Man jailed for assault that permanently scarred victim's face
A heavily Nazi-tattooed Dunedin man who brandished a knife to commit a robbery left his victim permanently scarred, a court has heard.
Kyle Justin Thornicroft, 28, appeared in the Dunedin District Court last week where he was jailed for two years and four months.
Counsel Deborah Henderson urged Judge Emma Smith to ignore her client's tattoos — including multiple swastikas and a Nazi eagle logo on his forehead — and said he was "working towards becoming a productive member of society".
The judge noted seven pages of criminal convictions featuring serious violence and property offences which had led to Thornicroft being locked up repeatedly.
His most recent stint behind bars came for domestic violence, threats, a weapons charge and failure to attend court.
Thornicroft's release conditions dictated he had to report to Probation to assist his rehabilitation and reintegration back into society.
But Judge Smith said the man had been verbally abusive to his Probation officer and said he would rather go back to jail than maintain contact with them.
On February 27 last year, Thornicroft sealed another trip to prison.
The victim had come to a house to buy methamphetamine.
Thornicroft, the court heard, had nothing to do with the drug deal, but formed the mistaken belief the man had supplied his sister with the class-A substance in exchange for sexual acts.
"It remains somewhat unclear what happened next," the judge said.
The defendant punched the victim in the face several times, one of the blows splitting the man's cheek and leaving him scarred.
The wound was thought to have been caused by a ring Thornicroft was wearing.
The man who had sold the victim the meth restrained him while the defendant — armed with a knife — rifled through his pockets, taking his drugs, cellphone, bank card, car keys and up to $50 cash.
Thornicroft said he would return the keys and phone if the man did not go to police.
The victim agreed but immediately reported the crime.
In a statement, he told the court he believed Thornicroft was going to kill him.
Crown prosecutor Richard Smith accepted the defendant's upbringing had significantly influenced his life's course.
Both his parents were well known to police, the court heard.
Judge Smith called Thornicroft's background "woeful" and said it had likely resulted in addiction issues he had consistently failed to shake.
rob.kidd@odt.co.nz , Court reporter
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
1News
4 days ago
- 1News
Drag racer's parachute may have contributed to fatal crash — coroner
A Christchurch drag racer died after losing control at almost 250km/h and crashing into a concrete wall at Ruapuna Raceway, but the car's parachute and harness may have contributed to his death. Licensed drag racer Craig Douglas Smith died after crashing his Ford Cortina race car during a practice run in 2021. In findings released on Wednesday morning, Coroner Mary-Anne Borrowdale said the 54-year-old was a highly experienced racer, who had been involved in the sport for 28 years. Smith raced a 1967 blue Ford Cortina sedan with a turbocharged 302 Windsor Ford V8 engine, with a three-speed C4 automatic transmission and a Ford nine-inch differential. He loved the vehicle and worked on it with his brother Shane, the coroner's report said. ADVERTISEMENT Craig Smith's Ford Cortina drag racer. (Source: Givealittle) On the day of the crash in October 2021, Smith had lined up at 10.30am for his first run of the day in good weather conditions in light winds with occasional slightly stronger gusts. He was racing alone against monitored speeds, rather than other racers. His brother Shane told the coroner Smith got a good clean and quick start, and crossed the finish line in 9.059 seconds — his best ever time. His previous best over a quarter mile was 9.13 seconds. Smith deployed his parachute cleanly but, within moments, the Cortina veered to the left, crossed the grass verge and crashed into a concrete wall barrier. At the time of the crash, the vehicle was doing 249 km/h. ADVERTISEMENT Smith was found trapped in the driving cabin, still in his racing harness with severe injuries and no pulse. Despite attempts to resuscitate him, he could not be revived. Evidence from the Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association showed the vehicle's parachute was attached lower than usual, but there was no specific requirement for where it should be attached at the time. The positioning of the parachute, combined with cross winds might have contributed to the loss of control, the association said. The morning's headlines in 90 seconds, including Ozzy Osbourne dies, a worrying find on Rakiura Stewart Island, and new Coke coming. (Source: 1News) It also said Smith's crotch strap, as part of the five-point racing harness, was not routed according to the recommendations, but it was within regulations at the time. His seat did not have a slot for the crotch strap to pass through, so he instead routed it across the front of his seat — a use described by the association as potentially unsafe. The association said "numerous crashes with similar or worse severity have occurred in drag racing over many years and it is the firm view of LVVTA that this crash should have been survivable". ADVERTISEMENT Coroner Borrowdale said the New Zealand Drag Racing Association had already made several changes, including specifying where parachutes should be positioned and seats that could be used. No autopsy was conducted, at the request of the family, so the coroner could not determine if a medical condition was a factor in the crash, but she thought it was improbable. Motor racing was a dangerous sport, although drag racing in New Zealand did not have a poor record for fatalities, Borrowdale said. "Mr Smith understood this and accepted the risks that racing involved. It is very sad that in this case the risks manifested as they did and cost Mr Smith his life."
