NSFAS Crisis to Board Scandals: 5 reasons SASCO wants Nkabane out
Sasco cited multiple failures under Nkabane's leadership, including severe delays in NSFAS disbursements, flawed board appointments, chronic underfunding of institutions, and the growing commodification of education.
"It is the direct result of poor governance by the Department of Higher Education and Training and the opportunistic, malicious, and poor bourgeoisie agenda by the university and college management.''
Kamatshe said the crisis facing students today is not incidental.
As previously reported by IOL, Nkabane has faced criticism following allegations of corruption and for allegedly misleading Parliament about the illegal appointment of the SETA board, including false details about the appointment process and panel composition.
Speaking at the ANC's Luthuli House on Sunday, Sasco president Alungile Kamtshe said, 'We contend that DHET, led by Minister Nobuhle Nkabane, within the government of national unity, has consistently failed to deliver on its most basic responsibilities.'
The South African Students Congress (SASCO) has called for the immediate removal of Higher Education Minister Nobuhle Nkabane , accusing her and the Department of Higher Education and Training (DHET) of catastrophic governance failures that are driving the higher education sector into crisis.
Sasco accused the Nkabane and her department of gross negligence, illegal conduct, and structural violence that disproportionately harms black, poor, and working-class students.
'We are left with no choice but to take a drastic stance in defence of the education sector that has been built through the blood, sweat and tears of the students and the public servants for over the centuries.''
Here are the five main reasons SASCO believes Minister Nkabane must go:
1. Illegal Appointment of the NSFAS Board
SASCO asserts that the current NSFAS board was illegally appointed, violating Section 5 of the NSFAS Act of 1999, which mandates that three out of thirteen board members must be nominated by national student organisations. The absence of these student-nominated representatives, SASCO argues, renders the board illegitimate and its decisions null.
'The Minister has failed in her duty relating to the appointment of the NSFAS board.To this extent, we declare that that board is illegal,'' said Kamtshe.
SASCO plans to take legal action to compel the Minister to comply with the law.
2. Delays in NSFAS Allowances & Student Exclusion
SASCO slammed the catastrophic delays in NSFAS disbursements, saying that thousands of students are still without their allowances midway through the academic year. Many are reportedly homeless, sleeping in libraries, toilets, or on the streets, while institutions issue exclusion letters.
'This is not just bureaucratic incompetence. It is structural violence. Institutions are merciless and have been dishing out exclusion letters to add insult to injury.'
They demand the immediate payment of all allowances by the end of the current recess, and an end to financial, academic, and accommodation-based exclusions,particularly targeting vulnerable first-year students.
3. Mishandling of SETA Board
SASCO alleges the appointment of Sector Education and Training Authority (SETA) boards and Community Higher Education Planning Committees (CHPCs) was riddled with secrecy, misrepresentation, and possible dishonesty to Parliament.
'The Minister may have lied to the Portfolio Committee. The process shows a pure disregard for the citizens of this country.'
They warned that the delay in appointments has created a vacuum, giving executives unchecked power due to the absence of board oversight. SASCO demands that the process to appoint new boards to be restarted immediately and be completed by August 1.
4. Negligence Over Student Housing & the Death of Sisonke
The tragic death of Sisonke, a student at Walter Sisulu University, is central to SASCO's call for accountability. SASCO accuses the Minister's office of spreading misinformation, claiming Sisonke was not a student, only for the claim to be proven false.
'The officials that publicly lied, continue to earn their salaries. The death of Sisonke was in vain.'
