State can't use medication evidence to counter insanity defense in fatal crash, Georgia court says
Michelle Wierson was driving her Volkswagen Tiguan at high speed through the streets of DeKalb County, in Atlanta 's suburbs, when she hit a Toyota Corolla stopped at a traffic light. The impact pushed the car into the intersection where it collided with another car. Miles Jenness, a 5-year-old passenger in the Toyota, suffered a traumatic brain injury and a severed spine and died days later.
Everyone agrees that Wierson caused the September 2018 wreck. Her defense attorneys filed notice that she intended to plead not guilty by reason of insanity, saying that at the time of the wreck she was suffering from a 'delusional compulsion' caused by mental illness that absolves her of criminal liability. The DeKalb County district attorney's office wanted to present evidence that Wierson had stopped taking some medication prescribed to treat bipolar disorder, arguing that the jury should be allowed to consider that she voluntarily contributed to her mental state.
The trial court said the state could use that evidence, but the state Court of Appeals reversed that ruling in a pretrial appeal. The state then appealed to the state Supreme Court, which upheld the intermediate appeals court's ruling.
An Atlanta-area psychologist with a years-long history of bipolar disorder, Wierson believed at the time of the crash that she was on a mission from God to save her daughter from being killed, her lawyers have said.
Georgia law outlines two tests for someone seeking to use an insanity defense at trial. Both have to do with the person's mental state 'at the time of' the alleged crime. The first says a person shall not be found guilty of a crime if they 'did not have mental capacity to distinguish between right and wrong' related to the act. The second says a person shall not be found guilty of a crime if the person acted because of 'a delusional compulsion' that 'overmastered' their will.
An expert hired by the defense and another engaged by the court found that Wierson met both of those criteria. Justice Andrew Pinson wrote in Wednesday's majority opinion that the law says nothing about the cause of the person's mental state at the time of the crime.
'Put simply, the plain language of the insanity-defense statutes gives not even a hint that these defenses would not be available to a person who has 'brought about' the relevant mental state voluntarily, whether by not taking medication or otherwise,' he wrote.
Robert Rubin, a lawyer for Wierson, has said that his client is 'haunted by the tragic consequences' of her actions. But he said in an email Wednesday that he hopes the Supreme Court ruling will allow the case to be resolved without a trial.
'The Georgia Supreme Court reaffirmed the basic principle that the focus of an insanity case is the defendant's state of mind at the time of the act,' he wrote. 'The State never disputed that our client was insane at the time of the accident. Its attempt to make this case about alleged medication compliance was misplaced and dragged this case out unnecessarily.'
The DeKalb County district attorney's office did not immediately have a comment Wednesday. Bruce Hagen, a lawyer for the Jenness family said in an email that he was 'very disappointed, although not surprised' by the high court's ruling.
In its ruling on this case, the Supreme Court also overturned its own ruling in a 1982 case that had created an exception to the insanity defenses. That case involved a man diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia who, against his doctor's orders, put himself in a highly stressful situation and ended up killing two people.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
4 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Surge in cannabis-induced psychotic episodes across the UK as potency of strains has increased
Cannabis-induced psychosis is becoming increasingly common across the UK, a leading psychiatrist has warned. The widely used class B drug – also known as marijuana or weed – can cause dependency, and, in the year to March 2024, 2.3million people in the UK reported using it. But while regular use has more than halved in the past two decades, the number of cannabis-induced psychosis episodes has spiked as varieties on sale have become stronger. Those experiencing a psychotic episode commonly have symptoms such as hallucinations, dissociation or unusual changes in behaviour. And while these resolve in most cases, side-effects can last for years. Studies show cannabis can even trigger schizophrenia – a chronic mental health condition characterised by psychotic episodes where individuals lose touch with reality, experiencing delusions and hallucinations. Dr Niall Campbell, a consultant psychiatrist at the Priory rehabilitation centre, warns of a deepening public health issue, stemming from easy online access to highly potent forms of the drug known as 'skunk'. Made from unpollinated cannabis plants which naturally contain higher levels of THC – the main psychoactive ingredient – skunk greatly increases the risk of paranoia and hallucinations. 'There has been a visible rise in the number of people needing intensive support for psychosis as a result of cannabis use,' said Dr Campbell. 'I don't think this is surprising given how easy skunk is to buy. What begins with smoking a few 'joints' and feeling a bit paranoid can easily escalate. Over time people can reach a psychotic state which won't go away, even if they stop smoking – they can become very depressed or suicidal.' It comes after the London Drugs Commission released a report earlier this year calling for more services to tackle cannabis addiction.
