Judge tells therapist who shoplifted due to 'Gaza' that she hopes ‘you give better advice to your clients than to yourself'
The court heard she passed all points of payment at Marks & Spencer in Dundrum Town Centre, Dublin 16, with items worth €223.70. She was charged under Section 4 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act.
Byrne, who represented herself in court, told Judge Anne Watkin she had taken the items in a 'moment of madness' after seeing disturbing images from Gaza.
She said she believed Marks & Spencer was 'funding genocide' and 'supporting the Zionists', and claimed the theft was a reaction to the horrific scenes she had seen.
She said that her kind of explanation might arise from 'overstepping at a protest march', but not from stealing from a shop.
Judge Watkin said it was 'an abuse of people who are suffering' to use their situation as an excuse for stealing groceries and clothing.
When Byrne asked, 'What am I meant to do?', the judge suggested it would be better to avoid shopping there at all if that was how she felt.
Byrne told the court she works as a self-employed therapist.
'Well, I hope you give better advice to your clients than to yourself,' Judge Watkin replied.
When Byrne said her clients were 'all in the same position' as her, the judge disagreed.
'No, they're not,' she said. 'They're not standing here in court being charged with theft.'
Judge Watkin imposed a €500 fine and gave Byrne six months to pay.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sunday World
14 hours ago
- Sunday World
Senior garda charged with rape offences
High-ranking officer suspended from duty after long-running investigation into alleged sexual misconduct sees him appear at sitting of district court Figures show there are currently 94 members of the force suspended from duty A senior garda has been suspended from duty after appearing in court charged with a number of rape offences. He was arrested following a long-running investigation into alleged sexual offences led by specialist detectives. The garda, who has a legal right to anonymity due to the nature of the alleged offences, appeared before a sitting of a district court last month where he was formally charged. The senior garda faces three counts of rape against a female, which allegedly occurred on separate dates in the same year a number of years ago. The injured party in the case was known to him. One of the alleged offences is contrary to Section 4 of the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990. Court records state that the other two charges relate to offences contrary to Section 48 Offences Against the Person Act, 1861 and Section 2 of the Criminal Law (Rape) Act, 1981 as amended by section 21 of the Criminal Law (Rape) (Amendment) Act, 1990. Figures show there are currently 94 members of the force suspended from duty News in 90 Seconds - Sunday, August 3rd He has also been suspended from duty by An Garda Síochána. His first court appearance was last month and he was remanded on bail. The senior officer is expected to appear in court again later this year. The legislation under which he is charged means he will face trial on indictment before the Central Criminal Court, which hears the most serious sexual offences. A Garda spokesperson said last night: 'As part of a Garda investigation into alleged sexual offences, a member of An Garda Síochána in Munster has been arrested and charged. The Garda is suspended.' The most recent figures available show that there are currently 94 members of An Garda Siochána suspended from duty. The figures, as of June 6, shows that these members have been suspended for a combined total of 89,534 days. They were released by Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan following a parliamentary question by Sinn Fein TD Carol Nolan. These suspensions relate to a wide range of issues including theft, disclosure of information and assaults. Over a third of suspensions also relate to sexual assaults, driving while under the influence, and domestic violence. A large number of incidents which have resulted in a member of An Garda Síochána being removed from duty have also occurred while they were off-duty. The Policing and Community Safety Authority heard in May that around 55 gardaí were at that time also on 'non-public facing duties'.
Irish Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Man appears in court after over €2m worth of cannabis stashed in trailer seized
A man has appeared in court charged in connection with the seizure of more than €2 million worth of cannabis which was stashed in a trailer at a port in Co Cork. On Sunday (July 27), Revenue officers seized 93 packets containing 107kg of herbal cannabis at the Port of Cork as a result of risk-profiling. The herbal cannabis, which had an estimated value of €2.1 million, was discovered with the assistance of detector dog Rua, in a trailer, which had originated in Croatia, and had disembarked a vessel arriving from Zeebrugge port in Belgium. A man in his 50s was arrested by Gardaí under Section 2 of the Criminal Justice (Drug Trafficking) Act 1996 and was detained at a Southern Region Garda Station. The man was subsequently charged in connection with the seizure and appeared before a special sitting of Cork District Court on Saturday (August 2). The man appeared before a special sitting of Cork District Court on Saturday (stock image) (Image: Google Maps) This seizures forms part of Revenue's ongoing operations targeting organised crime groups and the importation, sale and supply of illegal drugs. If businesses, or members of the public, have any information regarding smuggling, they can contact Revenue in confidence on Confidential Phone Number 1800 295 295. For the latest news and breaking news visit Get all the big headlines, pictures, analysis, opinion and video on the stories that matter to you. Follow us on Twitter @IrishMirror - the official Irish Mirror Twitter account - real news in real time. We're also on Facebook/irishmirror - your must-see news, features, videos and pictures throughout the day from the Irish Daily Mirror, Irish Sunday Mirror and Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest news from the Irish Mirror direct to your inbox: Sign up here. The Irish Mirror's Crime Writers Michael O'Toole and Paul Healy are writing a new weekly newsletter called Crime Ireland. Click here to sign up and get it delivered to your inbox every week
Irish Independent
a day ago
- Irish Independent
Judge tells therapist who shoplifted due to 'Gaza' that she hopes ‘you give better advice to your clients than to yourself'
Clodagh Byrne (32), of Tullycar Road, Castlederg, Co Tyrone, pleaded guilty at Dún Laoghaire District Court to theft on July 24 last. The court heard she passed all points of payment at Marks & Spencer in Dundrum Town Centre, Dublin 16, with items worth €223.70. She was charged under Section 4 of the Criminal Justice (Theft and Fraud Offences) Act. Byrne, who represented herself in court, told Judge Anne Watkin she had taken the items in a 'moment of madness' after seeing disturbing images from Gaza. She said she believed Marks & Spencer was 'funding genocide' and 'supporting the Zionists', and claimed the theft was a reaction to the horrific scenes she had seen. She said that her kind of explanation might arise from 'overstepping at a protest march', but not from stealing from a shop. Judge Watkin said it was 'an abuse of people who are suffering' to use their situation as an excuse for stealing groceries and clothing. When Byrne asked, 'What am I meant to do?', the judge suggested it would be better to avoid shopping there at all if that was how she felt. Byrne told the court she works as a self-employed therapist. 'Well, I hope you give better advice to your clients than to yourself,' Judge Watkin replied. When Byrne said her clients were 'all in the same position' as her, the judge disagreed. 'No, they're not,' she said. 'They're not standing here in court being charged with theft.' Judge Watkin imposed a €500 fine and gave Byrne six months to pay.
