
Bell, Telus spar over blame for 40-hour cellphone outage
In an eight-page letter sent to the Canadian Radio-television and Telecommunications Commission on June 27, Bell said the technical failure happened on the Telus side of the 911 cellphone system.
Telus has said publicly and to the CRTC that the problem was due to 'an equipment failure on the Bell facilities' and 'Telus does not know the reason for this failure.'
Philippe Gauvin, Bell's assistant general counsel, disputed that in the letter.
'As Telus knows, that explanation is inaccurate and unsupported by the facts,' he wrote.
'Telus misleadingly portrays a recent 911 outage for its customers in Manitoba as being due to an equipment failure on Bell facilities.'
SUPPLIED
Dean Switzer of Fisher Branch died of a heart attack on March 23, two days before his 56th birthday.
SUPPLIED
Dean Switzer of Fisher Branch died of a heart attack on March 23, two days before his 56th birthday.
Gauvin said Bell is committed to ensuring all parties maintain the highest level of reliability for 911 service and that Canadians have confidence in it.
Dean Switzer, 55, died on March 23, two days before his 56th birthday, while family and friends near Fisher Branch placed 22 calls to 911 — only to receive a message that said 'hang up and call back later.' They frantically performed CPR on him for 90 minutes.
An ambulance finally came after an off-duty RCMP officer went to their detachment to call emergency services.
Last month, Telus reported to the CRTC that a review of the incident found 177 unsuccessful calls had been made to 911 by 59 Manitobans from the time the service went down on March 22 at 8:15 p.m. to when it was restored at about noon on March 24.
Telus said after it became aware of the problem, it was fixed in a little more than an hour. It said it has disciplined an employee over the incident and has since added a double backup system if the 911 system goes down, as well as a third backup where calls would go to a live operator.
Raymond Switzer, Dean's father, said Wednesday the family is considering legal action against Telus.
'(Originally), I didn't want anything from Telus,' Switzer, 78, said. 'I just said I didn't want what happened to us to happen to another family. That's all I wanted. I've changed my mind since then.
'They don't give a rat's ass what happens to us.'
Switzer said Telus sent a letter to the family, which angered him further.
'They asked for a photo of my son so they could always remember what happened — I said that's not happening.'
Switzer, who said he backs calls by the Progressive Conservative party for an inquiry, said he still doesn't understand why an audio message told callers to call back rather than just saying the system was out of service.
'Because of that, they just kept calling,' he said.
'I'm not sure if my son would be around with us if he'd got help faster, but it didn't help.'
'They don't give a rat's ass what happens to us.'–Raymond Switzer
Bell noted in its letter to the CRTC that Telus reached out with questions the day before Telus submitted its final report on the incident on May 16. Bell said it hadn't had a chance to respond before the report was submitted.
Bell said those questions Telus had 'indicate that, far from being final and despite Telus' misleading claims regarding the cause of the failure, Telus was still uncertain, and may still be uncertain, with respect to the actual root cause of why Telus ceased sending 911 traffic to Bell during the outage.'
Bell said only Telus, and no other cellphone carrier, was affected with an outage to its 911 calls, after one of its two gateways for emergency calls did a four-minute reset.
The telecom also noted 'that media reports continue to indicate that Telus is, despite the overwhelming evidence to the contrary, attempting to shift the blame publicly for the outage experienced by its customers to Bell.
'While we tried to give Telus the opportunity to correct the record itself, it has chosen not to do so.'
A Bell spokeswoman said the company would not be commenting further on its CRTC submission.
A spokesman for Telus said in a statement that Bell's submission 'largely aligns with Telus' previous reports, acknowledging the initial network disruption originated on Bell's network.
Sundays
Kevin Rollason's Sunday newsletter honouring and remembering lives well-lived in Manitoba.
'There is no evidence to suggest our 911 services would have been disrupted had the initial Bell outage not taken place, and action was required by both Bell and Telus to bring Telus' 911 connectivity back online, as it was the sequencing of the reset that fully restored service. We have been transparent about the process failure on our side, acknowledging that our outage notification procedures with Bell were not properly followed.'
A spokeswoman for the CRTC said the regulator is reviewing the information it has received from Bell and Telus.
'As this remains an ongoing matter, we cannot comment further at this time,' said Mirabella Salem.
PC MLA Derek Johnson (Interlake-Gimli) said a public inquiry is necessary.
'(The two companies) are playing the liability hot potato, not me, not me,' Johnson said.
In a statement, Natural Resources Minister Ian Bushie said 'our No. 1 priority is the safety of all Manitobans and we will continue to work with the CRTC and the federal government to ensure that rural and remote Manitobans have access to 911 services when they need it most.'
kevin.rollason@freepress.mb.ca
Kevin RollasonReporter
Kevin Rollason is a general assignment reporter at the Free Press. He graduated from Western University with a Masters of Journalism in 1985 and worked at the Winnipeg Sun until 1988, when he joined the Free Press. He has served as the Free Press's city hall and law courts reporter and has won several awards, including a National Newspaper Award. Read more about Kevin.
