Benji Marshall's shock call after Wests Tigers' miracle win over Gold Coast Titans
Tigers coach Benji Marshall labelled his side's performance against the Titans as their 'worst game' of the season despite being on the right end of a 21-20 scoreline.
The Tigers won their seventh game of the season to eclipse last year's measly six-win total when utility Adam Doueihi slotted a field goal with ten seconds on the clock.
FOX LEAGUE, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every game of every round in the 2025 NRL Telstra Premiership, LIVE with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer >
It was a gritty win given the Tigers trailed by four points inside the final five minutes before a Jeral Skelton try and Doueihi's field goal lifted them over the last-placed Titans.
A relieved Marshall wasn't too impressed when he faced the media post-game.
'If I'm being honest, I thought today was our worst game. I don't think we played anywhere near our standard,' Marshall said.
Despite the victory, Benji Marshall wasn't happy with his squad.
'In the first half we were looking for things that weren't there and to me it looked like our heads weren't on the job.
'We addressed some things at half time and in the second half we completed well and gave ourselves a chance at least.
'To get the two points it helps, but we have a lot to improve on.'
The win likely assures the Tigers won't be collecting a wooden spoon for a third straight season.
At the end of Round 20, they sit four points clear of the Titans and four points outside of the eight.
Marshall was asked if he considered the Tigers already improving on last year's win total with six games in hand was a 'milestone'.
'I haven't even thought about that to be honest,' Marshall said.
'It's more frustrations around where we think we could have been or where we could be or where we are but it was important to win today.
'Don't want to say about how we got it but I'm glad we got it.'
Originally published as 'Today was our worst game': Benji's shock call after thriller
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Advertiser
39 minutes ago
- The Advertiser
Knights rookie off to England after signing with Super League club
A rookie Knights forward is set to depart the club, locking in his future with a Super League club. Brock Greacen, who made his NRL debut in June, has signed with English side Castleford Tigers for the next two years. The 23-year-old will depart his home-town NRL team at season's end, and potentially after just one first-grade appearance, unless he wins a call-up in Newcastle's remaining five games. A Denman Devils junior, Greacen has been on a third-tier deal at the Knights and balanced university studies with football in recent years. He has played 34 NSW Cup games since 2022. "I'm over the moon to have been able to bring Brock to the Tigers," Castleford's director of rugby Chris Chester said. "Brock is a young, hungry middle that has come highly recommended by a couple of my old teammates Blake Green and Michael Dobson at the Newcastle Knights. "He is a hard-working middle that can also play edge. "His effort levels both sides of the ball are second to none and I can't wait to start working with Brock in pre-season." Greacen added: "I'm really excited to be joining the club. I've heard some really good things about the fans, and the atmosphere over there. I can't wait to get over there." The Knights were happy to let Greacen depart to play at a higher level more regularly. The forward, who only featured for 16 minutes in his NRL debut, has been named to come off the bench for Newcastle's NSW Cup side against North Sydney on Sunday. The NRL team has a bye. A rookie Knights forward is set to depart the club, locking in his future with a Super League club. Brock Greacen, who made his NRL debut in June, has signed with English side Castleford Tigers for the next two years. The 23-year-old will depart his home-town NRL team at season's end, and potentially after just one first-grade appearance, unless he wins a call-up in Newcastle's remaining five games. A Denman Devils junior, Greacen has been on a third-tier deal at the Knights and balanced university studies with football in recent years. He has played 34 NSW Cup games since 2022. "I'm over the moon to have been able to bring Brock to the Tigers," Castleford's director of rugby Chris Chester said. "Brock is a young, hungry middle that has come highly recommended by a couple of my old teammates Blake Green and Michael Dobson at the Newcastle Knights. "He is a hard-working middle that can also play edge. "His effort levels both sides of the ball are second to none and I can't wait to start working with Brock in pre-season." Greacen added: "I'm really excited to be joining the club. I've heard some really good things about the fans, and the atmosphere over there. I can't wait to get over there." The Knights were happy to let Greacen depart to play at a higher level more regularly. The forward, who only featured for 16 minutes in his NRL debut, has been named to come off the bench for Newcastle's NSW Cup side against North Sydney on Sunday. The NRL team has a bye. A rookie Knights forward is set to depart the club, locking in his future with a Super League club. Brock Greacen, who made his NRL debut in June, has signed with English side Castleford Tigers for the next two years. The 23-year-old will depart his home-town NRL team at season's end, and potentially after just one first-grade appearance, unless he wins a call-up in Newcastle's remaining five games. A Denman Devils junior, Greacen has been on a third-tier deal at the Knights and balanced university studies with football in recent years. He has played 34 NSW Cup games since 2022. "I'm over the moon to have been able to bring Brock to the Tigers," Castleford's director of rugby Chris Chester said. "Brock is a young, hungry middle that has come highly recommended by a couple of my old teammates Blake Green and Michael Dobson at the Newcastle Knights. "He is a hard-working middle that can also play edge. "His effort levels both sides of the ball are second to none and I can't wait to start working with Brock in pre-season." Greacen added: "I'm really excited to be joining the club. I've heard some really good things about the fans, and the atmosphere over there. I can't wait to get over there." The Knights were happy to let Greacen depart to play at a higher level more regularly. The forward, who only featured for 16 minutes in his NRL debut, has been named to come off the bench for Newcastle's NSW Cup side against North Sydney on Sunday. The NRL team has a bye. A rookie Knights forward is set to depart the club, locking in his future with a Super League club. Brock Greacen, who made his NRL debut in June, has signed with English side Castleford Tigers for the next two years. The 23-year-old will depart his home-town NRL team at season's end, and potentially after just one first-grade appearance, unless he wins a call-up in Newcastle's remaining five games. A Denman Devils junior, Greacen has been on a third-tier deal at the Knights and balanced university studies with football in recent years. He has played 34 NSW Cup games since 2022. "I'm over the moon to have been able to bring Brock to the Tigers," Castleford's director of rugby Chris Chester said. "Brock is a young, hungry middle that has come highly recommended by a couple of my old teammates Blake Green and Michael Dobson at the Newcastle Knights. "He is a hard-working middle that can also play edge. "His effort levels both sides of the ball are second to none and I can't wait to start working with Brock in pre-season." Greacen added: "I'm really excited to be joining the club. I've heard some really good things about the fans, and the atmosphere over there. I can't wait to get over there." The Knights were happy to let Greacen depart to play at a higher level more regularly. The forward, who only featured for 16 minutes in his NRL debut, has been named to come off the bench for Newcastle's NSW Cup side against North Sydney on Sunday. The NRL team has a bye.
