Economic development has something to learn from — and teach — ecosystem building
Traditional economic development hunts for economic winners and big infrastructure, while ecosystem building focuses on stitching together many disparate parts, yet practitioners increasingly note they have much in common.
The two approaches are converging under 'entrepreneurship-led economic development,' with certifying bodies adding courses and professionals code switching between the terms to build broader coalitions.
Tensions persist — some grassroots efforts are dismissed as 'nice to have,' and some ecosystem builders scoff at 'fusty' marketing — but history suggests new disciplines mature by setting standards and proving outcomes.
→ Read on for details and join Chris Wink's weekly newsletter for more
Rob Williams remembers an unusual family dinner-table debate from his childhood.
His botanist father insisted that ecosystems were strictly natural phenomena. His small business-advocate mother argued that economic development could learn deeply from nature's interconnectedness. They each had a point.
Today, Williams is the founder and director of SourceLink, a category-defining nonprofit software platform spun out of Kauffman Foundation research. It is among the first in a constellation of tools that introduced the 'ecosystem building' metaphor to traditional state and local economic development, a big, boring and quietly influential discipline around creation of jobs, business and regional output.
Williams has an unusual balance. He's among the earliest definers of entrepreneurship ecosystem building, and he also has traditional economic development training.
'We can't thrive as economic developers without placing entrepreneurship and innovation at the heart of our strategies,' Williams said.
Williams is part of an industry transformation, and like other professional and academic changes before, it takes time to sort out standards. In the 1830s, sociology emerged from political philosophy to better understand the 'social physics' of how culture shaped individuals. In the 1980s, behavioral economics began as a splinter group before later shaping the entire field. In both and many other cases, individuals obsessed over a narrow set of differences within a larger, more established discipline long enough that those differences became their own field of study.
Local entrepreneurship boosters who identify as 'ecosystem builders' are attempting something similar.
In the 2010s, community organizers, startuppers and post-Great Recession economic activists formed coalitions around the country. Stewarded by funders led by the Kansas City-based Kauffman Foundation, these business and economic types took hold of the ecosystem metaphor. Then the post-COVID entrepreneurship boom gave ecosystem building its primetime moment.
'The pandemic showed us the fragility of some of our systems and the power of local entrepreneurship to build resiliency,' Williams said.
Today about 1,000 people list ' ecosystem builder ' as a job title on LinkedIn. Overwhelmingly they are entrepreneurs, small business advocates and self-identified connectors. In 2010, Technical.ly published the word 'ecosystem' about 100 times. Last year, we did so over 1,000 times, a 10x increase in 15 years. A similar, if lagging, surge followed in books.
Dating to those childhood debates between his parents, Williams understands better than most the nuance of the ecosystem metaphor: Many overlapping, differently-sized, independent species interact in unexpected ways to support each other. Traditional 20th century-style economic development focuses on economic winners (established businesses) and top-down investments (industrial policy and big infrastructure projects). As set down by the Kauffman Foundation, ecosystem building focuses on nascent entrepreneurs and stitching together many disparate parts of a local economy.
Economic development is the big-game hunter storming the bush. Ecosystem building is the botanist carefully handling a butterfly.
These differences can present discomfort. Politics are an obvious one: standard economic development has been a bastion of American-style conservative capitalism, whereas ecosystem building adopted progressive concepts of mutual aid and, quite literally, environmentalism.
Rather than an obstacle, Williams and others see this as an opportunity for coalition building. One of the only ideals that unites Americans across the political spectrum also unites progressive ecosystem builders and conservative economic development leaders: entrepreneurship.
'Entrepreneur-led economic development'
The work of integrating ecosystem building into the larger and more-established economic development can now focus on terminology and process.
The International Economic Development Council, the trade's primary certifying body with more than 4,500 members, is a natural leader, introducing courses and certifications.
The group received more than 100 applicants for its director of entrepreneurship position, according to LinkedIn, a role that Williams's own mother held. IEDC CIO Dell Gines, who spoke this month at the Technically Builders Conference, is a long-standing ecosystem-building champion, dating to his time at the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City. He has helped incorporate ecosystem building tenets into established economic development.
