Boy, three, starved to death by parents ‘had become invisible to authorities'
A review into his family's contact with authorities has found there was a lack of curiosity about how his parents' culture and lifestyle might have impacted on his wellbeing, warning that 'the safeguarding of children being impacted by harmful cultural practice is paramount'.
Naiyahmi (left) and Tai Yasharahyalah outside Coventry Crown Court (Matthew Cooper/PA)
Abiyah's parents, Tai and Naiyahmi Yasharahyalah, aged 42 and 43, were handed lengthy jail terms in December with a judge saying they had both 'played a part in starving' their son when it would have been obvious he needed medical care.
London-born Tai, a medical genetics graduate who also used the first name Tai-Zamarai, and former shop worker Naiyahmi shunned mainstream society and left Abiyah's body buried at their property in Handsworth, Birmingham, when they were evicted in March 2022.
A two-month trial at Coventry Crown Court last year heard the couple had 'invented' a belief system featuring aspects of Igbo culture that Tai, who grew up in both Nigeria and Peckham in south-east London, adapted to form a legal system he called 'slick law'.
The court heard that they lived off the generosity of others, occupying at one point a shipping container and at another a caravan in the Somerset area.
A local child safeguarding practice review, published on Wednesday, noted that Abiyah 'was only ever seen by a small number of professionals during his lifetime, and for a limited time only'.
According to records, he was seen by a health visitor in April 2016 shortly after his birth, and the following month for a check-up.
There was some contact in 2018 with a local authority social worker in London and four visits to a children's centre in Birmingham, but the review said: 'Records of these contacts and interactions are very limited, reinforcing that there was very little insight into (Abiyah's) existence, health or welfare.'
Abiyah's parents' trial heard police visited the Clarence Road property in Handsworth three times, including in February 2018 when Abiyah was alive.
The review stated that with regard to this visit 'no details were recorded' about Abiyah, with his presence 'almost invisible on review of records'.
Elsewhere, the review noted 'no exploration or curiosity' from the health visiting service, run by Birmingham Community Health Care NHS Foundation Trust, about Abiyah's mother's desire for a home birth with no medical intervention.
In March 2020, health visitor records said it had been noted at a safeguarding meeting that Abiyah had not been seen by them since his six-week assessment, with appointments at the one and two-year marks since his birth not attended.
He had also not received any routine immunisations. While a follow-up inquiry was planned, there was no record of why it never happened, although the review stated that the coronavirus lockdown which began that year likely contributed.
The various authorities coming into contact with the child's family showed a 'general lack of knowledge or assessment of the parents' belief systems', leading to an 'insufficient understanding about the impact on his care, the review said.
It added that his parents' behaviour 'often distracted or diverted professional attention' away from his safety and welfare.
The review stated: 'Parental resistance of advice, support or authority ultimately resulted in (Abiyah) becoming invisible and lost from professional view.'
The report included reflections that while social workers had been aware of the family's culture and parents' beliefs and lifestyle, they appeared not to have considered 'with detailed curiosity' the impact on Abiyah's safety and wellbeing, 'such as if indeed his overall needs were being met'.
The review, published by Birmingham Safeguarding Children Partnership, warned that while navigating race, ethnicity, culture and beliefs 'can be challenging' for those working in child safeguarding, there is a need for them to be 'confident to ask questions about different cultures and belief systems without fear of being perceived as discriminatory'.
Report author Kevin Ball added: 'If any family engages in cultural practices which are harmful to children, this must not be overlooked, and the safeguarding of children being impacted by harmful cultural practice is paramount.'
Abiyah's mother opted to take part in the review, stating she had believed she was 'doing the right thing at the time' for her son based on her cultural beliefs but that she now wished she had done more research about diet and healthcare.
She said it was 'hard to accept that my approach did not lead to the best outcomes for my child and that it took the court process to take me out of that bubble'.
Among its recommendations, the review said workforce guidance should be looked at to ensure it 'supports effective assessment and intervention which safeguards those children that become hidden from professional sight and/or when parents choose to live an alternative, or more off-grid lifestyle'.
