
Behind the Story: What next for Gaza as Netanyahu orders military takeover of Gaza City?
There has been widespread condemnation of the move by Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Visiting Fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations Dr Tahani Mustafa told Behind the Story there are many questions about what happens next.
"It's effectively distracting the international community, forcing them to focus on this plan regarding Gaza City and distracting from Israel's border practices in the Gaza Strip," she said.
"The deepening case of famine that we're starting to see, the fact that Israel has managed to completely derail another ceasefire agreement that could lead to a potential settlement, an end to the war and return of the hostages.
"What we are seeing now is this fixation on this plan that is going to take months in any case to implement if they do end up implementing it."
Dr Mustafa said there is no infrastructure to even move people within Gaza.
"The fact that there aren't any procedures to help people relocate internally within Gaza, never mind externally," she said.
"Gaza has no functioning roads left; how are you going to transport that many people to the south when you have functioning civic infrastructure to move them?"
Dr Mustafa said she believes the plan is part of a wider effort to depopulate the Gaza Strip.
"There are three main population centres left now in Gaza – Gaza City being the last in north – and that means that we're going to see those that are sheltering there being pushed now to the south," she said.
"Anyone who is left, anyone who refuses to leave, will be considered to be a legitimate combatant.
"It's already really very clear that we have no safe spaces.
"I think this is the first stage that we're seeing in Israel's bigger plan here, which is to effectively depopulate the Strip".
'Opinion is changing'
EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen called on Israel to 'reconsider' the plan, adding that humanitarian aid and a ceasefire "is needed now."
UN Human Rights Chief Volker Turk said the plan must be "immediately halted", while UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer said the plan was "wrong" and would "only bring more bloodshed".
Germany has said it will halt the export of military equipment to Israel which could be used in the Gaza Strip.
The UK, Spain, Egypt and Saudi Arabia have also condemned the move.
Dr Mustafa said such statements condemning Israel need to be followed up by action.
"They mean nothing if you're not going to actually substantiate them with actual real, tangible policies that can shift realities on the ground," she said.
"These moves so far that we've seen from some European states are substantive in the way of demonstrating to the rest of Europe, at least, that opinion is changing towards Israel.
"But unless it's followed by more substantive changes, then I don't think we're going to see anything tangible".
It comes amid deepening fallout in the US against Ireland's plans to pass the Occupied Territories Bill (OTB).
A group of US Congress members has written to US Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent asking him to consider adding Ireland to a list of countries which boycott Israel if the bill is passed.
Dr Mustafa said such moves can show others that "the tide is changing".
"That could very much be the thing that sort of catalyses other states to follow suit," she added.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Israel faces growing global condemnation over military expansion in Gaza
International condemnation grew on Saturday over Israel's decision for a military takeover of Gaza City, while little appeared to change immediately on the ground in the territory shattered by 22 months of war. Health officials said that 11 Palestinians seeking aid were shot dead, and 11 adults died of malnutrition-related causes in the past 24 hours. US special envoy Steve Witkoff was expected to meet with Qatar's prime minister in Spain on Saturday to discuss a new proposal to end the war, according to two officials familiar with the talks, who spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorised to speak with the media. Palestinians collect humanitarian aid packages from the United Arab Emirates after they were airdropped into Deir al-Balah, in central Gaza Strip (Abdel Kareem Hana/AP) Mediators in Egypt and Qatar are preparing a new ceasefire framework that would include the release of all hostages — dead and alive — in one go in return for the war's end and the withdrawal of Israeli forces, two Arab officials have told The Associated Press. – 'Shut the country down' Families of hostages were rallying again on Saturday evening to pressure the government of Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu amid new fears over the 50 remaining hostages, with 20 of them thought to be alive and struggling. 