![[UPDATED] Menara KL, parent company's suit against government to proceed to trial](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Fassets.nst.com.my%2Fimages%2Farticles%2Fmamakltowera_NSTfield_image_socialmedia.var_1752566936.jpg&w=3840&q=100)
[UPDATED] Menara KL, parent company's suit against government to proceed to trial
This came after High Court judge Roz Mawar Rozain dismissed the application by Communications Minister Datuk Fahmi Fadzil and the government to strike out the suit today.
Roz Mawar, in her ruling, said the case against Fahmi and the government should not be struck out at this stage as there are triable issues, particularly relating to the proposed agreement in 2022, that warrant a full hearing.
"Fahmi and the government gave five reasons to support their bid to strike out the suit.
"While I may agree with some of them, the court finds that the case should not be dismissed at this stage, especially on the 2022 agreement.
"This court cannot allow the striking out of the claims against the first (Fahmi) and second (the government) defendants, as this is not a clear and obvious case where the claim is plainly unsustainable.
"Therefore, I dismiss the first and second defendants' application to strike out the suit," she said.
Roz Mawar then fixed Nov 3 for the next case management.
During the same hearing, Roz Mawar also allowed the application by three companies named as defendants to strike out the suit.
According to Judge Roz Mawar, the pleadings filed against all three companies were weak, overly general, and insufficient for a claim that requires proof of specific elements.
"The plaintiffs failed to state specific facts to support their allegations concerning the defendants' knowledge, the manner of interference (whether direct or indirect) any specific intention to interfere, or any special damages suffered.
"The plaintiffs merely made bare allegations of dishonesty without stating specific supporting facts.
"The details provided were merely a repetition of general claims from an inducement of breach of contract allegation.
"The plaintiffs also failed to specify how the third to fifth defendants breached any duties related to the trust.
"Serious allegations such as dishonesty require serious statements supported by concrete facts, not just conclusions," she said.
In March 2024, Hydroshoppe and MKLSB filed a lawsuit against Fahmi, the government, LSH Service Master Sdn Bhd, LSH Best Builders Sdn Bhd, and Service Master (M) Sdn Bhd.
LSH Service Master is a joint venture between LSH Best Builders and Service Master, which was awarded the tower management concession, replacing Hydroshoppe and MKLSB.
Hydroshoppe and MKLSB filed the suit over the alleged wrongful termination of their agreement in November 2022, which included the extension of the company's concession period from 15 to 30 years.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
4 hours ago
- The Sun
Homebuyers redefine value amid shift in mindset
AT FIRST glance, Malaysia's residential property market may appear quiet, but beneath the surface, a meaningful transformation is under way: a fundamental shift in how Malaysians approach property ownership. Today's buyers are intentional, value-focused, and sharply attuned to economic signals. The optimism of past years has given way to a more measured mindset shaped by global volatility, domestic caution, and a widening disconnect between asking prices and buyer expectations. This is not a retreat from the market; it is a recalibration. Malaysians are still buying, but with greater purpose and scrutiny. Supply expands, buyer expectations refocus According to the Property Market Q1'25 Snapshots by National Property Information Centre (Napic), residential construction jumped by 30.2% year-on-year (YoY), an expression of developer confidence. Yet, transaction volume and value fell 6.2% and 8.9%, respectively, highlighting a growing misalignment between supply and demand. This shift is not rooted in economic weakness. With policy interest rate steady at 3% and inflation down to 1.4% in April, Malaysia's fundamentals remain stable. But instead of acting on optimism, buyers are choosing caution. It is a clear signal: affordability today is no longer just about price; it's measured by perceived value. Bridging the price gap through buyer alignment Differences between current residential offerings and evolving buyer preferences are becoming