The Advertiser
39 minutes ago
- The Advertiser
We're hosting the women, but will we ever land a men's Magic Round?
Sports and tourism leaders believe Newcastle should "go big" and position itself to take the NRL's Magic Round away from Brisbane, spruiking the Hunter's credentials ahead of the inaugural women's event this weekend. McDonald Jones Stadium in Broadmeadow is hosting the first NRLW Magic Round across Saturday and Sunday, where all six games will be played at the one venue. The women's round has been launched after the success of the men's event which has been held annually in Brisbane since 2019. The forecast rain might put a dampener on crowds at the women's version, but that hasn't diminished a view that Newcastle would be more than capable of hosting the men's Magic Round too. "We should strive for any event, as we have in relation to this one and as we have done with the events we've seen so successful [in the past]. You have to go big for the future," former rugby league administrator and Hunter resident, John Quayle, told the Newcastle Herald. "It doesn't happen just overnight, because cities now, in every event, are going to bid for the long term. They want it for their city. They don't want one-offs. "It's like the Grand Prix or Supercars, they are international events and with exposure sent around the world that you can't buy." As it stands, Brisbane will host the men's Magic Round until at least 2027, while a five-year extension has been mooted through to the 2032 Olympics. The Queensland government's strong financial support has kept the event in the Sunshine State since its inception. But whether its popularity ultimately wanes in Brisbane and the NRL opts to move it, remains to be seen. The NRL Nines suffered that fate after several years in Auckland before being revived and relocated to Perth in 2020. It hasn't been held since as the sport has generally moved away from the format at the elite level. Newcastle's track record in terms of hosting major sporting events speaks for itself. In the past year alone, the city has hosted the Wallabies, Wallaroos, Matildas and Women's State of Origin. The national women's netball and basketball teams have also previously played in the city, drawing capacity crowds. In a rugby league heartland, Knights games are well attended even when the team is struggling. But Magic Round is also about drawing visitors to justify government investment. Brisbane's Magic Round sold out this year, essentially attracting 150,000 fans across three days. McDonald Jones Stadium holds close to 30,000, which would likely mean more expensive tickets if it was to move to Newcastle, to draw similar revenue. One concern with drawing 30,000 people each day would be accommodation. But Will Creedon, a long-time Hunter accommodation provider and former local tourism chief, said the city had grown its short-term stay capacity and it wouldn't be an issue. "Why not?" Creedon said of hosting the men's event. "There's about 16,500 bedrooms across the region. That's not considering there are opportunities to bring people in by bus, or via train, from outlying areas. "Is there enough supply for each category of accommodation? That's an interesting question, but we'd be close to it I suspect. "But if we knew it was coming, and it was here every so often - I think we could do a Magic Round every five years - it would act as a stimuli to think about how we're going to fill the four years in between to drive innovation of inventory around transport and aviation." Mr Creedon, who now lives in Brisbane, believes the men's Magic Round will ultimately move to new locations. "Brisbane were very clever in what they've done, and the NRL ... do I think it will move? Absolutely," he said. "I actually think it will go to Asia and other places. There will be a bidding war, because the economic influence it has is significant, and the Hunter needs to be thinking like that. "Not just with the NRL, but every other code as well." Part of the 'magic' of Magic Round is the proximity of hospitality businesses to the venue. Newcastle's popular Beaumont Street is a five-minute drive, or 30-minute walk, from the stadium. The city centre is less than 10 minutes drive away. A train line to both is a mere 10-minute walk. "Newcastle is a great city for this sort of event because the CBD area is compact with lots of dining and entertainment options, spectators can access the stadium easily with public transport and we have so many other amazing attractions within a short distance to fill out visitors' itineraries," Business Hunter chief Bob Hawes said. "We've also got an airport that intra-and-interstate visitors can fly right into. "The economic benefits from events of this calibre flow onto a diverse range of businesses including accommodation providers, cafes and restaurants, pubs and clubs, but also service providers like caterers, cleaners, security companies, uber and taxi drivers and merchandise sellers. "It also projects the city and region onto television screens around the country." Other stakeholders the Herald spoke to raised the idea of Newcastle hosting a 'mini' men's Magic Round or a combined men's and women's version in the short term, if the men's event gets locked into Brisbane into the 2030s. That could potentially entail a one-day NRL triple-header on a Saturday, if other clubs were willing to sacrifice home games to bring matches here. Or perhaps a two-day event combining men's and women's fixtures. Newcastle Tourism Industry Group chair Dominic May said any large-scale sporting event that attracted people to the region for the first had flow-on benefits. "We've been very supportive of the partnership between Venues NSW and City of Newcastle to increase major events in the city, because across visitor-economy businesses ... what we often find is events are a big driver of people to the city and often for the very first time," May said. "People will often extend their stay pre-or-post major events, like this, and that's where the real value lies ... and we find they spread out right across the region. "Major events are also a big drawcard for repeat visitation. If a person has a great experience ... they're surprised by how much they enjoyed themselves ... they're likely to return for leisure