem with these repeated statements, I wrote for The Medical Independent a piece entitled 'We cannot be bystanders to genocide' (May 12, 2024), long before any Western government named it as such. In my first public address as president of the Irish Hospital Consultants' Association, I called for an end to the 'targeting of medical staff and hospital infrastructure in plain sight'. Several of our members are working on the frontline in Gaza hospitals, coming under live fire. We cannot be silent when it is these colleagues, their patients, and our Palestinian peers facing these desperate circumstances every day. We will always defend the right of healthcare practitioners to deliver care without fear of death or violence, and for their patients to live healthy dignified lives, whether that be in Ukraine, the Middle East, or any other conflict. Gabrielle Colleran, President, Irish Hospital Consultants Association, Dublin 14 You are as old as how you feel 'You are as old as you are portrayed' may be true ( Editorial, Saturday 21), but what about hitting the dance floor well in to your 80s and 90es as reported by an international newspaper last week about a group of Belgian nursing home residents as they danced and jived to 'bass-heavy' music among their much younger counterparts at a nightclub in central Brussels? You are as old as how you feel and your attitude to doing new things. 'There's no real age limit for knowing how to party, ' says the manager of the nightclub where Papy Booom — a Belgian non-profit that aims to address loneliness among older people and create more opportunities for fun — held their night out. Bring it on I say! Tom McElligott, Listowel, Co Kerry Industry crying out for tradespeople I have spent 39 years in the construction business, 33 of them as a self-employed contractor. To me, the elephant in the room is the lack of tradesmen and also general operatives in this sector. When I started out in 1986, we spent our first year in Anco — a government-based training facility and Cork RTC, now MTU. It was a great grounding for green lads starting out. Unfortunately, now we are moving all our children into college because of their popularity and encouragement from secondary schools to encourage kids to go there. There is also a perception out there, from parents mainly, that the construction industry is beneath their child. It's OK for them to train as a engineer/architect/quantity surveyor or possibly some of the physically easier trades of electrical or plumbing. The reality is we are crying out for groundsman, carpenters, blocklayers, and plasterers — the latter two are not a dying trade and will become extinct in the next 10 years or less, which will stagnate the construction industry. What needs to happen is for the Government to financially incentivise builders and tradesmen to employ and train young people. What's your view on this issue? You can tell us here At the moment, tradesmen as a whole — there are exceptions — aren't interested in putting the time into training an apprentice. The Government also needs to hold the revenue received from the construction industry, and use it to reinvest in the sector when there is a downturn in the economy and invest in public buildings such as schools, libraries, and hospitals to get better value for money during those times. More importantly, it will keep our building workforce in jobs. This process would encourage young people to go into the sector for stability, and also make parents more content in seeing their child enter the sector. Finally, a strong advertising campaign is needed to get young people to join the industry. Working in the industry can be deeply satisfying, working with your hands and brain and getting a lot of satisfaction. If you are prepared to work hard, listen, and learn, there are great opportunities to earn a good living and become financially secure after a few years of working, compared to going to college and having massive financial outlays in the process and struggling financially in poorly paid jobs at the end of your four or five years of college. Stephen McGrath, Fermoy, Co Cork Landing big tax bill The Connacht Tribune recently reported the dismay of Mayo councillors at the €385,000 that their council must pay to Revenue for their unused residential zoned land. If a council with an annual budget of €213m for 2025 alone cannot make use of its lands, what hope is there for mere mortal private developers without the fairy god-exchequer to fund them and who have things like tax to deal with. Local authorities have cumulatively paid over €11m in residential zoned land tax (RZLT) — clearly, councils have land they are not making use of. Remember that they have deemed their own land ready and suitable for housing. The Land Development Agency is seeking powers to buy private land, but this is a distraction from the real land hoarding done by the many arms of the State itself. Politicians created the ridiculous RZLT. That they find their own councils on the receiving end is a most pleasing karma indeed. Alex Wilsdon, Dublin Rd, Kilkenny Read More Letters to the Editor: My mother had a happy experience of residential care