Telegraph
9 hours ago
- Telegraph
‘Fat jabs left me so depressed it was like having The Deer Hunter theme on repeat in my head'
I can say without any doubt that I've never been depressed. So when I began using weight-loss injections three months ago it was a huge shock to find that rather than my usual unhappy-go-lucky self, I sensed something new. Something really bad. I was depressed and I could only assume it was a side effect of the drugs. Within a week of my first injection I felt a deep despair, seemingly from nowhere. Nothing had happened in my work or social life to trigger it. For a few days I searched for a cause, confused and concerned about where this blackness had come from. Suddenly, to an almost absurd, comical extent, existence seemed bleak and irredeemable. It was like having the theme tune to 1978's war drama The Deer Hunter playing in my head on repeat. After the initial shock, I had to somehow find a way to recognise this state for what it was: artificially induced – the mental equivalent of fake news. I have known lots of people with 'real' depression: the kind that keeps a person in bed for a week as if there were a weight tied to their body. The kind that waxes and wanes without reason, making it hard for those around them to empathise. I'd never known that feeling, yet here it was squatting on top of me day after day. Using weight-loss injections produced no other side effects. I have been sleeping well, I've not felt any nausea and I have undoubtedly lost weight, which was the whole point of this expensive experiment in the first place. Much of what has been written about the mental health impact of these treatments has been on either the positive effects of losing weight – improved self esteem – and how some who experience ADHD report a heightened sense of focus and concentration. Nowhere in the literature of the companies that make the treatments, or those who sell it, is there any suggestion that depression is a verifiable risk. Side effects are listed as nausea and vomiting, constipation, diarrhaea, reflux, headaches and fatigue. So much the same as a long stag weekend, rather than a continuous vigil at the edge of the abyss. The medications in question are known as 'glucagon-like peptide-1 receptor agonists' (examples are semaglutide in Ozempic and Wegovy, and tirzepatide in Mounjaro). They were conceived as a treatment for diabetes and were later found to have beneficial effects fighting obesity. They may also help with cardiovascular disease and even neurological disorders such as Alzheimer's. They work by mimicking the effects of the hormone GLP-1, which helps regulate blood sugar levels and appetite. Dr Riccardo De Giorgi, Clinical Lecturer in General Adult Psychiatry at the University of Oxford is currently studying the effects of these drugs and admits that it is too soon to know if there is a possible link with depression, but suggests evidence points to a positive, rather negative, impact on mental health. 'The most recent studies available suggest that GLP-1 medications do not increase depressive symptoms or suicidality,' he says. 'These are based on drug trials where the patients were measured for depression 'scores' and psychological wellbeing, and they didn't show a negative effect overall. 'What happens if you are exposed to these drugs and you have a history of depressive episodes? In that regard, we don't have any evidence at all. There are now some more trials pending on depression, but it's very early days.' I asked around amongst friends and friends of friends (there are so many people using these treatments now that they aren't hard to find), and several reported very similar experiences to my own. One mentioned feeling 'oversensitive and on the verge of tears all the time'. Another said she felt so depressed and exhausted through emotional stress that she had to stop using it. She wanted to start using jabs again but was afraid of reliving her depression. A third said the worst days were 'shocking' but eventually she began to feel better – whether that was because the effects wore off or because she became more adept at coping she couldn't be sure. For me, the strangest feature of this self-inflicted ordeal was that I couldn't trust my emotions. It was like I was in my own matrix, where what I was experiencing felt real but was actually a simulation I had brought on myself – all while paying a monthly fee for the privilege. When something bothered me at work, there was no way to measure its real importance, which meant there was no reliable way to respond to it. How could I tell if a crisis at home was trivial, a total catastrophe or something in between? Thinking about the terrible state of Britain and the world suddenly felt deeply personal rather than an essential part of my job. Just hearing the first bars of a John Barry film score or recalling a random memory of my daughters set me off like Adele at an awards ceremony. I wondered if my new mood was connected to missing food, since I had become a one-meal a day person with no snacking. Maybe giving up eating for pleasure was getting me down? But while I love food like Keir Starmer loves free glasses, not even giving up crisps could make me feel this hopeless. The accepted routes for treating 'real' depression do not really apply to me since all I needed to do was stop the injections. I could hardly start taking anti-depressants to cope with the artificially induced depression brought on by other drugs. Therapy to treat it also seemed ridiculous, since it would be treating something that I had the power to stop. That was not a luxury afforded to those unlucky enough to experience the real thing. The therapists I asked about this were none the wiser, expressing confusion about how they might treat a patient who believed their depression had been triggered not by a pre-existing condition or circumstance, but by weight-loss injections. For me, feeling this way was my choice: a trade off for a thinner waist and a current drop of 1st 9lbs. Dr De Giorgi offered one explanation, yet admits that until he and others are able to conclude further research there is still no clinical evidence of a link between the drugs and depression. 