Williams too. For example, Williams adopts IEDC's preferred phrase of 'entrepreneurship-led economic development' (or ELED in the industry jargon) when speaking with more establishment economic development leaders. Other times, he relies on the 'ecosystem building' term. Insiders cite subtle differences but on the whole, they're becoming interchangeable.
'We have so much in common that it's more about language differences,' Williams said. 'You're code switching depending on who you talk with.'
The merging isn't complete. At our storytelling-focused Builders Conference, one longtime ecosystem builder sneered on-stage at fusty economic development marketing. On the other side, a traditionally-trained economic development leader confided in me earlier this year that much grassroots 'ecosystem building' seems like 'a lot of Millennial bullshit.' For her, the small gatherings and resource mapping strike her as nice to have but not critical in her budget-constrained reality.
The lesson from past discipline changes is that both approaches have something to teach, and to learn.
Ecosystem building can sound faddish, and so years of establishing best practices and outcomes are welcome. Williams credits the 2017 book ' Beyond Collisions' as an example. Inspired by this, Technically has put forward a data-backed case for the economic outcomes of storytelling, another demonstrably important but squishy-sounding concept.
Likewise, though, traditional economic development can overlook the real-world actions of individual humans.
Entrepreneurs don't choose places to start companies. Entrepreneurs choose places to live and then start companies there. Place-based economic development needs humanity.
'It's like a Venn diagram but there's a lot more in the middle,' Williams said. 'There's no entrepreneurship-led strategy that's sustainable without a healthy ecosystem around it, and no ecosystem-building initiatives can work sustainably without critical economic development-led supports.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Technical.ly
16 hours ago
- Technical.ly
Cyber startup raises $15M to open Baltimore office and expand sales team
With cyberattacks on the rise in the US, a startup with bicoastal founders automating the process of protecting systems has raised millions to reach more customers. Pixee, founded in 2022, announced a $15 million seed round in May. Its tech addresses a gap in the broader market for cybersecurity products: Many tools exist to automate the search for vulnerabilities, but not to fix those flaws, explained Pixee cofounder and CEO Surag Patel. Right now, firms largely handle that process manually. Pixee uses agentic AI to make sure what's flagged is an issue in the code, and automates repairing the code to avoid attacks, he said. Software is being created faster than ever before, thanks to generative AI tools — which Patel, who lives in San Francisco, sees as a positive. But with that increase in software comes more technology susceptible to attacks, whether it's developed by a bot or a human. Pixee's announcement of the raise pointed to a 2024 study, conducted by the market intelligence-focused International Data Corporation with sponsorship by the software company JFrog, that showed that developers are also spending more hours on application security than in previous years. 'This boom of code — with that comes vulnerabilities,' Patel told 'That's an inevitable reality. And what we need is we need automation to automate the fixing of those vulnerabilities.' Growing Baltimore roots with funds from Silicon Valley This is Pixee's first raise, and it was led by Decibel and Wing VC in Palo Alto, with participation from Maryland's venture arm TEDCO and PrimeSet in Dallas. TEDCO contributed $1.5 million to the round. Patel and his cofounder, Baltimore-based Arshan Dabirsiaghi, will be using the funds to expand Pixee's go-to-market team. Up until now, they've primarily focused on hiring engineers, many of whom live in the Baltimore region. The company recently hired its first sales staffer, per Patel. 'The going-forward plan is: We need to start scaling up the awareness of Pixee,' he said. Engineers will still be brought on, Patel said, and he hopes to hire 10 employees to join the current staff of about 20 by the end of 2025. The startup is also looking at opening a formal office in the Baltimore area, though the staff currently gets together once a quarter for about a week to work in person. The founders have been raising capital since shortly after they were founded, per Patel, and it's been a 'quiet' process. The founders reached out to a handful of known investors through previous work. 'For us, we've been so heads-down just building a product, proving out the product and the market, the opportunity,' Patel said, 'and then focusing on the seed funding as secondary, honestly.' Dabirsiaghi is the cofounder of Baltimore's Contrast Security, which automates identifying vulnerabilities in software. The duo met when Patel joined that cybersecurity firm as its chief strategy officer. Saving developers time to innovate The startup self-reports a 76% acceptance rate of changes using the Pixee product. About 30,000 projects are using the firm's open source software, per Patel. He declined to share how many paying customers Pixee has, but noted he sells the product to large companies with around 300 or more developers. Pixee doesn't focus on a specific industry, but regulated ones in sectors like finance, medicine and the government have shown a lot of interest. Pixee is in talks with the federal government about contracting services, but Patel declined to share which agencies. Partnerships are also a core part of Pixee's model, and the company recently announced one with HCLTech to get connected with more customers. By getting connected to more customers, Patel wants this tool to save effort for developers so they can focus on important things outside of cybersecurity concerns. 'Now they can re-spend that time on the stuff they want to spend it on, which is generally not security, right?' Patel said. 'They want to be building cool features for customers, and things that might drive business or ideas.'