Otago Daily Times
5 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Parachute may have contributed to fatal drag race crash
A Christchurch drag racer died after losing control at almost 250kmh and crashing into a concrete wall at Ruapuna Raceway, but the car's parachute and harness may have contributed to his death. Licensed drag racer Craig Douglas Smith died after crashing his Ford Cortina race car during a practice run in 2021. In findings released on Wednesday morning, Coroner Mary-Anne Borrowdale said the 54-year-old was a highly experienced racer who had been involved in the sport for 28 years. Smith raced a 1967 blue Ford Cortina sedan with a turbocharged 302 Windsor Ford V8 engine, with a three-speed C4 automatic transmission and a Ford nine-inch differential. He loved the vehicle and worked on it with his brother Shane, the coroner's report said. On the day of the crash in October 2021, Smith had lined up at 10.30am for his first run of the day in good weather conditions in light winds with occasional slightly stronger gusts. He was racing alone against monitored speeds, rather than other racers. His brother Shane told the coroner Smith got a good clean and quick start, and crossed the finish line in 9.059 seconds - his best ever time. His previous best over a quarter mile was 9.13 seconds. Smith deployed his parachute cleanly, but within moments the Cortina veered to the left, crossed the grass verge and crashed into a concrete wall barrier. At the time of the crash, the vehicle was doing 249kmh. Smith was found trapped in the driving cabin, still in his racing harness with severe injuries and no pulse. Despite attempts to resuscitate him, he could not be revived. Evidence from the Low Volume Vehicle Technical Association showed the vehicle's parachute was attached lower than usual, but there was not specific requirement for where it should be attached at the time. The positioning of the parachute, combined with cross winds might have contributed to the loss of control, the association said. It also said Smith's crotch strap as part of the five-point racing harness was not routed according the recommendations, but it was within regulations at the time. His seat did not have a slot for the crotch strap to pass through, so he instead routed it across the front of his seat - a use described by the association as potentially unsafe. The association said "numerous crashes with similar or worse severity have occurred in drag racing over many years and it is the firm view of LVVTA that this crash should have been survivable". Coroner Borrowdale said the New Zealand Drag Racing Association had already made several changes, including specifying where parachutes should be positioned and seats that could be used. No autopsy was conducted, at the request of the family, so the coroner could not determine if a medical condition was a factor in the crash, but she thought it was improbable. Motor racing was a dangerous sport, although drag racing in New Zealand did not have a poor record for fatalities, Coroner Borrowdale said. "Mr Smith understood this and accepted the risks that racing involved. It is very sad that in this case the risks manifested as they did and cost Mr Smith his life."
NZ Herald
5 days ago
- NZ Herald
Auckland driveway death: Elizabeth Smith pleads guilty to manslaughter of Dean Fifield
Court documents state that Smith and Fifield had at one point lived at the same Moire Rd address in Massey, West Auckland, where the incident occurred. Smith returned to the address at about 11pm on June 13, 2024, 'with the intention of recovering property', according to the agreed summary of facts for the case. She brought with her two associates to assist with the task. Auckland accountant Elizabeth Lynn Smith appears in the High Court at Auckland, charged with the June 2024 murder of Dean Fifield in Massey. The charge was later downgraded to manslaughter. Photo / Michael Craig Things quickly escalated. Fifield came out of the house to confront the group, and the associates pulled out of the driveway and onto the road. 'Mr Fifield followed their vehicle on foot and angered by the situation began punching the associate's stationary vehicle with his closed fist, causing damage to the windscreen,' documents state. Smith, in her own car, a Mazda Axela, then drove out of the driveway and directly into Fifield. 'Ms Smith's vehicle struck Mr Fifield, which propelled him onto the bonnet initially before he fell under the front of Ms Smith's vehicle,' the agreed summary continues. 'Ms Smith continued driving a short distance with Mr Fifield wedged underneath her vehicle. 'Mr Fifield was trapped under the vehicle when it came to a stop on Moire Road.' Fifield was pronounced dead at the scene, after emergency responders took measures to lift the car. Auckland resident Dean Fifield was fatally struck by a car in Massey in June 2024. Elizabeth Lynn Smith was charged with murder but instead pleaded guilty today to manslaughter. Photo / Supplied Fifield previously described himself online as an avid amateur athlete with a background and passion for nutrition and food science. 'I believe you are what you eat, which reflects on happiness and wellbeing in our communities, providing the well-being to be and perform to everyone's best,' he wrote on his LinkedIn profile. 'Developing tasty consumer demanding healthy products which bump off the junk food products is one of my next big goals.' In online tributes after his death, friends described him as 'a lovely chap' and 'a force to be reckoned with'. 'A big heart, you couldn´t help but want to help anyone that you passed paths with,' one person wrote. Smith's murder trial had been set to begin in September. She will instead be sentenced next month. Justice Mathew Downs accepted the guilty plea today, ordering her to remain in custody until sentencing. Craig Kapitan is an Auckland-based journalist covering courts and justice. He joined the Herald in 2021 and has reported on courts since 2002 in three newsrooms in the US and New Zealand. Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
