Funding crunch delays K-IV project
For years, the K-IV project has been viewed as a lifeline for Karachi's residents suffering from chronic water shortages. Yet it appears that the financial and administrative hurdles plaguing the completion of the project are here to stay for another four to five years.
Originally launched in 2016 under the Sindh government and Karachi Water and Sewerage Corporation (KWSC) with an initial PC-1 cost of Rs25 billion, the K-IV project aimed to supply 260 million gallons per day (MGD) to Karachi within two years. However, due to severe mismanagement and design flaws, the project was halted in 2018 after achieving only 20 per cent progress. In 2021, the federal government transferred control of the project to the Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA), which redesigned it, inflating the project cost to Rs126 billion.
Construction resumed in 2022, with a revised completion target of December 2025. A WAPDA official, speaking on the condition of anonymity, confirmed that over 63 percent of the project has been completed, however, due to rising construction material costs, an additional Rs30 billion is required.
"A revised PC-1 has been submitted to the federal government for approval, but the project has reportedly been downgraded from the government's priority list. Against the remaining Rs40 billion requirement, only Rs3.5 billion has been allocated in the current budget, causing work stoppages on two filtration plants and a major pipeline section, while other components are progressing at a sluggish pace," confirmed the official.
Efforts to obtain official comments from WAPDA General Manager (South) and K-IV Project Director Aamir Mughal remained unsuccessful, as repeated attempts to contact his office yielded no response. Reportedly, the core component of the K-IV project involves laying an underground pipeline from Keenjhar Lake to Karachi's Kathore area, supervised by WAPDA. However, three additional critical projects tied to K-IV remain the Sindh government's responsibility.
The first project concerns the augmentation plan. This project, financed through a 260 million US dollars World Bank loan, involves laying approximately 100 kilometers of bulk distribution pipelines within Karachi and connecting them to existing pumping stations. Similarly, the power supply project involves installing a 132-kilovolt transmission line from Jhimpir grid station to the K-IV pumping complex near Keenjhar Lake to provide 50 megawatts power, with an estimated cost of Rs16 billion.
Lastly, the KB feeder canal lining project, spanning 38 miles, aims to rehabilitate and widen the canal from the Indus river to Keenjhar lake, to ensure full quota delivery. A senior KWSC official anonymously confirmed that while official schedules promised completion of these three projects within two years, actual timelines were expected to stretch much longer due to bureaucratic hurdles, utility shifting delays, and complex technical requirements.
Repeated efforts to reach Sindh's Secretary Irrigation, Zareef Khero, for comments remained unanswered, while the concerned Executive Engineer cited his recent appointment as an excuse for his inability to comment at this stage.
According to a survey conducted by the Express Tribune, Karachi's daily water requirement stands at 1,200 million gallons, while the city currently receives only 650 million gallons from the Indus River and Hub Dam, leaving a staggering shortfall of 550 million gallons per day.
The survey also revealed that the KWSC officials, in alleged collusion with the tanker mafia and illegal groundwater extraction networks, have created an artificial water crisis in several areas, including Clifton, Defence, Gulshan-e-Iqbal (13D-2, 13D-3), North Nazimabad, Nazimabad, Liaquatabad, and PECHS.
