Row over ‘Sardar Ji 3': trend of cross-border collaborations in Punjabi film industry unlikely to sustain
The film, which has not yet been released in India, is currently collecting huge profits in Pakistan and overseas, once again sparking a debate over the involvement of actors from the neighbouring country in Indian Punjabi films.
Speaking to The Indian Express, Punjabi singer-music director Ravinder Ranguwal said, 'The Punjabi film industry continued casting Pakistani actors, or rather, started featuring them more actively post-2016. All roles involving Pakistani actors were shot overseas.'
A major driver of this collaboration, industry insiders say, is the shared linguistic and cultural heritage between Charda Punjab (East Punjab in India) and Lehnda Punjab (West Punjab in Pakistan). Since both regions speak Punjabi, films that blend talent from both sides enjoy wider acceptability. 'The shared language and culture create an organic appeal in both Punjabs, which naturally enhances commercial success,' Ranguwal added.
However, he admitted that the situation might change now. 'After all the controversies that followed the Pahalgam terror attack, I don't think the Punjabi industry will cast Pakistani actors in future projects. Films that had already been signed are a different matter altogether, given the financial stakes involved,' he said.
The Chal Mera Putt franchise stands as a prime example of this trend. The first instalment, released in 2019, was a blockbuster and featured Pakistani actors like Iftikhar Thakur, Nasir Chinyoti, and Akram Udas in prominent roles. Its success was followed by Chal Mera Putt 2 (2020) and Chal Mera Putt 3 (2021), both of which included even more Pakistani talent and enjoyed massive popularity, particularly among the Punjabi diaspora in both countries and overseas.
According to an announcement made earlier this year, Chal Mera Putt 4 is scheduled for release in August, but with growing scrutiny of cross-border collaborations, the filmmakers have yet to disclose whether any changes have been made to the cast.
Besides this franchise, several other Punjabi films in recent years — including Maa Da Ladla, Honeymoon, and Carry on Jatta 3 — have featured Pakistani actors in significant roles. In fact, in the last four to five years, blending artists from both sides of Punjab had almost become a norm in the industry.
Now, with Sardar Ji 3 facing potential non-release in India due to its Pakistani cast, concerns are being raised about whether Chal Mera Putt 3 will meet the same fate. The film reportedly features an even more extensive lineup of Pakistani actors than the Dosanjh movie.
Following the Pahalgam attack, actor Iftikhar Thakur — one of the most celebrated Pakistani comedians involved in cross-border Punjabi films — had allegedly made controversial remarks directed at India, prompting a fresh wave of criticism. 'There's no shortage of talent in Punjab. We don't necessarily need to rely on Pakistani actors to make successful films,' Ranguwal had said then.
While the shared language and commercial potential of such collaborations have been key motivators, industry voices now question whether Punjabi cinema should follow Bollywood's path in phasing out Pakistani actors altogether. 'Even Hindi films are widely watched in Pakistan. So, if Bollywood can thrive without casting Pakistani actors, Punjabi cinema can also evolve with local talent,' said an insider from the Punjabi industry.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Mint
an hour ago
- Mint
Social media backlash no hurdle for OTT success as trashed titles grab top viewership spots
OTT (over-the-top) platforms are increasingly finding that social media backlash doesn't necessarily hurt viewership. Shows like The Royals and Nadaaniyan, which faced heavy trolling online, have emerged among the top streaming originals in Ormax Media's mid-year list, with 15.5 million and 8.9 million viewers, respectively. Further, varying consumer tastes are often not adequately reflected in social media algorithms, where there might actually be an audience base for what some consider unwatchable. 'Social media chatter about long-form content, be it theatrical, streaming or linear television, can be misleading, because you can find yourself in an echo chamber that is not even remotely reflective of the real world," Shailesh Kapoor, founder and chief executive officer (CEO), Ormax Media, wrote in a blog after publication of the list. Nitin Gupta, chief creative officer, Chaupal, a platform specializing in Punjabi, Haryanvi and Bhojpuri content, agreed that social media trolling does not always lead to a drop in viewership. 'In fact, sometimes it creates a sense of Fomo (fear of missing out) among audiences, even those who criticize the content. Trolling often becomes part of a larger conversation. It highlights areas that may need improvement but also brings more attention to the show," Gupta added. Backlash may help viewership Outrage on X or Instagram is loud, but it's rarely a perfect proxy for actual viewing behaviour, according to entertainment industry experts. Neelesh Pednekar, co-founder and head of digital media at Social Pill, a digital marketing agency, said the people who binge eight episodes on a weekend are not the same cohort crafting 20-thread takedowns. 