'The living will be murdered and the fallen will be lost forever' if the offensive goes ahead, said Einav Zangauker, whose son Matan is held in Gaza. She called on Israelis to 'help us save the hostages, the soldiers and the state of Israel… Shut the country down.' A joint statement by nine countries including Germany, France and Canada said that the 'strongly reject' Israel's decision for the large-scale military operation, saying it will worsen the 'catastrophic humanitarian situation', endanger hostages and further risk mass displacement. They said any attempts at annexation or settlement in Gaza violate international law. A separate statement by more than 20 countries including ceasefire mediators Egypt and Qatar along with Saudi Arabia, Turkey and the United Arab Emirates called Israel's decision a 'dangerous and unacceptable escalation'. Meanwhile, Russia said Israel's plan will aggravate the 'already extremely dramatic situation' in Gaza. The UN Security Council planned an emergency meeting on Sunday. And Germany has said it will not authorise any exports of military equipment to Israel that could be used in Gaza until further notice. – Killed while seeking aid Officials at Nasser and Awda hospitals said that Israeli forces killed at least 11 people seeking aid in southern and central Gaza. Some had been waiting for aid trucks, while others had been approaching aid distribution points. The sun sets behind buildings that were destroyed during the Israeli ground and air operations stand in the northern Gaza Strip as seen from southern Israel (Leo Correa/AP) Israel's military denied opening fire and said that it was unaware of the incidents. The military secures routes leading to distribution sites run by the Israeli-backed and US-supported Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, which did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Two witnesses told the AP that Israeli troops fired toward crowds approaching a GHF distribution site on foot in the Netzarim corridor, a military zone that bisects Gaza. One witness, Ramadan Gaber, said that snipers and tanks fired on aid-seekers, forcing them to retreat. In Deir al-Balah in central Gaza, some aid-seekers cheered the latest airdrops of aid. Hundreds of people rushed to grab what they could, though many have called the process degrading. Aid organisations have called airdrops expensive, insufficient and potentially dangerous for people on the ground. Israel's military said that at least 106 packages of aid were airdropped on Saturday as Italy and Greece joined the multi-country effort for the first time. Footage from Italy's defence ministry showed not only packages being parachuted over Gaza but the dry and devastated landscape below. 'This way is not for humans, it is for animals,' said one man at the scene, Mahmoud Hawila, who said he was stabbed while trying to secure an airdropped package. Palestinians collect humanitarian aid packages from the United Arab Emirates after they were airdropped into Deir al-Balah, in central Gaza Strip (Abdel Kareem Hana/AP) Barefoot children collected rice, pasta and lentils that had spilled from packages onto the ground. The United Nations and partners, whose existing aid delivery system has been criticised by Israel, has called repeatedly for more of the trucks waiting outside Gaza to be allowed not just into the territory, but safely to destinations inside it for distribution. – More deaths from hunger Gaza's Health Ministry said that 11 more adults died of malnutrition-related causes over the past 24 hours, bringing the total to 114 since it began counting such adult deaths in late June. It said that 98 children have died of malnutrition-related causes since the war began with the Hamas-led attack on southern Israel on October 7 2023, with militants killing around 1,200 people and abducting 251. Israel is 'forcing Palestinians into a state of near-starvation to the point that they abandon their land voluntarily,' Turkish foreign minister Hakan Fidan told a news conference in Egypt. The toll from hunger is not included in the ministry's death toll of 61,300 Palestinians in the war. The ministry, part of the Hamas-run government and staffed by medical professionals, does not distinguish between fighters or civilians, but says around half of the dead have been women and children. The UN and independent experts consider it the most reliable source on war casualties. Israel disputes the ministry's figures, but has not provided its own.


