Misleading post about WP new face Siti Alia's rally speech sparks online debate, Singapore News
At the party's first rally for General Election (GE) 2025 on April 25, the 43-year-old lawyer said that while Singaporeans meet their MPs to discuss "bread and butter issues", they would also like to "discuss the effects of certain laws or the government's positions on certain global issues".
"The concern for the humanitarian crisis in Palestine crosses the boundaries of race and religion. It is something that many Singaporeans, regardless of their ethnicity and beliefs, have expressed concern about," she said.
Clips of Siti Alia making these statements were stitched together and shared on Reddit with the title "WP's Siti Alia declares Palestine is important global issue, more important than bread and butter Punggol issues?"
This prompted a heated debate among netizens, some of whom criticised her for mentioning the topic during a GE rally.
One such comment read: "We are talking about Singapore and Singapore's policies and government. Singapore is so small, what use would that have on Palestine, which is halfway across the world?"
"We have matters that need to be fixed within Singapore borders and this topic being mentioned in a Singapore GE rally makes things very unappealing to me," read another comment.
Netizens who claimed they were at the rally in person wrote that they saw people "turn around and walk off" upon Siti Alia's mention of the topic.
Some other commenters, however, pointed out that she did not say the Israel-Hamas conflict took priority over local matters, adding that the post was misleading.
One such netizen wrote: "She didn't say in verbatim that the Palestine cause is more important than bread and butter issues in the video. That was inferred by [the Reddit post]."
"Her point is that such an important and sensitive global issue was inserted into the MOE curriculum without consulting parents. I don't think her intention was to express any stance on this issue," wrote another commenter. 'We want healthy discourse'
Siti Alia, who is a candidate for Punggol GRC, had started her speech by addressing concerns regarding the humanitarian crisis in Palestine.
She then brought up the Ministry of Education's (MOE) Character and Citizenship Education (CCE) lesson on the Israel-Hamas conflict, which sparked online discussion and parliament debate in 2024.
MOE eventually revised the lesson to make it better scoped for students of different age groups and provided teachers delivering it with additional support.
Siti Alia questioned why parents were not asked for consent before their children were taught that lesson.
"I put forward this example to show how much it means to the average Singaporean to have their voices heard. After all, the elected officials are elected in order to be the voice of Singaporeans," she said.
"This is where I hope that myself and my colleagues from The Workers' Party can help. No issue brought up by a constituent will be too trivial or unimportant to be raised. We want healthy discourse to take place," she added.
She was addressing some 10,000 attendees at a field along Anchorvale Crescent on April 24, alongside 12 other WP election candidates.
While it was the party's first physical rally since 2015, the long absence did not dampen the enthusiasm of rally-goers, who began trudging into the muddy field nearly two hours before the first speaker took to the stage.
For our GE2025 microsite, visit here.
