Bombay HC strikes down GST demand on TDR used by real estate developer
NAGPUR
: In an important ruling for
Maharashtra's real estate sector
, the Nagpur bench of Bombay high court set aside a GST demand issued to a city-based developer, holding that no taxable transfer of development rights occurred under the agreement in question. The decision offers clarity on the tax implications of development agreements in the real estate sector.
The division bench of justices Avinash Gharote and Abhay Mantri delivered the ruling while allowing a petition filed by Shrinivasa Realcon, which challenged a show-cause notice issued on August 14, 2024, and a consequent GST order dated December 10, 2024. The demand pertained to a development agreement executed on April 7, 2022, for constructing a residential complex on an 8,000 sq ft plot at mouza Lendra. The developer was appointed by the landowner for a consideration of Rs7 crore and two flats.
Senior counsel Akshay Naik, assisted by Abhishek Bhoot, argued that the project did not involve any transfer or purchase of development rights or floor space index (FSI) from external sources. Instead, the construction was based solely on the existing FSI or any statutory increase.
Entry 5B of the GST notification dated June 28, 2017, amended on March 29, 2019, allows taxation of services involving the transfer of TDR or FSI for construction purposes. However, the court noted the GST law does not define a 'transfer of development right'. It referred to Clause 11.2 of the Unified Development Control and Promotion Regulations, which outlines TDR as compensation in FSI granted by a planning authority, not applicable in the present case.
The bench concluded that the development agreement lacked any reference to the transfer of such rights and rejected the department's reliance on Clause 18 of the contract, which merely required compliance under the Maharashtra Apartment Ownership Act, 1970.
Declaring the transaction outside the purview of Entry 5B, the court quashed both the show-cause notice and the final order. "The transaction contemplated does not fall within Entry 5B of the notification of June 28, 2017, as amended by another notification of March 29, 2019. Neither the show-cause notice nor the consequent order can be sustained," the judges stated in their order, thereby setting them aside.
Key takeaways from HC verdict:
- There was no actual trading of transfer of development rights (TDR) in the agreement
- Entry 5B of GST notification could not be invoked in case
- GST Act does not define 'transfer of development rights'
- Developer used existing FSI or statutory increase, not external TDR
- Clause 18 of agreement was not proof of transfer
- Set aside both show-cause notice and final tax order
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
an hour ago
- Economic Times
Why is India outpacing China, US, EU and Germany?
Despite a slight moderation to 6.3% in FY26, the World Bank projects India to remain the fastest-growing major economy Synopsis Despite a slight moderation to 6.3% in FY26, India's economic growth remains robust, outpacing global trends. Fueled by strong domestic consumption, a favorable demographic dividend, and government-led capital expenditure, India stands out as the fastest-growing major economy. However, risks like oil import dependence and a weak export sector persist amid global economic turbulence. India's economic growth will moderate a bit in FY26 but will remain steady even though the rest of the world is faltering, as per the World Bank's latest estimates. It has brought down India's growth forecast for FY26 to 6.3% from 6.7% estimated in January. However, as per various estimates, India will still remain the fastest-growing major economy. ADVERTISEMENT Also Read: World Bank predicts India dhoom amid global gloom India first emerged as the world's fastest-growing major economy in 2015, surpassing China in terms of GDP growth rate. The convergence of a favorable external environment (low oil prices, for instance), domestic macroeconomic stabilization and a bold reform agenda laid the foundation for India's economic acceleration. From 2015–2018, India's GDP growth hovered between 7.5% and 8%, outpacing China, whose growth had slowed to around 6.5–6.7% due to a structural transition from investment-led to consumption-driven growth. Key reforms during this period included the Make in India initiative, liberalisation of FDI norms and steps toward fiscal consolidation. The Goods and Services Tax (GST) was passed in 2017, a landmark move toward a unified national market. From 2019 to 2020 was a period of headwinds. By late 2018 and 2019, growth began to moderate due to banking sector stress (notably in NBFCs), weakening private consumption, and sluggish private investment. In FY2019–20, GDP growth eased to 5%, compared with the 6.1% growth in the previous fiscal year, 2018-19, due to global economic conditions as well as a slowdown in the manufacturing and construction sectors, weak consumption growth and challenges in the financial sector. The COVID-19 pandemic in 2020 dealt a major blow to the economy, causing GDP to contract by 7.3% in FY21, its worst performance since independence. India rebounded strongly in FY22 with 8.7% growth, supported by a surge in domestic demand, public capex and recovery in services and exports. Since 2022, India has consistently maintained a growth rate of 6–7%, while most advanced economies and even China have decelerated significantly. The World Bank, IMF, and the UN have repeatedly reaffirmed India as the fastest-growing major economy from 2021 onward, a status