The Irish Sun
2 hours ago
- The Irish Sun
Russia is running ‘slave catalogue' of Ukrainian ‘orphans' with kidnapped children ‘treated like animals'
RUSSIA is allegedly running a grotesque online "slave catalogue" of abducted Ukrainian children in occupied territory. The profiles can be searched by hair colour, eye colour and even "personality" in the latest twisted move by Mad Vlad Putin's regime. 9 Russia is reportedly running a twisted online 'slave catalogue' of abducted Ukrainian children Credit: Reuters 9 Children from an orphanage in the Donetsk region, eat a meal at a camp in Zolotaya Kosa, the settlement on the Sea of Azov, Rostov region, southwestern Russia Credit: AP 9 Ukrainian officials previously warned its children are being trained up to fight in Putin's army Credit: Bring Kids Back Ukraine According to the NGO Save Ukraine, it features almost 300 children labelled as "orphans" or "left without parental care". But campaigners insist many were forcibly taken from their families, re-registered under Russian documents and are now being "matched" with Russian families as if they were animals in a pet shop. Mykola Kuleba, head of Save Ukraine, described it as 'digital trafficking' and a 'slave catalogue'. He warned: "This is not adoption. This is not care. This is digital child trafficking, masked as bureaucracy. "These children are not 'war orphans'. They had names, families and Ukrainian citizenship." According to The Times, the depraved search tool reportedly allows users to filter children by age, gender, health and physical traits - even by whether they are "calm" or "active". The portal is run by Luhansk's so-called Ministry of Education and Science — part of the self-proclaimed Luhansk People's Republic (LPR), a Russian-installed regime in territory internationally recognised as Ukrainian. While some of the children listed were born after Russia seized the area in 2014, Kuleba says most were born before occupation and held Ukrainian citizenship. Kyiv says the catalogue is just the latest stage in Moscow's mass child-snatching campaign — a programme that Ukrainian officials claim has seen tens of thousands of minors abducted since Putin's full-scale invasion in 2022. Yale researchers, UN experts and legal bodies have said the deportations could amount to war crimes. Nazi lies, Vlad's propaganda & troops on border… chilling signs Putin ready to invade ANOTHER European nation after Ukraine In 2023, the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Putin and his children's commissioner, Maria Lvova-Belova, over the illegal transfer and adoption of Ukrainian children. Russia has long defended these relocations as "humanitarian" - but Ukrainian officials and returned captives tell a far darker story. Survivors have described being beaten, starved, locked in basements, forced to sing the Russian national anthem, and banned from speaking Ukrainian in re-education camps. Some say they were told their parents had abandoned them. 9 Pictures show children inside Russian 're-education' camps in a bid to rid them of their Ukrainian heritage Credit: Bring Kids Back Ukraine 9 A chamber in Kherson where Ukrainian children were allegedly abused Credit: Security Service of Ukraine 9 Vitaliy was held at a camp in Yevpatroia and spoke of horrors he saw after begging to be released from an isolation cell Credit: BRING KIDS BACK UKRAINE 9 One 11-year-old, Illia, was forced to have shrapnel removed without anaesthetic after he was snatched by Russian soldiers Credit: BRING KIDS BACK UKRAINE Earlier this year, Moscow announced plans to send 60,000 kidnapped Ukrainian children to remote summer camps in the wilderness - a move critics see as deepening indoctrination. Ukraine's presidential adviser Daria Zarivna has accused Putin of 'weaponising' these children, warning they are being groomed to fight for Russia in future wars. She told The Sun: 'It's a threat to global security, to Ukraine's security.' Lvova-Belova - dubbed "Putin's childcatcher" and sanctioned by Britain for her role in the abductions - has openly bragged about "adopting" a boy from Mariupol. 'I was snatched by Russian soldier' ILLIA, 11, was deported from Mariupol after a Russian missile strike killed his mother and left him with horror shrapnel wounds when he was nine. His neighbours buried his mum's body in their back garden before he was snatched by Vlad's soldiers and taken for surgery at a camp in Donestk. The shrapnel was removed without any anaesthetic and he was forced to write and speak Russian and repeat "Glory to Ukraine as part of Russia". He says Russian forces tried to turn him into a "propaganda tool" but that he is not "one to be duped so easily." Illia's grandmother had been searching for her grandson ever since losing contact with her daughter in March 2022. It wasn't until they spotted the young boy in a video from Russia that she realised he was alone and that her daughter had been killed. His grandmother never gave up hope and set about getting her injured grandson back home where he belonged. Months later, Illia returned home to Ukraine and had further surgery to remove more fragments from his leg, while 11 remain. His grandmother Olena said: "He had a school, he had a home, he had a mother and he lost all of that - his entire childhood. "He kept to himself, he was afraid of noise, he was afraid of sirens. He had no memory. He now has dreams of becoming a doctor so that he can help fighters on the frontline as a combat medic. She is accused of overseeing the heartless bureaucratic machinery that strips Ukrainian children of their identities before placing them in Russian homes. Kyiv's Bring Kids Back Ukraine initiative has so far rescued nearly 700 minors, but thousands remain missing. Officials say no peace deal will be struck with Moscow until every abducted child is returned. 'This is genocide,' said Ukraine's Human Rights Commissioner Dmytro Lubinets. 'These children are not commodities. They are victims of a brutal campaign to erase our nation's future.' 9 Putin meets with Russia's Children's Rights Commissioner Maria Lvova-Belova Credit: AFP

