Court awards RM4.1mil to teen disabled at birth by delayed C-section
Judge Nurulhuda Nuraini Nor ruled that the 16-year-old boy, who now suffers permanent disability and is fully dependent on his mother, had been deprived of timely medical intervention after the doctor failed to perform an urgent C-section promptly.
The boy was awarded RM600,000 in general damages and RM3.5 million for future rehabilitation care, while his mother received RM80,000 for emotional distress and anxiety.
The court also ordered the doctor and the maternity home owner to pay RM100,000 in costs.
In her written judgment, Nurulhuda held the doctor personally liable for breaching his duty of care to both mother and child, and found the owner vicariously liable for the negligence that occurred on their premises.
The mother filed the lawsuit in 2020 on behalf of her son, who was born on Sept 28, 2009, at the privately run maternity clinic in Johor Baru.
According to court documents, she had sought help at the centre around 10am, where the doctor advised a C-section due to the umbilical cord being wrapped around the baby's neck.
However, the surgery was not performed until 7pm, -a delay the court found inexcusable.
The newborn was sent to the Sultanah Aminah Hospital at 5.30am on Oct 1, 2009, after he displayed signs of lethargy, poor sucking reflex, and breathing difficulty.
He was diagnosed with severe hypoglycaemia and infection.
Later assessments confirmed he had suffered irreversible brain damage.
Despite temporary discharge, the baby's condition deteriorated and he was eventually referred to the Kuala Lumpur Hospital, where a consultant child neurologist confirmed the extent of the injury.
The defendants represented by counsel B Thinesh and Raja Eileen Soraya Raja Aman, have since filed an appeal against the decision.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Borneo Post
40 minutes ago
- Borneo Post
Community support helps baby reach fundraising goal for surgery
Dr Jack (fourth right) symbolically hands over the funds raised by the public to Keh Chuong for his daughter Yvonne's upcoming ABI operation, as others look on. MIRI (Aug 5): A remarkable display of community support has enabled 22-month-old Yvonne Paw to receive a life-changing auditory brainstem implant (ABI) operation after fundraising efforts exceeded its target in just seven days. The campaign, which aimed to raise RM95,000 to fund the surgery, was officially closed today after collecting RM100,734.05 — surpassing the target by over RM5,000. The achievement was announced by the Miri City Cochlear Implant Society (MCCIS) on behalf of Piasau assemblyman Datuk Sebastian Ting Chew Yew during a press conference. 'As of Aug 5, the collection has reached RM100,734.05, exceeding our target. Datuk Sebastian has kindly requested that we end the fundraising programme, as we have achieved our goal,' said MCCIS deputy chairman Dr Wong Jack. CT scans at Miri Hospital revealed that Yvonne was born without cochleae in both ears, leaving her profoundly deaf since birth. Due to this rare condition, she is not eligible for the more common cochlear implant. Instead, she requires an ABI, which is specifically designed for patients with absent or damaged cochleae. The total cost of the operation is RM145,000, of which Yvonne's parents —both teachers — had managed to raise RM50,000 before seeking public assistance for the remaining funds. Medical experts advised that the ABI procedure should be carried out before the age of two, making the scheduled surgery on Aug 16, 2025 at Borneo Medical Centre (BMC) in Kuching a race against time. Moved by the family's plea, Ting launched the public fundraising programme with just 18 days to go before the scheduled operation. Yvonne's parents, Paw Keh Chuong and Wong Siew Chin, expressed their deep gratitude and emotion over the overwhelming public response. 'We are so grateful to all those who kindly and generously donated,' said Keh Chuong. 'To achieve the target within seven days is just unbelievable — we would have been grategul even if we achieved this by Aug 16.' Preparations for the surgery are underway. The donated funds were officially handed over by by Dr Jack on behalf of Ting to Yvonne's father at the Sarawak United People's Party (SUPP) Piasau office today, witnessed by MCCIS treasurer Dr Doris Jong and SUPP leaders. Yvonne and her mother will travel to Kuching on Aug 13 for pre-surgery preparations, including an MRI scan on Aug 14. Both parents will take leave from their teaching posts to accompany their daughter through the crucial procedure. Ting, who is currently overseas, issued a statement thanking the public, stating: 'We pray for the very best for baby Yvonne's upcoming surgery. God bless everyone who contributed to the success of this fundraising programme.' With financial concerns now resolved, Yvonne's parents are looking forward to the surgery's success — a gift from the generous Miri community, who have come together to give baby Yvonne the chance to hear for the first time in her life. fund raising hearing implants Sebastian Ting