'Some forms of depression are associated with high levels of inflammatory molecules, in which case the anti-inflammatory effects of GLP-1 medications would be helpful,' he explains. 'For other people, who are less prone to inflammation, the drugs might upset the balance in the body that is already in a sweet spot, so the drugs mean you have 'too little inflammation'. A degree of healthy inflammation is needed for the normal upkeep of brain cells. GLP-1 medications seem to be able to enter the brain, so we shouldn't be surprised if we find there are other implications such as mental effects.' Even if a link was ever proven, which is not likely as things stand, it's hardly going to provide much comfort. Most recently, the icing on this doom-laden cake – the kind a goth would get for his birthday at a Dracula festival in Whitby – was that I began to have nightmares. A mixture of Franz Kafka's brand of horror and Stephen King's It, they were like video nasties in which the lead character shouts: 'This isn't real!' and tries to wake themselves up. After a couple of these, I had to set a deadline to get myself off this stuff. No chiselled jawline is worth this. Kate Moss once famously said: 'Nothing tastes as good as skinny feels', but, for me, it was a case of nothing feels as bad as skinny tastes.
Daily Mail
11 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Pookie and Jett's throwback Trump photo sends the internet wild
A throwback photo of Campbell 'Pookie' and Jett Puckett wearing a Donald and Melania Trump Halloween costume has sent the internet wild with speculation about their political affiliation. The couple went viral after the internet caught onto Jett telling his wife she was 'looking absolutely fire tonight,' but now sleuths are digging into the Hermes-wearing couple's politics. An old photo of the pair dressed up as Donald and Melania at the President's 2017 inauguration resurfaced on Reddit. Pookie's dress was similar to the blue Ralph Lauren dress Melania wore, down to the blue gloves. Jett's outfit was also reminiscent of the tailored suits and trademark red tie Trump is often seen wearing. Although the Georgia-based couple has not addressed their political affiliation, many are speculating these old photos suggest they're Republicans. 'I would be more surprised if they dressed up as the Bidens lmao,' another wrote. 'Are y'all really surprised? Lol, I assumed this already,' a third fan wrote. 'I've never been less shocked in my life,' a fourth person wrote. The Atlanta-based couple met at a wine bar in Philadelphia after Jett approached her. They dated for ten months before getting engaged in 2018. They recently welcomed a baby together. Pookie was a former flight attendant and worked for the blog You Should Wear That. Wharton-educated Jett works in mergers and acquisitions in the dental industry. He began his career working in private equity, during which time his company bought up small dentist surgeries and other health businesses. They have been building their brand since 2020, but have recently taken off in part thanks to the discussion around her nickname. Fans have long been obsessed with the couple's relationship, with many praising how much Jett seems to appreciate his wife dressing up and surprising him. Theirs fans have also begun to speculate that they're acting for the camera. Pookie and Jett, who celebrated their seventh wedding anniversary in April, have also found themselves embroiled in a bitter controversy after images of Pookie 'cosplaying as a slave owner' at a plantation-themed party during her days as an Ole Miss college student resurfaced. Several unearthed photos of Pookie dressed in 'southern plantation glam' while attending the event have been posted on TikTok and Reddit last year - sparking a wave of backlash against the newly-minted influencer. The images show Pookie attending what appears to be an Antebellum-themed party, otherwise known as an 'Old South' party, at the University of Mississippi. Antebellum plantation-themed parties take inspiration from the period before the American Civil War, when wealthy white planters wielded the majority of power in the South - and often owned black slaves. In the images shared of Pookie, the influencer is seen dressed in a lacy pink-and-white ball gown, striking a number of poses, and standing alongside several fellow college students who are seen sporting similar attire. Pookie, who hasn't addressed her Melania outfit, did address her Ole Miss costume on her Instagram. 'As some of you may have seen, some old photos of mine recently resurfaced. At the time these photos were taken, I was 20. I didn't fully understand the impact of my actions the way I do now, 12 years later,' she wrote. 'I fully apologize for the harm this may have caused for some and take full responsibility. Jett and I love sharing our lives with you all and getting to know our community on such an intimate level. 'Because we live our lives so publicly, everything is on the internet, even my mistakes. We hope to continue to bring you with us on our journey as we continue to learn and grow.' Pookie currently has almost 200,000 TikTok followers and has gained more than six million likes.
