logo
Fringe Festival critic gets his comeuppance in entertaining 'Bring the House Down'

Fringe Festival critic gets his comeuppance in entertaining 'Bring the House Down'

Yahoo7 hours ago
Any profession can corrupt its practitioners — and arts critics are no exception. Are they enlightened standard-setters dragging us back from a cultural abyss — or deformed exiles from the arts who, with sharpened pens and bent backs, are ready to pounce on plot-holes and devour careers at a moment's notice?
If Charlotte Runcie's debut novel, "Bring the House Down," is anything to go by, it's a bit of both. The book centers around four heady weeks at the Edinburgh Fringe Festival, which begins the unraveling of two newspaper critics who have traveled up from London to cover the sprawling performance art event. Runcie, a former arts columnist for the Daily Telegraph, has created something so delightfully snackable that you may, as I did, gulp it down in two or three sittings.
Runcie's anti-hero is theater critic Alex Lyons. Alex gives everything he reviews either one star or five, and the latter are vanishingly rare. He bemoans a world of 'online shopping reviews,' where 'five stars has come to mean the baseline, rather than outstanding,' and so insists on panning almost everything he sees. What's bad for artists is good for him: His reviews become desperately sought-after career makers or breakers. 'The paper didn't allow Alex to award zero stars. Otherwise, he'd do it all the time.'
We learn about Alex's story through our narrator Sophie Ridgen, his colleague who, despite being in her mid-30s like Alex, is on a very different track. Alex rose quickly through the newspaper's ranks, and his reviews are featured on the front page almost daily. Sophie continues to toil as a junior culture writer, picking up whatever scraps nobody else wants. Sophie is also a new mom, overworking to compensate for time lost to maternity leave. She feels uncomfortable in her post-pregnancy body, exhausted and frustrated with her husband. Alex, on the other hand, finds it 'embarrassingly easy' to get laid.
But Alex's glory days are numbered. Early on at the Fringe, he sees a one-woman show that, unsurprisingly, he hates. He writes a review as devastating as it is personal (calling the star a 'dull, hectoring frump,' her voice a 'high-pitched whine'). All of this would be business as usual for Alex except for one problem: After quickly filing his review of the show, he bumps into Hayley Sinclair, its creator and star, in a bar. He takes her home and sleeps with her. He knew the one star was waiting for her; she did not.
When she finds out, there is hell to pay. Hayley transforms her nightly show into the 'Alex Lyons Experience,' collecting testimony from his ex-girlfriends and lovers, or even those who have simply received bad reviews from him. Over the following weeks her show swells into a Greek chorus of one man's wrongs. The whole nation, including members of Parliament, have hot takes (the performance is livestreamed). It doesn't help his case that Alex is a bit of a nepo baby, as his mother Judith is an actor whose name would be recognized in most British households.
Sophie, living with Alex in the company-rented flat, has a front row seat to his public unraveling. She watches the livestreams with guilty awe, stalks Alex and Hayley compulsively online, and feverishly scans social media for the latest gossip (Runcie is great at writing a fake mean Tweet/X dispatch). She starts missing calls with her husband and their toddler son, as she becomes fully obsessed with the drama unfolding in Edinburgh.
As she continues to inhabit the same flat as her colleague, Sophie is increasingly questioned by others as to whose side she's on, Alex or Hayley's. For much of the book, she seems unable to make up her mind. She refuses to give up on Alex, and increasingly becomes his only source of companionship, which she can't help but find flattering. But she also finds herself sympathetic to and magnetized by Hayley, whose popularity is blossoming on the Fringe circuit and beyond.
Read more: 10 books to read in July
While Alex and Hayley both appear to possess other-worldly levels of charisma, one flaw with Runcie's novel is that this is something we are repeatedly told, rather than shown. Alex spends most of the book being condescending to Sophie, and yet she is transfixed by him. 'He had the strange ability to make you feel as if you were the only person who was in on a joke, the only person who understood some fundamental truth about the world that escaped other people.' This feels unsatisfyingly generic, like something you might find in an online wedding vows template.
We are at least given more backstory and a more plausible explanation for Sophie's fascination with Alex: the ego trip. Having been dragged down by motherhood, a rocky marriage, and grief over the death of her own mother, Sophie enjoys Alex's increasing dependence on her, a lone rock of support amid an ocean of alienation. There is something undeniably delicious in watching someone you revere fall to their knees, and Sophie begins to see in Alex 'a tiny flickering of fear, at first only visible as a barely perceptible interruption to his arrogance, like a power cut that dims the lights for just a hundredth of a second.'
Read more: In defense of criticism: A theater critic asks what good does it do in an upside-down world
Hayley, unfortunately, never quite comes to life in the same way. And it remains unclear why her show, which is essentially a litany of (legitimate) complaints about a real-life terrible man with some added pyrotechnics, takes Edinburgh and the entire country by such storm. 'I find I can't explain why it had the effect that it did,' Sophie tells us. 'This wasn't theater, not really; it was a happening. The audience weren't spectators anymore, but a silent, connected web of righteous energy.' Without more to go on, we have no choice but to take her word for it.
The result feels like a missed opportunity to interrogate some important questions. How much does the identity (gender, race, or class) of the critic matter when it comes to their ability to judge art? What about the identity of the artist themselves? In other words, who shall criticize the critics? Readers may leave Runcie's novel feeling that some of these questions go unanswered, but this deeply entertaining novel is nonetheless well worth the price of admission.
Mills is a writer and human rights researcher who has worked for Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, the Wall Street Journal and Associated Press. She lives in New York.
Get the latest book news, events and more in your inbox every Saturday.
This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Wimbledon 2025: See Photos Of Biggest Celebrities Attending Matches
Wimbledon 2025: See Photos Of Biggest Celebrities Attending Matches

