Britain reassesses 'flawed' domestic abuse risk tool
Pauline Jones, mother of Bethany Fields, holds a photo of her late daughter, who was killed by an intimate partner, at Horsforth Hall Park in Leeds, Britain, August 7, 2025. REUTERS/Sam Tabahriti
LONDON - A month before she was stabbed to death by her ex-boyfriend, Bethany Fields walked into a police station in northern England to report his abusive and controlling behaviour. He had threatened to kill her, but she was not assessed as high risk.
Fields is among many domestic abuse victims failed by risk assessments based on a form known as DASH used by Britain's overstretched police forces, social workers and others for more than 15 years, according to two academic studies, several women's charities and victims' relatives.
"To get that form right literally means the difference between life and death," said Bethany's mother, Pauline Jones.
The charity which co-developed the form, SafeLives, has now been tasked by the government with a project which its CEO Ellen Miller described as examining the way to see "how a review could work through, how a bigger rewrite could happen".
"We know so much more now, that it needs to evolve, it needs to change," Miller said, confirming a project that is yet to be publicly announced.
DASH had saved many lives, she said, adding that it should be rewritten rather than replaced and that it was up to police to use it properly.
"The problem is not the DASH. The problem is police officers' values and behaviours," she said.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Business Singapore banks face headwinds in rest of 2025, but DBS is pulling ahead: Analysts
Asia Mixed reactions among Malaysia drivers on S'pore move to clamp down on illegal ride-hailing services
Asia Typhoon Podul slams into southern Taiwan; hundreds of flights cancelled
Business Singtel Q1 profit soars 317.4% to $2.9 billion on exceptional gains of $2.2 billion
Asia Diamonds, watches and shoes: Luxury items at heart of probe into South Korea's former first lady
Singapore Yishun man admits to making etomidate-laced pods for vaporisers; first Kpod case conviction
Sport New Hui Fen becomes first Singaporean bowler to win PWBA Tour Player of the Year
Singapore SG60: Many hands behind Singapore's success story
A report by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) into Fields' murder, published online in April this year, said the officer conducting the assessment was inexperienced to undertake such a sensitive assignment and lacked supervision; it also questioned the DASH form.
Those filling in the DASH (Domestic Abuse, Stalking and Honour-Based Violence Assessment) tick: "yes", "no", or "don't know" - sometimes labelled "other" - in response to questions about possible abuse.
The IOPC said the third option reduced the chances of officers pinning down a potential yes. That in turn reduces the chances of getting enough ticks for the assessment of high risk that triggers a referral for extra support.
Marsha Scott, chief executive of Scottish Women's Aid, said the DASH tool was "deeply flawed".
Researchers from the Universities of Manchester and Seville found the DASH "performs poorly at identifying high-risk victims", with 96.3% of such cases being wrongly assessed as standard (low) or medium risk in their study of 350,000 incidents logged by an unnamed major UK police force.
SafeLives did not respond to a request for comment on the statistic, published in Madrid-based journal Psychosocial Intervention in 2022.
The British system is not the only one to come under scrutiny. Spain's interior ministry said in January it had updated its gender violence management system to make it more effective; in June, it said British officials had visited to find out more.
Britain's interior ministry did not respond to a request for comment for this article. It has said reducing violence against women and girls is a priority and that it plans to publish a new strategy on the issue.
MISTAKES
In the year ending March 2024, there were 108 domestic homicides, of which 83 of the victims were female.
Reuters was not able to establish how many of those deaths followed DASH risk assessments or what those had concluded but found other deaths in which an assessment had been undertaken.
Seventeen weeks pregnant, Fawziyah Javed was pushed to her death from the top of the Arthur's Seat hill in Edinburgh in 2021. Her mother, Yasmin Javed, told Reuters her daughter had reported her husband's violent and controlling behaviour to the police.
Officers told her she was medium risk and despite the risk factor of being pregnant and a visit from police six days before she died, she was never referred for high risk support, her mother said, adding: "These mistakes are costing lives."
Contacted for comment, police said only that the IOPC is still investigating the force's response.
Both Javed's husband and Fields' ex-partner were convicted of killing them.
When asked about fatalities after DASH assessments, Miller said: "I think the DASH could always be better," adding that it was up to police to safeguard people from the risk of death in their recruitment and training.