purposes." The women's Magic Round could yet return to Newcastle next year given the NRL struck a deal with the NSW government for it to be held in 'regional NSW' for the three years. Depending on the level of interest, it could yet shift to places like Mudgee, Tamworth or Bathurst. Wollongong would be another alternative with a bigger stadium than the country towns. Securing the men's Magic Round would likely require significant government investment, like Queensland has funded. Sydney could shape as a competitor to Newcastle in attracting the event, but it has its own drawbacks and similar events like rugby sevens tournaments and the A-League's Unite Round have flopped in the state capital. A decent turnout at the inaugural women's Magic Round this weekend would only put another feather in Newcastle's sporting cap, and further its case to try and host the men's version. "Recently with the big international [sporting] events, we've seen it and the sports are recognising it," Quayle said. "The councillors, too, recognise how good it is for the region. "We are seeing this prominently over the last five years, with the concerts [the stadium hosts] as well, it doesn't take long over a number of days to match, if you're talking Brisbane, [a crowd] of 50,000. "But the administrators won't make the decision just on people, it's how the event will be, which for me, is always a big plus for Newcastle, is the support it's going to get." Hawes added: "Landing the NRLW Magic Round is a huge coup and snaring the men's version would add further to the Hunter's growing reputation as a high-quality host destination for national and international sporting events." Sports and tourism leaders believe Newcastle should "go big" and position itself to take the NRL's Magic Round away from Brisbane, spruiking the Hunter's credentials ahead of the inaugural women's event this weekend. McDonald Jones Stadium in Broadmeadow is hosting the first NRLW Magic Round across Saturday and Sunday, where all six games will be played at the one venue. The women's round has been launched after the success of the men's event which has been held annually in Brisbane since 2019. The forecast rain might put a dampener on crowds at the women's version, but that hasn't diminished a view that Newcastle would be more than capable of hosting the men's Magic Round too. "We should strive for any event, as we have in relation to this one and as we have done with the events we've seen so successful [in the past]. You have to go big for the future," former rugby league administrator and Hunter resident, John Quayle, told the Newcastle Herald. "It doesn't happen just overnight, because cities now, in every event, are going to bid for the long term. They want it for their city. They don't want one-offs. "It's like the Grand Prix or Supercars, they are international events and with exposure sent around the world that you can't buy." As it stands, Brisbane will host the men's Magic Round until at least 2027, while a five-year extension has been mooted through to the 2032 Olympics. The Queensland government's strong financial support has kept the event in the Sunshine State since its inception. But whether its popularity ultimately wanes in Brisbane and the NRL opts to move it, remains to be seen. The NRL Nines suffered that fate after several years in Auckland before being revived and relocated to Perth in 2020. It hasn't been held since as the sport has generally moved away from the format at the elite level. Newcastle's track record in terms of hosting major sporting events speaks for itself. In the past year alone, the city has hosted the Wallabies, Wallaroos, Matildas and Women's State of Origin. The national women's netball and basketball teams have also previously played in the city, drawing capacity crowds. In a rugby league heartland, Knights games are well attended even when the team is struggling. But Magic Round is also about drawing visitors to justify government investment. Brisbane's Magic Round sold out this year, essentially attracting 150,000 fans across three days. McDonald Jones Stadium holds close to 30,000, which would likely mean more expensive tickets if it was to move to Newcastle, to draw similar revenue. One concern with drawing 30,000 people each day would be accommodation. But Will Creedon, a long-time Hunter accommodation provider and former local tourism chief, said the city had grown its short-term stay capacity and it wouldn't be an issue. "Why not?" Creedon said of hosting the men's event. "There's about 16,500 bedrooms across the region. That's not considering there are opportunities to bring people in by bus, or via train, from outlying areas. "Is there enough supply for each category of accommodation? That's an interesting question, but we'd be close to it I suspect. "But if we knew it was coming, and it was here every so often - I think we could do a Magic Round every five years - it would act as a stimuli to think about how we're going to fill the four years in between to drive innovation of inventory around transport and aviation." Mr Creedon, who now lives in Brisbane, believes the men's Magic Round will ultimately move to new locations. "Brisbane were very clever in what they've done, and the NRL ... do I think it will move? Absolutely," he said. "I actually think it will go to Asia and other places. There will be a bidding war, because the economic influence it has is significant, and the Hunter needs to be thinking like that. "Not just with the NRL, but every other code as well." Part of the 'magic' of Magic Round is the proximity of hospitality businesses to the venue. Newcastle's popular Beaumont Street is a five-minute drive, or 30-minute walk, from the stadium. The city centre is less than 10 minutes drive away. A train line to both is a mere 10-minute walk. "Newcastle is a great city for this sort of event because the CBD area is compact with lots of dining and entertainment options, spectators can access the stadium easily with public transport and we have so many other amazing attractions within a short distance to fill out visitors' itineraries," Business Hunter chief Bob Hawes said. "We've also got an airport that intra-and-interstate visitors can fly right into. "The economic benefits from events of this calibre flow onto a