Marvin Haynes files wrongful conviction lawsuit after spending nearly 20 years in prison for murder he did not commit
Haynes was sentenced to life in prison when he was 17 for the murder of flower shop employee Randy Sherer. He always maintained his innocence, and no physical evidence tied him to the crime. A judge overturned his conviction in December of 2023.
The lawsuit filed by the national civil rights law firm Neufeld Scheck Brustin Hoffmann & Freidenberger, LLP seeks damages for the 19.5 years Haynes spent in prison.
The complaint named the City of Minneapolis and five police officers within the homicide department. It claims the officers used suggestion and coercion to fabricate a case against Haynes while "ignoring clear evidence that he had no connection to or knowledge of the crime."
"The Minneapolis Police Department officers who framed Mr. Haynes and the Department that allowed this injustice need to answer for their actions," Emma Freudenberger, a partner with NSBHF, said.
The lawsuit claims Haynes' Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights were violated.
When WCCO asked for a statement on the lawsuit, a Minneapolis city spokesperson said "the city has no comment."
Last November, Haynes filed a compensation claim with the Minnesota Supreme Court seeking nearly $2 million in damages.
Haynes' sister Marvina fought for years to clear his name, and in 2021 the Great North Innocence Project took his case. The original murder case for Sherer has not been solved.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Newsweek
3 days ago
- Newsweek
Peanut the Squirrel's Owners Seek $10M Over Death of 'Irreplaceable' Animal
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. The owners of P'Nut the Squirrel and a raccoon named Fred are suing the State of New York for $10 million in damages after the animals were euthanized last year. Mark Longo and Daniela Bittner filed the lawsuit on Thursday in the New York Court of Claims, alleging constitutional violations and wrongful killing of their animals by state officials. The lawsuit names the state, the Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC), and the Department of Health (DOH) as defendants. Newsweek contacted Longo's Attorney Nora Constance Marino, the DEC, DOH and the State of New York for comment by email. Why It Matters The lawsuit alleges that the seizure and killing of P'Nut and Fred were not only a violation of New York's wildlife laws, but also an infringement of the owners' Fourth and Fourteenth Amendment rights. Whether such laws even apply is debatable—the plaintiffs maintain neither P'Nut nor Fred were "wild animals" under the law, but rather "companion animals." If successful, the case could set precedent for how far state agencies can go in enforcing wildlife regulations, particularly when animals are domesticated and kept in private homes. The incident unfolded just before the 2024 presidential election, sparking widespread online outrage, and even bomb threats against officials. It became a rallying point for critics of government overreach, drawing attention from public figures such as Elon Musk and Joe Rogan. P'Nut the squirrel with Mark Longo. P'Nut the squirrel with Mark Longo. @peanut_the_squirrel12 /Instagram What To Know Longo and Bittner describe P'Nut's personality and abilities as unique and irreplaceable. Fred's personality and abilities, while still developing, were showing signs he too would be unique and irreplaceable—though they intended to release him back into the wild. The animals were both kept inside their home. New York law prohibits keeping squirrels and raccoons as pets because they are classified as wild animals. Many of P'Nut's fans knew about the couple's sanctuary because of his social media presence, and many donated because of his stardom. P'Nut's likeness, antics, and image were used for promotion, endorsements, sponsorships, and marketing by way of plaintiff D&M, including on Cameo and OnlyFans. Fred was beginning to build his own online following. The couple are seeking compensatory and punitive damages, along with legal fees and costs, claiming "severe emotional distress, humiliation, and damage to reputation." According to the lawsuit, a group of DEC and DOH agents, along with other law enforcement officers, arrived at the couple's Pine City property on October 30, 2024, to execute a search warrant. Both animals were seized during the raid and later killed by state officials. DEC officials said that P'Nut bit an agent through thick leather gloves during the raid, prompting both animals to be euthanized and decapitated for rabies testing. The state has since confirmed the tests were negative. The complaint alleges the killings were "not due to a fear of rabies," but were a "senseless act of violence" and "obscene demonstration of government abuse." The plaintiffs claim they were "unlawfully detained without probable cause and subjected to an unreasonable search and seizure," and that "despite having no evidence of criminal activity, Defendants proceeded to arrest Plaintiffs and initiate baseless charges." The suit also alleges that the seizure exceeded the scope of the warrant and that requests for the animals' remains have gone unanswered. "Defendants have engaged in a pattern of conduct that has deprived Plaintiffs of their constitutional rights under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments," the complaint states. It adds: "The acts and omissions of the Defendants were intentional, malicious, and taken with reckless disregard for the rights of the Plaintiffs." The filing follows an earlier lawsuit in Chemung County Supreme Court targeting local and state officials over the same incident. What People Are Saying Longo told the New York Post: "This is our opportunity to make change and seek justice for P'Nut and Fred." Marino, Longo's attorney, told the newspaper: "I hope justice is done, not just for my clients, but for our civil rights, P'Nut and Fred, and all animals." The October raid and subsequent animal killings drew national attention in the final days before the presidential election. Then Republican vice-presidential nominee JD Vance said at a rally in November: "Don is fired up about P'Nut the squirrel." Donald Trump Jr. said at a rally: "Justice for Peanut! Our government will let in 16,000 rapists, they will let in 13,000 murderers, they will let in 600,000 criminals across our border, but if someone has a pet squirrel without a permit, they will go in there and kill the squirrel." Elon Musk wrote on X: "Government overreach kidnapped an orphan squirrel and executed him." What Happens Next No trial date has been set in either the Court of Claims case, or the related Chemung County action.