[[nid:717197]]
bhavya.rawat@asiaone.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
Australia chides Israel after diplomats' visas revoked
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong said revoking the diplomats' visas was an 'unjustified reaction' by Israel. SYDNEY - Australia's foreign minister on Aug 19 criticised Israel for revoking visas held by Canberra's diplomatic representatives to the Palestinian Authority. Israel's tit-for-tat move followed Australia's decision on the evening of Aug 18 to block a far-right Israeli politician from the country ahead of a speaking tour. Australia and Israel have been increasingly at odds since Canberra declared it would recognise a Palestinian state at the UN General Assembly in September. Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong said revoking the diplomats' visas was an 'unjustified reaction' by Israel. 'At a time when dialogue and diplomacy are needed more than ever, the Netanyahu Government is isolating Israel and undermining international efforts towards peace and a two-state solution,' she said in a statement. The Australian government on Aug 18 cancelled the visa of far-right Israeli politician Simcha Rothman, whose party is within Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's governing coalition. Mr Rothman had been scheduled to speak at events organised by the Australian Jewish Association. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. World Arrangements being made for Putin, Zelensky to meet, says Trump World Trump's art of the 'peace' deal for Ukraine and Russia Singapore 'I vaped when I woke up until I slept': More youth vaping to cope with stress, say social workers Singapore 'I'd have phone in one hand, vape in the other': Youth addicted to vapes gets help to quit habit Singapore New ITE facility with mock-ups, simulations to train built environment students Opinion Dirty BlueSG cars and trashed bikes show us why Singaporeans can't have nice things Hours later, Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Saar said he had revoked the visas of Australia's representatives to the Palestinian Authority. 'I also instructed the Israeli Embassy in Canberra to carefully examine any official Australian visa application for entry to Israel,' he said. 'This follows Australia's decisions to recognise a 'Palestinian state' and against the backdrop of Australia's unjustified refusal to grant visas to a number of Israeli figures.' AFP
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
At White House Summit, a master class of diplomacy
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox US President Donald Trump, Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelensky and other European leaders pose for a family photo at the White House. WASHINGTON – Over the past seven months, the leaders of the Western world have been enrolled in an intensive course of Trumpology. One by one, presidents and prime ministers of European countries have travelled to Washington, learning all sorts of lessons about how best to handle the tricky man who sits behind the big desk in the gold-wrapped room shaped like an oval. On Aug 19, the whole class showed up at the White House. The time had come to put their education to use. And it was the Ukrainian leader, Mr Volodymyr Zelensky, who seemed to have learned the most since his last visit , when he was mocked for not wearing a suit, deemed insufficiently deferential and ultimately kicked out. This time, he showed up to his Oval Office meeting with a more formal look, a game sense of humour and a letter for the First Lady. 'I cannot believe it,' Mr Trump said as he looked Mr Zelensky up and down, taking measure of his new black-on-black get-up. 'I love it. Look at you.' In the Oval Office, Mr Zelensky again encountered Mr Brian Glenn, the right-wing reporter-instigator who criticised Mr Zelensky for his clothing the last time he was in the Oval. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. World Arrangements being made for Putin, Zelensky to meet, says Trump World Trump's art of the 'peace' deal for Ukraine and Russia Singapore 'I vaped when I woke up until I slept': More youth vaping to cope with stress, say social workers Singapore 'I'd have phone in one hand, vape in the other': Youth addicted to vapes gets help to quit habit Opinion Dirty BlueSG cars and trashed bikes show us why Singaporeans can't have nice things World Hamas accepts proposed deal for ceasefire with Israel and hostage release, Egyptian source says Mr Glenn told Mr Zelensky that he 'looked fabulous' now. Mr Zelensky played along: 'You are in the same suit. You see, I changed, you have not.' Everybody laughed. The Ukrainian president produced a letter from his wife addressed to First Lady Melania Trump. Mr Trump seemed thrilled by this. 'It's not to you, it's to your wife,' Mr Zelensky said as Mr Trump took the letter in hand. This caused Mr Trump to laugh and smile wide. 