'OTT platforms optimise for completion rates, watch hours, and repeat sessions, metrics that don't necessarily dip because a show is being roasted online. In many cases, backlash plateaus after 48-72 hours, while the title keeps quietly pulling steady (or even growing) streams. Unless the controversy hits a moral red line, such as calls for boycotts that spill into mainstream press, the impact is usually noise, not net loss," Pednekar added. Further, most OTTs have a playbook now which includes sentiment dashboards and social listening to separate genuine concerns from performative outrage, targeted public relations and creator outreach, such as giving interviews to the right journalists, seeding nuanced explainers and pushing 'making-of" content to shift the narrative. They may also attempt product-side tweaks such as changing tiles or thumbnails, re-cutting trailers, or altering synopsis language to reset expectations. Charu Malhotra, managing director and co-founder, Primus Partners, a management consultancy firm pointed out that in many cases, trolling ends up becoming free marketing. Controversy sparks curiosity and that is a real behaviour on OTT. When a show is being talked about, even negatively, people are more likely to check it out just to see what the trolling is about. For example, a show like Indian Matchmaking turned into a major online discussion point, mainly because of the social media criticism. Controversy mongers A lot of online outrage can stem from bad faith, Aparna Ramachandran, head–digital originals, Balaji Telefilms Ltd, said. Some individuals create outrage simply to increase their own online visibility or position themselves as opinion-makers by targeting major media brands. 'Therefore, it's essential to understand audience bias and parse through the noise for valuable signals. Platforms look for clear indicators—such as genuine criticism or a disconnect with the content or the brand—to determine their next steps," Ramachandran said, adding content typically has a long tail—its value is often recognized over time as it becomes part of larger conversations and cultural moments. Not all shows have benefited from controversies. Netflix's Leila, for example, set in a dystopian future with the world ruled by a totalitarian regime, didn't spark interest. To be sure, even as Indian OTT platforms navigate extreme criticism through a combination of strategies, most also provide age ratings and content warnings to help viewers make informed decisions about the content they consume. Some platforms have introduced self-regulation mechanisms to govern their content and address viewer concerns. Rajat Agrawal, chief operating officer (COO), Ultra Media & Entertainment Group that owns OTT platform Ultra Jhakaas, said, on one hand, excessive trolling can create a toxic environment around a show or film, making it less appealing to audiences. But on the positive side, trolling can sometimes generate buzz and increase curiosity as well. "We've seen titles, on our platform and elsewhere, benefit from what I call 'controversy curiosity'. In today's digital age, where everyone's forming opinions in real time, the algorithm rewards engagement, whether it's outrage or excitement. Sometimes, the best marketing is accidental controversy. That said, the content must ultimately deliver; if it doesn't, the spike is short-lived. But if the storytelling has merit, trolling ironically ends up being free publicity," said Kaushik Das, founder and CEO, AAO NXT, an Odia language platform. As far as regional platforms and shows go, controversial subjects do not spark as much debate because the viewer base is limited. Titles on bigger platforms are usually trolled online.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
How the centuries-old Jodidara tradition is fading in Himachal's Trans-Giri region
Netr Singh, 47, is the second eldest of four brothers. His elder brother, Suren Singh, 50, and younger brother, Chamel Negi, had left their native village of Shillai—tucked in the Giripar region dominated by the Hatti community—for the defence services and a private job, respectively. When it was time for their marriages, the family elders wanted to follow the traditional Jodidara system, in which brothers share a common wife. But Suren and Chamel, citing the transferable nature of their jobs, declined. Eventually, only Netr and his younger brother, Shanti Ram, married Anchal Devi under Jodidara rituals. The wedding took place on April 19, 2005. Netr now looks after the family's farmland and cattle, while Shanti Ram runs a small karyana shop near the Thari Devi shrine in Shillai, 200 km from Shimla. The Giripar region covers a large part of Himachal's Sirmour district—including Shillai, Stone, Kamru, Rajban, parts of Renuka Ji and Paonta Sahib—and stretches into neighbouring Uttarakhand's Hatti-dominated belt. It is named after the Giri river, which originates in Shimla district, runs through Sirmour, and meets the Yamuna at Paonta Sahib. The land across the river is known as Giripar. 'By the time I married under Jodidara, things had already begun changing,' Netr told The Indian Express, flipping through his wedding album. 