Every piece of reporting Kevin produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
Bell, Telus spar over 911 outage
Winnipeg Watch Bell and Telus continue to spar over who is responsible for a 911 outage earlier this year.


Global News
3 hours ago
- Global News
Calgary man injured in Russian drone and missile attack in Ukraine
'Unrelenting.' That is how Calgarian Paul Hughes describes the recent Russian attacks on Ukraine. 'For the last three hours the city has been bombarded by Shaheds and missiles and cruise missiles,' said Hughes, speaking to Global News from the darkened Ukrainian capital of Kyiv on Thursday evening. 'In the last two to three months it has really intensified,' added Hughes, with the sound of bombs exploding in the distance. 'June was almost 6,000 Shahed (drone) attacks, missiles — it's getting very bad here. You can smell it in the air. You can see the smoke.' View image in full screen Smoke rises after a Russian strike on Kyiv, Ukraine, on Friday, July 4, 2025. Associated Press/Yehor Konovalov Hughes has been in Ukraine since 2022 as a volunteer, doing humanitarian work with the Canadian charity H.U.G.S. (Helping Ukraine – Grassroots Support). Story continues below advertisement A few weeks after his arrival he was joined by his son MacKenzie, who is now 22 years old and has been working alongside Ukrainian troops, organizing relief efforts and humanitarian aid for people who have been displaced along the war's front lines. On Canada Day, during one of those massive Russian bombardments, MacKenzie was injured. Luckily he's still alive, but the extent of his injuries isn't yet clear. View image in full screen 22-year-old MacKenzie Hughes and his father Paul have been in Ukraine since 2022, working to deliver humanitarian aid to people displaced by the fighting along the front lines of the war. Courtesy: Paul Hughes When he got word of the attack, Paul Hughes rushed to be with his son. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'I've spent the last few days — drove down form Kharkiv immediately when I was contacted by his unit, so I've been with him constantly since July 1st,' said Hughes. 2:15 Russia launches largest drone strike of war on Ukraine MacKenzie has burns to about 30 per cent of his body. He was pinned under a vehicle but was saved by two other members of his team. Story continues below advertisement 'He's stable but he's not OK,' said the elder Hughes. 'You don't get hit by Shaheds and be OK.' Calgarian Paul Hughes, whose son MacKenzie is seen helping deliver humanitarian aid along the front lines of the war in Ukraine, said he is inspired by the bravery of the Ukrainian people. Courtesy: Paul Hughes Hughes said he has been in touch with the Canadian embassy, and there are people who have offered to try to get his son back to Canada. But MacKenzie said no — he didn't want to leave Ukraine. 'He's receiving very good care here in Kyiv,' said Hughes. 'At a burn unit that specializes in burns. I mean, some of the best doctors in the world are in Ukraine now because of all the trauma over the past three-and-a-half years. So they deal with a lot of burns. He's receiving exceptional care at the moment.' View image in full screen 22-year-old MacKenzie Hughes, from Calgary, is seen in a hospital in Kyiv, Ukraine after he was injured in a Russian attack on July 1, 2025. Courtesy: Paul Hughes After seeing so many innocent people killed in the Russian bombardments, Hughes is inspired by the bravery of the Ukrainian people. Story continues below advertisement 'There are people, civilians, predominantly civilians, dying on a regular basis from the terrorist attacks. On the front line, it's soldiers, but in the cities where it's purely civilian. This is pure terrorism,' said Hughes. 'It's one thing to have your generic type warfare and a front line and soldier versus soldier and artillery versus artillery, but this is unrelenting attacks on civilian population and that's pure terrorism.' Hughes concluded our interview by asking his friends back in Canada to keep his son in their thoughts. 'He's a very strong young man and he's got a really good chance to get back to form,' said Hughes. 'That's my hope as a father. I love my son.'

