Betrayed with a kiss: How Caravaggio's The Taking of Christ made its way to Ireland
Caravaggio
, including, simultaneously in 1603, Supper at Emmaus, which now belongs to the National Gallery in London, and The Taking of Christ, which is the pride of the
National Gallery of Ireland
.
Francesca Cappelletti, now director of the
Galleria Borghese
in Rome, found the original contract for the commission as a graduate student in the late 1980s. The painting had been misattributed to the Dutch painter Gerard van Honthorst from 1793 until then. Known in Italy as Gherardo delle Notti, van Honthorst was one of many painters who flocked to Rome to imitate Caravaggio's distinctive chiaroscuro style.
[
Caravaggio: the 'boozing, whoring, brawling and bisexual bad boy of baroque'
Opens in new window
]
The painting, which is on loan to the Caravaggio 2025 exhibition at the
Palazzo Barberini
in Rome, stayed in the Mattei family until 1802, when it was sold to the Scottish collector William Hamilton Nisbet. A descendant of Nisbet tried to bequeath it to the National Gallery of Scotland in 1920, but the Edinburgh museum declined, believing the Caravaggio and other pictures given with it to be copies.
Marie Lea-Wilson
, an Irishwoman, purchased the painting in Edinburgh in 1921 and took it home to Dublin, where she was a much-loved paediatrician. In 1930 Lea-Wilson gave it to the Jesuit House at 35 Leeson Street, to thank priests who comforted her when her husband, Capt Percival Lea-Wilson of the Royal Irish Constabulary, was assassinated by the IRA. The painting hung in the Jesuits' diningroom, gathering soot and dust, for 63 years.
READ MORE
The Jesuits asked
Sergio Benedetti
, head curator at the National Gallery of Ireland, to assess their paintings for restoration. Benedetti recognised the lost Caravaggio. The Jesuits put the masterpiece on permanent loan to the NGI.
'My mother and I travelled from Belfast to see The Taking of Christ when it was unveiled in 1993,'
Caroline Campbell
, the director of the NGI, says. 'I felt exalted and astonished ... This painting is really, really, really loved, and that is extraordinary.'
Caravaggio: Supper at Emmaus. Photograph © Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan – MiC
The painting is like a close-up of the crucial moment when Judas betrayed Christ to Roman soldiers by identifying him with a kiss. At the centre of the canvas stand Judas and a Roman soldier, both holding on to Christ. The Saviour looks down at his folded hands with an expression of suffering and resignation. His face is powerfully moving, even to nonbelievers. No reproduction can do it justice. 'This Christ is one of the most beautiful in the history of art,' Thomas Clement Salomon, director of Italy's
National Gallery
, says.
To the left of the canvas John the Evangelist attempts to flee, but a second Roman soldier has grabbed his cloak. To the right is a self-portrait of Caravaggio, illuminating the scene with a lantern.
At the Rome exhibition, Campbell is struck by similarities between The Taking of Christ and The Martyrdom of St Ursula, painted eight years later, shortly before Caravaggio's death. Again, we see two Romans in burnished armour, and the painter himself, as an onlooker. 'Caravaggio must have been thinking about The Taking of Christ just before he died,' Campbell concludes.
Caravaggio 2025 is at
Palazzo Barberini
, in Rome, until July 6th
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 hours ago
- Irish Times
Is the Rose of Tralee ‘uncancellable'?
The Rose of Tralee is one of the biggest events in Ireland's cultural calendar. It pumps millions of euro into the local economy and pulls in well over half a million viewers; no mean feat in an age of dwindling linear TV viewership. Almost 30 years of being lampooned as a 'Lovely Girls' competition thanks to that Father Ted episode has seen its popularity undimmed. It has evolved to permit married and transgender women enter the contest. READ MORE However 29 is still the cut-off age, meaning you are officially too old for Rose of Tralee at the age of 30. The title is bestowed upon a young woman whom the judges think would be a good 'cultural ambassador' for Ireland for the following year. While the spirit of diversity has been embraced, with women of colour among those to don the sash, is the competition still overly focused on a narrow version of femininity? Last year, the documentary 'Housewife of the Year' highlighted the eponymous competition which ran from 1969 to 1995. In what seems utterly baffling now, married women were judged on their ability to 'budget effectively and prepare a simple meal.' Eventually the competition was scrapped quietly. The weight of public opinion was rebelling against the societal norm of the quiet homemaker. But the Rose of Tralee doesn't appear to be in any such jeopardy, and is arguably as popular as ever. Reporter Niamh Browne joins the podcast from Tralee to ponder the question why the Rose of Tralee seems uncancellable. Presented by Aideen Finnegan. Produced by Declan Conlon and Andrew McNair.
