logo
Karl Lockhart: Instead of squabbling over a new chair, merge the CFTC with the SEC

Karl Lockhart: Instead of squabbling over a new chair, merge the CFTC with the SEC

Chicago Tribune8 hours ago
Today, trading stocks and options, wagering on an MLB game and buying cryptocurrency are just a swipe away — sometimes in the same app. The merging of these markets makes a strong case to merge the two federal agencies charged with regulating them, the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
And now is the time to do it. The Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC, has been squabbling over President Donald Trump's nominated chair, Brian Quintenz. The remaining CFTC commissioners have indicated they plan to leave by the end of the year. Meanwhile, the SEC will likely have a Republican vacancy in the near future when Commissioner Hester Peirce's term ends.
This setup creates a perfect scenario for Congress to pass legislation to merge these two agencies, something that has been called for — on a bipartisan basis — and considered for over 30 years. Quintenz could become the SEC's third Republican commissioner when Peirce departs, applying his past experience as a CFTC commissioner to smooth the transition.
Beyond the convenience of timing, why merge the SEC and the CFTC? First, the line between the two regulators' jurisdictions has always been blurry. An early debate centered on futures related to securities, and current confusion and jurisdictional squabbling have come up over the regulation of non-stablecoin crypto products. While the GENIUS Act's passage has brought clarity to stablecoins, a merged SEC-CFTC would immediately remove uncertainty over which agency should oversee other crypto innovations.
More importantly, markets have changed. The CFTC began as an agency to regulate futures on agricultural products, but the vast majority of futures and derivatives today are linked to financial products and instruments. Agricultural futures make up only a small sliver of the market.
What's more, the growth in event contracts — options that pay out based on whether a given event does or does not take place — and CFTC's approval of event contracts related to sports have effectively legalized sports gambling across the United States, folding that market into the CFTC's regulatory reach. In short, all markets for financial products — equities, debt, options, commodity and currency futures, crypto and, now, sports wagers — are merging.
Furthermore, the same players are participating in and employing the same tactics across all markets. Institutional investors such as hedge funds are applying big data, algorithms and artificial intelligence not only to stocks and bonds, but also to event contracts and sports betting markets. And, as mentioned above, retail investors — nonprofessional market participants trading for their personal accounts — can open the same app on their phones to trade stocks, options, crypto and sports-related event contracts anytime, anywhere.
A merged SEC-CFTC would cut down on compliance costs for firms that currently must abide by two sets of regulations. And it would allow for better-coordinated enforcement activities against bad actors who scam retail investors across multiple markets. Both agencies also have a similar structure — five commissioners, with at most a bare majority from the president's party to preserve independence — a crucial factor in our partisan era.
To be sure, as with any merger, some operational difficulties would be present as cultures and practices become aligned. But the SEC and the CFTC have fundamentally similar missions and roles. They just regulated what were different markets. Now, to best protect investors, facilitate capital formation and maintain a fair, orderly and efficient (now-unified) market, the SEC and CFTC should join forces.
Markets have merged. So should our regulators.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

South Carolina lawmaker awaiting trial on child sex abuse material charges resigns from office
South Carolina lawmaker awaiting trial on child sex abuse material charges resigns from office

Yahoo

time18 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

South Carolina lawmaker awaiting trial on child sex abuse material charges resigns from office