Despite the critical importance of the K-IV water project to Karachi's future water security, bureaucratic inefficiencies, lack of political will, and severe underfunding continue to jeopardize its timely completion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
11 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Fixing Karachi: Unlocking the Gridlock
Listen to article If there is one thing that repeated financial crises, whether domestic or international, have taught us, it is that financial independence is crucial for the survival of all levels of government. If financial stability does not exist, or if it exists but each level of government is not financially independent, then there lies little possibility for the respective government to continue doing its job. The era of financial dependence has long gone. While one of the largest revenues of the local governments is property taxes or municipal taxes, there is yet another substantial way of generating funds for meeting the needs at the grassroot level. In the financial world, such instruments are called "munis", the short form for municipal bonds. The idea behind municipal bonds is that they provide funds to local governments for development projects at a rate lower than banks would. Essentially, municipal bonds operate very similarly to government bonds (commonly called treasuries) wherein the municipality utilizes its good name as well as its credibility to seek funds from financial institutions as well as the public, who in turn are provided a fixed rate of return with the surety that there is minimal (practically zero) risk of default. Municipal bonds come in two broad types: secured and unsecured. Secured bonds are when an asset of a municipality is pledged for raising funds. Unsecured munis are what they appear to be; that is, they are unsecured to the extent that no specific asset is pledged. However, they do have the guarantee of the municipal government ensuring that the interest payments on the bond will be made and eventually the principal will be returned. Karachi is a humongous city with exceptional potential. It has become a common political comment in drawing rooms and dinner parties that Karachi generates the highest amount of revenue, yet the same is not being spent on the city. I would argue that there is more to this calculation than meets the eye. Suffice it to say at this stage that Karachi does not have the funds at the municipal level to ensure its development and the city is not financially independent. A ray of hope that appeared on the horizon is by virtue of MUCT (Municipal Utility Charges and Taxes) collection through K-Electric bills. This has resulted in a monthly revenue of nearly Rs 200 Million. In the 10 months of the last financial year, KMC received an amount of more than Rs 1.9 Billion as opposed to the previous annual collection of only Rs 155 Million. One must remember that MUCT is not a new tax and had always been in existence. However, there has never been a mechanism to properly collect this levy and realize its potential. The Karachi Metropolitan Corporation, through out-of-the-box thinking and keeping in view the ground realities of the city, partnered with a utility company to ensure recovery of MUCT. This has resulted in major financial gain for KMC, and the results of it can be seen every day around the city in the form of its development projects. Though one may question the quantum of development by KMC compared to the gigantic size of our city, however, after a long time KMC's presence in terms of development as well as rehabilitation appears to be visible and one is hopeful that the same will continue fairly, transparently and equitably. With that being said, the money recovered through MUCT is certainly not enough. Even otherwise, a lot of times money is needed now, whereas the revenue is likely to come in the next 5 to 10 years. That is where the concept of municipal bonds can be a game changer for the city of Karachi. Essentially, what is being proposed is the issuance of bonds to investors. Initially, these may be Pakistani investors. However, subject to regulatory approval, foreign investors may also be included. This will help raise money for funding development projects at very low rates, thereby ensuring financial viability and independence for the city of Karachi. Municipal bonds are utilized across the world in cities like New York, London, Ahmedabad and Pune, among others, to borrow money and fund development projects. India's municipal bond market, although nascent, has raised INR 5000 Crores which have directly translated into development works. Likewise, New York City has for decades funded subway expansions, schools and bridges through muni bonds. Municipal bonds have achieved the same feat for all such cities which have issued them. The precedent is clear. On state level, in Pakistan, the Government of Pakistan regularly issues bonds to local and foreign investors for the purpose of funding its development and day-to-day needs. Hence, while this is a novel idea from the perspective of a local government in Pakistan, it certainly is not new to the financial world. The only differentia between municipal bonds and