&w=3840&q=100)
'Commercialisation of citizenship': Malta's ‘golden passport' is illegal, rules EU top court
Europe's highest court on Tuesday struck down Malta's controversial 'golden passport' programme, ruling that it breached EU law by allowing individuals to effectively buy citizenship through investment, according to a report read more
Maltese passports are seen in this illustration taken April 29, 2025. Reuters File
Europe's highest court on Tuesday struck down Malta's controversial 'golden passport' programme, ruling that it breached EU law by allowing individuals to effectively buy citizenship through investment.
According to a Politico report, the European Commission had launched legal proceedings against Malta in 2022 over the scheme giving foreigners a Maltese — and therefore European Union — passport in exchange for a one-off investment of at least €600,000.
In its ruling, the Court of Justice of the European Union called the programme a 'commercialisation' of EU citizenship that undermined the principles of 'good faith' and 'mutual trust' among member states, added the report.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Though Malta suspended the scheme for Russian and Belarusian nationals after the Ukraine invasion, earlier beneficiaries reportedly included sanctioned Russian oligarchs, according to media reports.
Malta's government said it would comply with Tuesday's ruling and update its laws accordingly, reported Politico, citing local media.
'As always, the government of Malta respects the decisions of the courts,' Politico quoted the government as saying in a statement.
'At this moment the legal implications of this judgment are being studied in detail, so that the regulatory framework on citizenship can then be brought in line with the principles outlined in the judgment,' the statement added.
The Maltese government added that past recipients of the scheme would not be affected and said the scheme had raised hundreds of millions of euros.
A spokesperson for the Commission welcomed the ruling.
'European citizenship is not for sale,' Politico quoted the spokesperson as saying on Tuesday.
'We expect Malta to comply with this decision and apply it accordingly,' the spokesperson added.
The spokesperson urged the abolition of all similar citizenship-by-investment schemes across the EU.
While Cyprus and Bulgaria have already discontinued their golden passport programmes —Cyprus even revoking several, mostly issued to Russian nationals — the court's ruling was welcomed by NGOs as a major step toward closing loopholes in EU citizenship policies.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
'Today's judgment confirms that member states cannot commodify EU citizenship and operate reckless golden passport programmes,' Politico quoted Transparency International CEO Maíra Martini as saying in a statement.
Former Maltese Prime Minister Joseph Muscat, who launched the golden passport scheme in 2014, dismissed Tuesday's court ruling as politically driven.
In a Facebook post, he accused European Parliament President Roberta Metsola of 'working against our country.'
Muscat is currently facing prosecution in Malta over alleged corruption.
With inputs from agencies
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
41 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘Zelensky Gave Putin Reason To Bomb…': Trump Stuns Ukraine Amid Russian Attacks
/ Jun 07, 2025, 10:19AM IST U.S. President Donald Trump strongly criticised Ukraine following a wave of Russian attacks, blaming Kyiv's recent drone strikes on Russian nuclear-capable airbases for escalating the conflict. He stated that President Volodymyr Zelensky gave Vladimir Putin 'a reason to bomb Ukraine,' expressing clear disapproval of Ukraine's military strategy. Trump said he "didn't like" the escalation and warned that the strikes could justify a harsher Russian response. Ukrainian forces had targeted several Russian airfields last week, actions Trump suggested triggered the intensified assault.
NDTV
42 minutes ago
- NDTV
Starlink Plans Yet To Be Out In India, A Look At Pricing In Other Nations
Elon Musk's satellite communication company Starlink has received the licence from the Department of Telecommunications (DoT), a key milestone that will take it closer towards launching commercial operations in India. It is the third firm, after Eutelsat OneWeb and Jio Satellite Communications, to have been issued the licence to provide satellite internet services in the country. A fourth applicant, Amazon's Kuiper, is awaiting approval. According to DoT sources, the satellite-based internet service provider owned by billionaire Elon Musk will begin operations in India within 12 months by offering 600 to 700 Gbps, or gigabytes per second, of bandwidth. While the pricing for the low-Earth-orbit satellite internet service is yet to be announced in India, where data prices are currently among the cheapest in the world, former Starlink India Country Director Sanjay Bhargava said in 2022 that it would cost Rs 1.58 lakh per connection for the first year. From the second year, the cost would reduce to Rs 1.15 lakh, he said. Currently, Starlink has its market in over 100 countries, with residential and roaming plans. The residential plan, in most places, is categorised into two - Residential Lite (for low usage, smaller households) and Residential (for bigger households). According to business news website TechCentral, Zambia is one of the cheapest countries for Starlink satellite internet services in the world and the US, most expensive. Here is a look at Starlink's monthly pricing across countries: In Asia, Starlink is mostly available in Mongolia, Japan, Philippines, Malaysia, Indonesia, Jordan, Yemen and Azerbaijan. None of India's neighbours, except Bhutan and Bangladesh, have access to this internet service. In Bhutan, the Residential Lite Plan costs about Rs 3,000 and Standard Residential Plan about Rs 4,200. In Bangladesh, the Residential Lite costs nearly Rs 3,000 and the Residential plan costs Rs 4,000. Malaysia offers the Residential Lite plan for around Rs 2,600 and Residential plan for around Rs 4,600. The internet service is available for nearly Rs 4,000 in Japan and nearly Rs 6,000 in the Philippines. In America, the internet service has been launched in almost every country, except a few places like Bolivia and Venezuela. The Residential Lite costs around Rs 2,500 and the Residential, Rs 4,000 in New York. In Canada, the first one is available for Rs 6,800 and the second, for nearly Rs 9,000. Similarly, Starlink services are available in a majority of European countries, barring Bosnia, Ukraine, and Herzegovina, and Serbia. In France, the Residential Lite costs Rs 2,800 and the Residential plan, nearly Rs 4,000. The United Kingdom currently offers only the Residential plan for approximately Rs 8,700. The Residential Lite and Residential plans are available in Italy for Rs 3,400 and nearly Rs 5,000, respectively. Niger, Sierra Leone, Liberia, Zimbabwe and Mozambique are among the few African nations currently offering Starlink services. The Residential Lite is available for around Rs 4,000, and the Residential for around Rs 6,000 in Ghana. Nearly all of Australia and New Zealand are covered by the internet service provider.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