Forbes

time31 minutes ago

  • Forbes

Wimbledon 2025: See Photos Of Biggest Celebrities Attending Matches

LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 01: Cate Blanchett attends day two of the Wimbledon Tennis Championships at ... More the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 01, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Wimbledon, one of the biggest annual events in professional tennis, also attracts big-name celebrities — and there has been no shortage of major stars at the 2025 tournament. Wimbledon 2025 kicked off on June 30 in the Wimbledon neighborhood of Merton southwest of London, and wraps up on Sunday, July 30. One of the biggest headlines out of the prestigious tournament is that by July 4, a record eight Top 10-seeded players in the men's and women's competition were eliminated. Read on for a look at some of the stars in the stands watching history happen during the first week of play at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships, which are played annually at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club. LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 30: Sir David Beckham attends day one of the Wimbledon Tennis Championships ... More at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on June 30, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Soccer legend David Beckham attended Wimbledon Day 1 on June 30. LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 30: Jessica Alba and Honor Warren attend day one of the Wimbledon Tennis ... More Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on June 30, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Actor and business executive Jessica Alba and her daughter, Honor Warren, attended Wimbledon Day 1 on June 30. LONDON, ENGLAND - JUNE 30: Eddie Redmayne arrives in the Royal Box prior to the Gentlemen's Singles ... More first round match between Fabio Fognini of Italy and Carlos Alcaraz of Spain on day one of The Championships Wimbledon 2025 at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on June 30, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by) Oscar winner Eddie Redmayne and his wife, publicist Hannah Bagshawe, attended Wimbledon Day 1 on June 30. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 04: Rainn Wilson and Holiday Reinhorn attend day five of the Wimbledon Tennis ... More Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 04, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) The Office star Rainn Wilson and his wife, writer Holiday Reinhorn, attended Day 1 of Wimbledon on June 30. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 01: Britney Theriot and Russell Crowe attend day two of the Wimbledon Tennis ... More Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 01, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Oscar-winning actor Russell Crowe and his fiancée, Britney Theriot, attended Wimbledon Day 2 on July 1. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 01: Actresses Rebel Wilson and Cate Blanchett are seen in the Royal Box prior ... More to Ladies' Singles first round match between Barbora Krejcikova of Czechia and Alexandra Eala of Philippines on day two of The Championships Wimbledon 2025 at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 01, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by) Pitch Perfect star Rebel Wilson sat next to Oscar winner Cate Blanchett at Wimbledon Day 2 on July 1. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 02: Priyanka Chopra Jonas and Nick Jonas attend day three of the Wimbledon ... More Tennis Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 02, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Heads of State star Prinyanka Chopra Jonas and her husband, singer-actor Nick Jonas, attended Day 3 of Wimbledon on July 2. LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM - July 02: Actor John Cena and wife Shay Shariatzadeh, David Grohl and wife ... More Jordan watch tennis from the Royal Box during the second day of the 2025 Wimbledon Championships at The All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club in Wimbledon on July 02, 2025, in London, England (Photo by Ray Tang/Anadolu via Getty Images) WWE legend and Heads of State star John Cena and wife, Shay Shariatzadeh, sat next to Foo Fighters frontman Dave Grohl and his wife, Jordyn Blum, at Day 3 of Wimbledon on July 2. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 02: Louis Partridge and Olivia Rodrigo attend day three of the Wimbledon ... More Tennis Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 02, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Pop star Olivia Rodrigo and her boyfriend, Enola Holmes star Louis Partridge, attended Day 3 of Wimbledon on July 2. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 02: Olivia Rodrigo, John Cena, Shay Shariatzadeh and Dave Grohl attend day ... More three of the Wimbledon Tennis Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 02, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Olivia Rodrigo was also seated next to John Cena, Shay Shariatzadeh and Dave Grohl at Wimbledon Day 3. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 04: Professional Boxer Anthony Joshua looks on from the royal box alongside ... More boxing promoter Eddie Hearn ahead of the Gentlemen's third round match between Taylor Fritz of United States and Alejandro Davidovich Fokina of Spain on day five of The Championships Wimbledon 2025 at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 04, 2025 in London, England. (Photo) Two-time Heavyweight Boxing champ Anthony Joshua and boxing promoter Eddie Hearn attended Wimbledon Day 5 on July 4. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 05: Danny Ramirez and Glen Powell attend day six of the Wimbledon Tennis ... More Championships at the All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 05, 2025 in London, England. (Photo by Karwai Tang/WireImage) Captain America: Brave New World star Danny Ramierez and Top Gun: Maverick and Hit Man star Glen Powell attended Wimbledon Day 6 on July 5. LONDON, ENGLAND - JULY 06: Monica Barbaro and Andrew Garfield, wearing Ralph Lauren, attend day ... More seven of the Wimbledon Tennis Championships at the All England Tennis and Croquet Club on July 06, 2025 in London, England. (Photo byfor Ralph Lauren) A Complete Unknown and FUBAR star Monica Barbaro and her boyfriend, Spider-Man: No Way Home star Andrew Garfield attended Wimbledon Day 7 on July 6.

