
Activists protest Hindi is made compulsory for Classes 1-5
MUMBAI: Several organisations working in the education sector came together at Dadar on Sunday opposing the Maharashtra government's decision to implement Hindi as the compulsory third language for Class 1 to 5. The participants unanimously demanded the state to withdraw this and issue a government resolution declaring Hindi would not be compulsory in the upcoming academic year.
Last month, the state government made Hindi compulsory for Classes 1 to 5. Many educationists, scholars, and political leaders on Sunday voiced their concerns about what they described as 'an imposition of Hindi and a threat to Marathi language and identity.' They warned of demonstrations outside the six divisional commissioner offices and the education commissioner's office in Pune.
Prakash Parab, language expert and founding member of the Marathi Abhyas Kendra, which organised the meeting, called it a 'double betrayal to Marathi speakers' for the state to portray Hindi as optional while also pushing it. 'Making students learn a third language from Class 1 without valid justification and choosing Hindi for political convenience is an act of disloyalty to Maharashtra.'
Experts find that this three-language formula in these Classes, regardless of whether it's supported by the National Education Policy 2020, goes against the developmental needs of young children. Ramesh Panse, early education specialist and member of the government's steering committee, said, 'People often say children can learn three or four languages at a young age. It's true, but only if those languages are present in their surroundings. Otherwise, it becomes forced learning with little real benefit.'
Criticising the policy's practical implications, education researcher Girish Samant pointed out what this would mean for the teachers. 'One teacher already handles Marathi, English, and other subjects in most primary schools. Now they'll be expected to teach a third language too,' he said.
Many politicians too were present at the meeting, opposing Hindi compulsion for primary classes. Former industries and language minister Subhash Desai of the Shiv Sena (UBT) questioned the current administration's failure to implement earlier laws. Ajit Abhyankar of the Communist Party of India (Marxist) warned of stronger protests if the government doesn't reverse its decision.
Prabhakar Narkar of Janata Dal (Secular) spoke of regional tensions, especially in Konkan. 'Non-Marathi-speaking people have bought land there in large numbers. In such areas, forcing Hindi only deepens the challenges for Marathi-speaking residents.'
The organisation issued a statement with a series of action points, like forming a coordination committee with educationists, activists, and political representatives to steer the Marathi language movement. The group also reiterated its long-standing demand to implement compulsory Marathi teaching in all schools without delay.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Time of India
2 hours ago
- Time of India
Official work in Hindi, says Haryana education min — ‘I myself do not know English'
Gurgaon: Haryana education minister Mahipal Dhanda has directed his department to conduct all official work in Hindi. "I myself do not know English, and 90% of the people in our state are far from (understanding) English. Therefore, so that people can understand official work, I have ordered all work in the education department to be done in Hindi," the minister said at a press conference in Kurukshetra on Thursday. The announcement was made days after the directorate of higher education issued an order on June 10, saying all official correspondence "must henceforth be presented in Hindi". It also specified that any communication to the education minister and the additional chief secretary (education) should be in Hindi as well. Until now, the state education department had the option to use both Hindi and English. Calling Hindi the "rastrabhasha (national language)", Dhanda said that this policy is not "anti-English". "We are not enemies of English... We are not in favour of stopping English. Knowledge of other languages is also necessary. English-medium schools are still being opened in the state. For me, language is mainly to acquire knowledge, rather than becoming a barrier in practical work," the minister said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Buy Brass Idols - Handmade Brass Statues for Home & Gifting Luxeartisanship Buy Now Undo The Indian Constitution does not name any "national language", and both Hindi and English are recognised as "official languages". Dhanda on Wednesday pointed out that the policy is only for official communication and it is not related to academics. "What's the problem in this (policy)? It's a mode of communication, do it in any language... Hindi is better understood by people," a senior education department official in Panchkula said. Dushyant Thakran, a school teacher in Gurgaon, questioned if the policy would make any difference. "Schools are already focused on teaching children English," he said. Before this, controversy has erupted on the implementation of central govt's NEP, which pushes for a "three-language formula". Tamil Nadu govt has accused the Centre of trying to impose Hindi on the state, though the BJP govt has denied the charge as an unnecessary controversy. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .


Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
BJP seek LG's intervention as mandatory Urdu test for revenue official recruitment sparks outrage in Jammu
File photo: J&K LG Manoj Sinha (PTI) JAMMU: The mandatory requirement of knowledge of Urdu for recruitment as naib tehsildars (revenue officials) in Jammu and Kashmir has triggered uproar in the Jammu division, with J&K BJP brass meeting LG Manoj Sinha on Thursday to press for scrapping the move. The J&K Services Selection Board (JKSSB) issued a notification on June 9 for the recruitment of 75 naib tehsildars, with Urdu language test designated compulsory to qualify for the post. The notification has youths and organisations up in arms in the Jammu region, where students mostly study Hindi or Punjabi. Students and BJP-affiliated organisations have held protests decrying the move and accusing the Omar Abdullah government of depriving Jammu's youths of employment opportunities. J&K BJP president Sat Sharma and leader of opposition in the assembly Sunil Sharma on Thursday called on the LG and sought his intervention. Pointing out that the UT had five official languages — Hindi, English, Kashmiri, Dogri and Urdu — they said making the knowledge of one of these languages mandatory violated the constitutional principles of equal opportunity and administrative impartiality. The move created an unfair barrier as it was disadvantageous to aspirants from the Jammu division, they stressed. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Walgreens Hides This Cheap 87¢ Generic Viagra from Seniors – Here's Why fridayplans Learn More Undo BJP MLA Vikram Randhawa described the eligibility criterion as a 'conspiracy to block Jammu youth from securing govt jobs'. Former deputy CM Kavinder Gupta of the BJP demanded an immediate review of the decision and called for ensuring a level playing field to all candidates, irrespective of their regional and linguistic backgrounds. Bharatiya Janata Yuva Morcha (BJYM) activists held a massive protest in Jammu against what they termed a discriminatory and biased provision. ABVP, too, organised protests at all district headquarters in Jammu. Lashing out at the Omar govt, head of J&K chapter of BJYM, Arun Prabhat, said: 'The imposition of Urdu is a deliberate attempt to exclude deserving candidates from Jammu. Such regional discrimination will not be tolerated and we demand an immediate rollback.' A controversy over the issue in the past had prompted the J&K administration to decide in Nov 2022 that Urdu would not be mandatory for the naib tehsildar recruitment test, whenever these are held. Since then, JKSSB had not advertised any vacancies for the post or initiated the recruitment process. However, J&K Urdu Coordination Committee, Kashmir wing, had at that time expressed disappointment over the decision.


Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
Satyajit Patankar reminds Shambhuraj Desai of ‘betrayal' with Sena
Kolhapur: Satyajit Patankar, a recent defector from NCP (SP) to the BJP , has publicly accused Shiv Sena leader and minister Shambhuraj Desai of "betrayal". Patankar claims that the Bharatiya Janta Party (BJP) will help him restore "cultured politics" to the Patan assembly segment, a thinly veiled jab at Desai, whose father, Balasaheb, was once challenged by Patankar's father, Vikramsinh, about four decades ago. A visibly angered Desai retorted that the rivalry began when Vikramsinh Patankar rebelled against his father. Desai's supporters further circulated messages highlighting that Patankar was welcomed by a junior BJP leader, unlike Desai's own welcome to Shiv Sena by its late supremo Balasaheb Thackeray. After returning to Patan, the newly-joined BJP leader Patankar was asked about the comparison. "How did you treat the party whose top leader welcomed you to join. How did you leave the party? After that, how did you reach Guwahati via Surat? What was the reason to betray a party that welcomed you?" he retorted. The statement by Patankar is bound to continue to fuel the feud between the two key Mahayuti allies — which are the BJP and Shiv Sena. Desai has said that he will meet chief minister Devendra Fadnavis and his party leader, deputy chief minister Eknath Shinde, and speak his mind about letting Patankar join the BJP. Shambhuraj Desai was among the first batch of the MLAs who had joined the Eknath Shinde-led rebellion, which led to the downfall of the Mahavikas Aghadi govt in the year 2022. Follow more information on Air India plane crash in Ahmedabad here . Get real-time live updates on rescue operations and check full list of passengers onboard AI 171 .