Technical.ly
2 days ago
- Technical.ly
This Week in Jobs: Take these 24 tech career opportunities for a spin
Happy World Bicycle Day! The celebration was originated by Professor Leszek Sibilski, a Polish-American social scientist and cyclist whose academic project on bicycles and sustainability became a global initiative in the 2010s. It was declared by the United Nations in April 2018. Bicycles, invented in Germany more than 200 years ago, have stood the test of time as a simple, affordable and reliable means of transportation that is good for environmental sustainability and health. Since 2020, the popularity of bicycles, including electric bikes, has exploded. During the COVID lockdowns, when people were seeking safe outdoor activities for fitness and mental health, many cities saw record-breaking purchases and rentals — notably, the Citi Bike system in New York City saw a 67% increase during the early part of the pandemic. The popularity of bike-sharing programs didn't end with the lockdowns. In fact, their popularity continues to rise: Between March 2024 and March 2025, docked bike-share trips in major U.S. cities experienced a 17.5% increase. Riding a bike is kind of like a job search: balance, momentum and the occasional hill climb are part of the ride. The News Check out this roundup of South Philly small business entrepreneurs, including artists, chefs, activists, app developers and more. Track Pittsburgh aerospace startup Astrobotic's rise from CMU spinout to NASA moon partner. Philly's Fore Biotherapeutics raises another $38M for cancer drug trial. Developers aren't discounting the tech industry — but say companies must value humans over AI. What does Pennsylvania stand to lose if federal research dollars dry up? More than just the funding itself. Client Spotlight 'What's great about being at Comcast is that we can turn an idea into a product,' said software development engineer Jaylen Sanders. 'I brought an idea to my manager, we demoed it across the organization, and a year later, we were able to create, ship and launch the product.' The Jobs Greater Philly Penn Medicine is seeking a Senior Manager Data Engineering and a Cybersecurity Identity Management Senior Engineer. Law firm Morgan, Lewis & Bockius is looking for an IT Product Manager. CubeSmart is hiring a Database Engineer and a Technical SEO Analyst. Vanguard has several listings open: Machine Learning Engineer Public Relations Consultant, Senior Specialist Senior Product Manager The CIGNA Group needs a hybrid Workday Talent Solutions Analyst. DC + Baltimore Kite Pharma in Frederick is seeking a Senior IT Engineering Specialist Microsoft is hiring for hybrid Technical Support Engineering in DC. Maryland Department of Information Technology is hiring an IT Accessibility Specialist. Siemens in Chantilly is looking for a Building Automation Service Specialist. Software company Navigator in Frederick needs a Client Software Specialist. Pittsburgh Ford Office Technologies is hiring an IT Technical Account Manager. The City of Pittsburgh has a listing for a Technology Implementation Specialist. Meta is searching for a Technical Program Manager, XR Tech. Biotech company Softwriters needs a hybrid Technical Support Specialist. Remote Brooksource is looking for a remote Salesforce Helpdesk Technician. Bath & Body Works is looking for a remote Lead UX Designer. MrBeast is in need of a remote Netflix has a listing for a remote Full Stack Engineer (L5), N-Tech Software Engineering. The End In the words of Professor Sibliski: 'Have passion, perseverance, and be relentless!'
