How the papal conclave, for all its sacred mysteries, became a meme
The newfound, secular-leaning interest was fomented by the well-timed, October premiere of 'Conclave,' starring Ralph Fiennes and Stanley Tucci – a cherry on top of other cinematic portrayals of the papacy that captured audiences in the years of Pope Francis, including television drama 'The Young Pope' starring Jude Law and Diane Keaton, which premiered in 2016, and biographical drama 'The Two Popes,' released in 2019. 'The Young Pope,' in particular, cultivated a fascination with the pope's wardrobe and the material culture of the papacy.
When photos of the actual conclave in the Sistine Chapel emerged, they prompted a popular reaction: 'OH MY GOD JUST LIKE IN CONCLAVE (2024)'
The account Pope Crave on X – its name a play on the pop culture news account Pop Crave – has been posting nonstop about the conclave since early this year, starting as a fan art and meme page celebrating 'Conclave' the film. It quickly morphed, after the death of Francis in April, into something of a fan page for the actual conclave process and real-life cardinals.
The account began posting less about Tucci and more about Zuppi, the real-life archbishop of Bologna, Italy, who was among those seen as a contender for the papacy.
By the day of the conclave, the account became something of an actual live news feed about the process to elect the new leader of the Catholic Church. By the conclave's end, the account had nearly 100,000 followers.
Susan Bin, a 30-year-old artist in Dallas who is the lead administrator of Pope Crave, is not Catholic but was exposed to the church and its rituals in an academic sense by studying early Christian art and papal sarcophagi.
Bin created the account after watching 'Conclave,' to post fan art and discuss the movie. She also started and co-edited a 'Conclave' fan zine for charity, with art inspired by the movie from dozens of artists. The account took on a life of its own.
That so many people have a fascination with the conclave makes sense: it's a rare event steeped in ritual, spectacle and secrecy.
'It's the profane and the sacred; it's political but it's spiritual. It in itself is a spectacle,' Bin said. It's also totally closed-off, so quite literally, 'the only way we can participate is by memeing,' she said.
'The juxtaposition is extreme,' Bin said of the memeification of such a solemn, religious institution. But in terms of aesthetics and iconography, intrigue around the Catholic church is not so far-fetched, she said. 'Didn't Catholicism invent photo cards? Isn't Catholicism itself such an interesting nontraditional depiction of masculinity – a display of pageantry.'
Footage of Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, another social media favourite, and fellow Filipino cardinals walking down a cobblestone path, was set to the background music of Coolio's 'Gangsta's Paradise': 'As I walk through the valley of the shadow of death …'
Another video shared on X superimposes lyrics to Charli XCX's 'Brat' lead single over clips of Zuppi.
Making and circulating memes about this odd process allows young people to 'connect with something esoteric and arcane in a way that feels safe, funny and creative,' said Michael Budde, a professor of Catholic studies and political science at DePaul University.
Budde has noticed that very few of the memes are anti-Catholic or anti-religious, which he suspects is due 'to the love and respect Pope Francis engendered during his time as pope,' he said. 'Many young people found his humility, his humour, and his deep love of the poor and vulnerable at odds with stereotypes of Catholic clergy.'