SASCO demands justice for Sisonke, and calls for NSFAS to accredit institutionally owned residences, especially in historically disadvantaged universities where students live in unsafe and inhumane conditions.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
4 days ago
- The Citizen
35 DHET employees suspended for sexual harassment and theft
Over the past five financial years, the department suspended 157 employees in total. The department of higher education and training (DHET) is grappling with a personnel crisis, with 56 employees currently suspended on various charges ranging from sexual harassment to fraud. Rise Mzansi MP Songezo Siphiwo Zibi questioned former minister of higher education and training Nobuhle Nkabane about the suspensions. Zibi also questioned the DHET having the second most number of suspended employees among all national government departments as of 31 December 2024. Zibi initially asked about 35 employees who were put on suspension with full pay as at 31 January this year. However, while only providing the breakdown for the 35, the department recently also revealed that in the 2024/25 year, 56 employees in total were suspended. Scale of the suspension crisis The inquiry revealed serious misconduct allegations across multiple salary levels and demographics in the DHET. The suspended employees face various charges including sexual harassment, theft, fraud, assault and intimidation. Several cases involve allegations against students, highlighting concerns about the safety of the learning environment. ALSO READ: Ramaphosa fires Nobuhle Nkabane, appoints new higher education minister Financial impact The suspensions are costing taxpayers significantly. Monthly salaries for the 35 suspended employees range from R11 961 to R73 126, with most earning between R20 000 and R40 000 per month. Over the past five financial years, the department suspended 157 employees in total. The financial cost reached R31.7 million in salaries paid during this period. Individual cases and charges Among the most serious cases are multiple sexual harassment allegations. The eight employees facing these charges are: Ndlovu SP who earns R32 783.50, Garside RPK, who faces 'allegations of sexual harassment against students in exchange for marks' and earns R30 274.50 monthly while suspended. Mapadimeng J earning R25 663.87; Vilana M earning R40,675 87; Nkosi SM earning R21 466.00; Maneli GM earning R43 469.25; Mahlangu TM earning R24 348.0;, and Mienies SC earning R22 334.00. Several employees face fraud charges related to trade certifications. Thobejane SN and Mokoena JP both face 'allegations of fraud in processing trade certifications' and earn R23 626 and R18 579.75 respectively. Theft allegations feature prominently. Mdumbe PZ, Rigala B and Mbengo G all face theft charges. However, Rigala B and Mbengo G had 'no adverse findings' against them despite the allegations. ALSO READ: Five things you need to know about the new higher education minister Buti Manamela Timeline concerns The duration of disciplinary processes varies significantly. Some cases have been finalised, while others remain pending. Employee Vilana M's case status is 'unclear as the chairperson is on sick leave', despite earning R40 675.87 monthly. The department's data shows average resolution times have improved dramatically. In 2020/2021, cases took an average of 137.6 days to conclude. By 2024/2025, this dropped to 14.4 days on average. ALSO READ: Outa concerned about new higher education minister Five-year suspension pattern The suspension crisis has escalated over recent years. In 2020/2021, seven employees were suspended at a cost of R6.01 million. This number peaked at 56 suspensions in 2024/2025, costing R6.07 million. The 2022/2023 financial year saw the highest costs, with R10.55 million paid to 33 suspended employees. The 2023/2024 period had the most suspensions at 48 employees, costing R7.65 million. Departmental response to suspensions Nkabane's former office acknowledged the severity of the situation. According to the parliamentary reply, 'employees were placed on precautionary suspension due to various allegations of serious misconduct, ranging from sexual harassment and theft'. The department attributes prolonged suspensions to several factors. These include 'the complexity and severity of the allegation, sophisticated act of misconduct, shortage of investigators and the safety of witnesses'. ALSO READ: Parliament concludes Seta panel never existed Demographic breakdown The suspended employees span various salary levels from Post Level 1 (PL1), referring to the entry-level position for teachers to SL14. The majority are classified as black males and females, with some coloured and white employees also suspended. Higher-level employees face more complex charges. Ngubelanga LL, at salary level 14 earning R72 878.10, faces supply chain management irregularities. Muswaba MM, at level 13 earning R73 126.73, faces misconduct allegations under Section 188A procedures. Ongoing investigations and suspension cases breakdown Of the 35 suspended employees, 26 cases have been finalised, while eight remain pending disciplinary