diverse range of businesses including accommodation providers, cafes and restaurants, pubs and clubs, but also service providers like caterers, cleaners, security companies, uber and taxi drivers and merchandise sellers. "It also projects the city and region onto television screens around the country." Other stakeholders the Herald spoke to raised the idea of Newcastle hosting a 'mini' men's Magic Round or a combined men's and women's version in the short term, if the men's event gets locked into Brisbane into the 2030s. That could potentially entail a one-day NRL triple-header on a Saturday, if other clubs were willing to sacrifice home games to bring matches here. Or perhaps a two-day event combining men's and women's fixtures. Newcastle Tourism Industry Group chair Dominic May said any large-scale sporting event that attracted people to the region for the first had flow-on benefits. "We've been very supportive of the partnership between Venues NSW and City of Newcastle to increase major events in the city, because across visitor-economy businesses ... what we often find is events are a big driver of people to the city and often for the very first time," May said. "People will often extend their stay pre-or-post major events, like this, and that's where the real value lies ... and we find they spread out right across the region. "Major events are also a big drawcard for repeat visitation. If a person has a great experience ... they're surprised by how much they enjoyed themselves ... they're likely to return for leisure purposes." The women's Magic Round could yet return to Newcastle next year given the NRL struck a deal with the NSW government for it to be held in 'regional NSW' for the three years. Depending on the level of interest, it could yet shift to places like Mudgee, Tamworth or Bathurst. Wollongong would be another alternative with a bigger stadium than the country towns. Securing the men's Magic Round would likely require significant government investment, like Queensland has funded. Sydney could shape as a competitor to Newcastle in attracting the event, but it has its own drawbacks and similar events like rugby sevens tournaments and the A-League's Unite Round have flopped in the state capital. A decent turnout at the inaugural women's Magic Round this weekend would only put another feather in Newcastle's sporting cap, and further its case to try and host the men's version. "Recently with the big international [sporting] events, we've seen it and the sports are recognising it," Quayle said. "The councillors, too, recognise how good it is for the region. "We are seeing this prominently over the last five years, with the concerts [the stadium hosts] as well, it doesn't take long over a number of days to match, if you're talking Brisbane, [a crowd] of 50,000. "But the administrators won't make the decision just on people, it's how the event will be, which for me, is always a big plus for Newcastle, is the support it's going to get." Hawes added: "Landing the NRLW Magic Round is a huge coup and snaring the men's version would add further to the Hunter's growing reputation as a high-quality host destination for national and international sporting events." Sports and tourism leaders believe Newcastle should "go big" and position itself to take the NRL's Magic Round away from Brisbane, spruiking the Hunter's credentials ahead of the inaugural women's event this weekend. McDonald Jones Stadium in Broadmeadow is hosting the first NRLW Magic Round across Saturday and Sunday, where all six games will be played at the one venue. The women's round has been launched after the success of the men's event which has been held annually in Brisbane since 2019. The forecast rain might put a dampener on crowds at the women's version, but that hasn't diminished a view that Newcastle would be more than capable of hosting the men's Magic Round too. "We should strive for any event, as we have in relation to this one and as we have done with the events we've seen so successful [in the past]. You have to go big for the future," former rugby league administrator and Hunter resident, John Quayle, told the Newcastle Herald. "It doesn't happen just overnight, because cities now, in every event, are going to bid for the long term. They want it for their city. They don't want one-offs. "It's like the Grand Prix or Supercars, they are international events and with exposure sent around the world that you can't buy." As it stands, Brisbane will host the men's Magic Round until at least 2027, while a five-year extension has been mooted through to the 2032 Olympics. The Queensland government's strong financial support has kept the event in the Sunshine State since its inception. But whether its popularity ultimately wanes in Brisbane and the NRL opts to move it, remains to be seen. The NRL Nines suffered that fate after several years in Auckland before being revived and relocated to Perth in 2020. It hasn't been held since as the sport has generally moved away from the format at the elite level. Newcastle's track record in terms of hosting major sporting events speaks for itself. In the past year alone, the city has hosted the Wallabies, Wallaroos, Matildas and Women's State of Origin. The national women's netball and basketball teams have also previously played in the city, drawing capacity crowds. In a rugby league heartland, Knights games are well attended even when the team is struggling. But Magic Round is also about drawing visitors to justify government investment. Brisbane's Magic Round sold out this year, essentially attracting 150,000 fans across three days. McDonald Jones Stadium holds close to 30,000, which would likely mean more expensive tickets if it was to move to Newcastle, to draw similar revenue. One concern with drawing 30,000 people each day would be accommodation. But Will Creedon, a long-time Hunter accommodation provider and former local tourism chief, said the city had grown its short-term stay capacity and it wouldn't be an issue. "Why not?" Creedon said of hosting the men's event. "There's about 16,500 bedrooms across the region. That's not considering there are opportunities to bring people in by bus, or via train, from outlying areas. "Is there enough supply for each category of accommodation? That's an