Competitive power market faces delays
Despite approvals from the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) and the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra), following a six-month test run by the Central Power Purchasing Agency-Guarantee (CPPA-G), the Competitive Trading Bilateral Contracts Market (CTBCM) has yet to become fully operational.
Leading stakeholders from across Pakistan's energy and policy landscape convened a high-level multi-stakeholder dialogue hosted by Renewables First (RF) to discuss financial and technical readiness for the operationalisation of a competitive electricity market, a reform process that has shown accelerated progress in recent years.
The event brought together senior government representatives, legislators, regulatory bodies, development partners, and power sector experts to chart a path forward for implementing the long-delayed market reform under the CTBCM.
The CTBCM reform has already been approved by the ECC and Nepra, followed by a six-month test run by CPPA-G. However, its commercial operation has not begun to date.
During the event, the stakeholders expressed concern that the power sector of Pakistan remains entrenched in a single-buyer model, with CPPA-G as the sole purchaser and distribution companies (DISCOs) holding exclusive distribution licences. This structure has led to escalating capacity payments, underutilised generation assets, and suppressed private-sector participation.
Ramsha Panhwar, energy analyst at Renewables First, presented a critical overview of one of the most debated aspects of the CTBCM regime: the Use of System Charge (UoSC). She pointed out that the market has remained uncompetitive primarily because these charges have not been rationalised, making them unaffordable and excessively high for market participants.
"The UoSC is a central pillar of the CTBCM regime, determining how market participants pay for access to the transmission and distribution networks. However, more than 80% of the proposed UoSC comprises stranded costs and cross-subsidy, which exacerbates the overall power tariff. It directly affects the economics of open access and competitive supply," said Panhwar. "Rethinking the UoSC with a planned and phased recovery of stranded costs reduces the overall UoSC, making it attractive and affordable for the market participants."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
13 hours ago
- Express Tribune
Govt rejects lower gas tariff plea
The Commerce Division argued that tariff concession had been offered to those sectors that had a significant share in Pakistan's exports in 2011, whereas the glass industry's annual exports of $15.9 million were negligible. Photo: file The government has decided against granting a concessionary gas tariff to the zero-rated and export-oriented sectors. It made the decision while considering litigation pertaining to tariff reduction for such industries. In a recent meeting of the Economic Coordination Committee (ECC), it was observed that concessionary gas tariffs had already been exhausted in 2023 and considering those tariffs for zero-rated and export-oriented industries at the current stage may open the floodgates to similar cases. The ECC noted the position and directed the Commerce Division to pursue the case expeditiously in consultation with the Attorney General office. The Ministry of Commerce briefed the meeting that in 2019 Ghani Glass filed a writ petition in the Lahore High Court, praying that the concessionary gas/re-gasified liquefied natural gas (RLNG) tariff, fixed at Rs600 per million British thermal units (mmBtu) and granted to the zero-rated/export-oriented sectors, may be extended to the petitioner as well. The Petroleum Division, Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority, Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) and the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) were listed as respondents in the petition. However, the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of Commerce were not impleaded as parties in the case until April 7, 2025. The court directed that the Ministry of Finance, in coordination with the Ministry of Commerce and other relevant stakeholders, within 60 days, place the case of Ghani Glass before the ECC for developing a rational policy to ensure that only the export-oriented industries receive all concessions, rather than allowing sector-based classifications that permit non-exporting industries to take benefit unfairly. The ECC was directed to consider, within 60 days, the petitioner's request for the grant of tariff concession in respect of Sui gas/RLNG, with specific reference to discrimination by excluding glass from the export-oriented sectors. The relevant authority was also directed to examine the application of lower tariff to the petitioner from the date of filing the case (ie, 2015) until the period the benefit was extended to the zero-rated/export-oriented industries. The court directed that the ECC should take into consideration the potential of the glass industry to increase its export share and earn maximum foreign exchange. Furthermore, the forum should examine whether it was feasible to charge any export-focused industry higher prices compared to rates prevalent in other countries. The Commerce Division stated that the FBR, vide Statutory Regulatory Order (SRO) 1125(I)/2011, had granted zero-rated sales tax status to major sectors such as textile, carpet, leather goods, sports goods and surgical instruments. In 2018, the Petroleum Division extended the concessionary RLNG tariff of Rs600 per mmBtu to exporters of the same zero-rated sectors. Following the withdrawal of SRO 1125 through the Finance Bill 2019, an administrative gap emerged regarding the continuation of reduced gas tariffs. Consequently, the Ministry of Commerce declared the erstwhile zero-rated sectors as "export-oriented sectors" in December 2019. Accordingly, the tariff concession remained in place until 2023 and after that it was discontinued. The Commerce Division argued that the concession had been offered to those sectors that had a significant share in Pakistan's total exports in 2011, whereas the glass industry's annual exports of $15.9 million at that time were negligible. On the advice of the Ministry of Law and Justice, the Ministry of Commerce filed a Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal on June 12, 2025 in the Supreme Court, challenging the ruling of the Lahore High Court. Keeping that situation in view, the Commerce Division told the ECC that the demand of Ghani Glass for tariff concession was untenable and may not be entertained. It sought the ECC's approval for the proposal. The ECC considered the Ministry of Commerce's summary, "Implementation of Decision of the Lahore High Court in Writ Petition No 61559 of 2019 titled Ghani Glass versus Federation of Pakistan", and noted the position presented therein. It directed that the Ministry of Commerce may approach the Attorney General office.