Technical.ly
6 days ago
- Technical.ly
How Lithero is using AI to speed up pharma marketing compliance
Startup profile: Lithero Founded by: Nyron Burke Year founded: 2015 Headquarters: Philadelphia, PA Sector: Life sciences, AI Funding and valuation: $0.68 million raised as of May 2022, according to PitchBook Key ecosystem partners: Ben Franklin Technology Partners, Morgan Lewis, Drexel University, University City Science Center, Broad Street Angels, Ic@3401 In life sciences, everything takes longer. Nyron Burke, cofounder and CEO of the Philadelphia-based AI for life sciences company Lithero, learned that through years of working as a consultant with pharmaceutical companies that were always looking for ways to speed up the process of creating marketing materials. What may seem relatively simple, like a pharmaceutical pamphlet for a doctor's office, can take months to finalize due to compliance issues. The final draft, with its medical language and side effects disclosures, has to be just right, requiring multiple reviews by medical lawyers before it goes to print. It's a stark contrast to consumer marketing, where a marketing professional might be able to create a one-pager in a day. 'With life sciences, that just wasn't possible,' Burke told noting that the extra time it takes to make biotech marketing materials compliant also increases the cost tenfold. Burke founded Lithero in 2015, years before AI became a common part of everyday life. He knew that machine learning could make the process considerably faster by screening for compliance issues before a medical lawyer reviews it, cutting down on the number of reviews — and, crucially, time. 'Divine intervention' led to the development of the engine Before Lithero, Burke spent eight years working for the global professional services company Accenture, with a focus on pharma and biotech companies. 'The three things I spent my consulting career on were speed, cost and compliance in pharma marketing specifically,' he said. 'But with the aspirations that my clients had, I had to not just do a good job, but to fundamentally do something that was transformative.' The speed he wanted for his clients was impossible in the 2010s — each human review for compliance was necessary, but time-consuming. AI, Burke said, had no hype around it in 2015 when he had the idea to use it to help achieve the speed he was looking for. The one thing holding him back was that he didn't know enough about AI to build an engine that could do what he needed to do. Then he met Brandon Morton, an AI researcher at Drexel who was working on his doctorate at the time. 'We met at church randomly,' Burke said. 'It was like divine intervention … His research is really what powered our ability to actually do what we're doing.' Morton effectively became a cofounder of Lithero. Even with his leadership, Burke said, it was a challenge. 'AI is very, very difficult,' Burke said. 'People don't appreciate the beauty and the power of the human mind and how hard it is to get machines to simulate what we do.' An AI assistant that doesn't hallucinate The technology Lithero created is called LARA, Lithero Artificial Review Assistant. 'You could think of it sort of like an artificial lawyer,' Burke said. Once LARA has all of a client's necessary information, it essentially pre-screens the content. It's not meant to replace the client's human lawyer, just to make it so that the lawyer has less to do on each individual piece of marketing. Then, he said, LARA will understand the client-specific content well enough that the client can use the tool for other things as well, such as creating annotations and comparing content to customer behavioral data. While today people tend to think of large language model generative AI like ChatGPT when they think of AI, LARA still isn't generative — it doesn't generate content based on prompts, it is a screening and correlation tool that can be trained to know everything about a specific brand. As such, it is not susceptible to drawbacks like hallucinations, when an AI model randomly answers with false information presented as fact, often a result of insufficient data or bias. The public launch of generative AI did help the company, though, by making the concept of an AI tool less obscure. 'It has normalized what we're doing,' Burke said. 'We're in a very conservative, cautious, slow industry — it changed the conversations that I was having.' Now, he says, there is a lot of demand, and a lot of clients bringing them new ideas on how the company can continue to grow. 'Our future is not just compliance, it's also creative,' Burke said. 'We recently launched some creative assistants, and are seeing this amazing amount of excitement.' From one to ten To get to where Lithero is today, with a team of ten and a growing roster of clients, it spent years based at Ic@3401, a University City coworking and incubation space sponsored by Drexel University and the University City Science Center that closed in 2024. One of its earliest investors, apart from friends and family, was Ben Franklin Technology Partners. Burke also credits its law firm Morgan Lewis as a big supporter, as well as angel investment group Broad Street Angels.