Annie Hudson, Chair of the Child Safeguarding Practice Review Panel, said the case raised 'very serious questions' about local and national safeguarding systems.
She added: 'The local child safeguarding review published today highlights important learning, including about how Abiyah became invisible and lost from the view and oversight of professionals. It evidences strongly the paramount importance of understanding what life is like for children, and not being distracted or diverted away by parental behaviour when considering children's safety and welfare.
'It is important to respect parents' faith and beliefs. However, as this review highlights, professionals must always be mindful of whether their views about parents, including their faith, race and culture, is inhibiting their capacity to be questioning and act together in a timely way to safeguard and protect children.'
Partnership co-chairs James Thomas and Sue Harrison said: 'Protecting children out of professional sight is a real challenge, given the limits of statutory powers to ensure all children are regularly seen. Our partnership has made this one of our top strategic priorities to ensure that we do everything we possibly can to identify risk to those children who are out of sight.'
Abiyah's parents were arrested on December 9 2022, leading to the discovery of their son's body five days later.
Tai and Naiyahmi Yasharahyalah were sentenced to 24 and a half years and 19 and a half years, respectively, having been found guilty of perverting the course of justice, causing or allowing the death of a child, and child neglect.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Western Telegraph
39 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Diane Abbott advised Jeremy Corbyn against founding new party, event told
Ms Abbott, who served as Mr Corbyn's shadow home secretary when he was Labour leader, said she had spoken to him before its launch, and said it was not a good idea. Speaking at an event at the Edinburgh Book Festival, the current longest-serving female MP said: 'There were people around Jeremy encouraging him to set up a new party, and I told him not to. 'It's very difficult under first-past-the-post system for a new party to absolutely win. If it wasn't first-past-the-post, then you can see how a new party could come through, but I understand why he did it.' Ms Abbott said she thought the party, formed by her long-time friend Independent MP Mr Corbyn (Islington North) alongside Independent MP Zarah Sultana (Coventry South), would outperform people's expectations. It was launched last month, but is still without a formal name. She said she believed it would take advantage of a broader discontent with politics in Britain. Former Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn and then-shadow home secretary Diane Abbott during a visit to Finsbury Park Mosque in 2019 (Victoria Jones/PA She paid tribute to Mr Corbyn and Ms Sultana but said: 'At this point in time, it's difficult to see how a brand new party wins. 'However, I think Jeremy's party is going to do a lot better than people think because a lot of people who are not necessarily terribly left-wing people, are a tiny bit disappointed about the way we've gone in the past year.' The MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington indicated her disappointment with the Labour Government. She had the whip withdrawn for the second time in two years in July, after she expressed a lack of regret about comments to the Observer in 2023 that suggested that Jewish, Irish and Traveller people experience prejudice, but not racism. However, she implied she would not join Mr Corbyn's party. Ms Abbott said: 'It's a tricky state of play. I wouldn't have thought that you'd have a Labour Government and they'd be cutting winter fuel allowance for the elderly and benefits for the disabled.' She was also critical of the Government's proscription of Palestine Action and labelled the decision 'a complete disgrace'. Diane Abbott in 1986 when she was Hackney North and Stoke Newington Labour election candidate (PA) 'What they are seeking to do is proscribe protest as such,' she said. 'I mean, we all saw the pictures of the people in Trafalgar Square – 500 people? Half of them over 60. Come on, these are terrorists? I think this is an attempt to bear down on (protest).' She added her more than 40 years in Labour meant it was too late to leave it. She was elected to Parliament in 1987, and was the only black female MP in the Commons for a decade until Labour's landslide under Tony Blair. In response to a question about whether she thought she would ever be accepted 'at the heart' of the Labour Party, she replied: 'I think I am at the heart of the Labour Party, it's other people who aren't.' Ms Abbott, whose book A Woman Like Me, was the subject of the interview in the Scottish capital by campaigner Talat Yaqoob, also told the audience of her anger at not being called by Commons speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle in the aftermath of racist comments by Conservative Party donor Frank Hester in 2024. She said she had stood during a Prime Minister's Question session more than 40 times to be called to speak, after Sir Keir Starmer, Rishi Sunak and Sir Ed Davey had all spoken about the incident. Mr Hester was reported to have said Ms Abbott made him want to 'hate all black women' and that she 'should be shot'. The remarks brought widespread condemnation, including from Sir Keir, but she told the event her office was used to receiving racist abuse. 