Her hope, she said, was that a "refreshed DASH" would be used adequately in every case.
OTHER OPTIONS
The interior ministry has asked other charities to help SafeLives "bring together insights" into the systems for assessing and managing risk in the country, a letter from the ministry to one of them who asked to remain anonymous showed.
Several charities contacted by Reuters said they feared the project would not go far enough.
Ngozi Fulani, CEO of Sistah Space, a charity supporting victims from African and Caribbean heritage, said the DASH may not be effective for many in those communities, due to mistrust of police linked to institutional racism.
"They chose to leave us out, that speaks for itself," she said, referring to the fact they have so far not been asked to contribute to the project.
The Spanish police and some organisations are using new technology to assess future risk: Berlin-based startup Frontline has a machine learning risk assessment and British data scientist and former police officer Tori Olphin has created an algorithmic model to predict future harm, for example.
The College of Policing, a professional body for police in England and Wales, has developed its own tool, DARA, with Cardiff University Professor Amanda Robinson, to address what she says are some of DASH's flaws, particularly around coercive control, which only became a criminal offence there in 2015.
A police representative said they would assess all the available tools.
"Police officers must be supported with the right training and tools to identify offences and protect victims," said Assistant Chief Constable Claire Bell, Deputy Director of the National Centre for Violence Against Women and Girls and Public Protection. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
10 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Trump ally Erik Prince plans to keep personnel in Haiti for 10 years to fight gangs and collect taxes
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox The prominent Donald Trump supporter and private security executive Erik Prince says he has a 10-year deal with Haiti to fight the country's criminal gangs, and then take a role in restoring the country's tax-collection system. In an interview with Reuters, Prince said his company, Vectus Global, would be involved in designing and implementing a program to tax goods imported across Haiti's border with the Dominican Republic once the security situation is stabilized. He said he expected to wrestle control of major roads and territories from the gangs in about a year. 'One key measure of success for me will be when you can drive from Port-au-Prince to Cap Haitian in a thin-skinned vehicle and not be stopped by gangs,' Prince said in the interview. Prince would not comment about how much the Haitian government would pay Vectus Global, nor how much tax he expects to collect in Haiti. The new president of the transitional council, Laurent Saint-Cyr, who was inaugurated on August 7 as part of a planned rotation of council leaders, did not respond to requests for comment. Haiti's former council president and prime minister also did not respond to requests for comment. Vectus began operating in Haiti in March, deploying mainly drones in coordination with a task force led by the prime minister, but the long-term engagement and the involvement in tax collection have not been previously reported. A person familiar with the company's operations in Haiti told Reuters that Vectus would intensify its fight against the criminal gangs that control large swathes of Haiti in the coming weeks in coordination with the Haitian police, deploying several hundred fighters from the United States, Europe and El Salvador who are trained as snipers and specialists in intelligence and communications, as well as helicopters and boats. Vectus's force includes some French and Creole speakers, the person said. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Over 100 people being investigated for vape offences, say MOH and HSA Singapore Bukit Merah fire: Residents relocated as town council carries out restoration works Singapore askST: What to do in the event of a fire at home Singapore Jalan Bukit Merah fire: PMD battery could have started fatal blaze, says SCDF Singapore askST: What are the fire safety rules for PMDs? Asia AirAsia flight from KL to Incheon lands at wrong airport in South Korea Asia India and China work to improve ties amid Trump's unpredictability Singapore From quiet introvert to self-confident student: How this vulnerable, shy teen gets help to develop and discover her strength Prince, a former U.S. Navy Seal, founded the Blackwater military security firm in 1997. He sold the company in 2010 after Blackwater employees were convicted of unlawfully killing 14 unarmed civilians while escorting a U.S. embassy convoy in Baghdad's Nisour Square. The men were pardoned by Trump during his first term in the White House. EXPANDING ROLE Since Trump's return to the White House, Prince has advised Ecuador on how to fight criminal gangs and struck a deal with the Democratic Republic of Congo to help secure and tax its mineral wealth. 