The Journal
4 hours ago
- The Journal
Inside Port au Prince: Purge-like gang violence, drone strikes and millions going hungry
LAST UPDATE | 6 Aug AN AID WORKER in the Haitian capital of Port au Prince likened the heavy fighting in the city to the horror film 'The Purge' when he spoke to us in March of last year. Matt Knight, country director in Haiti for the Irish charity GOAL, says the situation has only deteriorated further since then, with 1.4 million people now internally displaced within the Caribbean nation. Knight spoke to The Journal as efforts continue to secure the release of Mayo woman Gina Heraty and seven others, including a three-year-old child, abducted from the Sainte-Hélène orphanage on the outskirts of the city over the weekend . Haiti has suffered multiple social and political collapses since the days of a long-running dynastic dictatorship which ended in the 1980s. The Haiti earthquake of 2010 destabilised the fragile state much further, with the latest outbreak of gang-led violence beginning five years ago as a feeble government struggled to contain domestic unrest. The violence has spiralled from there and now the gangs have control of 90% of the capital city, with their tentacles also reaching out into the jungles of the interior. Knight, one of Gina Heraty's fellow humanitarians in Port au Prince, runs a team of aid workers spread out across the city. Based on his experiences living and working in Haiti, he says what was already a desperate situation is continuing to deteriorate. 'According to UN figures half the population are in need of humanitarian assistance – it's gone up to about six million over the last year when it was 2.6 million last year. 'That is an extra three million people who just don't know where their next meal is coming from – Haiti is now in the top five countries at risk of famine. 'It is a really, really serious situation and compounded by that security issue.' Gang wars have raged across the country and the capital in particular in recent months. To combat the problem the ailing Haitian government hired American mercenaries to try and find a way to quell the violence. A Kenyan deployment last year of hundreds of police officers to Haiti in a US-funded and UN-backed mission to help local law enforcement secure the country has failed to bring peace. Kidnapping of local people has been a daily reality but the kidnapping of a foreign aid worker is a departure from the norm – this has worried security sources we spoke to in Haiti and elsewhere. A security source in the region has said that the assessment regarding those Kenyan forces is that they were ill-prepared for what they faced and because of the continuing danger many are now remaining inside their compounds. Advertisement As a result the fighting is often left to the murky mercenary groups, particularly ones from the US, who are now using tactics taken from the Ukraine war. They are using first-person view explosive drones to attack the gangs. In one high profile attack last month, sources said, a major player in one of the gangs suffered severe burns. That attack was launched as many of the gangsters were watching a football match inside their enclaves across the city. Video has also emerged of drone blasts targeting roving groups of gunmen inside heavily fortified locations. It has meant that gang leaders, such as Jimmy 'Barbecue' Chérizier – the leader of the group believed to be behind the orphanage kidnappings, Viv Ansanm – have sourced heavily armoured cars and are taking security measures to defend against the drones. People in Port au Prince gather water from burst water pipes. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo Febrile atmosphere Knight said it is not all disaster in Haiti with some areas across the island nation relatively safe. The biggest challenge for his team, which is made up of local Haitians, is getting in and out of gang controlled areas. What they have done is develop a set strategy to liaise closely with the gangs to allow free passage – he believes this has been working as the gangs are also benefiting from the food aid he and his team are distributing. Knight said at this stage, it is clear that Haitians are now sick of the gang violence and that there is a movement by local people to take action. 'There comes a point where everybody gets sick of it and the tide will turn. We have seen that in terms of the response to the armed groups. 'In some instances the community has armed themselves and responded to the armed gangs and dealt with them in a kind of vigilante fashion. 'It's not ideal, and what everybody needs is a workable political solution, and that doesn't appear to be just around the corner – it's complicated.' Matt Knight, who is country director of Irish charity GOAL inside Port au Prince. GOAL GOAL Local solution Knight said locals are speaking about Haiti's possible solution being similar to that achieved in El Salvador in Central America. Heavy handed police tactics were used to arrest gangsters and there was also direct negotiations to control the gangs. Knight's message to the international community is that there needs to be a massive influx of funding to help build a major humanitarian response. While he had warm praise for the Irish Government efforts to fund his work in the country he was very critical of the cuts to USAID by the Trump regime. 'We're allowing gangs to have far more power than they should have because of the lack of funding. I think if we were able to make the communities more resilient, they would be able to deal with these kind of problems internally.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal