Nursing chief 'can't recall' seeing risk assessment that led to suspension of nurse who had complained about trans doctor using female changing room
Gillian Malone said she perceived that allegations about Ms Peggie confronting transgender medic Dr Beth Upton were 'unacceptable'.
Ms Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with Dr Upton at the Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy, Fife - where they both worked - on Christmas Eve 2023.
She was placed on special leave and then suspended after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about 'patient care'.
Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against Fife health board and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination and victimisation.
On Thursday, Ms Malone, told the tribunal she perceived a Datix report from January 3, 2024 regarding a conflict on Christmas Eve to be 'a discriminatory allegation'.
She said she had no role in the investigation, that she had never met Ms Peggie, and had no awareness of 'tension' between either the nurse or Dr Upton.
But she said she was aware of the nurse's concerns due to an email from August 2023.
Ms Malone told the tribunal the decision to suspend Ms Peggie was made following a risk assessment carried out by Esther Davidson, the nurse's line manager, however when asked if she had seen the risk assessment, she said: 'I can't recall.'
Giving evidence, she said: 'When I read content of Datix I thought the comments were concerning.
'At this time they were allegations, I did believe there was behaviour in there which could constitute bullying and harassment which were of concern and could require investigation.'
She added: 'Within original Datix there is a comment that there has been other work-related incidents.'
During cross-examination by Ms Peggie's barrister, Naomi Cunningham, Ms Malone - the most senior staff member to appear at the tribunal - said she agrees there are two biological sexes and that sex is a 'medically salient fact'.
Ms Cunningham read from an email sent by an HR worker, which said: 'We discussed suspension being last resort and options to mitigate risk...
'Esther felt it would be almost impossible to keep them apart so spoke to Gillian Malone... she believes there is a patient safety issue due to seriousness of the allegation and therefore wishes to suspend.'
Ms Cunningham said: 'It looks as though you were essentially behind the decision to suspend.'
Ms Malone said: 'It was Esther who completed the risk assessment.'
She was also asked about an email titled 'Formal Complaint' sent by Dr Upton on June 11.
Ms Cunningham then suggested the reason Ms Peggie was suspended was 'because she had told Dr Upton she wasn't happy about him using the women's changing room'.
Ms Cunningham said: 'That is the first documentary trace shown to the tribunal of the document 'Formal Complaint' which contains earlier incidents, being passed on to anyone from hospital management at all. Do you say that document was already in the hands of somebody, either as a printed out statement or sent as an email, before June 11?'
Ms Malone said: 'I'm not aware of that.'
Ms Cunningham said: 'Do you agree that if the tribunal finds that the reason for suspension was about the incident on Christmas Eve and wasn't about the prior allegations relating to patient care, that wasn't sufficient justification for suspension?'
Ms Malone said: 'The justification for suspension was based on a risk assessment which wasn't undertaken by me.'
Asked to identify what she perceived to be most unacceptable in the allegations made by Dr Upton, Ms Malone replied: 'I find it unacceptable that any colleague would confront another colleague in the manner described.'
She added that Ms Peggie should have raised concerns through her line manager rather than 'face-to-face on Christmas Eve'.
Ms Cunningham said: 'If the tribunal finds that the claimant didn't ask about his genes, would you say otherwise that was a point she was entitled to make, that he shouldn't be there? If she said to Dr Upton 'I don't think you should be here because you're a man', even if she didn't say anything about chromosomes?'
Ms Malone said: 'I think that was already raised back in August, I wouldn't have expected that to be face-to-face on Christmas Eve.'
Ms Cunningham added: 'I'm suggesting that by challenging Dr Upton's presence in the changing room she was complaining he was harassing her; it was her rejection of that harassment which gave rise also to the disciplinary and suspension, it was her refusal to tolerate what he was doing.'
