logo
Not just a few bad apples: The Canadian Armed Forces has a nagging far-right problem

Not just a few bad apples: The Canadian Armed Forces has a nagging far-right problem

Canada News.Net13-07-2025
The Canadian Armed Forces (CAF) is making headlines. But not, as they probably hoped, for the renewed recruiting efforts they're about to launch. Instead, they are once again confounded by a far-right scandal.
The latest episode is the arrest of four CAF members and ex-members. Three of them have been charged with taking concrete steps to facilitate terrorist activity and possessing prohibited firearms. A fourth man was charged with possession and storage of prohibited firearms and devices.
The crew had allegedly been under surveillance by the federal government's Integrated National Security Enforcement Team since 2021, most likely when equipment, weapons and ammunition began to go missing from military installations. The weapons were finally seized in January 2024, some in the personal vehicle of one of the suspects, but the group remained free for another 18 months.
As is usual with these types of efforts, a certain degree of amateurism was present at multiple stages of the alleged scheme, which may have developed on the fly. The idea that a micro-militia might successfully seize and hold territory in Canada is far-fetched at best.
Recruitment efforts for the suspected mission, complete with propaganda and self-aggrandizing pictures of military training, took place on, you guessed it: Instagram. (We won't publish the name of the account.)
It might be pointed out that any large organization like the CAF inevitably represents a microcosm of society, meaning that it can't be expected to be free of various forms of undesirable behaviour, including political extremism. But this "rotten apple" theory of far-right extremism in the CAF falls somewhat short of explaining the situation.
First, the rotten apples seem too numerous. Just days before the recent arrests, the CAF announced on July 3 it was investigating the participation of other soldiers in a private Facebook page named the "Blue Hackle Mafia." The page disseminated openly racist, homophobic, misogynist and antisemitic content.
These events point to a phenomenon difficult to measure within western countries, even though it's very real. The penetration of ideas associated with the far right within the military and law enforcement agencies is currently happening. Whether more or less structured, the emergence of underground small groups are more or less ready to "take action."
Second, previous reports have identified a general laissez-faire approach within the CAF regarding far-right activities. In a 2022 independent report commissioned by the CAF, the presence of white supremacist and other far-right ideologies was identified not only as a growing problem for the Army, but also one that was not being addressed.
Similar conclusions were reached in the 1997 report on the behaviour of Canadian soldiers in Somalia, which had explicitly recommended that "the Canadian Forces establish regular liaison with anti-racist groups to obtain assistance in the conduct of appropriate cultural sensitivity training and to assist supervisors and commanders in identifying signs of racism and involvement with hate groups." In other words, neither the concern nor the awareness is news.
At the root of the problem is a peculiar affinity between most forms of far-right ideologies and military or paramilitary/policing organizations.
It's absurd to simply paint such organizations as inherently far right in their nature, of course. But strict authority structures and notions of defence, fellowship, honour - as well as the projection of power through physical strength and training and the accompanying symbolism of weapons, fatigues, uniforms and campaign-like deployments - are all very appealing to far-right extremists.
This nexus has been amply documented and leads to multiple practical implications: extremist groups trying to recruit active or retired soldiers; soldiers joining existing groups or setting up their own; veterans joining existing groups or creating their own, like the founders of Quebec's La Meute; professionally trained lone wolves, like Correy Hurren, who attempted to "arrest" Prime minister Justin Trudeau at Rideau Hall in 2020)
Members of extremist groups also routinely try to join the military to benefit from training, which elevates their standing within the group.
Military, former and active, and law enforcement members are to be found in multiple "militia" groups like the Three Percenters, the Proud Boys, the Oath Keepers, Diagolon and the Boogaloo movement, for instance. Some are overtly anti-government and/or anti-system, like the Veterans 4 Freedom or The Base.
It may sound strange to think of military personnel or veterans getting involved or creating an anti-government movement when they've served under the flag sometimes for decades. The apparent paradox quickly disappears once we understand the manifold individual motivations that underpin their actions.
They range from the feeling of having served a timourous government that failed to make proper use of the Armed Forces at its disposal. The absence of deployments to theatres of conflict also generates frustration among some in search of military adventure.
A lot of young men are quickly bored with exercises that never satisfy their expeditionary spirit. The role of camaraderie, of group dynamics based on mutual aid, honour and the presence of danger, as well as mental health issues, must not be overlooked. Not to mention the idea, strong in some units, of defending a singular idea of a "fatherland" endangered by government contempt and inaction.
What is striking in the light of the recent charges in Quebec is not so much the racist and anti-semitic ideological ideas allegedly held by the accused group members. It's the primacy given to a patriarchal ideology that explicitly targets women and gender. Fascination with Russia and the war in Ukraine waged by Vladimir Putin is also palpable.
In short, the CAF is still wrestling with far-right demons, though in a new context of social media acceleration and global loss of confidence in democratic institutions. The situation has a high potential to undermine confidence in Canada's Armed Forces at a time when geopolitical tensions are .
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Laws around intimate partner violence questioned in wake of Madisson Cobb's shooting death
Laws around intimate partner violence questioned in wake of Madisson Cobb's shooting death

CTV News

timean hour ago

  • CTV News

Laws around intimate partner violence questioned in wake of Madisson Cobb's shooting death