How Indian export businesses are using AI to stay ahead on global tax rules
Live Events Indian organisations have long embraced Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning technologies in various aspects to achieve their business goals. Now, they are actively exploring ways to implement these advancements responsibly and profitably. This goal closely aligns with the Digital India initiative , launched in 2015 to build a next-generation empowered many measures, the country is steadily progressing toward this vision, with its digital economy projected to contribute nearly one-fifth of the nation's GDP by 2030. This shift holds significant potential for businesses operating domestically, as well as for those planning to expand into global markets.. However, they must address regulatory compliance, cross-border taxation, and evolving trade policies to navigate international trade these concerns, many organisations are turning to technology-driven tax solutions. A recent survey stated that 92% of companies have adopted or planned to implement digital tax platforms within the next five years. Moreover, over half are actively integrating AI-driven technologies to streamline tax functions, paving the way for a smarter, more automated compliance constant stress of creating a tax-transparent and globally connected trade environment has driven Indian exporters to seek the best-in-class solutions. This stress arises from the multilayered regulations they need to tackle from the outset. In the US, for instance, tax compliance becomes challenging due to the multijurisdictional nature of sales tax. Each state imposes their own rates and economic nexus laws requiring businesses to collect and remit sales tax once they exceed certain revenue thresholds, even if the company has no physical presence there are over 13,000 sales and use tax jurisdictions in the US with their policies and deadlines. Similarly, the VAT system in the European Union (EU) has its own set of requirements. An Indian exporter selling across member states may need to charge different VAT rates based on the product type and the buyer's location, leading to a convoluted network of compliance responsibilities. This can be overwhelming, especially as compliance errors can lead to penalties and disruptions in overcome this, AI-powered tax systems offer an integrated solution that consolidates tax laws from multiple jurisdictions, automating calculations, filings, and regulatory updates. By reducing manual efforts and decreasing the risk of errors, AI helps exporters redirect their focus from regulatory burdens to strategic AI-enabled platforms can help track real-time transactions, proactively flagging potential issues before filing returns. For example, if an Indian exporter selling apparel online approaches California's economic nexus threshold of $500,000 in sales, AI systems can alert the business to register for sales tax in that utilizing ML algorithms, AI can also predict future tax liabilities based on historical data and projections, helping businesses avoid unforeseen tax burdens. Simultaneously, AI and ML make accessing and interpreting vast amounts of tax data stored in the cloud easier. AI-driven platforms can source and structure this data, helping businesses understand what has changed, track new tax rates, and automatically find the correct rates for each product and line with this, companies are increasingly adopting advanced technologies, such as GenAI, blockchain, and data analytics, to revolutionise their tax to recent studies, 87% of tax and finance professionals believe GenAI will significantly enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of their operations. GenAI helps businesses automate complex tax-related processes, such as generating accurate tax reports, predicting potential liabilities, and identifying discrepancies across jurisdictions. This allows organisations to swiftly adapt to regulatory shifts, ensuring greater compliance and reducing the risk of costly mistakes in cross-border the basicsThe push for Digital India is propelling significant progress in various sectors, focusing on leveraging technology to streamline operations and compliance. A recent example of this impel is the launch of Bharat Trade Net (BTN), a unified digital platform designed to simplify cross-border trade. BTN focuses on enhancing logistics, customs clearance, and trade documentation processes, which are often burdensome for it significantly improves transparency and provides easier access to financing, making it simpler for Indian businesses to expand. Given this, as AI drives tax compliance and automation, it has the potential to enhance the capabilities of platforms like BTN, ensuring that Indian businesses remain innovative and efficient the collaboration between the government and businesses will be crucial in shaping a future-ready tax ecosystem. With this, the increasing adoption of third-party, automated tax solution providers signals towards more secure, scalable, and cost-efficient solutions for managing tax compliance. Looking ahead, all these advancements will smoothen the tax processes and empower businesses to respond faster to regulatory changes, ensuring greater accuracy and transparency. As the industry evolves, Indian exporters need to be better equipped to meet the obstacles of a rapidly changing tax world, enabling sustainable growth and unfolding new opportunities for businesses and the economy author is VP, Product Management, The views expressed are solely of the author and ETCIO does not necessarily subscribe to it. ETCIO shall not be responsible for any damage caused to any person/organisation directly or indirectly.