Ms Malone said: 'It was the manner in which she raised it.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
38 minutes ago
- The Guardian
‘Horrendous blisters': Retired UK banker, 65, attempts to run 200 marathons in 200 days
The first fortnight was tough – terrible blisters, a flare of gout that needed a visit to A&E and the rapid realisation that running 200 marathons in 200 days around the coast of Great Britain would not be a walk in the park. But Steve James, a 65-year-old retired banker from Devon, has found his feet, and on Thursday reached the halfway mark – an average of 100 marathons in 100 days. 'In those first two weeks I was thinking: 'What have I done?'' James said. 'I've been running for 50 years and never get blisters – but I had horrendous ones for the first 10 days. My feet felt like they had been put in a vice and squeezed. The gout was a bit of curveball but the hospital prescribed some stuff and it went away. Now I feel fine.' James's progress along the coastlines of England, Wales and Scotland is being tracked by experts from the University of Exeter, who are keen to find out the effects of such an extreme challenge on an older person. He set off from Topsham, on the south coast of Devon, in April and headed to Kent in south-east England. He then ran north to John o'Groats in north-east Scotland and is on the Scottish west coast steadily working his way south. There is no set route. He has a plan but adapts and changes it. 'If you're in Devon and Cornwall and Wales, there is a clearly defined coast path. In Scotland there's virtually no coast path, so you're carving out your own routes. I've been on the Isle of Mull, which was never in the original itinerary, but I hopped on and off and it worked.' The challenge is to do, on average, a marathon every day. Some days, depending on where the accommodation is, it might be a bit less; others a bit more, and he is not trying to clock good marathon times. 'I am not flat out every day. There's a lot of walking involved, a bit of jogging, a bit of running – a real mix. And I'm stopping a couple of times each day just to sort of rest up, if you like, have a coffee, a cake or whatever, and then get going again.' 'It's all about routine,' said James, who is from Devon and trained for his challenge on Dartmoor. 'It's all about getting up at the same time, leaving at the same time; it's a bit like going to work. I love the physical challenge, the idea of stretching myself physically. I'm not especially talented at things – you wouldn't want to play golf with me, you wouldn't want me on your football team. But I can keep going.' He is not following the sort of diet an elite athlete might adopt. When the Guardian spoke to him, James had eaten cereal, a bacon baguette, cake and was planning fish and chips for dinner, washed down with a couple of pints. The Exeter researchers assessed James before his departure and he sends data daily for them to analyse. They are studying his calorie intake, oxygen levels and muscle measurements to examine the effect of the challenge. He has lost about 10kg but the team has seen no ill-effects to his health. Freyja Haigh, a nutritional physiology researcher at the University of Exeter, said: 'Steve gives us a real insight into how this type of endurance impacts the body of an older person. We're unsure at the moment if Steve's weight loss is from fat or muscle mass.' James, who is raising money for Cancer Research UK and the Scouts, passes the time by listening to music and is also learning Cymraeg – Welsh. By the time he gets to Wales, he hopes to be able to order a pint in the language. He thinks the most difficult stretch physically will be the north coasts of Devon and Cornwall. 'I'm kind of hoping by then my body's completely acclimatised and I'll be able to cope with that.'
Times
9 hours ago
- Times
Nurse ‘questioned the being' of trans doctor, tribunal told
A veteran nurse 'questioned the being' of a transgender doctor by claiming they had no right to use female changing rooms, a senior NHS consultant had claimed. Kate Searle maintained that Beth Upton had been subjected to a 'hate incident' in a confrontation on Christmas Eve 2023, in which Sandie Peggie told the biologically male doctor, who identifies as female, they should not be in women's facilities. The senior clinician broke down in tears during her second day of giving evidence to Peggie's tribunal, in which the nurse is claiming she faced discrimination and harassment by NHS Fife and Upton as result of having to share female changing facilities with a colleague she considers male. On occasions, Searle contradicted the evidence other senior NHS Fife staff had given to the tribunal. She said she could 'not recall' lobbying against Peggie's return to work after a period of suspension.