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Brendan Canty on his film Christy: ‘The Brits loved that it was from Cork. They thought there was an exotic flavour to that'
'Our premiere was before 1,000 people,' says Brendan Canty . 'I didn't know cinemas even had 1,000 people. It was nuts.' The news that Christy, Canty's debut feature, was to debut at Berlin International Film Festival came as a happy surprise. There was further rejoicing when it took Grand Prix in the Generation 14plus section. The Irish nation has recent history there. Colm Bairéad's An Cailín Ciúin made its debut in the Generation section three years ago and, after winning two awards, embarked on the long road to an Oscar nomination. Does that feel like pressure? 'I'd noticed that, but, if anything, that was a cool thing,' says Canty, a chatty young Cork man. 'I wouldn't have said I was well versed on what are the best festivals. The fact that An Cailín Ciúin had premiered in the same section was good enough for me. That was really cool. That was amazing.' Already the recipient of international raves, Christy stars the newcomer Danny Power as a troubled young man who, ejected from foster care, winds up living with his older half-brother, Shane, in a stable family home. Shane, nervous that Christy will bring havoc, insists the arrangement should be temporary, but foster care is hard to find for a young man nearing the age of majority. Over a busy 99 minutes, Christy bounces from dangerous cousins to incorrigible pals to a possible career as a barber. It's a noisy, energetically acted piece that has flavours of Shane Meadows at his best. READ MORE Pop video and film director Brendan Canty on location filming Christy 'The second night it screened in a more low-key kind of indie cinema,' says Canty. 'And that brought everything down to earth. It just felt more real. It was an incredible experience.' Canty, already an experienced pop video director – he broke through with the promo for Hozier 's Take Me to Church – originally shot Christy as a short film. Did he always intend to expand it into a feature? 'We always wanted to write a feature, but we couldn't crack it,' he says. 'So we parked the feature, wrote the short, and then cast it. We came across the Kabin and all those kids and immediately said, 'We want to do more with them.'' He refers to the Kabin Studio , a not-for-profit music and creative hub that offers young Cork people a space to sing, create art and, crucially, develop hip-hop skills. Garry McCarthy, Kabin Studio's creative director – and producer of The Spark, the huge viral hit that the hub's Kabin Crew had with Lisdoonvarna Crew in the summer of 2024 – suggested to Canty that some of the kids might be interested in fleshing out the early, shorter version of Christy. 'They were all just unbelievable,' says the film-maker. 'All the kids pretty much came from this place. It was kind of surreal. So, we just leaned into it. After the short film, Covid happened. Before that I made a music video up there. I ended up doing acting workshops there during Covid. I just became involved and immersed in the world. It kept giving us more and more and more. It became the heartbeat of the film.' It spikes you up. There was a buzz, and I was able to start making commercials — Canty on the success of Take Me to Church The short film generated immediate buzz for Canty and his writer, Alan O'Gorman, after its premiere in 2019. 'In the film world and TV world, people were really losing their mind for it,' says the director. 'They could see the potential of something like that. So we had the script, and then we had the short film and it was easy for people to kind of visualise.' BBC Films soon came on board as producers, and the boys were away. Christy has much fun with the heavy vernacular of Knocknaheeny, in the northern reaches of Cork city. The dialogue is rich with local slang. One wonders what their international partners made of it all. 'We always thought that was going to be more of a challenge,' says Canty. 'But it was never really an issue. If anything the Brits loved that it was from Cork. I think they thought there was an exotic flavour to that! They were very good at listening and guiding us. They knew we were the people who could bring authenticity and specificity to that area, to that project.' Canty seems an impressively relaxed and confident character. Then again, he is no sort of novice. Over the past few years he has developed a strong reputation in the worlds of music videos and commercials. 'They've been my film school,' he says. The shift up seems to have come with his video for Take Me to Church, in 2013. That promo was instrumental in turning Hozier from a cult (if even that) into a genuine phenomenon. The director was confident a breakout was imminent even if those around him were not. 'I was told I was the first ever person to purchase Take Me to Church,' he says. 'It was available for free on Bandcamp – or name a price. And I was the first person to name a price, which was cool.' He remembers being surprised that those around him didn't grasp the song could be an international hit. 'I was, like, 'I just think this is bigger.' And they were, like, 'No, our plan is just to focus on Ireland for the next year.' Fair enough. I've seen big tracks go f**king nowhere. But they didn't think much more of it. They wouldn't admit that now. But then it blew up when it came out. And that changed very quickly.' The monochrome video went viral and ultimately registered two nominations at the MTV video awards. That is the sort of thing that gets noticed in the industry. 'It spikes you up,' he says. 'There was a buzz, and I was able to start making commercials. Then I got signed to a production company, which is cool. I made a few commercials, and the producer of one was able to fund my first short film: For You. I learned a lot from that.' Christy: Brendan Canty's debut feature film stars newcomer Danny Power He says working on commercials and videos doesn't just educate you about the technical stuff – it teaches you communication skills. 'Being able to handle the pressure – there's just so much money – and dealing with clients and stuff like that prepared me so well for dealing with the machine of a feature film,' he says. 