'It's hard to imagine them operating without the consent of the Trump administration,' said Romain Le Cour Grandmaison, head of the Haiti program at Geneva-based Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime. When asked for comment about Le Cour Grandmaison's assertion, a State Department spokesperson said it has not hired Prince or his company for any work in Haiti. A senior White House official said: "The U.S. government has no involvement with the private military contractor hired by the Haitian government. We are not funding this contract or exercising any oversight.' It's unclear whether Prince's contract would be affected by the change of leadership in Haiti earlier this month. In an August 7 televised address, Saint-Cyr said he welcomed more international support to fight the gangs. 'I am inviting all the international partners to increase their support, send more soldiers, provide more training," he said. "Help us with a more robust international force.' The crisis in Haiti has worsened in recent years, as armed gangs gained territory and attacked hospitals, police stations and prisons, taking control of strategic transport routes and extorting funds from the population. Rights groups accuse the gangs of massacres, rapes, kidnappings and arson. About half the population is food-insecure and over 8,000 people in displacement camps face famine-level hunger. Haiti used to collect half of its tax revenue at the border with the Dominican Republic, but gang control of key transport routes has crippled trade and cut off state income, a report commissioned last year by Haiti's government and several multilateral organizations found. This has undermined the government's ability to respond to the crisis or deliver basic services, the report said. The Dominican Republic is a key source of grains, flour, milk, water and other food staples for Haiti, according to customs data. Haiti also relies on imports from the Dominican Republic for textiles, consumer goods, and medical supplies. Security contractors working in Haiti have faced challenges operating in a country with entrenched links between the gangs, local police and some factions of the government. Earlier this year, a team from American security firm Studebaker Defense abandoned their mission in Haiti after two of their members were abducted, likely due to corrupt police officials, the New York Times reported. Mounir Mahmalat, who serves as a country coordinator of the World Bank's Fragility, Conflict and Violence Group, said that it was virtually impossible to ensure the safe transport of goods or the security of people working in Port-au-Prince. Other security firms working in Haiti have raised questions about how Vectus would hold onto cleared gang territory as well as the wisdom of channelling resources to private security firms instead of the country's own security forces. "Resorting to private military companies cannot be seen as a solution to insecurity in Haiti,' said Gedeon Jean, head of Haiti's Center for Human Rights Analysis and Research. 'The use of private companies has often resulted in human rights violations.' While a private force could help police restore security, Jean warned against large spending on a foreign company while Haiti's own security forces lack funds and equipment. REUTERS
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Poland foils attack on city's water system, amid ‘ongoing' cyber war with Russia
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Polish Deputy Prime Minister Krzysztof Gawkowski indirectly blamed Russia for the attack in a post on X. WARSAW - Poland foiled a cyberattack against the water and sewage system of a 'large city', Deputy Prime Minister Krzysztof Gawkowski said on Aug 14, adding that a cyber war with Russia was 'ongoing'. 'At the last minute, we managed to ensure that when the attack began, our (security) services found out about it and we shut everything down. We managed to mitigate it,' Mr Gawkowski told web portal speaking of the attack which took place on Aug 13. 'Yesterday, it was possible to end up in a situation in which one of the larger cities would have been left without water,' he added, refusing to name the city in question in order not to 'stir up people's emotions'. Mr Gawkowski, who is also the minister of digital affairs, did not indicate who might be the perpetrators of the attack, but in a post on X he referred to Russian hostility. 'No Russian planes will fly into Warsaw nor will tanks roll in – instead, their digital counterparts will appear,' he wrote. 'The first stage of such an attack may involve attempts to cut us off from water, gas and electricity, paralyse communications or halt logistics,' he added. According to Mr Gawkowski, Poland, which invests heavily in cybersecurity, currently foils 99 per cent of cyberattacks. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Over 100 people being investigated for vape offences, say MOH and HSA Singapore Bukit Merah fire: Residents relocated as town council carries out restoration works Singapore askST: What to do in the event of a fire at home Singapore Jalan Bukit Merah fire: PMD battery could have started fatal blaze, says SCDF Singapore askST: What are the fire safety rules for PMDs? Asia AirAsia flight from KL to Incheon lands at wrong airport in South Korea Asia India and China work to improve ties amid Trump's unpredictability Singapore From quiet introvert to self-confident student: How this vulnerable, shy teen gets help to develop and discover her strength On Aug 13, the Polish national prosecutor's office announced that it had charged three Poles and three Belarusians suspected of sabotage on behalf of 'foreign intelligence services'. A Ukrainian citizen accused of acts of sabotage, 'recruited by foreign services', was also arrested that day, according to Prime Minister Donald Tusk. In July, Mr Tusk told reporters that Poland had so far detained 32 people suspected of 'cooperating with Russian intelligence services'. AFP