For all the silliness of the memes, Pope Crave was coming from a place of sincerity and community, and wanting to bring levity and lightness, Bin said. 'Pope Francis was a huge believer that an institution that's as heavy and dogmatic as the church needed lightness,' she said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
27-05-2025
- NZ Herald
HBO's Harry Potter reboot cast: Everything you need to know
Who's playing Harry, Ron, and Hermione? More than 32,000 children responded to a public casting call to play the world's three most famous young wizards last year in the hope of landing the role of a lifetime. Producers whittled down the audition tapes and then ran workshops and screen tests. The lucky trio have been confirmed as Dominic McLaughlin as Harry Potter, with Arabella Stanton playing Hermione Granger, and Alastair Stout as Ron Weasley. All are described as being screen newcomers, though McLaughlin is in Gifted, a yet-to-be-aired CBBC series based on Marilyn Kaye's children's novels about kids with superpowers. Stanton has previously appeared in the stage musicals Matilda and Starlight Express, while Stout's agent (which says he does a 'northern' accent) credits him with appearing in an Albert Bartlett potato advert. These are the most important casting decisions, as McLaughlin, Stanton, and Stout will be expected to carry the show and deal with huge public scrutiny for years. Francesca Gardiner and Mark Mylod, the Harry Potter show-runners, said of the trio: 'After an extraordinary search led by casting directors Lucy Bevan and Emily Brockmann, we are delighted to announce we have found our Harry, Hermione, and Ron'. 'The talent of these three unique actors is wonderful to behold, and we cannot wait for the world to witness their magic together onscreen. 'We would like to thank all the tens of thousands of children who auditioned. It's been a real pleasure to discover the plethora of young talent out there.' Who is in the cast? Like the films, the series is sure to be a Who's Who of A-list talent, with budgets that dwarf almost everything else on TV. The first performer to confirm their participation was the Conclave star John Lithgow, cast as Hogwarts' headmaster Albus Dumbledore. Lithgow, 79, said that he did not expect to be asked to follow in the footsteps of Richard Harris, Michael Gambon, and Jude Law (who all played Dumbledore in the Wizarding World films). 'Well, it came as a total surprise to me. I just got the phone call at the Sundance Film Festival for yet another film, and it was not an easy decision because it's going to define me for the last chapter of my life, I'm afraid,' he said in February. 'But I'm very excited. Some wonderful people are turning their attention back to Harry Potter. That's why it's been such a hard decision. I'll be about 87 years old at the wrap party, but I've said yes.' HBO has officially revealed its first batch of stars to populate the new Hogwarts. I May Destroy You star Paapa Essiedu has been cast as potions master Severus Snape, while Ozark's Janet McTeer is to play deputy headmistress Minerva McGonagall, a role that was made famous by the late Dame Maggie Smith and previously linked with Sharon Horgan and Rachel Weisz. Other stars confirmed to have signed up are Shaun of the Dead's Nick Frost succeeding Robbie Coltrane as gamekeeper Rubeus Hagrid, while the role of cantankerous caretaker Argus Filch is filled by comic performer Paul Whitehouse. We also have our first villain. Quirinus Quirrell, the Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher in Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone who is later revealed to be under the control of the evil Lord Voldemort, will be portrayed by Luke Thallon. The 29-year-old is best known as a stage actor. Who will play Voldemort himself in later series is being kept under wraps, but those said to be in the frame include Oscar-winner Cillian Murphy. The confirmed Harry Potter cast so far: John Lithgow (Albus Dumbledore) Janet McTeer (Minerva McGonagall) Paapa Essiedu (Severus Snape) Nick Frost (Rubeus Hagrid) Paul Whitehouse (Argus Filch) Luke Thallon (Quirinus Quirrell) How will the series be different from the films? HBO boss Casey Bloys has said that the series will be a 'very, very specifically British 1990s production'. The series is being overseen by Gardiner and Mylod, Brits who are both alumni of HBO's Succession. One need only look at their track record to know that the series will not merely be a rehash of the films. Gardiner worked on the TV adaptation of Philip Pullman's His Dark Materials; while Mylod's hits include Game of Thrones and The Menu, a Ralph Fiennes horror satirising fine dining. It is expected that the series will be darker than the films, with HBO looking for a slightly older viewership than the pre-teens who were the primary target of the cinematic pictures. Friends of Gardiner – who wrote her master's thesis on the importance of darkness in kids' stories and has spoken of her dislike for patronising children – say that she wants to bring a grittier, 'Wednesday/Tim Burton vibe' to the series. Perhaps most notably, the characters will be the same age as they are in the books, with each series presumably following the school year. That means, for instance, that Snape (played by the inimitable Alan Rickman in the films) will be in his early 30s on the small screen. Essiedu is 34; Rickman, by contrast, was 55 when the first film was released. The exception is Dumbledore, who lived to the ripe old age of 115. Lithgow is unlikely to want to be working in his 12th decade. Is JK Rowling involved? Despite selling more than 600 million Harry Potter books and amassing a fortune of almost £1 billion (according to the Sunday Times Rich List), Rowling has become a polarising character in recent years for her public contributions to the transgender debate. 'That's a very online conversation, very nuanced and complicated and not something we're going to get into,' Bloys said at an investor presentation in April 2023. 'Our priority is what's on the screen.' The 59-year-old author is key to the whole series: she serves as its executive producer and will have the final say on all the casting choices. Rowling praised HBO for 'preserving the integrity' of her books and said that the new adaptation will 'allow for a degree of depth and detail only afforded by a long-form television series'. Will the original stars return? Probably not. Many of the original cast members – including Radcliffe, Grint, and Watson – have criticised Rowling's trans views, while others (including Gambon and Rickman) have died. Jason Isaacs, who played the villainous Lucius Malfoy in the films, was asked about whether he would mount a comeback to the Wizarding World at the premiere of The White Lotus in February. 'I'm hoping to come back as Hermione,' he said, not entirely seriously. 'I sent my audition tape in and I've yet to hear. But they have my number.' When will the series be broadcast? Filming at the Warner Bros studio in Leavesden, Hertfordshire, is not scheduled to start until the summer, so it is unlikely that it will hit our screens before 2027.