more noticeable across key regions. In Kuala Lumpur, high-rise homes took the biggest hit, with prices dropping 7.3% quarter-on-quarter, which was the steepest decline among property types. According to Napic, overhang grew 14.8% year-on-year, with unsold units mostly being condominiums priced between RM200,000 to RM300,000. However, data from PropertyGuru Malaysia for April 2025 indicates that the condominium market is stabilising towards an equilibrium, showing only a slight month-on-month decrease in demand of 0.7% for condo-miniums. Selangor, meanwhile, tells a different story. According to Napic data, the price gap is widening in the apartment and serviced residence segments, but savvy buyers remain active when value aligns with expectations. Overhang fell nearly 40% year-on-year, signalling strong movement in well-priced, practical homes. Across most segments, caution dominates mark-to-market activity amid ongoing economic uncertainty. Penang continues to attract attention, especially in the condominium segment. PropertyGuru Malaysia's April 2025 data showed a 9.1% increase in condominium listing views, driven by infrastructure developments such as the LRT Mutiara Line. However, Napic data indicates a decline in transactions for homes priced above RM1 million, reflecting growing resistance to premium price points. Johor is shaping up as a market where rising prices are starting to test buyer patience. Napic reports an 8.7% year-on-year increase in high-rise prices for Q1'25. Correspondingly, PropertyGuru Malaysia's April 2025 data shows a 19.5% year-on-year decline in interest for serviced residences, with overall views for non-landed homes also trending downward. Like the non-landed property types, demand for landed property types also decreased YoY. The rise of the value-conscious buyer A dip in the demand index does not mean buyers have disappeared. In fact, they are just more selective. According to April 2025 data from PropertyGuru Malaysia, apartment views fell 14.1% while semi-detached homes dropped 21.4% year-on-year. Yet, property types that strike a smart balance between price, location, and lifestyle are defying the trend. Some even gain traction. 0 Selangor is a standout. Terraced homes continue to outperform, with demand rising 2.7% year-on-year and overhang falling 40%, according to Napic. This points to a healthy alignment between supply and real buyer appetite. 0 In Penang, condominium interest surged 9.1% year-on-year, buoyed by better connectivity and more competitive pricing, highlighting the positive impact of infrastructure upgrades like the upcoming LRT Mutiara Line. 0 Meanwhile, in Johor, the story is more nuanced. Napic data shows a 3.2% year-on-year increase in the All-Housing Price Index, led by high-rise and terraced homes. However, the price growth appears to be dampening sentiment, with declining demand suggesting that affordability concerns are weighing buyer decisions. These shifts tell us something important: buyers haven't exited the markedt. They are just more focused on finding real value. Developers are reimagining value in real time As buyers become more measured and data-driven, developers are also evolving their strategies to stay aligned. The traditional playbook of driving volume or focusing solely on premium segments is being rebalanced to meet a market increasingly shaped by value-conscious demand. Success now lies in realistic pricing, particularly in the resilient RM500,000 to RM800,000 bracket. Homes within this range continue to see steady interest, especially when paired with strong connectivity and well-designed, liveable environments. Transit-oriented developments and communities with integrated green spaces are emerging as long-term favourites among buyers. Equally important is understanding the new pace of decision-making. Buyers are being more deliberate, investing time in research, comparisons, and consultations before committing. In this era of intentional ownership, developers who align with value-driven demand through realistic pricing, livability, and accessibility are well-positioned to thrive. At PropertyGuru, we continue to support our partners with timely market insights and actionable data to help them better anticipate buyer behaviour, optimise offerings, and drive stronger outcomes across all segments. This article is contributed by PropertyGuru & iProperty country manager Malaysia, Kenneth Soh.