Business Wire
05-08-2025
- Business Wire
Richard Guiltinan Joins Vartabedian Hester & Haynes
DALLAS--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Richard J. Guiltinan has joined the Dallas office of Vartabedian Hester & Haynes LLP as the latest addition to the law firm's white collar and investigations practice group. Mr. Guiltinan joins the firm from the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Texas, where he has served since 2017 as a civil prosecutor for False Claims Act and healthcare fraud investigations. Mr. Guiltinan joins the firm from the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Texas, where he has served since 2017 as a civil prosecutor for False Claims Act and healthcare fraud investigations. He was lead attorney in multiple complex matters, including successful lawsuits against a pharmacy management company and its executives, a pain management clinic, and a clinical laboratory. His practice also focused on investigations related to tariffs and trade obligations. In addition, he served for three years as the Civil Healthcare Fraud Coordinator for the Northern District of Texas. Prior to joining the DOJ, Mr. Guiltinan was an associate in the Dallas office of Haynes and Boone for six years. While in private practice, he represented multiple clients in governmental investigations involving fraud, antitrust claims and securities litigation. 'Richard is bringing the perspectives gained while prosecuting white collar cases, coupled with his years in private practice,' says Conrad Hester, the firm's managing partner. 'This depth of experience will be invaluable as we build this practice area into one of the finest and most effective in North Texas.' Mr. Guiltinan earned his law degree with honors from the Northwestern University School of Law and his undergraduate degree from Yale University. Last month, the firm announced the hiring of Richard Roper, a former U.S. Attorney for the Northern District, to lead its white-collar litigation practice. Through his tenure with the DOJ and 17 years in private practice, Mr. Roper has conducted more than 150 jury trials involving securities, healthcare fraud and public corruption. 'It's going to be an honor to work alongside Richard Roper,' says Mr. Guiltinan. 'I have enormous respect for him, and we share a vision for how this firm can add expertise and resources to provide our clients with high-quality representation that offers greater flexibility and fewer conflicts than larger firms. That's why I've made this move.' About Vartabedian Hester & Haynes Based in the Dallas-Fort Worth area, Vartabedian Hester & Haynes is a client-focused and results-oriented litigation boutique founded in early 2024. Learn more at
CBS News
02-08-2025
- CBS News
Minneapolis police impressed by Lotus worker who used jiu-jitsu to fight off attacker
The downtown Minneapolis worker attacked while taking out the garbage has been given an opportunity to serve and protect his community. Jezarius Sheldon got the attention of the Minneapolis Police Department, which is looking for recruits. Sheldon, 19, is counting his blessings that no one was seriously hurt when a verbal assault outside Lotus turned violent, and he was forced to defend himself. He says that while talking to the police, he was presented with an incredible opportunity. "He said I was very impressed the way that I held my own, and the way that I performed, considering the circumstances, I was very controlled, I was very disciplined in my actions, and he was like, 'You would do well as a police officer,'" said Sheldon. Sheldon says he was flattered, but he has plans to serve the public in a different way. He is a nursing student at the University of Minnesota. "I do want to be a nurse, that's the goal," said Sheldon. On scholarship for his good grades, he wants to continue a family health care legacy. "The fact that I get to go and pursue my education somewhere like the U of M, it's a blessing, and I'm very grateful," said Sheldon. What he does want is safety for his coworkers and others who work in this corner of Loring Park. "We see people who are physically violent outside our store, people urinate on our sidewalk, defecate on our sidewalk, call us names. I've been spit on, I've been hit," said Jim Connelly, who works at a neighboring business, Rainbow Road. Five weeks ago, Connelly's store was robbed. "A young man came in, masked, body totally covered, put a knife by my back, put a knife up my throat, put me down on my knees and then opened the till and took the money out," said Connelly. He hopes people contact Minneapolis City Hall to ask for more police and protection for areas plagued by crime. "We have no response from police; the police are too busy. The response from City Hall is, 'We're going to look into it. We're going to form a committee. We're going to think about how we're going to get this resolved.' But after 29 years, it's only gotten worse because it's never gotten better," said Connelly. Jezarius says he does not hate his attacker. Police have stepped up patrols by Lotus. So far, no arrests have been made in connection with the attack.