it is expected to retain at least through to projections from the United Nations' World Economic Situation and Prospects 2025, the IMF, and the World Bank, India is poised to remain the fastest-growing major economy, outpacing China, the US, the European Union, Germany and other developed economies. This growth differential is not merely a statistic but a reflection of shifting structural dynamics, macroeconomic fundamentals and policy contrasts among global players. ADVERTISEMENT The global economy is expected to expand by just 2.3% in 2025, a deceleration from previous expectations. This subdued pace underscores the persistence of several cross-cutting headwinds: Rising protectionism, especially through tariff escalation and strategic decoupling (notably between the U.S. and China), is limiting trade volume growth. The World Bank warns that global trade expansion in 2025 will likely be under 2%, significantly below the historical average of 4–5%.Central banks in developed economies, particularly the ECB and the Federal Reserve, are maintaining cautious monetary stances amid persistent core inflation, resulting in elevated real interest rates that inhibit both consumer spending and capital investment. The war in Ukraine, US-China tensions, and energy supply disruptions continue to undermine investor confidence and disrupt global supply chains. Demographic aging, productivity stagnation and tepid innovation diffusion are combining to suppress growth in key economies like Germany and Japan. ADVERTISEMENT The US will see projected growth of around 1.4% in 2025 as per the World Bank, down from 2.3% projected in January, marking a slowdown, primarily due to the delayed effects of monetary tightening., weakening consumer sentiment due to inflation fatigue, and political uncertainty in an election year, which could delay public investment growth projection remains unchanged at 4.5% in 2025, modest by its historical standards. Although policy tools remain available, Beijing faces structural issues in its real estate sector, declining labor force participation, and rising geopolitical isolation and capital outflows. ADVERTISEMENT The euro area is expected to grow by just 1%, while Germany remains one of the weakest performers among OECD members. Energy insecurity and high input costs post-Russia sanctions continue to weigh on industrial production. Structural reliance on exports, especially to a slowing China, is increasingly a liability. A lag in green transition investments reduces medium-term is projected to grow at 6.3% in FY26, maintaining its status as the world's fastest-growing major economy. The reasons for this outperformance are both cyclical and structural. Unlike export-reliant economies, India benefits from a consumption-heavy GDP structure. A growing middle class, rising urbanization and increasing per capita income create a resilient consumer base that cushions the economy from global shocks. ADVERTISEMENT India remains in its demographic sweet spot. With a median age of 29, the labour force continues to expand, driving both demand and productivity gains. In contrast, aging populations in Europe, China, and Japan act as long-term drags on capital expenditure, especially in infrastructure (roads, railways, energy, and digital infrastructure), has a strong multiplier effect. This investment boom has also crowded in private sector investment, particularly in manufacturing and logistics. Reforms such as the GST, Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, and digital public infrastructure (UPI, Aadhaar stack) have enhanced formalization, compliance, and productivity in the IT and digital services exports continue to surge, and the country is increasingly positioning itself as a global back office for advanced services including fintech, edtech, and healthtech, coming a long way to Global Capability Centres from call centres of early 2000s. This high-margin sector provides a valuable cushion to current account pressures. Amid US-China decoupling and China+1 strategies, India is attracting foreign direct investment into electronics, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors and renewable energy despite optimism, India is not immune to global turbulence. Key risks include dependence on oil imports, which exposes it to energy price shocks. A relatively weak export sector may limit benefits from global recovery phases. Fiscal pressures can grow if subsidies rise due to electoral considerations. The global economy is navigating a low-growth equilibrium, marked by fragmented trade, demographic drag and inflation inertia. India's growth, by contrast, is being propelled by favorable demographics, domestic demand and policy momentum. What distinguishes India is not just its headline growth rate but the underlying composition of the economy. Whether this momentum translates into sustained long-term convergence with advanced economies will depend on India's ability to broaden the benefits of growth, invest in human capital, and build resilience against future global shocks. (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel) (Catch all the Business News, Breaking News, Budget 2025 Events and Latest News Updates on The Economic Times.) Subscribe to The Economic Times Prime and read the ET ePaper online. NEXT STORY
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Cost of green hydrogen in India set to fall by up to 40%