The Star
6 hours ago
- The Star
Asean news headlines as at 10pm on Tuesday (July 15)
Malaysia Freedom of Information Bill expected to be tabled by year-end, says Anwar Teen hands over mother's jewellery worth RM140,000 to scammers Cabinet yet to receive official memo on US ambassador pick, says Fahmi Maori community can be a model for Orang Asli tourism, socio-economic development, says Zahid Fighting corruption boosts economic growth, ensures national harmony, says Anwar Integrated Asean supply chain key to tackling US trade policies, says Liew Govt to review Judicial Appointments Commission Act, says Azalina KL ranks 12th globally in QS Best Student Cities 2026 Border control agency tightening security at transit zones to prevent illegal entry Anwar expected to announce judicial appointments July 16 Malaysia to host Smart City Expo KL 2025 in September Australian Foreign Minister Penny Wong honours Sabah, reaffirms commitment to Asean Malaysia's economic model must be readjusted to withstand external pressures, says HR minister MACC nabs two Bangladeshis linked to 'counter setting' syndicate Rock legends Deep Purple are back in Kuala Lumpur after 15 years for a super concert at Mega Star Arena on Nov 23 University stabbing suspect remanded for four days Two Chinese nationals killed in crash on NSE near Tapah MAHB enhances KLIA T1 with RM30mil upgrades to improve passenger experience In the heart of Sabah, Danum Valley is a living jungle like no other No evidence of AI chip smuggling found, says Zafrul Japanese multinational to invest RM500mil in mall expansion in Seremban 2 Tourists can plan their journey around KL with this handy guidebook Loke: PM to announce new Chief Justice after obtaining Malay Rulers' consent Mara to sponsor 100 students bound for NZ varsities S'wak exploring strategic tie-ups in utilities, space industry in China Bali ferry tragedy: Wisma Putra confirms M'sian's death, says all consular processes concluded 'Superman' Syed Saddiq attends birthday party of Bella Astillah's children Singapore Singapore intensifies crackdown on vapes; young suspected Kpod peddlers nabbed in Bishan, Yishun The Violinist, Singapore's first animated historical film, set for August 2026 release Singapore public healthcare institutions to record all Kpod cases, confiscate vapes Singapore researchers get S$25mil grant to screen, treat lung cancer in Asian patients Actor-artist Chen Xi marries Japanese girlfriend in Singapore Singaporean actress Sheila Sim takes hair-cutting course after giving daughter 'awful' haircut S$10mil Toto results to be announced on July 17; no winners in past three draws Thailand Supreme Court hears fourth session on Thaksin's hospitalisation during sentence Thailand delays tourist entry fee till 2026 Golf, the femme fatale embroiled in sex scandal with monks, faces arrest over embezzlement of temple funds Suspended Thai PM asks court for more time to respond to ethics case Thailand unexpectedly delays naming new central bank chief Thai police submit sedition case against Hun Sen to prosecutors Thailand's changing cannabis rules leave farmers in a tough spot French President Emmanuel Macron, right welcoming Indonesia's President Prabowo Subianto at the Elysee Palace in Paris n July 14. - AP Photo Indonesia Indonesia rescues 11 who swam for hours to survive boat capsize Search extended for 17 missing victims in Bali Strait ferry tragedy Indonesian diva and pop princess Bunga Citra Lestari to jive stage with Jaclyn Victor and violinist Dennis Lau for 'love concert' in KL Indonesia trains migrants workers as cultural ambassadors abroad Philippines Magnitude 5.8 earthquake strikes Luzon, Philippines Cops raid online lending company in Pasig City, nab 168 employees Reforms could help transform Philippines into middle-class society by 2040: World Bank Search for missing Philippine cockfighting enthusiasts in Taal Lake to take six months: Remula Vietnam Vietnam's capital to help residents switch to electric vehicles SpaceX expected to launch Starlink services in Vietnam from fourth quarter German customs officials find 1,500 tarantulas hidden in biscuit packaging from Vietnam Vietnam's former top health official prosecuted in dual bribery scandals Cambodia Archaeologists restoring ninth brick tower of Bakong temple in Cambodia's famed Angkor park Defence minister demands public apology for assault on Cambodian soldier at Ta Mone Thom Cambodian ministries going digital with e-invoice platform Myanmar Four consecutive earthquakes strike within hours in Myanmar Myanmar welcomes over 500,000 foreign tourists in H1 2025 Laos Laos, Cambodia, Myanmar to release 100 million fingerlings into rivers Laos moves toward integrating digital ID systems Brunei Brunei Sultan announces landmark reforms and digital transformation on 79th birthday Brunei's lion dance