hearings. One employee resigned during the process and two cases resulted in no adverse findings despite initial allegations. Sexual harassment represents the most common charge, with eight employees suspended for various forms of harassment. Theft allegations account for three suspensions, while fraud in processing trade certifications led to two suspensions. Other charges include 3 cases of improper conduct, 2 cases each of assault and sabotage allegations, and individual cases of gross negligence, intimidation, falsifying documents, conflict of interest, and unauthorised possession of equipment. Several cases remain unresolved. Disciplinary hearings for multiple employees are scheduled to conclude by various dates through September 2025. Some employees await final determinations. READ NEXT: R10k just to show up: Fear of 'Nkabane 2.0' as ANC Youth League leaders get hospital board positions
TimesLIVE
5 days ago
- TimesLIVE
Mandela Day is for giving back — not just for 67 minutes
In 1970 Robert Greenleaf released an essay entitled, 'The Servant as a Leader'. Greenleaf could hardly have expected to start a revolution in the then fledgling leadership discipline. Of particular interest and intrigue was that Greenleaf had used what ought to have been contradictory terms, namely 'servant' and 'leader' to describe a type of leader. In a nutshell, he argued that the best leaders were those who saw their main task as serving those they had been tasked to lead. This was contrary to the dominant idea at the time that those who lead should lord it over those in their charge. As we this month commemorate Nelson Mandela International Day, or Mandela Day as many of us call it, we are once again reminded of the importance of leaders who place their followers first in the quest to transform the institutions they lead. Former president Mandela may have never described himself in the terms articulated by Greenleaf. Still, it is commonly understood that Mandela personified what it means to dedicate one's life to serving one's people. In fact, in his first public address after being released from prison in 1990, he said: 'I stand here before you not as a prophet but as a humble servant of you, the people.' The number 67 was chosen to reflect the number of years former President Mandela spent in public life and includes the years he was imprisoned as well as his tenure as South Africa's first democratically elected president. It was for this attitude that the UN in 2009 declared Madiba's birthday, July 18, as Nelson Mandela International Day and encouraged everyone to dedicate at least 67 minutes of their time and lives to helping those who needed a hand, and to do so without expecting anything in return. The number 67 was chosen to reflect the number of years former President Mandela spent in public life and includes the years he was imprisoned as well as his tenure as South Africa's first democratically elected president. As has been tradition for the last 15 years, many South African individuals and organisations will identify and choose an institution they can dedicate their 67 minutes of service to, and this is to be strongly encouraged. This year's Mandela Day Theme, 'It is still in our hands to combat poverty and inequality', is consistent with the three priorities of the government of national unity (GNU). The education sector, especially the higher education and training sector, is well placed to play an active role in combating poverty and inequality. Mandela himself reminded us that 'education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world'. As someone with executive oversight over the department of higher education and training (DHET) as well as its entities, I see this potential to change the world every day. Education is never an end but rather a means to an end, which is to meaningfully integrate the educated person into the economy and improve their lives and those of their loved ones. I am also acutely aware of the challenges the sector faces. Some of the challenges are systemic in nature and will not be overcome overnight. These include the gaps in funding for tuition and for the provision of adequate bed space for students. We also have the real challenge that some of our Sector Education and Training Authorities (Setas) being more likely to make news for poor governance and unethical behaviour than for having the positive impact in combating poverty and inequality. The two reports released by the commission for gender equality (CGE) last year further highlighted the prevalence of sexual harassment and GBV in the post-school education and training (PSET) system. While all the above-mentioned are equally urgent, if I were to single out another area of our PSET system that needs more urgent attention than others, it would be the Community Education and Training (CET) colleges. These are offshoots of the former Adult Basic Education and Training (Abet) centres. CET students best embody what Madiba said about education having the potential to change the world. Yet they remain what I often refer to as the 'stepchild of the stepchild' of the higher education sector. They receive about 2% of the