Advocates for victims of domestic violence are calling on Ottawa to create a new section of the Criminal Code to help prevent future tragedies. Advocates for victims of domestic violence are calling on Ottawa to create a new section of the Criminal Code to help prevent future tragedies. Looking to Ottawa for changes to domestic violence laws The recent shooting death of Madisson Cobb in a Haysboro parkade is sparking calls for change to laws relied upon by police in cases of domestic violence. Cobb's ex-boyfriend, Devon Bradley Malik, is charged with first-degree murder. Cobb had a restraining order against Malik at the time. 'She did everything she was supposed to do. She got out. She got the protection order; she got all of it, and it still wasn't enough,' said Jordan Guildford, founder of Gems for Gems, an organization committed to awareness and fundraising for victims. 'Our laws are just not strict enough.' An ambassador with her organization is arranging a rally at Municipal Plaza at noon on Saturday. 'The whole point of it is to raise awareness about the change that needs to happen,' said Guildford. Speakers include family of victims, police and domestic violence prevention advocates. 'Everyone can do something to end this cycle,' said Guildford. Malik's family members spoke to CTV News, saying he continued to obsess over and harass Cobb. It's alleged he was even GPS-tracking her car despite the court order to stay away. He was also charged with criminal harassment before her death. Officials with Sagesse Domestic Violence Prevention Society say criminal charges are more effective than restraining or protection orders. 'Often, when someone pursues a restraining order or protection order, they are pursuing it because it's their only avenue. But if there were coercive control legislation, there might be an avenue that actually allows the police to lay charges, which then puts that perpetrator into a different place in terms of how the system is going to watch them,' said Andrea Silverstone, Sagesse CEO. Canadian lawmakers were close to passing a law that would make 'coercive control' a criminal offence. Bill C-332 died when the election was called, and its fate is unknown until Parliament resumes in the fall. Police have announced a charge of first-degree murder in the death of Madisson Cobb. Madisson Cobb With Cobb's death now before the courts, Calgary police will not comment specifically on that case, but sent CTV News a statement, which read in part: 'While we are unable to comment on specific legislative proposals, we support any measures that enhance public safety and our ability to protect the community. Coercive control is a pattern of behaviour we frequently encounter in domestic violence cases. Additional legal tools that recognize and address this form of abuse could strengthen our efforts to support victims and hold offenders accountable.' In May, the province announced 'Alberta's 10-Year Strategy to End Gender-Based Violence,' outlining more than 100 targeted actions to prevent violence and support survivors. 'This includes significant investments in prevention, education and survivor services,' according to a statement sent to CTV News on Tuesday. It continued, 'Alberta is firmly committed to ending all forms of gender-based violence, and we recognize the growing concern around intimate partner violence (IPV). While some have called for IPV to be formally declared an epidemic, Alberta remains focused on leading with action rather than symbolic declarations to address the root causes and impacts of not only IPV but gender-based violence in its entirety.' The press secretary for Alberta's Ministry of Arts, Culture and Status of Women says an announcement is expected next week on the topic. Questions about strengthening surveillance of violators of restraining orders and protection orders were not answered in time for deadline.

Majority of B.C. residents want mandatory voting, survey finds
Majority of B.C. residents want mandatory voting, survey finds

CTV News

timean hour ago

  • CTV News

Majority of B.C. residents want mandatory voting, survey finds

An Elections B.C. sign is seen covered in rain on election day in Vancouver, B.C., Saturday, Oct. 19, 2024. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Ethan Cairns With voter turnout in B.C. on the decline for decades, last reaching 70 per cent 25 years ago, many in the province want to see action to turn that trend around. In fact, a poll out Thursday from Research Co. shows 61 per cent of those surveyed support mandatory voting, similar to the rules in place in Australia. Fifty-six per cent want elections returned to the month of May, and 54 per cent want public holidays on voting days. The same poll found 77 per cent want to see candidates requried to take part in at least one debate Meanwhile, 65 per cent of those surveyed said say they're satisfied with the current first-past-the-post system. 'This is actually very interesting because its coming at the heals of (one of) the closest elections we've had – and also a very close federal election,' said Research Co's Mario Canseco. Still nearly half say they'd actually prefer proportional representation – a system favoured in much of Europe, and one that would see province-wide vote percentages reflect the number of seats elected per party. UBC political scientist Stewart Prest said a change to proportional representation would blunt the concerns about vote splitting. Those worries can lead to 'some dysfunctional politics at times,' said Prest. 'Most spectacularly, we had the B.C. United simply give up,' he added, of the party's capitulation to the B.C. Conservatives last year. Proportional representation has been voted on in multiple referendums, and failed each time – including when then-premier John Horgan tried to make it sound hip in 2018, during a debate ahead of a referendum on the issue. 'If you were woke, you'd know pro rep is lit,' he famously quipped. As for expanding voting rights, only 37 per cent of those surveyed by Research Co. favour lowering the voting age like they did in the U.K. B.C. Green Party MLA Rob Botterell is on an all-party comittee looking into potential changes to improve the province's democratic system. 'When you look at whats happening south of the border, you say it's always the right time to be strengthening our institutions,' he said Thursday. Friday at 2 p.m. is the deadline for British Columbians who wish to submit written submissions to the committee. The committee's finding's will be reported to the legislature by this December. Research Co.'s survey was conducted online from July 13 to 15 among 814 adults in B.C., and the results were statistically weighted according to Canadian census figures. The results have a margin of error of plus or minus 3.1 percentage points, 19 times out of 20.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store