'I've been an MP for 38 years, and custom practice in the chamber is if you're being talked about, you get called. It's just a courtesy. I was so shocked that I wasn't called. 'But I heard later from someone who had reason to know, that what happened was that Rishi didn't want me called, because (Hester) was a Tory donor and it would look bad for them, and I'm afraid Keir Starmer didn't want me called because he wanted to milk the issue (for) political advantage, without mentioning me.' She said Sir Keir had approached her after the questions session and asked what he could do to help. 'I said, 'Yes, you can restore the whip'. And as if he hadn't heard, he said, 'Is there anything I can do for you?' It was like he was deaf. And I said, 'Yes, you can restore the whip', and he realised I wasn't going to play that game and he went off.'
Glasgow Times
an hour ago
- Glasgow Times
SNP loses thousands of members as deficit soars to nearly £500,000
The 2024 accounts, published by the Electoral Commission, also show an outstanding £60,000 loan from former chief executive Peter Murrell may be 'written off'. They also show the £100,000 motorhome seized by Police Scotland during its investigation into the SNP's finances is now worth just £41,284. As of June this year, the party's membership had fallen to 56,011 – down from 64,525 the same time last year and less than half of its peak of around 125,000 in 2019. The SNP remains by far the biggest political party in Scotland in terms of membership. Amid falling membership numbers, the party's deficit surged to £455,254 in 2024, compared with a surplus of £661,568 in 2023. Stuart McDonald, SNP national treasurer, said in the accounts: 'It is important to point out that a deficit of this nature is not unusual during a parliamentary election year – for example 2021, 2017 and 2016 all saw similar or greater deficits incurred.' The SNP's membership has more than halved since its peak under the leadership of Nicola Sturgeon, pictured at a party rally in 2014 (Andrew Milligan/PA) But he also admitted 'challenging' membership numbers and staff redundancies have impacted the party's finances. The SNP still owes its former chief executive £60,000 following a loan of £107,620 in 2021, of which the party paid £47,620 back that same year. However, it suggested Mr Murrell, who has appeared in court charged with alleged embezzlement, may never be paid back. It states: 'There is no formal loan agreement in place, no interest is charged on the outstanding balance, and no specific repayment terms have been agreed. 'The former chief executive has not formally requested repayment of the outstanding balance. 'Due to the absence of agreed repayment terms and the lack of recent communication regarding settlement, there is uncertainty as to when, or if, this loan will be repaid to the former chief executive, and whether it may ultimately be waived or written off. 'This uncertainty regarding the future outflow of economic benefits from the party represents a significant judgment made by the party in assessing the nature of the liability and is disclosed to ensure the financial statements provide a true and fair view of the financial position.' The motorhome seized by Police Scotland in 2023, which originally cost around £100,000, has also collapsed in value as it remains impounded by officers. The vehicle is now worth just £41,284, the party estimates. The accounts were independently audited by MMG Chartered Accountants which identified no 'material uncertainties'. Conservative Craig Hoy said the SNP has 'serious questions' to answer (Fraser Bremner/Scottish Daily Mail/PA) Scottish Conservative MSP Craig Hoy said the report raises 'serious questions' for the SNP. He said: 'With a deficit of nearly half a million it is clear the nationalists cannot be trusted to even run their own finances, never mind the ever-growing black hole they are presiding over in Scotland's finances.' He said it is 'remarkable' the SNP still owes money to Mr Murrell, and he called on party bosses to 'come clean' in relation to the campervan. 'It is now worth well over less than half of what they initially paid for it, though they claim they expect it to be released in the future,' he said. 'As even diehard nationalists continue to lose faith in the SNP, it sums up why we must get them out next year and finally move Scotland on from the SNP's independence obsession.' A spokesperson for the SNP said: 'The SNP is the largest political party in Scotland by far and it is very encouraging to see extraordinary levels of donations over the course of last year – the highest since 2017. 'Our success relies on all of our members and supporters who contribute in whatever way they can. 'We are approaching the 2026 election ahead in the polls and ready to take our positive vision of Scotland's future as an independent country to the people.'