troupe to 'roar' at world championships China is experiencing a relentless heatwave, with temperatures forecast to exceed 40 deg C in parts of the country as residents prepare for the summer season to reach its peak on July 20. - AFP Aseanplus Australia sidesteps US tensions to seek closer China trade ties Hong Kong opens probe into AI-generated porn scandal at university China's Xi vows greater support for Russia as he meets Lavrov Pilot groups reject claims of human error in Air India crash Japan man sells Ferrari to fund shelter for 'taxing' dogs, repay pet that saved his life Heatwave sweeping across China could be unprecedented Parent of top student, teacher break into South Korean school to steal exam papers Typhoon Nari makes landfall over Japan's Hokkaido Teacher, teen arrested at Hong Kong airport in 'Ice', ketamine drug cases China steps in as US pulls back from diplomacy, report says Elegant Fine Caviar: Malaysian-owned caviar from a sturgeon farm in China World's oldest marathon runner dies aged 114 in road accident Fringe party vows to put 'Japan First' to chip away at LDP rule China's Q2 GDP growth tops forecast even as US tariff risks mount Squid Game's tragic couple speak out on their harrowing on-screen relationship Tech takes centre stage as Chinese students weigh up major choices Fringe party vows to put 'Japan First' to chip away at LDP rule Astronauts from India, Poland, Hungary head for splashdown with NASA veteran Japan's ruling coalition seen losing upper house majority, polls show Australia looks to scrap surcharges on most card payments Nvidia's CEO says it has US approval to sell its H20 AI computer chips in China Lego doubling down on China market Japan launches government body to address concerns over foreigners Bangladesh struggles to contain the fallout of an uprising that toppled its leader last year 'Butter': the foodie feminist bestseller skewering sexism in Japan Japan ruling party support plunges ahead of national election in NHK poll HK actor Ray Lui's wife flaunts RM216k handbag while vacationing with husband in Europe Asian markets mixed as China's economy meets forecasts
Borneo Post
10 hours ago
- Borneo Post
Travel company, director claim trial over unpaid refunds
Zulkarian KOTA KINABALU (July 15): A travel company and its director pleaded not guilty at a Magistrate's Court here on Tuesday to six charges of failing to comply with Consumer Claims Tribunal (TTPM) orders to refund a total of RM232,526.80 to six individuals. Emraz Travel & Tours Sdn Bhd and its director, Datuk Zulkarnain Endut, 44, claimed trial before magistrate Dzul Elmy Yunus. Both were granted bail of RM1,000 with one local surety for each charge. Zulkarnain entered the pleas on behalf of himself and the company. He was represented by counsel Farah Nazriah Chun Lee @ Mohd Fadzlee Lee, while Deputy Public Prosecutors Shafiq Mahadi and Md Syafique Md Helmie appeared for the Ministry of Domestic Trade and Cost of Living (KPDN). The company and Zulkarnain face six charges under Section 117(1) of the Consumer Protection Act 1999 for failing to comply with TTPM award orders. If convicted, they face a fine of up to RM10,000, imprisonment of up to two years, or both. According to the charges, they allegedly failed to pay the awarded claims — ranging from RM24,666.80 to RM50,000 — between 24 July 2023 and 25 January 2024 at the KPDN Sabah office, Federal Government Administrative Complex, Jalan UMS. The third accused, Datin Mazuin Mustafa — Zulkarnain's wife and also a company director — was absent due to a high-risk pregnancy, supported by a medical report from Putrajaya Hospital dated 20 June 2025. Her lawyer informed the court that this is her first pregnancy and is into the 11th week, with travel deemed unsafe. Counsel Farah Nazriah requested that the arrest warrant against Mazuin be revoked, to which the prosecution had no objection. Deputy Public Prosecutor Shafiq requested that a pre-trial case management (PTCM) be scheduled in two months and that the court be updated on Mazuin's ability to attend. He noted the case is of public interest due to its connection with multiple Umrah packages and substantial financial losses. He also proposed bail at RM2,000 per charge with one local surety, along with a condition for the accused to report to KPDN on the 17th of every month. Farah Nazriah appealed for minimal bail, citing that the accused is a Malaysian citizen with no fixed income following the company's winding-up on 17 July 2024. She also highlighted the accused's personal responsibilities, including his wife's medical condition. The accused are facing other charges throughout Malaysia, including in Sabah, Sarawak and Peninsular Malaysia. The court fixed 23 September 2025 for pre-trial case management and maintained bail at RM1,000 per charge with one local surety.