NZ Herald
12-05-2025
- NZ Herald
How the papal conclave, for all its sacred mysteries, became a meme
The newfound, secular-leaning interest was fomented by the well-timed, October premiere of 'Conclave,' starring Ralph Fiennes and Stanley Tucci – a cherry on top of other cinematic portrayals of the papacy that captured audiences in the years of Pope Francis, including television drama 'The Young Pope' starring Jude Law and Diane Keaton, which premiered in 2016, and biographical drama 'The Two Popes,' released in 2019. 'The Young Pope,' in particular, cultivated a fascination with the pope's wardrobe and the material culture of the papacy. When photos of the actual conclave in the Sistine Chapel emerged, they prompted a popular reaction: 'OH MY GOD JUST LIKE IN CONCLAVE (2024)' The account Pope Crave on X – its name a play on the pop culture news account Pop Crave – has been posting nonstop about the conclave since early this year, starting as a fan art and meme page celebrating 'Conclave' the film. It quickly morphed, after the death of Francis in April, into something of a fan page for the actual conclave process and real-life cardinals. The account began posting less about Tucci and more about Zuppi, the real-life archbishop of Bologna, Italy, who was among those seen as a contender for the papacy. By the day of the conclave, the account became something of an actual live news feed about the process to elect the new leader of the Catholic Church. By the conclave's end, the account had nearly 100,000 followers. Susan Bin, a 30-year-old artist in Dallas who is the lead administrator of Pope Crave, is not Catholic but was exposed to the church and its rituals in an academic sense by studying early Christian art and papal sarcophagi. Bin created the account after watching 'Conclave,' to post fan art and discuss the movie. She also started and co-edited a 'Conclave' fan zine for charity, with art inspired by the movie from dozens of artists. The account took on a life of its own. That so many people have a fascination with the conclave makes sense: it's a rare event steeped in ritual, spectacle and secrecy. 'It's the profane and the sacred; it's political but it's spiritual. It in itself is a spectacle,' Bin said. It's also totally closed-off, so quite literally, 'the only way we can participate is by memeing,' she said. 'The juxtaposition is extreme,' Bin said of the memeification of such a solemn, religious institution. But in terms of aesthetics and iconography, intrigue around the Catholic church is not so far-fetched, she said. 'Didn't Catholicism invent photo cards? Isn't Catholicism itself such an interesting nontraditional depiction of masculinity – a display of pageantry.' Footage of Cardinal Luis Antonio Tagle, another social media favourite, and fellow Filipino cardinals walking down a cobblestone path, was set to the background music of Coolio's 'Gangsta's Paradise': 'As I walk through the valley of the shadow of death …' Another video shared on X superimposes lyrics to Charli XCX's 'Brat' lead single over clips of Zuppi. Making and circulating memes about this odd process allows young people to 'connect with something esoteric and arcane in a way that feels safe, funny and creative,' said Michael Budde, a professor of Catholic studies and political science at DePaul University. Budde has noticed that very few of the memes are anti-Catholic or anti-religious, which he suspects is due 'to the love and respect Pope Francis engendered during his time as pope,' he said. 'Many young people found his humility, his humour, and his deep love of the poor and vulnerable at odds with stereotypes of Catholic clergy.' For all the silliness of the memes, Pope Crave was coming from a place of sincerity and community, and wanting to bring levity and lightness, Bin said. 'Pope Francis was a huge believer that an institution that's as heavy and dogmatic as the church needed lightness,' she said.