Business Recorder
16 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Leghari asks Discos to coordinate with industrial units, SEZs
ISLAMABAD: Minister for Power, Sardar Awais Ahmed Khan Leghari, has directed all Distribution Companies (Discos) to coordinate with industrial units and Special Economic Zones (SEZs) to implement power supply and billing through a single point. According to the Power Division, the directive was issued in light of a decision by National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra). Following Cabinet approval, the Power Division submitted a request to Nepra on February 25 to allow electricity to be supplied to SEZs through a single point of delivery. Under the new framework, Discos will supply electricity to these zones at one point as per the terms of newly established agreements. This move aims to reduce unnecessary interference and curb corruption within the electricity distribution system. Industrial power tariff: Power Div, APTMA at odds over cross-subsidy calculation The Nepra, in its letter referred to Pesco's letter of March 26, 2025, whereby the template of the O&M Agreement (the 'Agreement') was submitted for review and approval of the Authority in terms of Nepra (Supply of Electric Power) Regulations, 2015 (the 'Supply Regulations'). In consideration of Pesco's letter, Nepra clarified that there is no provision for the approval of a template Agreement under the Supply Regulations. However, to facilitate the process, the Authority initiated a consultative process and sought comments in the matter from the concerned stakeholders by publishing a notice in the newspapers. In this regard, various stakeholders, especially the developers of SEZ(s) & Industrial Estates, submitted their comments in the matter, raising various concerns on the submitted Agreement and the same were shared with the Ministry of Energy (Power Division) through letter of June 04, 2025, for submitting rejoinder(s). The Power Division, through its correspondence of July 03, 2025, submitted its response on behalf of all XW-DISCO(s) agreeing to some comments of the stakeholders, while there appeared to be disagreement on several other points. It was also stated in the response of the Ministry that the O&M arrangement is an alternative framework, and does not preclude the SEZs and other eligible entities from obtaining licences for Distribution and Supplier of Last Resort. Apart from this, the Authority also reviewed the submitted Agreement and observed various discrepancies in the same in terms of the Supply Regulations. In light of the foregoing, the Authority directed all Discos to address the observations and negotiate the Agreements with the prospective O&M operator(s). Thereafter, the negotiated draft Agreement may be submitted to the Authority for approval underRegulation 5(2) of the Supply Regulations. It further emphasized that the finalized agreement must be consistent with the provisions of the aforementioned regulations, as well as all the applicable laws and documents. Earlier, on January 28, 2025, the Power Minister stated that the government is considering offering electricity to the industrial sector at marginal cost for three years. Other potential reforms under review include changes to net metering regulations, phasing out the uniform tariff structure, and limiting power procurement through CPPA-G to only committed projects totaling 7,000 MW. He also disclosed that eight out of the ten Discos are slated for privatization, with financial advisors expected to be appointed by the first week of February. 'If there were no uniform tariff across the country, the performance of K-Electric in terms of losses and recovery would not be as it is today,' he added. Meanwhile, the Board of Investment (BoI) has instructed relevant stakeholders to resolve issues faced by investors in SEZs. Several meetings of the Working Group on SEZs have been held in response to a request from the Special Investment Facilitation Council (SIFC) concerning the draft development agreement. These issues were also discussed in a meeting between SEZA Punjab and the Punjab Board of Investment and Trade (PBIT), where it was suggested that Challenge Fashion (Pvt) Ltd could negotiate the terms of its agreement directly with SEZA Punjab. The CEO of Challenge Fashion (Pvt) Ltd confirmed the company's willingness to proceed and stated that a follow-up letter had been sent to BoI after the meeting. However, it appeared the letter did not reach its destination. It was emphasized that negotiations with SEZA Punjab should proceed first, after which BoI would intervene as needed. The CEO added that construction on the project would begin once the access road is completed. Construction on the road began in September 2024 and concluded by February 2025. Additionally, the SEZ requires utility services at zero point to begin the allotment process. The Chair/Director General (SEZs & Projects) at BoI asked SEZA Punjab to clarify the situation. A representative from SEZA Punjab responded that SNGPL had issued a demand notice to the company, which must be settled before any further progress can be made. The CEO of Challenge Fashion (Pvt) Ltd stressed that it is the government's responsibility to ensure the provision of utilities up to zero point. The company remains committed to developing the internal infrastructure as planned. SEZA Punjab then requested guidance from BoI on how to proceed. Regarding Hub SEZ, the Chair invited the Managing Director (MD) of LIEDA to provide an update. The MD reported that the zone is currently facing funding challenges related to its development. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025