those issued by the state will be the level of government backing it. They would operate in a similar manner. At its core, this structure would empower Karachi to raise capital independently, enabling it to fund critical infrastructure and development projects without being reliant on federal or provincial handouts. The advantages will be far reaching: fiscal autonomy, timely project execution, public trust of Karachiites, and urban renewal. Bringing such a structure to Karachi through KMC is not just about finance. It is about redefining the city's capacity to shape its own future. The time for bold and systemic solutions is now. While nay sayers may question it by arguing that the Federal Government should be contributing or the Government of Sindh should be funding it since Karachi is the biggest contributor to the national or provincial exchequer, the argument would be futile since nay sayers have to just say "nay" and not account for their sayings. As Mayor, though with some effort, I am able to get funding from the Provincial Government, Federal Government is completely apathetic to the needs of our city and I don't see that lax attitude changing. With such a predicament staring me straight in the eye, one is left with two options: first is to fight incessantly throughout the term and hope for handouts, or secondly to take the driving seat and enhance KMC's own revenue base. Needless to say, that the latter is a more solution oriented approach. It is my firm belief that the only way for the city of Karachi to progress and come at par with international municipalities is by way of financial independence. The concept of municipal bonds as proposed will be a major step in this direction not only for the city of Karachi. But it will also prove to be a benchmark for all other big cities of Pakistan and municipalities. Let us hope that this time around we will not get stuck in petty politics but will rather focus on the bigger picture. This city belongs to all of us, and I hope that people from all quarters will support in this endeavourso that we, Karachites, can realize the immense potential of this unique metropolis. Let me conclude by drawing influence from a Chinese proverb which I am rephrasing as "the best time to act was yesterday, the second-best time is TODAY". It is time we ACT. Writer is serving as the 28th Mayor of Karachi
Business Recorder
12 hours ago
- Business Recorder
World Bank MENAAP official meets Wapda chief
LAHORE: World Bank Practice Manager for Middle East, North Africa, Afghanistan and Pakistan (MENAAP) Husam Mohamed Beides, accompanied by Senior Energy Specialist Gunjan Gautam, Friday called on Chairman Wapda Naveed Asghar Chaudhry and discussed with him the matters relating to World Bank-funded Tarbela 5th Extension and Dasu Hydropower Projects. Member Water Syed Ali Akhtar Shah, GM/PD Dasu HPP Amir Shafiq-ur-Rehman and GM/PD Tarbela 5th Extension Umair Mannan also attended the meeting. It is pertinent to mention that World Bank is providing financial support worth US$1517 million and US$390 million for under-construction Stage-I of Dasu and Tarbela 5th Extension respectively. The World Bank's Practice Manager was given a rundown of the physical progress achieved so far, ongoing construction works, and schedule for completion of key activities on both projects. He was also apprised of the financial progress and monetary requirements for completion of Dasu and Tarbela 5th Extension Hydropower Projects. Speaking on the occasion, Chairman Wapda appreciated the World Bank's contribution for harnessing low-cost, clean and green energy in Pakistan through Wapda projects. He said that Wapda takes pride in being the partner in progress with the World Bank, as the biggest development portfolio of the World Bank in Pakistan relates to Wapda projects. The Chairman expressed the hope that the World Bank-Wapda partnership will further extend in the days to come. Thanking Wapda for arranging the briefing about progress of Dasu and Tarbela 5th Extension Hydropower Projects, World Bank's Practice Manager lauded the efforts made by Wapda for improving the ratio of environment-friendly electricity in the National Grid and mitigating adverse impact of climate change. He said that the World Bank and Wapda will continue exploring avenues for mutual cooperation for hydro development in Pakistan. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Business Recorder
13 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Govt focus on reservoirs minimal despite water woes
