'Criminal': Elton John condemns UK's AI copyright plans
Creative industries globally are grappling with the legal and ethical implications of AI models that can produce work after being trained on existing material.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants the UK to become an AI superpower and has proposed relaxing copyright laws to allow AI developers to train their models on any material to which they have lawful access.
The proposal would require creators to proactively opt out to stop their work from being used.
The biggest names in the industry, including John, Paul McCartney, Andrew Lloyd Webber and Ed Sheeran, have urged the government to change course, saying the proposal will make it even harder for young people to make a living in the creative industries.
"The danger is for young artists, they haven't got the resources to keep checking or fight big tech," John told the BBC.
"It's criminal and I feel incredibly betrayed.
"A machine ... doesn't have a soul, doesn't have a heart, it doesn't have human feeling, it doesn't have passion. Human beings, when they create something, are doing it ... to bring pleasure to lots of people," he said.
John has sold more than 300 million records across his six-decade career.
A supporter of Starmer's Labour Party, he said he had always sought to support young artists and would continue to fight against the changes.
The government says it is seeking a solution that will enable creative industries and AI companies to flourish.
It said on Sunday it was consulting on measures, would publish an assessment on the economic impact of any move, and would not sign off on anything unless it was "completely satisfied they work for creators".
Britain has long outperformed in the creative industries, with thousands employed in sectors including theatre, film, advertising, publishing and music.
Elton John has accused the British government of "committing theft" by proposing tech firms could train artificial intelligence models on the UK's music and creative output without guaranteeing proper recompense.
Creative industries globally are grappling with the legal and ethical implications of AI models that can produce work after being trained on existing material.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants the UK to become an AI superpower and has proposed relaxing copyright laws to allow AI developers to train their models on any material to which they have lawful access.
The proposal would require creators to proactively opt out to stop their work from being used.
The biggest names in the industry, including John, Paul McCartney, Andrew Lloyd Webber and Ed Sheeran, have urged the government to change course, saying the proposal will make it even harder for young people to make a living in the creative industries.
"The danger is for young artists, they haven't got the resources to keep checking or fight big tech," John told the BBC.
"It's criminal and I feel incredibly betrayed.
"A machine ... doesn't have a soul, doesn't have a heart, it doesn't have human feeling, it doesn't have passion. Human beings, when they create something, are doing it ... to bring pleasure to lots of people," he said.
John has sold more than 300 million records across his six-decade career.
A supporter of Starmer's Labour Party, he said he had always sought to support young artists and would continue to fight against the changes.
The government says it is seeking a solution that will enable creative industries and AI companies to flourish.
It said on Sunday it was consulting on measures, would publish an assessment on the economic impact of any move, and would not sign off on anything unless it was "completely satisfied they work for creators".
Britain has long outperformed in the creative industries, with thousands employed in sectors including theatre, film, advertising, publishing and music.
Elton John has accused the British government of "committing theft" by proposing tech firms could train artificial intelligence models on the UK's music and creative output without guaranteeing proper recompense.
Creative industries globally are grappling with the legal and ethical implications of AI models that can produce work after being trained on existing material.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants the UK to become an AI superpower and has proposed relaxing copyright laws to allow AI developers to train their models on any material to which they have lawful access.
The proposal would require creators to proactively opt out to stop their work from being used.
The biggest names in the industry, including John, Paul McCartney, Andrew Lloyd Webber and Ed Sheeran, have urged the government to change course, saying the proposal will make it even harder for young people to make a living in the creative industries.
"The danger is for young artists, they haven't got the resources to keep checking or fight big tech," John told the BBC.
"It's criminal and I feel incredibly betrayed.
"A machine ... doesn't have a soul, doesn't have a heart, it doesn't have human feeling, it doesn't have passion. Human beings, when they create something, are doing it ... to bring pleasure to lots of people," he said.
John has sold more than 300 million records across his six-decade career.
A supporter of Starmer's Labour Party, he said he had always sought to support young artists and would continue to fight against the changes.
The government says it is seeking a solution that will enable creative industries and AI companies to flourish.
It said on Sunday it was consulting on measures, would publish an assessment on the economic impact of any move, and would not sign off on anything unless it was "completely satisfied they work for creators".
Britain has long outperformed in the creative industries, with thousands employed in sectors including theatre, film, advertising, publishing and music.
Elton John has accused the British government of "committing theft" by proposing tech firms could train artificial intelligence models on the UK's music and creative output without guaranteeing proper recompense.
Creative industries globally are grappling with the legal and ethical implications of AI models that can produce work after being trained on existing material.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer wants the UK to become an AI superpower and has proposed relaxing copyright laws to allow AI developers to train their models on any material to which they have lawful access.
The proposal would require creators to proactively opt out to stop their work from being used.
