Bombay HC strikes down GST demand on TDR used by real estate developer
NAGPUR
: In an important ruling for
Maharashtra's real estate sector
, the Nagpur bench of Bombay high court set aside a GST demand issued to a city-based developer, holding that no taxable transfer of development rights occurred under the agreement in question. The decision offers clarity on the tax implications of development agreements in the real estate sector.
The division bench of justices Avinash Gharote and Abhay Mantri delivered the ruling while allowing a petition filed by Shrinivasa Realcon, which challenged a show-cause notice issued on August 14, 2024, and a consequent GST order dated December 10, 2024. The demand pertained to a development agreement executed on April 7, 2022, for constructing a residential complex on an 8,000 sq ft plot at mouza Lendra. The developer was appointed by the landowner for a consideration of Rs7 crore and two flats.
Senior counsel Akshay Naik, assisted by Abhishek Bhoot, argued that the project did not involve any transfer or purchase of development rights or floor space index (FSI) from external sources. Instead, the construction was based solely on the existing FSI or any statutory increase.
Entry 5B of the GST notification dated June 28, 2017, amended on March 29, 2019, allows taxation of services involving the transfer of TDR or FSI for construction purposes. However, the court noted the GST law does not define a 'transfer of development right'. It referred to Clause 11.2 of the Unified Development Control and Promotion Regulations, which outlines TDR as compensation in FSI granted by a planning authority, not applicable in the present case.
The bench concluded that the development agreement lacked any reference to the transfer of such rights and rejected the department's reliance on Clause 18 of the contract, which merely required compliance under the Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act, 1970.
Declaring the transaction outside the purview of Entry 5B, the court quashed both the show-cause notice and the final order. "The transaction contemplated does not fall within Entry 5B of the notification of June 28, 2017, as amended by another notification of March 29, 2019. Neither the show-cause notice nor the consequent order can be sustained," the judges stated in their order, thereby setting them aside.
Key takeaways from HC verdict:
- There was no actual trading of transfer of development rights (TDR) in the agreement
- Entry 5B of GST notification could not be invoked in case
- GST Act does not define 'transfer of development rights'
- Developer used existing FSI or statutory increase, not external TDR
- Clause 18 of agreement was not proof of transfer
- Set aside both show-cause notice and final tax order
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Relief for Gali: HC suspends conviction, grants him bail in illegal mining case
Hyderabad: Telangana high court Wednesday suspended both the conviction and sentence of Karnataka former minister and mining baron Gali Janardhan Reddy in an illegal mining case while also giving him bail, an order that would save Gali's position as an MLA. Following the conviction and seven-year sentence imposed by a special CBI court, Gali stood disqualified as an MLA and the election authorities would have held a bypoll soon for his seat (Gangavathi). Agreeing with the arguments of the legislator's lawyer, senior counsel S Nagamuthun, that damages from the conviction were irreversible, Justice K Lakshman also ordered his release from jail with certain conditions. Gali was told not to leave the country or commit unlawful acts anywhere and to furnish two sureties worth Rs 10 lakh. He has already served half of the seven-year sentence while being a remand prisoner. Along with Gali, three other individuals – BV Srinivas Reddy (Obulapuram Mining Company MD), VD Rajagopal (former director, AP mines and geology department) and Mehfuz Ali Khan (PA to Gali) – and one entity, the company OMC, were convicted by the special CBI court last month. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Amazon's Hottest Selling Hearing Aid Is Back On Sale Oricle Hearing Aid Learn More Undo On Tuesday, apart from Gali, Justice Lakshman stayed the conviction of the entity OMC. The judge also granted bail to the other three with the same conditions. The criminal appeals of these three against their conviction will be heard on Aug 11. Srilakshmi issue to be heard on June 19 The judge also sought a counter from the CBI in the criminal revision plea filed by senior IAS officer and former AP industries secretary Y Srilakshmi and posted her case to June 19. The HC had earlier discharged her from the case but the CBI had appealed in the Supreme Court, which directed the HC to hear the CBI version also before arriving at a conclusion. On Tuesday, senior counsel P Venugopal, appearing for Srilakshmi, said she has an apprehension about Justice Lakshman hearing her revision plea in view of last year's judgment delivered by him where he had refused to quash the case against her. When CBI counsel Srinivas Kapatia sought a week's time to file their counter, the judge reminded him that the CBI could not dodge filing a counter now, saying, "You complained to the apex court about the HC not hearing your version. But here you have not filed your counter despite a three-month deadline fixed by the Supreme Court asking the HC to decide the issue." Srilakshmi had succeeded Kripanandam as industries secretary. The special court, while convicting Gali and the others, had acquitted Kripanandam as well as then industry minister Sabitha Indra Reddy in the illegal mining case.
Time of India
6 hours ago
- Time of India
Iron trader held by GST team for 26cr tax fraud
Raipur: A 32-year-old iron trader from Raipur, was arrested by State Goods and Services Tax (GST) officials in connection with a fraudulent tax credit scheme that cost the govt a whooping loss of Rs 26 crores in revenue. According to joint commissioner Narendra Verma, the trader, Aman Agarwal, has been involved in fictitious transactions under the guise of bogus firms from 2023 to 2025, with a total of Rs. 262 crore worth of buying and selling transactions. Agarwal is accused of availing Rs. 26 crore in input tax credit by creating fake sales with these ghost companies. Special commissioner, Chhattisgarh GST T L Dhruv said that the challan will be put up in court and further probe will be done. Agarwal, who runs iron scrap and steel businesses, reportedly created 10 fake firms, to manipulate the tax system. He used these firms to show inflated purchases between 2023 and 2025, claiming tax credits that were later passed off to other traders in the state. The fake firms were allegedly responsible for purchasing iron and steel products worth Rs. 144 crore, resulting in a Rs. 26 crore tax loss for the state. Agarwal even listed deceased individuals as the owners of some of these firms, officials said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 2025 Top Trending Local Enterprise Accounting Software [Click Here] Accounting ERP Click Here Undo For instance, he reported transactions for companies registered under names of people who had died in 2010, but the purchases were shown in 2013 and 2015. Agarwal was arrested under GST Sections 69 and 132B and the police and GST officials are continuing their investigation. Authorities say this case highlights the growing issue of tax fraud in the state and have assured that they will continue to monitor such operations closely.
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
MP praises 11 years of good governance of PM Modi
Motihari: Former Union agriculture minister and MP Radha Mohan Singh praised 11 years of the Narendra Modi govt. Talking to reporters here, he said 11 years are a symbol not only of good governance but also of India's renaissance. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now He said PM Modi has established India as a self-reliant, strong and respectable nation by prioritising public service. He mentioned historical steps like GST, Digital India and Startup India, which has made India the fastest-growing economy in the world. He further said initiatives like the , Ayushman Bharat, Ujjwala Yojana, and Awas Yojana have empowered crores of poor people. He said the govt has established fast-track courts across the country, and today 745 such courts are operational, including 404 that deal exclusively with cases under the Pocso.