DHET total budget to share across 200 community learning centres and their nearly 1,600 satellite centres where teaching and learning take place. What is more concerning is that bulk of their annual funding goes to salaries, leaving very little for other needs such as infrastructure. Many CET colleges are hosted in schools owned by the department of basic education because they do not have facilities of their own. This is itself a disincentive for some individuals who do not want to be seen studying in facilities designed for younger children. Another challenge for students attending CETs is that, unlike their counterparts in the PSET system, they do not receive any aid from the National Student Financial Assistance Scheme (NSFAS). Consequently, food insecurity is high and students often choose to forego classes if this clashes with an opportunity to earn a day's wage that can keep hunger at bay. Where food insecurity is high, there tends to be a shortage of hygiene products. This is why I have decided to give my 67 minutes to one of these colleges in Kariega, Eastern Cape that so urgently need our support. That said, we cannot afford to throw our hands up in despair. It will be unMandela-like to do so. Madiba's life is an example of never giving up to the challenges of the day, no matter how insurmountable they might be. As he famously said, 'it always seems impossible until it's done'. The PSET system desperately needs servant leaders. We need men and women who properly appreciate that the education enterprise cannot succeed unless there is collaboration with all areas of society, including the private sector. For it to be done, the PSET sector needs partners. We need leaders like Mandela in local government institutions, traditional leadership authorities, business and non-governmental organisations to each identify how they too can serve in the effort to combat poverty and inequality. Equally, we need leaders within the sector who have the foresight and are open to partnerships and deliberately seek these out to enhance what their own organisations can offer to their stakeholders and to society at large. With more than 100 entities under the DHET ambit and tens of thousands of students in our various institutions of higher education, it can be said with the utmost humility that the sector is too big to fail. On the flipside, the sector's success will have an impact in every home, workplace and in our economy. With our service, we can ensure that we are the side of making the sector succeed.
The Citizen
28-07-2025
- The Citizen
Nsfas backs new Higher Education leadership, reaffirms support
Nsfas reiterated its central role in the national project to transform higher education through inclusive policy and funding reform. The National Student Financial Aid Scheme (Nsfas) has pledged its full support for newly appointed Minister of Higher Education and Training Buti Manamela, and Deputy Minister Dr Nomusa Dube-Ncube. Nsfas reaffirmed its commitment to transforming South Africa's higher education sector. The Nsfas board congratulated both leaders following their appointment by President Cyril Ramaphosa last week, describing the move as an opportunity to drive innovation and improve access to quality education for students across the country. 'The board is confident that Minister Manamela's leadership will inspire ongoing progress and innovation within the sector, thereby promoting greater access and success for South Africa's students,' Nsfas said in a statement. Confidence in new leadership Manamela, who previously served as deputy minister in the same department during the sixth administration, replaces Dr Nobuhle Nkabane. Dube-Ncube, a seasoned public servant and former KwaZulu-Natal premier, was appointed in terms of section 93(b) of the constitution. Nsfas lauded the experience both bring to the ministry, particularly Dube-Ncube's track record in governance. 'Her unwavering dedication will undoubtedly enhance the ministry's efforts to support learners and institutions nationwide,' the board stated. The swearing-in ceremony for the two leaders took place at Tuynhuys in Cape Town, officiated by President Ramaphosa and Deputy President Paul Mashatile. ALSO READ: Five things you need to know about the new higher education minister Buti Manamela Pushing forward with innovation and inclusion Nsfas reiterated its central role in the national project to transform higher education through inclusive policy and funding reform. 'Nsfas remains dedicated to supporting the ministry's vision and government's vision of transforming higher education through innovative funding solutions and inclusive policies,' it said. The scheme said it looks forward to working closely with both Manamela and Dube-Ncube. 'We look forward to collaborating with the minister to advance accessible, high-quality higher education for all South Africans.' The board's remarks come at a time when the funding model and operations of Nsfas are under scrutiny, making its alignment with the new leadership critical for rebuilding trust and improving delivery. NOW READ: Ramaphosa fires Nobuhle Nkabane, appoints new higher education minister