'Now, if ten marriages happen, only one might follow the tradition—and in a modest way. The eldest brother alone shares the stage with the bride and takes the saat phere. Only his horoscope is matched with hers.' The album cover reads: Wedding: Netr Sang Aanchal (Netr with Aanchal). A large photo of Netr in a sehra with bride Aanchal is flanked by a smaller one showing Shanti Ram with her. The couple has five children—three daughters, Vanshika, Mehak and Dikshu, listed under Netr's name in official records, and one son, Naveen, under Shanti Ram's. All bear their mother's name, Anchal Devi, renamed Balma Devi after marriage. One child was later adopted by Suren Singh. Both Suren and Chamel now live outside the Giripar region and visit Shillai only occasionally. Over the years, Netr has seen more Hattis—especially those working away from home—move away from Jodidara. His own wooden, hill-style home lies downhill from that of Pradeep and Kapil Negi, two brothers who married the same woman, Sunita Chauhan from nearby Kunhat, on July 11 this year, keeping the polyandry tradition alive. Videos from their wedding went viral on social media. Local priest Mohi Ram Sharma, 63, from Bhangata village, said, 'Such marriages are rare now. Times have changed. Many brothers who marry the same woman later separate, leaving her with either the elder or one of the younger brothers. Even in my family, Jodidara has broken down.' He added, 'The recent marriage in Shillai happened after nearly four years. The last such wedding I recall was three or four years ago in a nearby village. I don't know if that one survived.' Jodidara—a form of fraternal polyandry—has long been part of Hatti tribal culture in the Trans-Giri region of Himachal Pradesh and adjoining Uttarakhand. It is believed to have evolved to prevent division of ancestral land and maintain unity among brothers in the harsh, mountainous terrain. In the Hatti wedding tradition, called Jajda, the bride arrives in a procession, where rituals like Seenj are performed. A priest chants mantras, sprinkles holy water, and offers jaggery as a blessing from the family deity. Ramo Devi, 79, a widow once married to three brothers, summed it up: 'It all depends on rajamandi (mutual consent). Agar rajamandi sachi hai to Jodidari nibh jayegi (If there is genuine consent, it works. If not, it fails).' Kapil Chand, an office-bearer of the Kendriya Hatti Samiti—which led the push for Scheduled Tribe (ST) status for the Hattis in 2024—said, 'Jodidara helped us gain ST recognition. It was a social strategy to combat poverty, prevent land fragmentation, and keep families united. Shillai was once called the kala-pani of Himachal for its remoteness. Even today, it lags behind other backward areas like Bharmour, Pangi, or Kinnaur.' A 2025 study by sociologists Shiv Kumar and Thakur Prem Kumar, published in the Journal of Neonatal Surgery, links Jodidara's decline to higher education and new job opportunities. 'Youngsters work in cities or abroad. They fear being mocked,' said Sharma. Himachal Industries Minister Harshwardhan Chauhan, who represents Shillai in the Assembly, acknowledged that polyandry is 'declining with time.' Echoing him, senior local BJP leader Baldev Singh Tomar—himself from the Hatti community—said, 'Jodidara and Jamindara (landlordism) were linked. Jodidara prevented division of land in this once-poor area. Under Jamindara, work was divided: one brother farmed, another tended cows, another goats. The aim was to keep the family strong as a united joint unit.' Tomar, whose three grandfathers all married under Jodidara, added: 'Our immediate family still has around 68 members. It's rare today, but if it happens, people here don't frown upon it. In fact, they watch with interest to see if the marriage will work—or if one brother will marry separately.'
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
Punjab Grill Opens In Chandigarh: It's A Royal North Indian Feast You Shouldn't Miss
I have always felt that Chandigarh, my hometown, offers the best north Indian cuisine, especially Punjabi food. So, I was thrilled to hear that Punjab Grill-a name synonymous with luxury dining-finally opened its first outlet in Chandigarh at Nexus Elante Mall. Naturally, I had to be among the first to experience it, and the visit did not disappoint. I was quite impressed with the interiors; it was rich yet contemporary decor with warm lighting, echoing Punjab's grandeur but with a modern touch. The attentive service immediately made the experience feel premium, just as I had expected from Punjab Grill's legacy. The meal began with shorbas- both chicken and mutton. Served piping hot, these soups were hearty, flavourful, and generously filled with chunks of meat, making them almost a meal on their own. Curious to try something offbeat, I sampled the Salmon Tikka. It's not a dish that will appeal to everyone; the subtle rawness of the salmon is an acquired taste, but I appreciated the kitchen's attempt at experimentation. In contrast, the classic kebabs lived up to their reputation- succulent, well-spiced, and cooked to perfection. The Dahi ke Kebab followed and turned out to be a star appetiser- crispy on the outside, meltingly soft inside, with a tangy-savoury flavour that lingered. Among the mains, the iconic Dal Tadka and Pindi Chana Masala were slightly salt-heavy, though otherwise robust in flavour. The Palak Chironji and Mushroom Tadka stood out for their unique, earthy taste-a refreshing twist to traditional greens. And of course, the classic Mutton Gosht Biryani was everything you'd expect from Punjab Grill- rich and indulgent. For dessert, the Gulab Jamun arrived in an unexpected avatar with multiple flavour options. It was easily one of the best versions I've had-delicate, soft, and not overly sweet, ending the meal on a high note. Kulfi falooda was also a great dish to end the meal with. Drinks too deserve a mention. The Chocolate Strawberry Shake was excellent, balancing indulgence with freshness. I also tried Rola Cola after my meal, and it was the perfect digestive drink, packed with a punch of lip-smacking flavours. Overall, Punjab Grill's Chandigarh debut is a perfect blend of tradition, innovation, and opulence. While just a couple of dishes could use fine-tuning, the overall meal was delicious and the experience was immersive and memorable. For anyone in the city craving authentic North Indian flavours with a luxe twist, Punjab Grill is bound to become a go-to destination.