Paul McCartney wishes ‘very happy' 85th birthday to Ringo Starr
Paul McCartney wishes ‘very happy' 85th birthday to Ringo Starr

Yahoo

time36 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Paul McCartney wishes ‘very happy' 85th birthday to Ringo Starr

Sir Paul McCartney has wished a 'very happy' 85th birthday to his 'dear friend' and former Beatles band member, Sir Ringo Starr. Sir Ringo's son, drummer Zak Starkey, and musician Sean Ono Lennon, son of Beatles star John Lennon and artist Yoko Ono, were among others sending birthday messages to the drummer from Liverpool. On Monday Sir Paul, 83, posted a photo of the pair, credited to his late wife, photographer Linda McCartney, and wrote: 'A very happy birthday to my dear friend, Ringo (or should I say, Sir Richard). 'I hope you have a wonderful day full of love. – Paul.' View this post on Instagram A post shared by Paul McCartney (@paulmccartney) Every year on July 7, the Beatles drummer, whose real name is Sir Richard Starkey, hosts an annual 'peace and love' moment to mark his birthday. As a collective moment of global unity, the musician invites people from across the world to pause at 12 noon local time to say, think, or post 'peace and love'. On Monday, The Beatles Story Museum in Liverpool celebrated peace and love with an arts and crafts workshop. Members of the public took photos alongside a sculpture of a hand in a peace sign that was created using an original casting of Sir Ringo's right hand. The Beatles are the best-selling musical act of all time and one of the most influential groups in the world, having achieved 18 UK number one singles.

Giant Leeds Utd mural painted on side of fan's house - and one star loves it
Giant Leeds Utd mural painted on side of fan's house - and one star loves it

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Giant Leeds Utd mural painted on side of fan's house - and one star loves it

A Leeds United fan has gone the extra-mile to show his team his devotion by having a mural painted on the side of his house - and it's caught the attention of one fan favourite. Artist Kieran Bradshaw, 34, wanted to find a deserving fan to offer up their home for a mural to be painted on the side of it, eventually picking Danny Moran of Wesley Croft, who has the self-claimed best view of the stadium. Kieran explained to Danny that the art would be funded by a Leeds United fan group in America - the Colorado and Nashville / Tennessee - and he would not have to pay a penny for the priviledge of the artwork. The only thing he had to do was agree on a design. READ MORE: Man suffers leg wound after gunshots ring out across Leeds - police statement in full READ MORE: I visited the Leeds suburb surrounded by stunning countryside and home to 'best reservoir walk' Danny said: "The design process went a bit back and forth as the company also had to agree what/who was in the mural. Especially as some players are already featured in some in the area. After agreeing on a design everything was set to paint it "I am over the moon with it and on the first match I am taking out the fence posts so fans walking past can take pictures of it or/ and with it. I love how it looks with the stadium in the back." It took Kieran six days to paint the main men and legends of the team, such as Jack Charlton, Billy Bremner and David Batty, alongside more recent Whites heroes Raphinha, Klich, Liam Cooper and Gaetano Berardi. And it hasn't gone unnoticed by the past and present stars of the club. Ex fan favourite Raphael Dias Belloli, aka Raphinha, even reposted the picture and said 'lovely' with a face with hearts for eyes and a fire emoji. Meanwhile, Kieran is just pleased to have done his bit for Leeds history. He said: "I am honoured to have contributed to the history of Leeds united legends, within such close proximity to the legendary stadium. To be able to have Elland Road as a backdrop for the mural within its final imagery gave me such a great sense of fulfilment." Get all the latest and breaking news in Leeds by signing up to our newsletter here.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store