
Music trade bodies accuse BBC of ‘arbitrary' changes after Bob Vylan Glastonbury set
There is serious concern among artists and music agencies over a BBC decision that means any musical performances deemed to be high risk will not be broadcast live or streamed live.
The BBC came under pressure from the government after it did not cut a Glastonbury livestream that showed Bobby Vylan, whose real name is Pascal Robinson-Foster, leading chants of 'death, death to the IDF', referring to the Israel Defense Forces.
The performance was never shown on terrestrial television, but viewers could have seen it via an on-demand livestream on iPlayer, where it was available for five hours. The BBC's director general, Tim Davie, and chair, Samir Shah, have apologised and disciplinary action is expected for some of those directly involved.
However, music industry insiders said the corporation has seriously overreacted, pointing to the fact that extensive Glastonbury coverage has been running for years without serious incident. Several also cited free speech concerns for artists.
David Martin, the head of the Featured Artists Coalition (FAC), the UK trade body representing music artists, called for a rethink and said it was a moment for 'cool heads and an even-handed approach'.
'The BBC is absolutely fundamental to the continued success of British music, and particularly vital to supporting our new and emerging artists' development,' he said.
'The FAC wholeheartedly supports the network's remit for public service broadcasting, something which is encapsulated by their Glastonbury coverage. That remit also comes with responsibilities. The BBC is rightly held to the highest regulatory, legal and editorial standards. If those standards have been breached, then there should be appropriate guidelines to follow.
'But the idea of preemptively grading artists according to their 'risk' factor feels arbitrary and disproportionate – and a dangerous step towards censorship. That kind of approach could potentially curtail artistic freedom around certain genres and inadvertently punish those who are simply expressing their views. It's a road I think we should resist going down.
'Live music is incredibly important to the UK. It provides entertainment and cultural capital. But it's also an art form, and our performers should be free to challenge, provoke and take risks.'
Naomi Pohl, the general secretary of the Musicians' Union, said she was very concerned by the BBC's decision to be more cautious about live music broadcasts.
'We really don't want to see the BBC broadcasting fewer live events,' she said. 'It's such a shame there has been this shadow cast over this year's Glastonbury coverage, because it has had fantastic viewing figures. It's been all over iPlayer and people have been tuning in live.
'We need to talk to the BBC about it directly. But I don't want to see any broadcasters now broadcasting fewer live events because they don't want to take the risk. The whole of the music industry will be feeling that, because it's so crucial to us to have the BBC.'
The BBC's decision came after significant political pressure. Lisa Nandy, the culture secretary, said the incident – together with other BBC issues over Gaza coverage – could be 'a problem of leadership'. Davie currently has the support of the BBC board.
There is frustration among some in the BBC that the number of people who actually saw the Bob Vylan broadcast was very small. Others say editorial cuts have aggravated issues around the monitoring of live streams.
A BBC spokesperson said: 'We will continue to bring audiences a range of music performances, both live and on-demand, and we respect artists' freedom of expression. However, Bob Vylan's offensive and deplorable behaviour on one of our Glastonbury live streams was completely unacceptable and we are sorry it appeared on the BBC.
'This is why we have made immediate changes to livestreaming music events, and these alongside our editorial guidelines will shape our plans going forward.'

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Mark Wright 'signs up for much-loved television show' with cast rumoured to include Molly-Mae Hague and JoJo Siwa - three months after the birth of his first child with Michelle Keegan
Mark Wright has reportedly agreed to appear on the next instalment of Celebrity Bake Off. The reality TV star, 38, will be joining a star-studded cast on the much-loved Channel 4 show, with Molly-Mae Mague and JoJo Siwa two of the celebrities rumoured to have signed up. If the speculation is true, it would mark the radio host's first television appearance since the birth of his daughter Palma Elizabeth in March, who he shares with wife Michelle Keegan. Filming for the show, which is set to air next year, is believed to have already finished. A source told The Sun: 'Mark has had his hands full being a new dad but he found time to film for the new series of Celebrity Bake Off. 'It's a cause close to Mark's heart as it's all for the Stand Up Cancer charity and he is a big fan of the show. 'It won't air until next year so fans will have to wait a good few months to find out how he fares in the tent.' After the most recent series of Celebrity Bake Off finished in March, speculation about the possible cast for next year's follow-up has been rife. While both Molly-Mae and JoJo have been rumoured to enter the tent, Babatunde Aleshe was the latest star to have reportedly signed up last month. The 38-year-old previously featured on I'm A Celeb in 2022. A TV insider told The Sun: 'Babatunde is guaranteed to be hilarious and will no doubt have plenty of banter with Paul, Noel, Caroline and Alison. 'He's not known for his prowess in the kitchen so there's sure to be some panicky moments laced with the good humour he's known for. 'His energy on the Gogglebox sofa has always been pure positivity and very infectious, and bosses are hoping he'll bring that to the tent.' Former Love Island star and influencer extraordinaire Molly-Mae's rumoured inclusion would mark her long-awaited return to reality TV. A source seemingly confirmed speculation about her appearing on the show, saying: 'She will be a great addition to the line-up and bring a healthy helping of Love island glamour to the tent. 'Molly's now one of Britain's biggest TV stars and has seen her fame steadily grow since she first appeared on the ITV dating show back in 2019.' Mark's decision to join Molly, JoJo and Babatunde in the tent comes after 'the biggest achievement of his life', welcoming his new-born with Michelle, 38. Having married in 2015, it wasn't until a decade later in March of this year that the couple announced the birth of their first-born. It's thought that they chose the name Palma because of their strong links to Mallorca, which has been their go-to holiday destination for years and the setting of their pregnancy reveal photoshoot. Appearing on his Heart Breakfast show with Olly Murs a few days after his daughter's birth, Mark recalled the moment he got to hold her for the first time. The former TOWIE star said: 'Mate, it's actually hard to put into words. 'It's the biggest achievement of my life it's all I think about but obviously, hats go off to my wife she is an absolute superhuman, a superhero for bringing this baby into the world.' Sharing his appreciation for Michelle, he added: 'It makes you realise what our mums did for us and makes me have so much more respect than I already had and what women had to go through. 'It's the best feeling in the world. I wake up every morning just so excited to see her face.' He continued: 'That moment when I held her in my arms, it gets me emotional now thinking about it. 'I suppose everything else goes out the window and its made me realise what life is all about and my little baby Palma I love you so much and I can't wait to spend the rest of my life with you.


BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Free activities every night of summer holidays across Sefton parks
A range of free events for young people are being rolled out across Sefton's parks every night over the summer Park Nights activities include inflatable sports, archery, kin ball, which is a team game played with a large ball, along with crazy golf, go-karts and have been put on by Sefton Council and run from 17:00 to 19:00 BST throughout the week across parks in Birkdale, Bootle, Crosby, Formby, Litherland, Maghull, Netherton and Southport.A council spokesperson said: "Sessions will take place in parks across Sefton, offering a fantastic way for young people to stay active, try new sports, and enjoy the summer evenings." The free activities, which run until 29 August, are being put on as part of the authority's Active Sefton change weekly and are weather dependent, the council said. Locations Park Nights activities will take place at:Duke Street in Formby and Marian Gardens in Netherton from 17:00 to 19:00 BST every Monday, with the exception of Monday 25 AugustKirkstone Park in Litherland and Bedford Park in Birkdale from 17:00 to 19:00 BST on TuesdayKing George V in Maghull and Linacre Bridge Community Hub in Bootle from 17:00 to 19:00 BST on Wednesday Poets Park in Bootle and Hesketh Park in Southport from 17:00 to 19:00 BST on ThursdayCanning Road Recreation Ground in Southport and Coronation Park in Crosby from 17:00 to 19:00 BST on Friday Listen to the best of BBC Radio Merseyside on Sounds and follow BBC Merseyside on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.


BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
'Scarborough Open Air Theatre told me to bring sun cream then confiscated it'
On a scorching hot weekend in June, Leanne Fish prepared to dance the evening away at Scarborough Open Air 39-year-old, from Hull, was a regular at the venue and this time had booked to see electronic duo Basement temperatures set to reach 25 degrees, the theatre posted to Instagram, reminding concert goers to pack sunglasses and sun arrived on 21 June, armed with her factor 30 - only to be asked to hand it over by security staff. "Being fair-skinned and previously being diagnosed with cancer, I take things like that a little bit more seriously," Leanne said."I always take my sun cream everywhere anyway."Once at the venue, security did the usual routine of checking bags, but stopped Leanne when they found her sun cream."He said 'oh you can't take it in' and I replied, 'well why can't I take it in?'," Leanne said."He told me it's not allowed, it's on the prohibited items list."He took it off me, I wasn't allowed to go in with it." Upset by the situation, Leanne messaged her dad, Steve Fish, once she got inside. "I was straight on the phone to Scarborough Open Air Theatre and the lady on the phone said it was down to the security," he said."I was annoyed about it on the day because the sun cream just goes in a bin apparently, so it's just a waste of money."Steve believed the sun cream could have been mistaken for a spray or aerosol and that was the reason for its removal. "The security guys maybe need a little bit more training to identify what is and what isn't a spray," he added.A spokesperson for Scarborough Open Air Theatre confirmed sun cream was not on the prohibited items added all security teams had been "thoroughly briefed" on what was and what was not a prohibited item and they were looking into Leanne's complaint. Leanne is due to return to the venue in August for a Will Smith concert, but said she was worried the same thing would happen again."I'll be in the seated section this time, so I'll be sat in the sunny area of the arena," she said."If the sun's out and it's warm, I'm going to need sun cream."When they specifically put out a safety message, you go through the gate and they take it off you, it's ridiculous."The venue said the management team would speak to Leanne about her experience and "ensure her next visit to Scarborough OAT is a pleasurable one for both her and her family". "Just to reiterate, sun cream is not a prohibited item at the venue and Leanne should 100% bring this with her to the concert she is attending in August," a spokesperson said. Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.