4 hours ago
Canadians in ICE detention centres left in legal limbo as families try to secure release
Relatives of Canadians detained by ICE in the United States say they're furious and frustrated by the treatment of their loved ones and the battles they're having to fight for even the most basic information. Global Affairs Canada said it's aware of roughly 55 Canadians in U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody, though it said that the numbers can fluctuate. Cynthia Olivera — born in Mississauga, Ont., but living in Los Angeles — was arrested last month when she and her husband went to an immigration office to complete an interview for her U.S. citizenship application. Paula Callejas of Montreal was in the process of finalizing a work visa when she was arrested for a misdemeanor — and then transferred to an ICE facility. Olivera and Callejas's families told CBC News the weeks since their arrests have been a nightmare, filled with phone calls to lawyers and ICE bureaucracy. Enlarge image (new window) Paula Callejas from Montreal has been in ICE custody for more than three months after being charged with a misdemeanor in Florida, her family says. (Name withheld) Photo: (Name withheld) We're completely concerned for her overall safety and health, a member of Callejas's immediate family told CBC News. CBC is not naming the family member over concerns they may have their own immigration issues while travelling to the U.S. Olivera's husband, Frank Olvera, said what was meant to be a routine immigration interview ended up feeling more like a trap. We were flabbergasted, Olvera told CBC News. No due process. Olivera, 45, moved to the U.S. with her family when she was young, her husband said. The two met in the '90s, married (she kept her last name), had children together and have been living in L.A. since then. About two years ago, since the children are now older, we decided to hire a lawyer and start the immigration process the correct way, Olvera said. Decades-old U.S. entry refusal But instead of completing the interview, Olivera was arrested by immigration officials over a decades-old border issue, her husband said. They lured us into our immigration appointment … took my wife, put her in handcuffs, swept her away, he said. They didn't even give us an opportunity at the interview. Nothing. Olvera said that in 1999, Olivera had travelled to Canada to attend her mother's funeral and was initially denied re-entry because she was pregnant and told border agents she planned to have the child in the U.S. Olivera is now being held by ICE at a detention centre in El Paso, Texas, Olvera said. Earlier this year, U.S. President Donald Trump issued a raft of executive orders that aim to clamp down on illegal immigration and advance his goal of overseeing the largest deportation operation in American history. Stephen Miller, White House deputy chief of staff and the main architect of Trump's immigration policies, has pushed ICE to aim for at least 3,000 arrests a day, up from about 650 a day during the first five months of Trump's second term. Earlier this week, Trump and Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem toured a new immigration detention facility in Florida that officials have dubbed Alligator Alcatraz. We are going after murderers and rapists and traffickers and drug dealers and getting them off the streets and getting them out of this country, Noem said after the facility tour. Callejas was in the process of finalizing a work visa when she was charged with a misdemeanor in Florida. Although she pleaded not guilty to the charge, she was handed over to ICE and has been held for more than three months. The 45-year-old had been travelling to the U.S. in recent years with plans to expand her swimsuit business, according to her family. When reached for comment, ICE confirmed that both Callejas and Olivera are in custody but offered few details. Callejas's family said she has been transferred multiple times and last they heard she was in Arizona. But ICE told CBC News that it seems she is in El Paso. We feel completely stressed out because we have no idea if one day she's going to be there or somewhere else, Callejas's relative said. Callejas's family is also now on the hook for her legal fees in both her criminal and immigration cases. They said they want her returned to Canada so she can deal with her misdemeanor charge. At least one Canadian detained by ICE was eventually released. Jasmine Mooney from B.C. was arrested and held for nearly two weeks (new window) after trying to get a work visa renewed. She returned to Canada in mid-March. Johnny Noviello, another Canadian citizen, died while in ICE custody last week (new window) . His death is under investigation. Olvera said his wife agreed to be deported so that she can at least continue her citizenship application in Canada before returning to her family. But he said there doesn't seem to be any urgency on ICE's part. There is absolutely no reason why ICE cannot deport her. They're just taking their sweet old time and I don't know why, Olvera said. We're willing to pay the ticket, whatever it takes. I'm willing to pay for an ICE agent to escort her to Canada if that's what's needed. I'm willing to pay for the ICE agent trip back. Like Callejas, Olivera has been transferred multiple times, her husband said. Both women's families raised concerns about the conditions of their detention. The food is not great. The conditions of the sleeping arrangements — she tried to give us a hint that pretty much they get crammed up. It's really inhumane, Callejas's family member said, noting that all the calls are recorded. Olvera described a similar situation at the facility where his wife is being held. It's horrible. They're treated like animals. Sometimes they get hot food, sometimes they don't, he said. 'I'm ashamed to be an American' Olvera — a third-generation American whose family immigrated from Mexico — said he typically votes Democrat but voted for Trump in November because he wanted a change. Now he appears to be questioning that decision. I'm ashamed to be an American right now. I turn on the TV and I see them running around.… they're just chasing brown people nowadays, he said. On the day of his wife's arrest, Olvera said he and his lawyer weren't allowed to exit out the front of the building. They escorted us out the back of the building by the trash cans, the loading dock, he said. They didn't want to go back through the lobby where we entered from, because they're trapping a bunch of people at these immigration appointments. Unlike Olivera, Callejas may not want to return to the U.S. once her cases are resolved. It was her dream to live in Florida just because of the business and [her] passion, the family member said. After all of this, she's actually given up on that dream. She just wants to get out. Darren Major (new window) · CBC News