Western Telegraph
an hour ago
- Western Telegraph
SNP loses thousands of members as deficit soars to nearly £500,000
The 2024 accounts, published by the Electoral Commission, also show an outstanding £60,000 loan from former chief executive Peter Murrell may be 'written off'. They also show the £100,000 motorhome seized by Police Scotland during its investigation into the SNP's finances is now worth just £41,284. As of June this year, the party's membership had fallen to 56,011 – down from 64,525 the same time last year and less than half of its peak of around 125,000 in 2019. The SNP remains by far the biggest political party in Scotland in terms of membership. Amid falling membership numbers, the party's deficit surged to £455,254 in 2024, compared with a surplus of £661,568 in 2023. Stuart McDonald, SNP national treasurer, said in the accounts: 'It is important to point out that a deficit of this nature is not unusual during a parliamentary election year – for example 2021, 2017 and 2016 all saw similar or greater deficits incurred.' The SNP's membership has more than halved since its peak under the leadership of Nicola Sturgeon, pictured at a party rally in 2014 (Andrew Milligan/PA) But he also admitted 'challenging' membership numbers and staff redundancies have impacted the party's finances. The SNP still owes its former chief executive £60,000 following a loan of £107,620 in 2021, of which the party paid £47,620 back that same year. However, it suggested Mr Murrell, who has appeared in court charged with alleged embezzlement, may never be paid back. It states: 'There is no formal loan agreement in place, no interest is charged on the outstanding balance, and no specific repayment terms have been agreed. 'The former chief executive has not formally requested repayment of the outstanding balance. 'Due to the absence of agreed repayment terms and the lack of recent communication regarding settlement, there is uncertainty as to when, or if, this loan will be repaid to the former chief executive, and whether it may ultimately be waived or written off. 'This uncertainty regarding the future outflow of economic benefits from the party represents a significant judgment made by the party in assessing the nature of the liability and is disclosed to ensure the financial statements provide a true and fair view of the financial position.' The motorhome seized by Police Scotland in 2023, which originally cost around £100,000, has also collapsed in value as it remains impounded by officers. The vehicle is now worth just £41,284, the party estimates. The accounts were independently audited by MMG Chartered Accountants which identified no 'material uncertainties'. Conservative Craig Hoy said the SNP has 'serious questions' to answer (Fraser Bremner/Scottish Daily Mail/PA) Scottish Conservative MSP Craig Hoy said the report raises 'serious questions' for the SNP. He said: 'With a deficit of nearly half a million it is clear the nationalists cannot be trusted to even run their own finances, never mind the ever-growing black hole they are presiding over in Scotland's finances.' He said it is 'remarkable' the SNP still owes money to Mr Murrell, and he called on party bosses to 'come clean' in relation to the campervan. 'It is now worth well over less than half of what they initially paid for it, though they claim they expect it to be released in the future,' he said. 'As even diehard nationalists continue to lose faith in the SNP, it sums up why we must get them out next year and finally move Scotland on from the SNP's independence obsession.' A spokesperson for the SNP said: 'The SNP is the largest political party in Scotland by far and it is very encouraging to see extraordinary levels of donations over the course of last year – the highest since 2017. 'Our success relies on all of our members and supporters who contribute in whatever way they can. 'We are approaching the 2026 election ahead in the polls and ready to take our positive vision of Scotland's future as an independent country to the people.'