interesting question, but we'd be close to it I suspect. "But if we knew it was coming, and it was here every so often - I think we could do a Magic Round every five years - it would act as a stimuli to think about how we're going to fill the four years in between to drive innovation of inventory around transport and aviation." Mr Creedon, who now lives in Brisbane, believes the men's Magic Round will ultimately move to new locations. "Brisbane were very clever in what they've done, and the NRL ... do I think it will move? Absolutely," he said. "I actually think it will go to Asia and other places. There will be a bidding war, because the economic influence it has is significant, and the Hunter needs to be thinking like that. "Not just with the NRL, but every other code as well." Part of the 'magic' of Magic Round is the proximity of hospitality businesses to the venue. Newcastle's popular Beaumont Street is a five-minute drive, or 30-minute walk, from the stadium. The city centre is less than 10 minutes drive away. A train line to both is a mere 10-minute walk. "Newcastle is a great city for this sort of event because the CBD area is compact with lots of dining and entertainment options, spectators can access the stadium easily with public transport and we have so many other amazing attractions within a short distance to fill out visitors' itineraries," Business Hunter chief Bob Hawes said. "We've also got an airport that intra-and-interstate visitors can fly right into. "The economic benefits from events of this calibre flow onto a diverse range of businesses including accommodation providers, cafes and restaurants, pubs and clubs, but also service providers like caterers, cleaners, security companies, uber and taxi drivers and merchandise sellers. "It also projects the city and region onto television screens around the country." Other stakeholders the Herald spoke to raised the idea of Newcastle hosting a 'mini' men's Magic Round or a combined men's and women's version in the short term, if the men's event gets locked into Brisbane into the 2030s. That could potentially entail a one-day NRL triple-header on a Saturday, if other clubs were willing to sacrifice home games to bring matches here. Or perhaps a two-day event combining men's and women's fixtures. Newcastle Tourism Industry Group chair Dominic May said any large-scale sporting event that attracted people to the region for the first had flow-on benefits. "We've been very supportive of the partnership between Venues NSW and City of Newcastle to increase major events in the city, because across visitor-economy businesses ... what we often find is events are a big driver of people to the city and often for the very first time," May said. "People will often extend their stay pre-or-post major events, like this, and that's where the real value lies ... and we find they spread out right across the region. "Major events are also a big drawcard for repeat visitation. If a person has a great experience ... they're surprised by how much they enjoyed themselves ... they're likely to return for leisure purposes." The women's Magic Round could yet return to Newcastle next year given the NRL struck a deal with the NSW government for it to be held in 'regional NSW' for the three years. Depending on the level of interest, it could yet shift to places like Mudgee, Tamworth or Bathurst. Wollongong would be another alternative with a bigger stadium than the country towns. Securing the men's Magic Round would likely require significant government investment, like Queensland has funded. Sydney could shape as a competitor to Newcastle in attracting the event, but it has its own drawbacks and similar events like rugby sevens tournaments and the A-League's Unite Round have flopped in the state capital. A decent turnout at the inaugural women's Magic Round this weekend would only put another feather in Newcastle's sporting cap, and further its case to try and host the men's version. "Recently with the big international [sporting] events, we've seen it and the sports are recognising it," Quayle said. "The councillors, too, recognise how good it is for the region. "We are seeing this prominently over the last five years, with the concerts [the stadium hosts] as well, it doesn't take long over a number of days to match, if you're talking Brisbane, [a crowd] of 50,000. "But the administrators won't make the decision just on people, it's how the event will be, which for me, is always a big plus for Newcastle, is the support it's going to get." Hawes added: "Landing the NRLW Magic Round is a huge coup and snaring the men's version would add further to the Hunter's growing reputation as a high-quality host destination for national and international sporting events." Sports and tourism leaders believe Newcastle should "go big" and position itself to take the NRL's Magic Round away from Brisbane, spruiking the Hunter's credentials ahead of the inaugural women's event this weekend. McDonald Jones Stadium in Broadmeadow is hosting the first NRLW Magic Round across Saturday and Sunday, where all six games will be played at the one venue. The women's round has been launched after the success of the men's event which has been held annually in Brisbane since 2019. The forecast rain might put a dampener on crowds at the women's version, but that hasn't diminished a view that Newcastle would be more than capable of hosting the men's Magic Round too. "We should strive for any event, as we have in relation to this one and as we have done with the events we've seen so successful [in the past]. You have to go big for the future," former rugby league administrator and Hunter resident, John Quayle, told the Newcastle Herald. "It doesn't happen just overnight, because cities now, in every event, are going to bid for the long term. They want it for their city. They don't want one-offs. "It's like the Grand Prix or Supercars, they are international events and with exposure sent around the world that you can't buy." As it stands, Brisbane will host the men's Magic Round until at least 2027, while a five-year extension has been mooted through to the 2032 Olympics. The Queensland government's strong financial support has kept the event in the Sunshine State since its inception. But whether its popularity ultimately