'You're still answering to the BBC. You've got all those heads of departments. I remember when my execs in the BBC came in during pre-production, they were quite impressed by how in control I was of everything on a first feature. They said, 'Normally our first-time directors are freaking out right now.'' There were a lot of challenges. Christy features such experienced Cork actors as Chris Walley , from The Young Offenders, and Alison Oliver , from Saltburn, but most of the cast are nonprofessionals – a few rappers among them – encountered in and about the Kabin Studio. Power travelled an unlikely path towards the lead role. He was originally cast in a smaller part for the short, but the film-makers concluded their first choice for lead would not do. 'I told Danny, 'Well, look, you're Christy now.' And he was, like, 'I'll be whoever you want me to be.' I think me giving him the job empowered him. It unlocked something, because, from then on, he was a different actor. He just had the confidence. It was a crazy transformation. He's just a complete natural.' Some actors just have it. 'He's got so much range and he's got so much intelligence,' says Canty. 'He's kind of a freak and he was from the start – once he got that confidence from the short film. It's not like he's way better now.' [ Young Offenders star Chris Walley: 'What is it about Cork? I dunno. That's a dangerous question to ask a Cork person' Opens in new window ] It strikes me that putting five or six years between the short and the feature made the latter a very different sort of film. Power was a kid in the first piece. Now he is essentially a young man. 'There was a ticking clock on it, definitely,' says Canty. 'And I think we just got there in time. The BBC were saying, 'We're not green-lighting this just because your kids are getting older. You need to get it f**king right.' We got lucky.' Christy is just the sort of project that launches careers. Canty is considering a TV spin-off from the film. He is working on a feature with a new writer. He is also still processing what just happened. 'Once in a lifetime you come across the right group of people,' he says. 'It's something you can't force.' A wry smile as he contemplates the reality. 'I am not in a rush, but when I find whatever it is – or when it finds me – that will be sweet.' Christy is in cinemas from Friday, August 29th
Irish Times
21 hours ago
- Irish Times
Literary prize cancels annual award following backlash over inclusion of Irish author John Boyne
The Polari Prize, the annual literary prize for LGBTQ+ literature, has announced that it will 'pause' the prize this year following a controversy around the nomination of a book by Irish author John Boyne , who has previously expressed gender-critical views. After the longlist for this year's Book of the Year prize was published earlier this month and included Earth by John Boyne, more than half of this year's nominated authors (all of whom are born or work in the UK and Ireland) withdrew their books from the longlist and two of the prize's judges resigned . A petition calling on Polari to remove Boyne's book from its longlist was organised by authors Niamh Ní Mhaoileoin and Emma van Straaten and signed by over 800 writers and publishing industry workers. Boyne, who lives in Dublin, is best known for his best-selling 2006 novel The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas, which was turned into a film in 2008. The controversy that led to the cancellation of this year's prize stems largely from a birthday tribute Boyne wrote for JK Rowling in the Irish Independent in late July. In it, he referred to himself as a 'fellow Terf'. He called 'grown women' who support the rights of children to access gender-affirming healthcare and of transpeople to use single-sex spaces 'astonishingly complicit in their own erasure'. Terf is an acronym for trans-exclusionary radical feminist. READ MORE The Polari Prize released a statement today announcing its decision to 'pause' this year's prize. It was doing this, it added, while the prize 'increase[s] representation of trans and gender non-conforming judges on the panel for all awards and undertake[s] a governance and management review to include our aims and values and work to better support everyone within our LGBTQ+ Polari community'. I came very close to the edge this week because of the endless harassment at the hands of both strangers and fellow writers — John Boyne The organisation also extended its 'heartfelt apologies to everyone affected this year, for the disappointment and despair this has caused'. It stated that 'Polari is not and has never been a trans exclusionary organisation. These are not our values and we condemn all forms of transphobia'. The Polari Prize was founded in 2011 by journalist Paul Burston and the Polari Salon, which is a multi-award winning literary LGBTQ+ literary salon. Last Thursday, Boyne posted a statement to his Bluesky and X social media accounts where he said: 'I came very close to the edge this week because of the endless harassment at the hands of both strangers and fellow writers. I remained silent throughout but there's been a few moments where I thought it would be easier not to go on. There's really only so much abuse one person can take. However, I'm still here. Because I have too many books in me that I still want to write.' On August 7th, the Polari Prize released a statement where it defended its decision to include Boyne on its longlist for Book of the Year. It said: 'It is inevitable given the challenges we face and the diversity of the lived experience we now represent under the LGBTQ+ Polari umbrella, that even within our community, we can at times hold radically different positions on substantive issues. This is one of those times.' Today's statement on social media said the award 'was supposed to be a celebration of exceptional LGBTQ+ literature [but] has been overshadowed by hurt and anger, which has been painful and distressing for all concerned and we apologise to everyone who has been affected'. Polari added it would now 'explore discussions about the tensions between the claims of freedom of expression and the need to create inclusive and supportive spaces in a world hostile to our trans community members and our community at large'.