'I want it!' he said. Later in the afternoon, Mr Trump and Mr Zelensky joined the leaders of Britain, Germany, Italy, France and Finland in the state dining room. The Nato secretary-general, Mr Mark Rutte, and the president of the European Commission, Dr Ursula Von der Leyen, were there as well. Both had, at various times earlier in 2025, found their own methods for dealing with Mr Trump. Now, they sat together and tried to work him as one. Around the table they went, thanking him for all that he had done while ever so gently slipping in their specific pleas for a lasting security guarantee in Ukraine and an immediate ceasefire. Managing Trump This delicate dance seemed momentarily at risk when German Chancellor Friedrich Merz insisted a bit more forcefully than the others that a ceasefire was of paramount importance. Mr Trump had gone to Alaska days earlier with the stated aim of achieving a ceasefire, but after he failed to get one, he changed his tune. His public position now is that a ceasefire is not necessary to continue with negotiations. When Mr Merz insisted that the opposite was the case, the smile left Mr Trump's face. Nails on a chalkboard. Someone had upset the president. He got defensive for a moment, but then the meeting started to hum along at a pleasant pitch once more. European leaders in the dining room were there to manage a global crisis. Which meant they also had to manage the mood of one famously mercurial man. The subject of this high-level diplomatic summit was diplomacy mixed with psychology. Adding to the surreal nature of the thing was the way Russian President Vladimir Putin hovered over it all, just out of sight, like a character offstage. Mr Trump kept bringing up Mr Putin's perspective. 'Vladimir Putin wants it to end,' he claimed. He repeatedly mentioned that he needed to call Mr Putin to update him on how the meetings were shaping up. The Europeans looked stoic at every mention of Mr Putin, as if they hardly needed to be reminded of the Russian leader's viewpoint. Who has better mastered the technique of appealing to Mr Trump's sensibilities, Mr Putin or the Europeans? After the Russian leader got his face time with Mr Trump at their summit in Anchorage on Aug 15, the American president came away having adopted much of Mr Putin's approach on Ukraine. But by the end of the day, it did seem as if the Europeans had learned a thing or two. 'I had a very good meeting with distinguished guests,' Mr Trump wrote on social media after it was all over. NYTIMES
Straits Times
4 hours ago
- Straits Times
Trump's US tariffs seen fostering new China-Global South trade order
More than half of China's total trade surplus is with the Global South, compared with 36 per cent for the US and 23 per cent for Western Europe. Hong Kong – US President Donald Trump's tariff war is accelerating Beijing's trade and investment push into developing nations known as the Global South, according to research by S&P Global, potentially creating a new trade order dominated by Chinese firms. China's goods exports over the past decade have doubled to nations mostly across South-east Asia, Latin America and the Middle East, compared with growth of 28 per cent to the United States and 58 per cent to Western Europe, S&P Global said in a report on Aug 19. That trend has accelerated in the five years since Mr Trump's first term. The tariff-led push comes while Chinese firms are seeking new markets abroad as the world's second-largest economy slows, and as its companies seek to carve out manufacturing hubs for goods from electric vehicles to electronics. 'High uncertainties under US tariffs and China's slowdown will continue to motivate Chinese firms to head to the Global South,' S&P Global's economists said in the report. 'The result could be a new order of global commerce where South-South trade becomes the new centre of gravity and Chinese multinationals emerge as the new key players.' Economic data last week underscored the pain of US tariffs on China's economy, with factory activity rising at the slowest rate since November and investment in property and infrastructure falling. Exports to the US slumped in July for a fourth month in figures reported on Aug 7, though shipments to countries in Africa to South-east Asia more than made up for the dip. Chinese officials have increasingly sought to bolster relations with developing nations in recent months, reducing trade barriers and signing new trade deals. In June, Chinese President Xi Jinping said he would eliminate all import tariffs on almost all African nations, and he has attended summits and held meetings with Latin American and South-east Asian leaders. China's trade with its 20 largest partners in the Global South now makes up on average 20 per cent of those countries' gross domestic product, according to S&P Global. As well, more than half of China's total trade surplus is with the Global South, compared with 36 per cent for the US and 23 per cent for Western Europe. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. World Arrangements being made for Putin, Zelensky to meet, says Trump World Trump's art of the 'peace' deal for Ukraine and Russia Singapore 'I vaped when I woke up until I slept': More youth vaping to cope with stress, say social workers Singapore 'I'd have phone in one hand, vape in the other': Youth addicted to vapes gets help to quit habit Opinion Dirty BlueSG cars and trashed bikes show us why Singaporeans can't have nice things World Hamas accepts proposed deal for ceasefire with Israel and hostage release, Egyptian source says There has been some pushback that Chinese officials will need to navigate, S&P Global noted, including workers and industry groups rallying against cheap imports that are dislocating local industry. 'Despite these risks, high uncertainties under US tariffs and China's slowdown will continue to motivate Chinese firms to head to the Global South,' its economists wrote in the note. BLOOMBERG