wanes in Brisbane and the NRL opts to move it, remains to be seen. The NRL Nines suffered that fate after several years in Auckland before being revived and relocated to Perth in 2020. It hasn't been held since as the sport has generally moved away from the format at the elite level. Newcastle's track record in terms of hosting major sporting events speaks for itself. In the past year alone, the city has hosted the Wallabies, Wallaroos, Matildas and Women's State of Origin. The national women's netball and basketball teams have also previously played in the city, drawing capacity crowds. In a rugby league heartland, Knights games are well attended even when the team is struggling. But Magic Round is also about drawing visitors to justify government investment. Brisbane's Magic Round sold out this year, essentially attracting 150,000 fans across three days. McDonald Jones Stadium holds close to 30,000, which would likely mean more expensive tickets if it was to move to Newcastle, to draw similar revenue. One concern with drawing 30,000 people each day would be accommodation. But Will Creedon, a long-time Hunter accommodation provider and former local tourism chief, said the city had grown its short-term stay capacity and it wouldn't be an issue. "Why not?" Creedon said of hosting the men's event. "There's about 16,500 bedrooms across the region. That's not considering there are opportunities to bring people in by bus, or via train, from outlying areas. "Is there enough supply for each category of accommodation? That's an interesting question, but we'd be close to it I suspect. "But if we knew it was coming, and it was here every so often - I think we could do a Magic Round every five years - it would act as a stimuli to think about how we're going to fill the four years in between to drive innovation of inventory around transport and aviation." Mr Creedon, who now lives in Brisbane, believes the men's Magic Round will ultimately move to new locations. "Brisbane were very clever in what they've done, and the NRL ... do I think it will move? Absolutely," he said. "I actually think it will go to Asia and other places. There will be a bidding war, because the economic influence it has is significant, and the Hunter needs to be thinking like that. "Not just with the NRL, but every other code as well." Part of the 'magic' of Magic Round is the proximity of hospitality businesses to the venue. Newcastle's popular Beaumont Street is a five-minute drive, or 30-minute walk, from the stadium. The city centre is less than 10 minutes drive away. A train line to both is a mere 10-minute walk. "Newcastle is a great city for this sort of event because the CBD area is compact with lots of dining and entertainment options, spectators can access the stadium easily with public transport and we have so many other amazing attractions within a short distance to fill out visitors' itineraries," Business Hunter chief Bob Hawes said. "We've also got an airport that intra-and-interstate visitors can fly right into. "The economic benefits from events of this calibre flow onto a diverse range of businesses including accommodation providers, cafes and restaurants, pubs and clubs, but also service providers like caterers, cleaners, security companies, uber and taxi drivers and merchandise sellers. "It also projects the city and region onto television screens around the country." Other stakeholders the Herald spoke to raised the idea of Newcastle hosting a 'mini' men's Magic Round or a combined men's and women's version in the short term, if the men's event gets locked into Brisbane into the 2030s. That could potentially entail a one-day NRL triple-header on a Saturday, if other clubs were willing to sacrifice home games to bring matches here. Or perhaps a two-day event combining men's and women's fixtures. Newcastle Tourism Industry Group chair Dominic May said any large-scale sporting event that attracted people to the region for the first had flow-on benefits. "We've been very supportive of the partnership between Venues NSW and City of Newcastle to increase major events in the city, because across visitor-economy businesses ... what we often find is events are a big driver of people to the city and often for the very first time," May said. "People will often extend their stay pre-or-post major events, like this, and that's where the real value lies ... and we find they spread out right across the region. "Major events are also a big drawcard for repeat visitation. If a person has a great experience ... they're surprised by how much they enjoyed themselves ... they're likely to return for leisure purposes." The women's Magic Round could yet return to Newcastle next year given the NRL struck a deal with the NSW government for it to be held in 'regional NSW' for the three years. Depending on the level of interest, it could yet shift to places like Mudgee, Tamworth or Bathurst. Wollongong would be another alternative with a bigger stadium than the country towns. Securing the men's Magic Round would likely require significant government investment, like Queensland has funded. Sydney could shape as a competitor to Newcastle in attracting the event, but it has its own drawbacks and similar events like rugby sevens tournaments and the A-League's Unite Round have flopped in the state capital. A decent turnout at the inaugural women's Magic Round this weekend would only put another feather in Newcastle's sporting cap, and further its case to try and host the men's version. "Recently with the big international [sporting] events, we've seen it and the sports are recognising it," Quayle said. "The councillors, too, recognise how good it is for the region. "We are seeing this prominently over the last five years, with the concerts [the stadium hosts] as well, it doesn't take long over a number of days to match, if you're talking Brisbane, [a crowd] of 50,000. "But the administrators won't make the decision just on people, it's how the event will be, which for me, is always a big plus for Newcastle, is the support it's going to get." Hawes added: "Landing the NRLW Magic Round is a huge coup and snaring the men's version would add further to the Hunter's growing reputation as a high-quality host destination for national and international sporting events."
