Alberta's transgender ban in sports exempts visiting out-of-province athletes
Tourism and Sport Minister Andrew Boitchenko said the discrepancy is out of his hands.
'We don't have authority to regulate athletes from different jurisdictions,' he said in an interview.
In a followup statement, ministry spokeswoman Vanessa Gomez added it's due to outside sporting organizations being bound by out-of-province or international guidelines.
She added the rules allow the government 'to do what is best for Albertan athletes, while also showcasing Alberta as a premier destination for national and international sport events.'
Starting Sept. 1, the province will block transgender athletes from Alberta who are 12 and older from competing in female amateur sports. It's one of a suite of changes surrounding transgender health, education and sport introduced last year by Premier Danielle Smith's United Conservative Party government.
Story continues below advertisement
The laws sparked polarizing debate.
Proponents, including Smith, say it's about fairness on the playing field, so girls are not battling opponents with biological advantages. Detractors say it's about stigmatizing and punishing those in the transgender community.
Hannah Pilling, a track athlete who petitioned in favour of restricting transgender people in female sports, has welcomed the new regulations. She said in an interview she hopes Smith's government takes it further.
'It's kind of hard to enforce that on other athletes that are coming to compete in Alberta, but it's definitely still not completely fair,' Pilling said.
Get breaking National news
For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up
By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy
She added that she would like to see future rules apply to men's divisions.
Transgender athlete Allison Hadley said the exemption for out-of-province athletes suggests the legislation is not really about fairness or safety.
'If I had the resources to (move), honestly, I probably wouldn't be in Alberta now,' she said. 'We're here in a province that doesn't want us to be in the public or exist in many ways.'
Hadley said she didn't pick up cross-country skiing to win medals. She said she was in it for the health benefits, the motivation that competition brings to her training and the camaraderie on the trail.
Story continues below advertisement
'It really sucks to have that taken away,' she said.
Mark Kosak, head of the Alberta Colleges Athletic Conference, said a restriction preventing transgender athletes from coming to Alberta to compete might have stopped the organization from ever hosting a national championship again.
'So there's some relief from us,' Kosak said.
He said the conference hosts more than 1,000 events a year and, of those, between 40 and 50 host out-of-province competitors.
He said he's unaware of any transgender athletes competing in the conference.
Kosak added that the sporting community didn't ask for the government's new rules.
'This is not a priority. This is not a concern,' he said. 'It's not an issue.'
The rules will be enforced through a complaint-driven process. Female athletes subject to complaints need to prove their sex registration at birth.
For those who were born elsewhere but live in Alberta and can't retrieve documents that clearly state their sex at birth, Boitchenko said the government will look at 'alternative documents.'
'We'll be looking at (it) case by case, making sure that nobody feels that they can't compete just because they lost certain documents,' he said.
Story continues below advertisement
Possible sanctions for bad-faith complaints against athletes could result in written warnings or code of conduct violations.
Bennett Jensen, legal director at LGBTQ+ advocacy group Egale, said the validation process alone is a 'gross violation of the privacy of all women and girls.'
He said the government is introducing a complaint-based 'snitch line' for complaints that will spur even more public policing of women's bodies and gender presentation among young girls — whether they're transgender or not.
He said a 12-year-old, at a vulnerable stage of her life, could be subject to scrutiny and humiliation based on her physical appearance.
Jensen also said the government's biological advantage argument falls apart in many instances, including for those athletes receiving hormone replacement therapy.
Boitchenko said inclusion is the goal, and the government is planning to expand grants to encourage sporting organizations to create coed divisions where numbers allow.
Pilling's father, Dave Pilling, said he sits on the board for the Southern Alberta Summer Games, where they introduced open categories in all sports this year.
But for the Alberta Colleges Athletic Conference, Kosak said creating coed divisions across the majority of sports is 'totally impractical and unrealistic.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
30 minutes ago
- CBC
Who's vetting tenants? + Arctic sovereignty
The National talks to frustrated landlords who blame their real estate agents for bad tenants, but whose responsibility is it to vet them? And why Nunavummiut say investment in northern communities is crucial to Arctic sovereignty.