Otago Daily Times
30-04-2025
- Otago Daily Times
Changing seasons, turning over pages
There's something familiar and comforting about autumn — a season captured, loved and preserved in art, music and film. From the nostalgia of movies like Dead Poets Society to Taylor Swift's 2012 album Red , autumn invites reflection. As the leaves turn and the air cools, students' mid-semester break offers a shift in the rhythms of study and the mood of our city itself. I am sure that mid-semester break is a misleading name for many students. The reality for most, however, is far from restful. Assignment due dates beckon, exams loom, time is spent catching up on readings and lectures, and the guilt of unfinished work creeps in. The break often feels like a balancing act between appreciating the need to rest and battling the sense that you could and should be doing more. It becomes hard to escape the productivity guilt that seems stitched into the fabric of student life. Dwelling on this feeling only worsens as winter creeps closer, days shorten and light fades earlier. It becomes easy to feel as though time is slipping away ... I have found that the best practice is to acknowledge this feeling. Perhaps there is something to be said for viewing the break not as a sprint to productivity, but also as a chance to rest. A true break — even a small one — can offer a precious reset, an opportunity to check in with yourself, form new habits and spend time on forgotten hobbies. Picking up your instrument again, reading something not on the prescribed reading list. For some, leaving the student bubble aids this reset. Many students escape Dunedin altogether — heading home despite the airfares, or travelling elsewhere with family or friends. Mid-semester break coincided nicely with one of the two weeks of school holidays; hopefully, those students who did return home got to spend time with their younger siblings. The change was palpable for those who stayed in Dunedin during the mid-semester break. The usually buzzing streets in north Dunedin quietened. The competition for the best library seats vanished, and the best spots were there for the taking. For those remaining, spending even a few days off campus or exploring new parts of the city that are usually overlooked provides refreshment. Mid-semester breaks at the hall in the first year were also nice. The place emptied, and one got a chance to spend more time with those who stayed around. At Knox, my friends and I felt we had most of a castle for a week. How lucky we were. This year the slower rhythm of the break felt particularly fitting as Anzac Day and Pope Francis' death fell during our break, thus providing moments for reflection and remembrance. Not everyone can afford a proper break. For some students, mid-semester break is when fulltime university pauses and fulltime work kicks in. Picking up extra shifts becomes necessary in the never-ending struggle to afford rent, groceries and heating bills. It is important to remember that students' experiences of what a break entails vary widely. Breaks change as you move through university years, too. First years' semester one mid-semester break might have felt like an actual holiday, with no classes and no real understanding of the academic mountain ahead. In later years, the break can feel heavier — a strategic time to get ahead, to finish assignments and lay down some groundwork for exams. Many brains work on, humming on keyboards, scribbling notes and committing to determined learning while also enjoying breaks together, laughing, talking, catching up in the patches of sun. Alas, ever lurking in the background is the quiet drumbeat of exams. The timetable has been out for a few weeks, and the countdown has begun. The university itself is gearing up for an important time, too. This coming Sunday and Monday, prospective students and their parents will flood the campus, city and hotels, attending academic information sessions and touring the halls. I am looking forward to having my cousin from Melbourne stay to attend these days as a prospective student. Sunday's itinerary is smaller; hands-on activities and tours of the hostels. Each hostel will be memorable and appealing to these high school students for different reasons and leave them with exciting decisions to make. Monday is the biggest day with full programmes of course introductions, expos and walking tours. Open day is a chance for future students to glean what life here could be like. As a year 13 student, this was a glimpse into what the next year held for me. As Dunedin edges into winter, our city transforms. The beauty of the orange and red leaves of late autumn remind us that while the seasons shift and pressures build, there is a charm in change. Electric blankets emerge from cupboards; heaters and heat pumps stand ready for winter's chill. The walk to uni gets darker and the season mirrors the academic year as we draw inwards and focus on endurance and perseverance. F. Scott Fitzgerald puts it more poetically than I can in The Great Gatsby : "Life starts all over again when it gets crisp in the fall." Kind regards, Grace. • Dunedin resident Grace Togneri is a fourth-year law student.