ISLAMABAD: Despite the devastating impact of climate change on Pakistan's infrastructure, massive water losses worth billions of dollars and ongoing inter-provincial disputes over water distribution, the government's focus on developing water reservoirs remains minimal. 'The government is working on water reservoirs, but not with the urgency this task demands. We have neither built major reservoirs in the past 40 years nor improved our water usage methods,' said a government official, speaking on condition of anonymity. Pakistan consistently ranked among the top 10 most vulnerable countries to climate change - largely due to the strain on the Indus River system which has been exacerbated by the unilateral withdrawal from the Indus Water Treaty by India in the aftermath of the Pahalgam terror attack and India's insistence that Pakistan is responsible without providing any proof. Water flow in rivers increasing Over 80% of the country's arable land is irrigated by Indus waters. Rising temperatures and recurring heatwaves are expected to intensify water scarcity and worsen drought conditions. According to the Public Sector Development Programme (PSDP) for 2025–26, the government allocated Rs 20 billion for the Dasu Hydropower Project (Stage-I), Rs 3.4 billion for the 1,410 MW Tarbela 5th Extension Hydropower Project, and Rs 500 million for the 54 MW Attabad Lake Hydropower Project. Additionally, funds have been set aside for the refurbishment and upgradation of Mangla Power Station to enhance its capacity from 1,000 MW to 1,310 MW. Rupees 25 billion has been earmarked for the Diamer-Bhasha Dam (including the Tangir Hydropower Project), while Rs 7.78 billion is allocated for land acquisition and resettlement (2nd revised) under the same project. The Mohmand Dam Project (800 MW) has received a substantial allocation of Rs 35.72 billion. The federal government is currently exploring financing options for the $10 billion Diamer-Bhasha Hydropower Project—$8 billion for the dam and $2 billion for the transmission line. Development partners have shown reluctance to commit the required funds. The project, which has an installed capacity of 4,500 MW and a gross storage of 8.1 MAF, is expected to generate 18.1 billion units of electricity annually, plus an additional 2.5 billion units for downstream projects. It is seen as crucial for enhancing energy security, reducing carbon emissions, and addressing water shortages. Last month, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif chaired a high-level meeting where he directed authorities to remove all obstacles hindering the timely completion of the $15 billion Diamer-Bhasha Dam, calling it vital for Pakistan's energy and agricultural security. Officials involved in water infrastructure stress the need for diverting additional financial resources toward reservoir development beyond current commitments. The Water and Power Development Authority (WAPDA), responsible for building and managing dams, estimates that new projects could make an additional 10 million acre-feet (MAF) of water available within 4–5 years. 'With new dams, water availability could rise from the current 13 MAF to 23 MAF per annum,' the former Wapda chairman told a parliamentary panel in January. However, the main challenge remains financing, especially for key reservoirs like Diamer-Bhasha. Pakistan currently has access to 135 MAF of surface water, of which 102 MAF is used for agriculture. Nearly 94% of this water goes to agriculture alone. Experts argue this percentage must be reduced—China, for example, brought it down from over 90% to 60%. Efficient irrigation methods, largely under provincial jurisdiction, have yet to be implemented. While the World Bank has funded efforts such as concrete canal delivery systems, actual progress on the ground remains limited. Command area development activities are underway but remain unsatisfactory. Currently, around 450 million acres of land are irrigated with canal water, which typically faces a 25% supply shortfall. To close this gap, Pakistan needs 15–16 MAF of new storage capacity. However, the Diamer-Bhasha Dam, with a 6.4 MAF capacity, will not be operational until 2029 or 2030—by which time demand could increase to 14–15 MAF. Even then, the DBD would only reduce the shortage from a projected 35% to around 25%. Pakistan is now bearing the consequences of its prolonged inaction on water storage infrastructure. To address financing gaps, the government has approached the Arab Consortium—including the Saudi Fund, Kuwait Fund, OPEC Fund, and the Islamic Development Bank (IsDB)—for support. These institutions previously supported the Mohmand Dam, and securitization of existing assets like the Ghazi Barotha Dam is now being explored to fund DBD. 'IsDB, SFD, and the ADB have been approached to help bridge the $3.5 billion funding gap for DBDP. However, no multilateral development bank has yet stepped up as an anchor financier,' said an official source. 'If Wapda is to secure funding, there are two main options: either the government provides a sovereign guarantee — which is unlikely — or Wapda issues a bond based on its balance sheet. But that's not feasible either, given its Rs 214 billion in receivables from the power sector,' said the source. This receivable is part of the broader issue of circular debt, which undermines Wapda's creditworthiness. Lenders are expected to scrutinize Wapda's repayment capacity before committing funds. The government is also exploring loans secured against operational projects or offering attractive returns to entice investors. Nine out of Pakistan's ten largest cities lie within 50 kilometers of the Indus River. The continued degradation of the Indus Basin presents a looming economic, social, ecological, and demographic threat to the country's development and stability. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