The cost of green hydrogen in India , the country that is aiming big in the renewable energy space, is expected to fall by up to 40 per cent with the support and incentives the government is providing, according to a report by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. The levelised cost of green hydrogen in India is seen falling towards ₹260-310 per kg ($3-3.75 per kg). India provides cheap renewable electricity to hydrogen manufacturers, waives Inter-State Transmission Charges for open access, lowers distribution and transmission charges, and lowers the GST rate for hydrogen to 5 per cent. Besides, the report asserts electrolyser manufacturers are projected to achieve a 7-10 per cent reduction in total system costs for the first five years, starting in 2024--₹2,960/kW (USD 36/kW) being the average annual realisable base incentive. "While the green hydrogen scheme is an important step for India, refinements are needed to promote long-term investment and project viability," says the report. The report asserted that India's green hydrogen mission has been enthusiastically received by industry. It added, however, that the scheme needs fine-tuning to attract startups, be competitive for global players and create a supply chain and secure demand to ensure the industry's long-term viability. "If successful, it could help build India's green hydrogen industry with benefits for a range of sectors including agriculture, transport and manufacturing," the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis report added. India launched its National Green Hydrogen Mission in January 2023 with an overall outlay of ₹19,744 crores. The country has set an ambitious target of achieving a green hydrogen production capacity of 5 million tonnes by the end of 2030. The programme consists of two distinct financial incentive mechanisms to support domestic electrolyser manufacturing and Green Hydrogen production. The green hydrogen mission, which aims to establish 5 million tonnes of annual green hydrogen production capacity by 2030, represents a significant step towards realising India's ambitions in the hydrogen economy. India meets a sizable portion of its energy needs through fossil fuels, and various renewable energy sources, including green hydrogen, are seen as an avenue to reduce dependence on conventional sources of power. Green energy for climate mitigation is not just a focus area for India; it has gained momentum globally. At COP26 held in 2021, India committed to an ambitious five-part "Panchamrit" pledge. They included reaching 500 GW of non-fossil electricity capacity, generating half of all energy requirements from renewables, and reducing emissions by 1 billion tonnes by 2030. India as a whole also aims to reduce the emissions intensity of GDP by 45 per cent. Finally, India commits to net-zero emissions by 2070.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Cost of green hydrogen in India set to fall by up to 40%: Report
The cost of green hydrogen in India , the country that is aiming big in the renewable energy space, is expected to fall by up to 40 per cent with the support and incentives the government is providing, according to a report by the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis. The levelised cost of green hydrogen in India is seen falling towards ₹260-310 per kg ($3-3.75 per kg). India provides cheap renewable electricity to hydrogen manufacturers, waives Inter-State Transmission Charges for open access, lowers distribution and transmission charges, and lowers the GST rate for hydrogen to 5 per cent. Besides, the report asserts electrolyser manufacturers are projected to achieve a 7-10 per cent reduction in total system costs for the first five years, starting in 2024--₹2,960/kW (USD 36/kW) being the average annual realisable base incentive. "While the green hydrogen scheme is an important step for India, refinements are needed to promote long-term investment and project viability," says the report. The report asserted that India's green hydrogen mission has been enthusiastically received by industry. It added, however, that the scheme needs fine-tuning to attract startups, be competitive for global players and create a supply chain and secure demand to ensure the industry's long-term viability. "If successful, it could help build India's green hydrogen industry with benefits for a range of sectors including agriculture, transport and manufacturing," the Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis report added. India launched its National Green Hydrogen Mission in January 2023 with an overall outlay of ₹19,744 crores. The country has set an ambitious target of achieving a green hydrogen production capacity of 5 million tonnes by the end of 2030. The programme consists of two distinct financial incentive mechanisms to support domestic electrolyser manufacturing and Green Hydrogen production. The green hydrogen mission, which aims to establish 5 million tonnes of annual green hydrogen production capacity by 2030, represents a significant step towards realising India's ambitions in the hydrogen economy. India meets a sizable portion of its energy needs through fossil fuels, and various renewable energy sources, including green hydrogen, are seen as an avenue to reduce dependence on conventional sources of power. Green energy for climate mitigation is not just a focus area for India; it has gained momentum globally. At COP26 held in 2021, India committed to an ambitious five-part "Panchamrit" pledge. They included reaching 500 GW of non-fossil electricity capacity, generating half of all energy requirements from renewables, and reducing emissions by 1 billion tonnes by 2030. India as a whole also aims to reduce the emissions intensity of GDP by 45 per cent. Finally, India commits to net-zero emissions by 2070.