Express Tribune
2 days ago
- Express Tribune
Power minister voices dismay over lack of consultation
The minister for power has expressed concerns over ignoring the Power Division while providing electricity consumption data of shipbreaking and recycling processes for tariff categorisation and determination by the National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (Nepra). The Economic Coordination Committee (ECC) of the cabinet, in a recent meeting, held discussions on declaring shipbreaking and recycling as an industry. It directed the Maritime Affairs Division to consult the Power Division while gathering data of electricity consumption in shipbreaking and recycling for tariff categorisation and determination. The power minister expressed reservations that the Power Division had not been consulted to ascertain the total electricity consumption by the shipbreaking sector, which was essential. The Ministry of Maritime Affairs recalled that the ship recycling facility at Gaddani, Balochistan had once been the third largest in the world. The sector has largely been operating informally without being officially given the industry status. However, the shipbreaking and recycling sector has been accepted as an industry by the Balochistan Development Authority. The ministry said that the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR), on the recommendation of the Engineering Development Board, had notified Customs General Order No 04/2022 containing a list of locally manufactured goods for providing exemptions and concessions from duties and taxes under the concessionary regimes/SROs for items not manufactured locally. The Pakistan Ship Breakers Association was the only entity manufacturing re-rollable and re-meltable scrap through ship recycling, adding value and providing direct employment to 20,000-24,000 skilled and unskilled workers at Gaddani, along with indirect employment to scores of women in the surrounding areas. The ministry explained that the re-rollable scrap was the key raw material for re-rolling to produce construction bars. Owing to its mild steel composition and strength, it has also been the primary raw material for hundreds of cottage industries, operating in Punjab and across the country, producing thousands of tools and hardware items for industrial and domestic use. It is also used in the manufacturing of wire rods and agricultural implements. The re-meltable scrap (HMS 1&2) is consumed by steel melting furnaces, including large steel manufacturing units, to produce ingots, billets and re-bars. The ministry added that Pakistan had acceded to the International Convention for the Safe and Environmentally Sound Recycling of Ships 2009, known as the Hong Kong Convention, in November 2023. The convention aims to ensure that ships, when recycled at the end of their operational life, do not pose unnecessary risks to human health, safety or the environment. It deals with environmentally sound recycling of ships, the establishment of safe facilities for hazardous material disposal and the welfare of workers engaged in ship recycling. The Hong Kong Convention was set to take effect on June 25, 2025. Therefore, the formal declaration of ship recycling as an industry was necessary to implement the convention within the given timeframe. The Ministry of Maritime Affairs requested the Ministry of Industries and Production to initiate the process for granting industry status to shipbreaking and recycling. The Ministry of Industries responded that there was no specific legal criterion to determine which sector could be declared as an industry. However, as per precedent, each request for such a declaration is submitted by the relevant ministry to the federal cabinet through sharing a summary with the ECC. The Ministry of Maritime Affairs told the forum that a summary seeking the ECC's approval was submitted to the cabinet on March 26, 2025. The cabinet called for obtaining views of the relevant stakeholders, including the ministries of commerce and finance as well as the FBR. These stakeholders supported the proposal. In light of that, the ministry recommended that the shipbreaking and recycling sector should be formally declared an industry to enhance the local manufacturing of re-rollable and re-meltable scrap and to comply with the standards set by the Hong Kong Convention. The ECC's approval was sought for the proposal, which considered the summary submitted by the Ministry of Maritime Affairs and approved the proposal.
