Leading Without Fear: The Case For Trust-Driven Healthcare Leadership

Forbes

11-07-2025

Paula Ferrada is the Chair, Department of Surgery – IFMC and System Chief for Trauma and Acute Care Surgery at Inova Healthcare System.
As a trauma surgeon, I have witnessed injuries that are, sadly, unsurvivable. I've stood over patients whose lives hung by a thread—some saved, others lost. And I've come to understand, more deeply with each experience, that what stands between life and death in those moments is not just the skill of the surgeon. It is the power of a team.
From the moment a critically injured patient rolls through the emergency department doors, a choreography of urgency unfolds. Nurses, emergency physicians, anesthesiologists, respiratory therapists, radiology techs and operating room (OR) staff are each poised, responsive and trusted to do their part. There is no time to waste, no room for ego. In those high-stress, high-stakes moments, the team matters more than any individual's technical brilliance.
This is why compassionate leadership and psychological safety are not abstract ideals in healthcare—they are life-saving imperatives.
Leading Through Trust, Not Fear
Simon Sinek once shared that the Navy SEALs, when choosing their most elite team members, value trust over performance. In healthcare, the stakes may not be combat, but they are just as real. We make decisions every day that determine whether someone will live or die. And like elite military units, the strongest healthcare teams are built not just on capability but on relationships.
This is especially true in trauma care, where every second matters. Trust accelerates action. It removes doubt, energizes communication and reduces cognitive load. In environments where people feel safe to speak up, ask questions and admit uncertainty, the entire system becomes more adaptive and, ultimately, more effective.
Safety Drives Performance
Kostas Dervitsiotis writes that trust is essential for performance and adaptation in high-reliability environments. This applies directly to trauma care, where adaptation is not a luxury—it's survival. Psychologically safe teams are faster, smarter and more agile. They debrief after cases without fear of blame, improve continuously and support one another through the emotional toll of the work.
In 2014, Weller, Boyd and Cumin found how tribalism in healthcare—rigid silos between doctors, nurses and staff—creates dangerous communication breakdowns. When we dismantle those barriers through compassionate leadership, we allow for collective excellence. Nurses speak up, techs are heard and surgeons lead by example. The result is a cohesive unit that performs under pressure because it is built on mutual respect.
I've seen firsthand how a shift in culture—grounded in trust and psychological safety—can transform a healthcare system. At our institution, we made a deliberate investment in fostering open communication, mutual respect and team accountability across disciplines. The results were unmistakable: We improved efficiency without sacrificing safety. Our teams became faster, more agile and more responsive—yet never at the expense of our patients' well-being.
We saw fewer complications, stronger coordination and greater consistency in surgical outcomes. Errors were caught before they reached the patient. And most importantly, team members felt safe to speak up about processes, concerns and how we could be better. These gains didn't come from control or compliance—they came from creating a space where people felt empowered to do their best work and trusted to act in service of the patient. It's a model of leadership that is not only sustainable but essential.
Compassion Is Not Soft, It's Strategic
We must reframe compassion not as a "soft skill" but as a strategic imperative. When leaders model vulnerability, curiosity and emotional intelligence, they foster environments where people feel safe to contribute fully. Husebø and Olsen (2016) found that clinical leadership development improves responsiveness, quality and trust—especially in emergency settings. These are not secondary gains. They are central to operational success.
At our hospital, surgical efficiency increased alongside safety. First-case on-time starts improved from 52% to 74%. We created additional access points for patients and surgeons by developing flexible scheduling systems. And we built leadership development meetings into our workflows to promote continuous learning and shared accountability.
Brené Brown says, "You can't get to courage without walking through vulnerability." When we allow ourselves and our teams to lead with curiosity instead of judgment—to replace shame and blame with questions and learning—we create the conditions for excellence. Shame and blame are inversely proportional to accountability. When team members feel shame, they shut down. When they feel safe, they lean in.
What Structural Safety Looks Like
Compassionate leadership also shows up in system design. It's in how we staff our teams, schedule our shifts and support mental wellness. It's in the way we conduct debriefs—not to assign blame but to learn. It's in policies that prioritize recovery, rest and resilience.
These values travel. I've seen them take root across continents in my global trauma work. From Latin America to the U.S., the most successful trauma teams share a common thread: They are led by people who understand that excellence requires empathy.
Building Teams That Save Lives
When we invest in compassionate leadership and psychological safety, we're not just creating better workplaces but better outcomes. Fewer medical errors. Greater staff retention. Higher patient satisfaction. Stronger innovation.
Healthcare is not just a science—it is a human endeavor. And at its best, it is led by those who understand that leading with trust, humility and compassion is not only good leadership—it is lifesaving leadership.
As Brené Brown reminds us: 'Vulnerability is the birthplace of innovation, creativity and change.' In medicine, it is also the birthplace of trust—and trust saves lives.
Forbes Business Council is the foremost growth and networking organization for business owners and leaders. Do I qualify?