Canada News.Net
3 hours ago
- Canada News.Net
Alberta Premier urges Canadian PM to designate Lawrence Bishnoi gang as "terrorist entity"
Alberta [Canada], July 16 (ANI): Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has urged Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney and his cabinet to formally label the Lawrence Bishnoi gang as a 'terrorist entity', citing its involvement in transnational crime and violence in Canada and abroad. In a statement posted on X on Tuesday, Smith, Alberta's 19th Premier and Leader of the United Conservative Party (UCP), described the Bishnoi gang as a global criminal organisation involved in offences such as violence, extortion, drug trafficking, and targeted killings, including incidents in Canada. Highlighting the growing threat posed by the organised crime groups operating across international borders, the Premier said that gang activity 'knows no boundaries and respects no borders.' 'The Lawrence Bishnoi Gang is a transnational criminal network responsible for violence, extortion, drug trafficking and targeted killings, including here in Canada. Its reach is global, and its intent is criminal and violent,' she said in her post on X. 'Alberta wants to send a clear message: you are not welcome here,' Smith added. The Premier emphasised that officially labelling the gang as a 'terrorist entity' would empower law enforcement agencies across provincial and municipal levels to more effectively combat its operations, while calling on the Canadian Government to act with urgency. 'Formally designating the Bishnoi Gang as a terrorist entity will unlock critical powers, allowing provincial and municipal-level law enforcement agencies to access the necessary tools and resources needed to effectively disrupt operations and protect our people,' the post read. 'The time for action is now. Alberta's government is asking the federal government and Prime Minister Mark Carney to join them in taking a stand and act to protect Albertans and all Canadians,' it added. Lawrence Bishnoi is currently under the custody of the Indian Government under many charges, including the links to the killing of Punjabi rapper Sidhu Moose Wala back in 2022, in a reported gang rivalry. This incident drew widespread national attention, which catapulted Bishnoi and his gang into the mainstream. His gang also took credit for the assassination of Nationalist Congress Party leader Baba Siddique last year. (ANI)
CBC
4 hours ago
- CBC
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith suggests premiers start constitutional talks
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith says it could be time for premiers to hold another constitutional convention. At the province's first Alberta Next panel town hall meeting in Red Deer Tuesday evening, the premier gauged the crowd's appetite for getting other premiers together in a room to discuss reopening the constitution. "There is a real appetite to fix some of these things that are just foundational," Smith said near the end of the meeting. Canada hasn't engaged in formal constitutional negotiations since 1992, when the premiers and then-Prime Minister Brian Mulroney failed to get Quebec to sign on to the 1982 constitution in the Charlottetown Accord negotiations. The risk of reopening the constitution, Smith said, is that other provinces could attempt to include changes that Albertans may not want. In a conference hall in Red Deer's Westerner Park, a panel of 16 politicians, business leaders, medical professionals and others sat before six Alberta flags, hearing ideas, questions and comments from a crowd of at least 400 people. Up for discussion at the town halls are the potential merits and drawbacks of creating a provincial police service, a provincial pension plan, and assuming more provincial responsibility for tax collection. Organizers showed a series of videos asking attendees questions, such as considering changes to federal transfer arrangements — including equalization — changes to constitutional powers, and potentially withholding social benefits from some immigrants. Smith said the number of sheriffs working in policing roles for a new provincial police service could double in size in the near future. Event emcee and premier's office staffer Bruce McAllister also held impromptu straw polls, asking attendees to raise their hands and hold them up if they supported creating an Alberta pension plan or an Alberta provincial police service. Roughly 80 per cent of the people attending raised their hands in support of both. Several residents, who said they came from Red Deer, Trochu, Sylvan Lake, Stettler and beyond, implored elected officials to act upon the proposals, adding that the government doesn't need to hold referenda to make a decision. Alberta law would require the government to hold a referendum before giving notice to pull out of the Canada Pension Plan (CPP). A minority of attendees complained about the panel's videos and online surveys, saying the information is biased in favour of acting on the proposals, blames Ottawa for provincial problems, and fails to consider the cost of such decisions. Some attendees hoping for separation Wade Collinge of Sylvan Lake was among speakers advocating to the panel for the separation of Alberta from Canada. Reopening the constitution to make change is no solution, given the necessity of securing the support of Ontario or Quebec for any change, he said in an interview before the event. "The west will never become equal in Canada, from what I understand, unless we can open the constitution, and opening the constitution is pretty much ironclad shut," said Colligne, who was wearing an Alberta Prosperity Project tank top, and button that said, "Commonwealth of Alberta." The Alberta Prosperity Project is a separatist advocacy group. Bill Tompkins drove an hour from Rocky Mountain House to attend the meeting to hear ideas about the province's future, he said. Tompkins, a separation advocate, likes the idea of a provincial police service and Alberta's own pension plan. He said the federal government interferes too much in Alberta, and uses coercion by attaching conditions to spending federal funds. "I feel that the federal government has mismanaged the taxpayers' money — not only Albertans' but all of them," he said. Attendees asked the panel to limit money flowing to Quebec through equalization, but also suggested emulating Quebec policies, including by holding a referendum on independence, so the rest of Canada takes Alberta's grievances seriously. Smith said Quebec is sitting on a cache of natural gas that it isn't extracting, and that untapped revenue should be factored into Quebec's share of equalization funding. Some speakers pushed back against separatist sentiment, telling the panel that Albertans should be willing to support their fellow Canadians. After the event, Dave Travers, who's from Red Deer, said there was a large far-right wing element to the crowd, and that he doesn't think their sentiments reflect most Albertans' perspectives, as shown by public polling. "Danielle Smith's having a hard time just making her bed. And the house is looking awfully dirty," he said, referring to the struggling health-care system, allegations about mismanagement of health contracts and procurement, and the rapid spread of measles in the province. A few protesters gathered outside the venue, including Cassidy Simone, who said talk of separation ignores the rights of Indigenous people. "I'm really concerned that we're going to forget about Indigenous peoples and all the reconciliation that we have been working toward and trying to achieve within the past year," Simone said. Heather Plaizier, who lives near Sundre, stood outside the venue holding a sign saying, "UCP policies hurt water, wildlife, people." She said she couldn't get a ticket to get inside the event. Plaizier said the panel has shared biased surveys and information. She doesn't feel the members are listening to the public. "I feel like there's kind of a set agenda and it doesn't matter what we say," she said. "I hate to go into a consultation with that expectation, but I would love to see actual consultation happen." A second town-hall panel is scheduled for the Edmonton area on Wednesday evening.