The biggest names in the industry, including John, Paul McCartney, Andrew Lloyd Webber and Ed Sheeran, have urged the government to change course, saying the proposal will make it even harder for young people to make a living in the creative industries.
"The danger is for young artists, they haven't got the resources to keep checking or fight big tech," John told the BBC.
"It's criminal and I feel incredibly betrayed.
"A machine ... doesn't have a soul, doesn't have a heart, it doesn't have human feeling, it doesn't have passion. Human beings, when they create something, are doing it ... to bring pleasure to lots of people," he said.
John has sold more than 300 million records across his six-decade career.
A supporter of Starmer's Labour Party, he said he had always sought to support young artists and would continue to fight against the changes.
The government says it is seeking a solution that will enable creative industries and AI companies to flourish.
It said on Sunday it was consulting on measures, would publish an assessment on the economic impact of any move, and would not sign off on anything unless it was "completely satisfied they work for creators".
Britain has long outperformed in the creative industries, with thousands employed in sectors including theatre, film, advertising, publishing and music.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Perth Now
8 hours ago
- Perth Now
Man gets Jet2 slogan tattoo
A man tattooed the Jet2 slogan on his right arm. Craig Hicks, an ambulance controller from Telford, West Midlands, England, splashed out £300 to get "Nothing beats a Jet2 holiday", and the airline's logo on his right arm sleeve, because he is a "big fan" of Jet2. The airline's catchy slogan from its advert campaign theme has recently become a global social media craze, with people using it over videos of travel mishaps. He is quoted by The Mirror as saying: "I just thought it's quite topical at the moment, why not? It's just so popular at the moment." The new body art piece completes his "aviation sleeve", which also features a Concorde and a jet engine. And Craig - who is flying with Jet2 to Tenerife, Spain, in December - hopes his Jet2 tattoo can impress the airline enough for him to bag a free flight. He added: "I'll be getting it out on that flight definitely. All my friends keep saying I could get a free holiday out of this! "A freebie would be nice ... "I'm definitely going to show it to Jet2 staff when I next fly with them to Tenerife in December... All my friends and family absolutely love it. "My mum said I was mad." Jet2 has used Jess Glynne's 2015 track, Hold My Hand, in its adverts and on its aircraft for almost 10 years - and Craig loves Jess and the song. He said: "I love Jess Glynne and love that song. I recently flew with Jet2 to Madeira. "I just thought it would be ace to get 'Nothing beats a Jet2 holiday'. "I like Jet2 and thought it would be cool. It's my favourite British airline. I'm definitely a big fan of them. I love everything to do with aviation."
The Advertiser
9 hours ago
- The Advertiser
India's Modi vows to punish Pakistan for future attacks
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has warned Pakistan that India will punish its neighbour if there are future attacks on India as he marked 78 years of independence from British colonial rule. Modi's remarks on Friday come three months after nuclear-armed rivals India and Pakistan engaged in four days of intense fighting, their worst clash in decades. Modi addressed the country from New Delhi's 17th-century, Mughal-era Red Fort, saying India has established a "new normal" that does not differentiate between "terrorists" and those who support terrorism. He said he would not tolerate what he called Islamabad's "nuclear blackmail". "India has decided that it will not tolerate nuclear threats. For a long time, nuclear blackmail had been going on but this blackmail will not be tolerated now," Modi said. There was no immediate response from Pakistan to Modi's remarks. Pakistan previously has rejected India's statements about nuclear blackmail as provocative and inflammatory. However, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday announced the creation of a new "Army Rocket Force Command" to bolster the country's defence capabilities. Sharif made this announcement during a speech marking Independence Day celebrations, but gave no further details. India celebrates its Independence Day one day after Pakistan. The two states came into existence as a result of the bloody partition of British India in 1947. The process sparked some of the worst communal violence the world has seen and left hundreds of thousands dead, and triggered one of the largest human migrations in history. India and Pakistan exchanged tit-for-tat military strikes in May that brought them to the brink of a war. The fighting between the two countries was sparked by an April massacre by gunmen in Indian-controlled Kashmir that killed 26 people, mostly Hindu tourists. India blamed the attack on Pakistan-backed militants. Islamabad denied responsibility while calling for a neutral investigation. Days after the massacre, India launched strikes on Pakistan and said it had hit nine "terrorist infrastructure" sites. Pakistan responded by sending waves of drones into India, as well as missile and artillery bombardments. Dozens of people were killed on both sides until a ceasefire was reached May 10 after US mediation. Modi did not directly mention US President Donald Trump's tariffs on India in his Independence Day speech but said he would not compromise on the agriculture sector, one of the main sticking points in trade negotiations with the US. Earlier in August, Trump imposed a 25 per cent penalty on India in addition to 25 per cent tariffs for buying oil and weapons from Russia. India has resisted US pressure to open its markets to some farm products as Modi's government is unwilling to risk angering farmers, who are a powerful voting bloc. "India will not compromise on interest of farmers," he said. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has warned Pakistan that India will punish its neighbour if there are future attacks on India as he marked 78 years of independence from British colonial rule. Modi's remarks on Friday come three months after nuclear-armed rivals India and Pakistan engaged in four days of intense fighting, their worst clash in decades. Modi addressed the country from New Delhi's 17th-century, Mughal-era Red Fort, saying India has established a "new normal" that does not differentiate between "terrorists" and those who support terrorism. He said he would not tolerate what he called Islamabad's "nuclear blackmail". "India has decided that it will not tolerate nuclear threats. For a long time, nuclear blackmail had been going on but this blackmail will not be tolerated now," Modi said. There was no immediate response from Pakistan to Modi's remarks. Pakistan previously has rejected India's statements about nuclear blackmail as provocative and inflammatory. However, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday announced the creation of a new "Army Rocket Force Command" to bolster the country's defence capabilities. Sharif made this announcement during a speech marking Independence Day celebrations, but gave no further details. India celebrates its Independence Day one day after Pakistan. The two states came into existence as a result of the bloody partition of British India in 1947. The process sparked some of the worst communal violence the world has seen and left hundreds of thousands dead, and triggered one of the largest human migrations in history. India and Pakistan exchanged tit-for-tat military strikes in May that brought them to the brink of a war. The fighting between the two countries was sparked by an April massacre by gunmen in Indian-controlled Kashmir that killed 26 people, mostly Hindu tourists. India blamed the attack on Pakistan-backed militants. Islamabad denied responsibility while calling for a neutral investigation. Days after the massacre, India launched strikes on Pakistan and said it had hit nine "terrorist infrastructure" sites. Pakistan responded by sending waves of drones into India, as well as missile and artillery bombardments. Dozens of people were killed on both sides until a ceasefire was reached May 10 after US mediation. Modi did not directly mention US President Donald Trump's tariffs on India in his Independence Day speech but said he would not compromise on the agriculture sector, one of the main sticking points in trade negotiations with the US. Earlier in August, Trump imposed a 25 per cent penalty on India in addition to 25 per cent tariffs for buying oil and weapons from Russia. India has resisted US pressure to open its markets to some farm products as Modi's government is unwilling to risk angering farmers, who are a powerful voting bloc. "India will not compromise on interest of farmers," he said. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has warned Pakistan that India will punish its neighbour if there are future attacks on India as he marked 78 years of independence from British colonial rule. Modi's remarks on Friday come three months after nuclear-armed rivals India and Pakistan engaged in four days of intense fighting, their worst clash in decades. Modi addressed the country from New Delhi's 17th-century, Mughal-era Red Fort, saying India has established a "new normal" that does not differentiate between "terrorists" and those who support terrorism. He said he would not tolerate what he called Islamabad's "nuclear blackmail". "India has decided that it will not tolerate nuclear threats. For a long time, nuclear blackmail had been going on but this blackmail will not be tolerated now," Modi said. There was no immediate response from Pakistan to Modi's remarks. Pakistan previously has rejected India's statements about nuclear blackmail as provocative and inflammatory. However, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday announced the creation of a new "Army Rocket Force Command" to bolster the country's defence capabilities. Sharif made this announcement during a speech marking Independence Day celebrations, but gave no further details. India celebrates its Independence Day one day after Pakistan. The two states came into existence as a result of the bloody partition of British India in 1947. The process sparked some of the worst communal violence the world has seen and left hundreds of thousands dead, and triggered one of the largest human migrations in history. India and Pakistan exchanged tit-for-tat military strikes in May that brought them to the brink of a war. The fighting between the two countries was sparked by an April massacre by gunmen in Indian-controlled Kashmir that killed 26 people, mostly Hindu tourists. India blamed the attack on Pakistan-backed militants. Islamabad denied responsibility while calling for a neutral investigation. Days after the massacre, India launched strikes on Pakistan and said it had hit nine "terrorist infrastructure" sites. Pakistan responded by sending waves of drones into India, as well as missile and artillery bombardments. Dozens of people were killed on both sides until a ceasefire was reached May 10 after US mediation. Modi did not directly mention US President Donald Trump's tariffs on India in his Independence Day speech but said he would not compromise on the agriculture sector, one of the main sticking points in trade negotiations with the US. Earlier in August, Trump imposed a 25 per cent penalty on India in addition to 25 per cent tariffs for buying oil and weapons from Russia. India has resisted US pressure to open its markets to some farm products as Modi's government is unwilling to risk angering farmers, who are a powerful voting bloc. "India will not compromise on interest of farmers," he said. Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has warned Pakistan that India will punish its neighbour if there are future attacks on India as he marked 78 years of independence from British colonial rule. Modi's remarks on Friday come three months after nuclear-armed rivals India and Pakistan engaged in four days of intense fighting, their worst clash in decades. Modi addressed the country from New Delhi's 17th-century, Mughal-era Red Fort, saying India has established a "new normal" that does not differentiate between "terrorists" and those who support terrorism. He said he would not tolerate what he called Islamabad's "nuclear blackmail". "India has decided that it will not tolerate nuclear threats. For a long time, nuclear blackmail had been going on but this blackmail will not be tolerated now," Modi said. There was no immediate response from Pakistan to Modi's remarks. Pakistan previously has rejected India's statements about nuclear blackmail as provocative and inflammatory. However, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday announced the creation of a new "Army Rocket Force Command" to bolster the country's defence capabilities. Sharif made this announcement during a speech marking Independence Day celebrations, but gave no further details. India celebrates its Independence Day one day after Pakistan. The two states came into existence as a result of the bloody partition of British India in 1947. The process sparked some of the worst communal violence the world has seen and left hundreds of thousands dead, and triggered one of the largest human migrations in history. India and Pakistan exchanged tit-for-tat military strikes in May that brought them to the brink of a war. The fighting between the two countries was sparked by an April massacre by gunmen in Indian-controlled Kashmir that killed 26 people, mostly Hindu tourists. India blamed the attack on Pakistan-backed militants. Islamabad denied responsibility while calling for a neutral investigation. Days after the massacre, India launched strikes on Pakistan and said it had hit nine "terrorist infrastructure" sites. Pakistan responded by sending waves of drones into India, as well as missile and artillery bombardments. Dozens of people were killed on both sides until a ceasefire was reached May 10 after US mediation. Modi did not directly mention US President Donald Trump's tariffs on India in his Independence Day speech but said he would not compromise on the agriculture sector, one of the main sticking points in trade negotiations with the US. Earlier in August, Trump imposed a 25 per cent penalty on India in addition to 25 per cent tariffs for buying oil and weapons from Russia. India has resisted US pressure to open its markets to some farm products as Modi's government is unwilling to risk angering farmers, who are a powerful voting bloc. "India will not compromise on interest of farmers," he said.
West Australian
9 hours ago
- West Australian
India's Modi vows to punish Pakistan for future attacks
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has warned Pakistan that India will punish its neighbour if there are future attacks on India as he marked 78 years of independence from British colonial rule. Modi's remarks on Friday come three months after nuclear-armed rivals India and Pakistan engaged in four days of intense fighting, their worst clash in decades. Modi addressed the country from New Delhi's 17th-century, Mughal-era Red Fort, saying India has established a "new normal" that does not differentiate between "terrorists" and those who support terrorism. He said he would not tolerate what he called Islamabad's "nuclear blackmail". "India has decided that it will not tolerate nuclear threats. For a long time, nuclear blackmail had been going on but this blackmail will not be tolerated now," Modi said. There was no immediate response from Pakistan to Modi's remarks. Pakistan previously has rejected India's statements about nuclear blackmail as provocative and inflammatory. However, Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday announced the creation of a new "Army Rocket Force Command" to bolster the country's defence capabilities. Sharif made this announcement during a speech marking Independence Day celebrations, but gave no further details. India celebrates its Independence Day one day after Pakistan. The two states came into existence as a result of the bloody partition of British India in 1947. The process sparked some of the worst communal violence the world has seen and left hundreds of thousands dead, and triggered one of the largest human migrations in history. India and Pakistan exchanged tit-for-tat military strikes in May that brought them to the brink of a war. The fighting between the two countries was sparked by an April massacre by gunmen in Indian-controlled Kashmir that killed 26 people, mostly Hindu tourists. India blamed the attack on Pakistan-backed militants. Islamabad denied responsibility while calling for a neutral investigation. Days after the massacre, India launched strikes on Pakistan and said it had hit nine "terrorist infrastructure" sites. Pakistan responded by sending waves of drones into India, as well as missile and artillery bombardments. Dozens of people were killed on both sides until a ceasefire was reached May 10 after US mediation. Modi did not directly mention US President Donald Trump's tariffs on India in his Independence Day speech but said he would not compromise on the agriculture sector, one of the main sticking points in trade negotiations with the US. Earlier in August, Trump imposed a 25 per cent penalty on India in addition to 25 per cent tariffs for buying oil and weapons from Russia. India has resisted US pressure to open its markets to some farm products as Modi's government is unwilling to risk angering farmers, who are a powerful voting bloc. "India will not compromise on interest of farmers," he said.