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — A South Carolina Republican lawmaker in jail awaiting trial on charges he distributed sexual abuse material involving children has resigned his seat in the state House. RJ May's resignation letter was dated Thursday but didn't arrive at the offices of House leadership until Monday morning. May wrote that 'it is in the best interests of my family and constituents to resign immediately.' It does not mention the 10 charges he faces or the more than a decade in prison that prosecutors have suggested May could face if convicted. The return address on the letter was May's Lexington post office box. He is currently being held at the Edgefield County jail without bond as he awaits trial as soon as next month. May's federal public defender did not respond to an email Monday. The three-term Republican is accused of using the screen name 'joebidennnn69' to exchange 220 different files of toddlers and young children involved in sex acts on the Kik social media network for about five days in spring 2024, according to court documents that graphically detailed the videos. The files were uploaded and downloaded using May's home Wi-Fi network and his cellphone, prosecutors said. Some were hidden by the use of a private network but others were directly linked to his internet addresses. At his arraignment, May's lawyer suggested someone could have used the Wi-Fi password that was shown on a board behind a photo May's wife may have posted online. Each of the 10 charges carries a five-to-20-year prison sentence upon conviction. Calls for May's resignation were nearly unanimous in the South Carolina House, including members who were most closely aligned with May as he helped found the Freedom Caucus of the chamber's most conservative members. The House Ethics Committee last month started an investigation that appeared to be the first step in trying to kick May out of the House. May worked as a political consultant. He was elected in 2020 and in his five years in the House upset many mainstream Republicans as he continued to run campaigns for people looking to knock out incumbents in GOP primaries. The timing of May's resignation should allow his replacement to be chosen in a special election before the 2026 General Assembly session starts in January.

Diane Francis: Trump sets his sights on the banking industry
Diane Francis: Trump sets his sights on the banking industry

Yahoo

time18 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Diane Francis: Trump sets his sights on the banking industry

Last week, U.S. President Donald Trump signed an executive order that aims to prevent banks from discriminating against customers because of their politics, religion or 'lawful business activities,' such as owning crypto assets. He told CNBC that in years past, JPMorgan Chase and other banks have 'discriminated against me very badly, and I was very good to the banks.' Apparently, such complaints are not uncommon. 'Conservatives have said that regulators appointed by President Joe Biden spent past years conscripting banks to target Trump's political opponents. Tech investor and Trump adviser Marc Andreessen had said about 30 founders of tech start-ups were 'de-banked.' He called the project 'Operation Chokepoint 2.0.,' ' read a recent report in the Washington Post. In an attempt to prevent increased scrutiny from the federal government, many banks have increased their lobbying and updated their policies to make it clear that they don't discriminate on the basis of politics or religion. But financial institutions will face future scrutiny. While this is an American initiative, it will affect Canadian banks because of their extensive operations south of the border. Canada's five biggest companies are all banks based in Toronto. Many of them own branches and extensive in assets south of the border. It's hard to believe that there would be a concerted top-down initiative to de-bank customers purely based on politics, but in America's deeply polarized society with its localized banks, this would not be surprising. Moreover, their restrictions on financial and tech startups is understandable and began because two banks specializing in crypto — Silvergate and Signature — went bust in 2023, according to the Washington Post. They failed because they didn't appropriately manage the risks, said Steven Kelly, former associate director of research at the Yale Program on Financial Stability. But Trump's fight with banks that allegedly discriminate against the cryptocurrency industry is also political, as he intends to make America the world's crypto capital. Trump's crypto business has boomed and is worth billions. Currently, Canadian banks are gun-shy about crypto, but they may now be forced to start dealing with crypto startups, at least in the U.S. However, Canada's foreign ownership restrictions may prove to be an a bigger challenge, for both Ottawa and the Big Five banks. Trump has publicly, and incorrectly, claimed that Canadian restrictions mean that American banks are forbidden from operating in Canada. 'Canada doesn't allow American Banks to do business in Canada, but their banks flood the American Market. Oh, that seems fair to me, doesn't it?' Trump wrote on social media in March. That's untrue. There are 16 U.S.-based bank subsidiaries operating in Canada with billions in assets, according to the Canadian Bankers Association. But American banks operating in Canada are heavily regulated and somewhat restricted when it comes to providing retail banking services to consumers. It seems clear that Trump wants to eliminate all barriers to entry so that American banks can directly compete in Canada against local banks and offer the same services that Canadian banks provide. So stay tuned. Trump has never let the facts get in the way of a policy. Sign in to access your portfolio

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store