Borneo Post
11 hours ago
- Borneo Post
RM100,000 aid to improve services, enhance patient care at SGH
Dr Yii (centre) hands over the cheque to SGH director Dr Ngian Hie Ung (right). KUCHING (Aug 5): Bandar Kuching MP Dr Kelvin Yii's parliamentary office has allocated RM100,000 to support critical upgrades at the Sarawak General Hospital (SGH). The Democratic Action Party (DAP) lawmaker said a major portion of this funding will be used to procure 20 new computers. 'Those new devices will be distributed across key departments including the one-stop counter, plastic surgery clinic, emergency department, surgical wards, bed management unit, infection control unit, gynaecology ward, and female medical ward,' he said in a statement yesterday. Dr Yii added that the upgrade will significantly enhance the hospital's digital infrastructure, streamline work processes, and improve service quality for both patients and staff. The allocation will also cover the purchase of 10 chairs for the one-stop counter, two air-conditioning units for the ticketing counter and ID clinic, 50 portable drainage stands (PODS), and four infusion pumps. 'These upgrades are essential to improving the hospital's functionality, ensuring a more comfortable environment for patients and staff, and strengthening SGH's capacity to deliver timely and quality care,' he said. Dr Yii noted that SGH has long been one of the busiest and most vital healthcare institutions in the region, managing a consistently high patient volumes. He also reaffirmed his commitment to continue supporting the hospital's efforts to enhance its facilities services.
Sinar Daily
21 hours ago
- Sinar Daily
Zayn Rayyan not neglected or abused, child psychologist tells court
Dr Noor Aishah Rosli, 49, the founder of the CPC International psychology clinic in Bandar Baru Bangi, confirmed that she had reviewed the reports provided by the defence. 04 Aug 2025 09:46pm Zayn Rayyan Abdul Matin's mother, Ismanira Abdul Manaf appeared at the Sessions Court today. - Bernama photo PETALING JAYA - A child psychologist testified in the Sessions Court today that the late Zayn Rayyan Abdul Matin had not been neglected or abused, as indicated by three medical reports from Selayang Hospital and Sungai Buloh Hospital. Dr Noor Aishah Rosli, 49, the founder of the CPC International psychology clinic in Bandar Baru Bangi, confirmed that she had reviewed the reports provided by the defence. When questioned by lawyer Haresh Mahadevan, Dr Noor Aishah said there was no evidence in the reports suggesting that Zayn Rayyan had suffered neglect or abuse. "The reports show no indication of neglect or abuse," the fifth defence witness said during examination-in-chief in the proceedings of Ismanira Abdul Manaf, who faces charges of child neglect involving Zayn Rayyan. Dr Noor Aishah elaborated on the definition of neglect, explaining that the American Psychiatric Association (APA) outlines various forms, including emotional, physical, and educational neglect. She emphasised that neglect must occur over a consistent period to be classified as such. "If a child misses lunch because the guardian is sick, it wouldn't be considered neglect. "But if the child consistently receives inadequate food and is expected to find food themselves, this could be classified as neglect,' she said. In relation to the amended charge against Ismanira, which refers to neglect causing potential physical injury to the child, Dr Noor Aishah pointed out that the use of the word "likely" in the charge implies uncertainty and does not definitively point to physical injury. When questioned whether the amended charge clearly indicated neglect by the accused, the witness responded that it was not specified in the charge. On July 21, Judge Syahliza Warnoh ordered Ismanira to enter her defence after the prosecution successfully established a prima facie case against the woman, while her husband, Zaim Ikhwan Zahari, 30, was acquitted and discharged. The couple was accused of neglecting their autistic son, Zayn Rayyan, in a manner likely to cause physical injury between noon on Dec 5 and 9.55 pm on Dec 6, 2023, in the vicinity of Block R, Idaman Apartment, Damansara Damai, extending to a nearby river. They were charged under Section 31(1)(a) of the Child Act 2001, read together with Section 34 of the Penal Code, which carries a maximum sentence of 20 years' imprisonment, a fine of up to RM50,000, or both, upon conviction. The trial continues tomorrow. - BERNAMA More Like This