CNA
an hour ago
- CNA
HSBC plans major global expansion of office, staff surveillance, documents show
LONDON :HSBC plans to step up surveillance of staff and buildings by adding more cameras and biometric access to its premises globally, internal documents seen by Reuters show, a move that comes amid growing concerns about companies' extensive monitoring of workers. As part of its "global security strategy", the bank plans a four-fold increase in the number of cameras at its new building in the City of London, a site about half the size of its existing office in Canary Wharf, an internal presentation by the bank's protective security team dated May 2025, seen by Reuters, shows. According to the presentation, the new London building is expected to have an estimated 1,754 cameras, up from about 444 devices installed in its current global headquarters in Canary Wharf in London. It also plans to double its biometric readers to access the new building to 779 from 350. Under the plan, reported here for the first time, access to HSBC's top-tier buildings, including in Britain and the U.S., should be based on biometric verification, including full-hand recognition. Access can also be "digital", with employees expected to use their own mobile phones to badge in, the presentation document shows. HSBC, Europe's biggest bank by assets, employs more than 210,000 people globally, including more than 31,000 across the UK. Most employees are expected to use personal mobile phones with a firm-installed software on them to gain access. This has met with some resistance from staff, a person with knowledge of the policies said. As of the end of last year, most of the UK staff had yet to adhere to the biometric and digital access policy which the bank started to implement in 2022, in part because of opposition, according to the person. "The safety and security of our people is at the forefront of everything HSBC does," an HSBC representative told Reuters. "We regularly risk assess every building and dependant on the identified risk and vulnerabilities, we continue to invest in the latest cutting-edge technology to safeguard our colleagues, customers and visitors in line with industry standards," the bank added. Companies have increased surveillance of staff amid a shift to hybrid working, while advances in technology allow for more sophisticated controls. Banks in particular have stepped up monitoring to ensure the parts of their businesses that are heavily regulated comply with conduct rules. National privacy laws determine what companies can monitor. The extensive surveillance enabled by new technologies is raising concerns about risks to workers' rights and wellbeing, according to a May report by the Institute for Public Policy Research, a London-based think tank. In July, HSBC requested that senior staff globally report to the office at least four days a week, starting from October, a bank spokesperson said. Previously, the bank had no global policy on the matter, with approaches varying depending on the country, they said. As demands for office space grow again, the bank has decided to add to its planned City of London HQ, with a new smaller presence in Canary Wharf, Reuters reported. The documents seen by Reuters do not include references to the new Canary Wharf office space. The bank's security project is overseen by Diane Marchena, global head of protective security, who reports to Chief Operating Officer Suzy White, the person with knowledge of the matter said. Marchena and White declined to comment for this article. ISRAELI SURVEILLANCE TOOLS HSBC has been working with Israeli firm Octopus since at least 2024, adopting some of its tools for surveillance in the UK and Hong Kong and is planning more rollouts for monitoring, other documents outlining HSBC's global strategy seen by Reuters show. HSBC plans the deployment of Octopus tools in other countries such as India and Mexico this year, the documents, which are undated, show. Israel is one of the world's leading exporters of surveillance. Octopus says it sells its tools to buyers in 28 countries. Its technology has been reportedly used by entities, including the Israeli government to monitor some Israeli cities and a European Union-funded refugee camp on the Greek island of Samos. A representative for Octopus did not take Reuters calls seeking comment and the company did not respond to a Reuters email seeking comment. An HSBC spokesperson said the bank does not comment on vendors or suppliers. TRADING FLOORS In HSBC's new London building, the increased video surveillance will include cameras at entry and exit points of trading floors, the May 2025 presentation shows, and the use of artificial intelligence analytics. HSBC's budget for the initial rollout of the new London building surveillance was recently tripled to about $15 million, the person familiar with the matter said. According to the presentation, "theft incidents" in its Canary Wharf building "point to the need for increased CCTV capabilities on working floors," and that recent "crime data" showed an increase of incidents, including burglary, within a one-mile radius of the new office.