Sydney Morning Herald
2 hours ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
Conferences, mid-week games and 10-team finals: How a 20-team NRL competition could work
T he NRL has started sitting down with potential broadcast partners to open discussions about the future of the sport. With a team in Perth entering the competition in 2027 and a team in Papua New Guinea the following year, the NRL is just one team away from reaching its desired 20-team competition. That could come as early as 2030. This masthead has spoken to the key stakeholders in the sport to map out what a 20-team competition could look like, including the introduction of conferences and a change to the State of Origin period. Conferences There has been considerable debate in recent years about the NRL transitioning to a conference-based system, similar to those of several major American sports. In a 20-team competition, there are two viable options. One option is to split the competition into two 10-team conferences. That model, however, raises issues with the number of games played in a regular season. If teams played the other teams in their conference twice, and the other conference once, the competition would be extended from 24 to a 28-game season. That's never happening. The model posed by this masthead is based on a four-conference system consisting of five teams in each conference. That allows teams to play each other once (19 rounds), then a rivalry month leading into the finals series, when teams square off against their conference opponents for the second leg of their home-and-away fixtures. The current draw sees some teams play opponents twice, with no formula or fairness behind the selections. 'Twenty teams is the right number,' ARL Commission chairman Peter V'landys said. 'It's just a matter of when and how we can get there. We want to ensure the first two teams are successful. The Dolphins were successful. We want to make sure the Perth Bears and PNG are equally successful. That might bring the 20th team forward. The success of the two teams will determine how quickly we can move to a 20-team comp. 'Conferences done correctly, yeah, absolutely, I like it. When I first started as chairman, I had a delegation of high-profile coaches and administrators. They wanted conferences, so I've always had it in the back of my head. Tribalism is the main ingredient in our sport.' With nine Sydney teams, it makes it difficult to place them into two clear conferences. By placing the 'Big Six' Sydney teams in terms of fan bases and history (Roosters, Dragons, Rabbitohs, Bulldogs, Tigers and Eels) into two separate groups, you ensure more blockbuster games for broadcasters and fans. 'It'll be great for the gate,' Roosters chairman Nick Politis recently said. 'Playing the Sydney teams twice is better for us than playing the Titans or Dolphins at home. Revenue will go through the roof. You'll get better crowds. It's fair. 'We get back to playing a proper draw, not all over the place like it is now. That's fairness. Now, the top clubs play each other twice, and the bottom teams play each other twice, and we end up somewhere in the middle and get a close comp. Everyone says we're geniuses, but we're not. It's engineered.' Eastern conference: Sydney Roosters, South Sydney Rabbitohs, St George Illawarra Dragons, Cronulla Sharks and Manly Sea Eagles. Western conference: Parramatta Eels, Canterbury Bulldogs, Wests Tigers, Penrith Panthers and Perth Bears. This masthead placed the Perth Bears into a Sydney conference due to their North Sydney fan base. Placing them in another conference with teams like the Warriors, Cowboys or Papua New Guinea will only add to the extensive travel those teams will undertake. Northern conference: Brisbane Broncos, Gold Coast Titans, North Queensland Cowboys, Dolphins and Papua New Guinea. Southern conference: Melbourne Storm, Canberra Raiders, Warriors, Newcastle Knights and a potential second NZ-based team. 'Peter and Andrew have our complete support and confidence as they go into these broadcast negotiations,' South Sydney chief executive Blake Solly said. 'We know they're concentrating on the most compelling competition they can and getting full value for our broadcast rights. One of the great things about the conference system is the certainty it provides you year in, year out. 'Particularly the opportunity to build strong rivalries inside your conference. Anyone who has an interest in the NFL knows how passionate those rivalries can be in the conference and how much fans look forward to the fact they are taking place home and away every year.' While the teams in the southern conference would be required to travel further distances than the teams in the Sydney conferences, it is no more travel than they are currently being asked to undertake. 'We would need convincing as an out-of-town club whether a conference system would be good or not,' Raiders chief executive Don Furner said in fear of the disadvantage of the additional travel. Length of season Most would agree that the current NRL season, at 24 games with three byes, is too long. However, broadcasters pay top dollar for a product that provides commercial partners a substantial window of promotion. The same goes with the clubs, who would be significantly impacted by a draw that would only see teams play each other once (19 rounds). The Rugby League Players' Association believes a 19-20 game regular season is an optimal amount to reduce the workload on players and minimise injuries. Clubs are mindful, however, that reducing the season to 19-20 games will impact their corporate revenue, sponsorship deals and the income from tickets and membership. 'I understand the need to protect the players and the increasing demands of the game, but that would be a major change from where we are right now,' Eels chief executive Jim Sarantinos said. 'Reducing the number of home games for each club from 12 to 9 would have a significant impact on how clubs engage with fans, members and sponsors, and the business model across the whole game would need to change.' There are currently 204 games in the NRL regular season. Even if the competition is reduced by one round, the NRL will increase the number of regular-season games to 230 (13 per cent increase) with the addition of two extra games per round with the new teams. 'Personally, I'd like to see the season shorter,' Furner said. 