The Independent
12 hours ago
- The Independent
Consultant admits ‘flagrant breach of confidentiality' in Peggie gender dispute
A consultant sobbed as she spoke about her involvement in a dispute between a transgender doctor and a gender-critical nurse – as well as admitting a 'flagrant breach of confidentiality', a tribunal heard. Sandie Peggie was suspended after she complained about having to share a changing room with transgender medic Dr Beth Upton at Victoria Hospital, Kirkcaldy, Fife, on Christmas Eve 2023. She was placed on special leave after Dr Upton made an allegation of bullying and harassment and cited concerns about 'patient care'. Ms Peggie has lodged a claim against NHS Fife and Dr Upton, citing the Equality Act 2010, including sexual harassment; harassment related to a protected belief; indirect discrimination; and victimisation. On Wednesday, consultant Dr Kate Searle admitted she sought out a witness to patient safety allegations made by Dr Upton, which occurred previously in December 2023 but were unreported. Dr Searle sobbed when the woman was mentioned and alleged that the healthcare worker 'did not want to be involved in this for fear that, as a mixed race person, she feared Ms Peggie's views about her race would affect her going forward working in our department with Ms Peggie'. During cross-examination by Ms Peggie's barrister, Naomi Cunningham, Dr Searle admitted she had not been subject to disciplinary proceedings for it. Dr Searle agreed that the witness was 'the only person who was likely to be able to shed light on Dr Upton's claim that Ms Peggie refused to engage', in a resuscitation unit, however, she argued with Ms Cunningham about the woman's recollection of the incident. Ms Cunningham said the healthcare worker 'gave a clear answer that factually contradicted Dr Upton, as she said she recalled a conversation between Beth and Sandie, although couldn't recall details', during an internal probe, the tribunal heard. However, Dr Searle argued three times about the witness's recollection and concluded that the healthcare worker was 'contradicting herself', and said twice that she could not 'recall when it happened'. She said she 'couldn't recall' when she spoke to the healthcare worker, and admitted sending an email to 19 consultants on December 29 2023, describing the comments allegedly made by Ms Peggie as 'questioning her (Dr Upton's) whole being' the tribunal heard. Ms Cunningham asked if the doctor got in touch with the investigation manager to 'confess that you had left confidentiality in ruins' with an email to 19 consultants sent on December 29 2023, regarding the dispute which offered 'support' to Dr Upton and to 'condemn the actions' of Ms Peggie. Dr Searle said: 'I did not.' She denied attempting to 'bend the rules and transgress boundaries' by accompanying the junior doctor to an investigation meeting, and was accused by Ms Cunningham of 'turning up the temperature and increasing the emotional heat of the Datix report', the tribunal heard. Datix is a system used in healthcare settings to report incidents and manage risk, with a view to improving care. Dr Searle said: 'I reported it at time as I saw fit.' Ms Cunningham said: 'If the normal rules had been followed you wouldn't have been allowed to be present for Dr Upton's interview.' It was put to her that approaching a witness was a 'flagrant breach' of confidentiality. Dr Searle said: 'In hindsight, yes.' The barrister said priorities were 'surprising', and added: 'It seems you were more shocked by Sandie's refusal to play along with the pretence Dr Upton is a woman than about allegations of abandoning patients in resuscitation.' Dr Searle said: 'We didn't initially see they were big patient safety issues but, once it was all reported, we see they are.' She admitted adding the word 'rapist' to a Datix report although Dr Upton's account referred to a comment about prisons, the tribunal heard. Ms Cunningham said: 'You have added the word 'rapist' to the Datix haven't you?' Dr Searle said: 'What makes that comment so offensive and intimidating is the inference it is like Isla Bryson who is convicted male rapist, which is why its important to mention that on Datix.' She told the tribunal: 'I would not have known what sex Dr Upton was assigned at birth.' The consultant said she believed Ms Peggie had been cleared during a disciplinary 'due to lack of evidence', and 'believed and still do, that this was a hate incident', the tribunal heard. The tribunal continues.