'It's such a long season with rep football and trial matches. If there was a way to satisfy the broadcasters with less NRL games, that would be an ideal outcome. I look at the amount of games in the NFL, and it works for them.' Finals format It's imperative to place a greater importance on conference rivalry games. Incentivising the conference champion will only add to the spectacle of some of the blockbuster matches. The reward for the highest-ranked team in each conference (based on the overall ladder) is a direct pathway into the finals series. Those teams would be seeded from 1-4 based on the best overall win/loss record throughout the season. That would guarantee the conference champion a second chance if they lose their opening game of the finals. Those teams, based on the current NRL ladder after 21 rounds, would be the Raiders, Bulldogs, Broncos and Sharks. The other six teams would be seeded from 5-10 in order of their overall standing on the combined ladder. In the first week of the finals, 7th would play 10th and 8th would play 9th for the right to progress into the final eight the following week. Teams 1-6 would be given the week off in the first week of the finals. This would help negate the current situation, which sees many teams resting their players in the final round of the regular season to prepare for the finals at the expense of the integrity of the competition. The opening weekend of the finals would determine the two teams that would join the remaining six teams in week two of the finals. From that point, the current top eight finals system would be applied. It gives broadcasters an additional two sudden-death finals games to sell to commercial partners and provides the game with an uplift in attendance and television viewers. By reducing the regular season by one round and extending the finals series by one week, the NRL grand final will remain on the October long weekend. 'I used to think the ideal model was to split the competition into two conferences and have your Sydney grand final and out-of-Sydney grand final, with the two teams playing in some sort of Super Bowl,' South Sydney coach Wayne Bennett said. 'Once we get to 20 teams, there will be too many teams for that. Maybe the four conference system is the way to go because we need more rivalry games.' State of Origin period The television ratings speak to the beast that is State of Origin, but often the representative fixture comes at the detriment of the NRL competition. Clubs pay their premium players top dollar, only to lose some of them to State of Origin, often picking up injuries or returning both physically and mentally fatigued. 'Currently, it's the worst model we can have,' Bennett said. 'It's the timing of it and how it least impacts the clubs. One of the great fallacies of our game is that the best team doesn't always win the grand final. Not every season, but Origin has impacted on the finals and the premiers. I laugh because I've coached all these years and with a high number of Origin players in my teams. 'I'm qualified to tell you how much it takes a toll. I have no doubt we should have gone back-to-back premierships at the Dragons, but Origin killed us. When the players came back they were physically drained and mentally shot after a brutal series. We never recovered from that.' State of Origin belongs in the middle of the season, but does it have to last so long? Does it have to have such a significant impact on the NRL teams? There are currently 53 days between when the players arrive in camp for game one and when they leave after game three. They do return to their clubs in between matches, but the NRL can't continue to allow Origin to have such a major impact on clubs. 'The Origin schedule is a bit like Frankenstein's monster,' Solly said. 'The NRL competition provides the ARLC with 90 per cent of its revenue, yet a three-game series disrupts it for almost 30 per cent of it. No other premier sporting club competition would accept that disruption. People at the NFL, the NBA, the Premier League think we clubs are mad in accepting that position. 'The current Origin window is a complete disaster for clubs. It takes our best players away too often and for too long. We understand that this current system was a product of this TV cycle.' 'We much preferred the Wednesday-Sunday-Wednesday schedule of the previous system, and we've been vocal in seeking change from the NRL. We respect that Andrew and Peter can't do anything in this cycle, but everyone in the game wants a shorter Origin period with less disruption to the NRL competition.' Under the model proposed, the Origin period would be reduced from 53 days to 29. Players would remain in camp for the duration of the series, playing the first game on a Wednesday, the second game 10 days later on a Sunday, and the third 10 days later on a Wednesday. The model proposed would see NRL clubs lose Origin players for just one game each. Split rounds and mid-week matches, similar to the English Premier League over the Christmas period, would give broadcasters an 18-day footy festival each May (combination of NRL games, men's Origin, women's Origin, under 19's Origin and under 21 Test matches involving Australia, New Zealand, Tonga and Samoa). It would also ensure Origin players remain in camp throughout the series, negating the risk of injuries suffered when returning to club land and continually building on the hype of the series without the stoppages that currently exist. 'As long as the solution doesn't compromise the quality of the product, because Origin is so big and so unique, it needs to be taken into account,' Queensland Rugby League boss Ben Ikin said. 'But more importantly, as long as the rules that they change advantage Queensland and not NSW, we'll be fine.' International window Like the Six Nations in European rugby union, there is an opportunity to build an annual competition that helps grow the international game. A Five Nations tournament involving England, Australia, Samoa, Tonga and New Zealand would be played each year (non World Cup years) over five weeks, starting a fortnight after the grand final. The annual leave entitlements of the players would prohibit the competition running longer than five weeks (mid-November), therefore, the winner of the Five Nations would be determined by the ladder and not a final. 'Because of the club's success we've gone deep into the year, and that has been compounded by representative player selection,' Panthers rugby league chief executive Matt Cameron said. 'Although we're really proud of this success, it does put pressure on the preseason time frame and any future model that would help alleviate these pressures would certainly be a benefit to all clubs.'
