Indiana PTABOA residency bill advances; Lake County member who inspired bill hasn't served since January
Samantha Steele, who is also a Cook County Board of Review commissioner, wasn't reappointed to her seat and left the board in early January, said Lake County Assessor and PTABOA secretary LaTonya Spearman. The Board of Commissioners appointed Warren Reeder, a local real estate agent, she said.
Steele had served on the Lake County PTABOA since 2020, Spearman said. Steele declined to comment on her leaving the PTABOA board.
In her Cook County Board of Review biography, Steele states she is a level three assessor and appraiser with more than 15 years of experience in property valuations.
Meanwhile, Senate Bill 187, which changes PTABOA members' residency, passed out of the House Local Government Committee Tuesday in a 8-0 vote without committee discussion or public testimony. Rep. Julie Olthoff, R-Crown Point, the House sponsor of the bill, said in committee that Lake County would be impacted by the bill because a member, Steele, lived in Illinois and served as an elected official there while serving on the Lake County PTABOA.
Senate Bill 187, authored by State Sen. Dan Dernulc, states the term of anyone serving on a county PTABOA who isn't an Indiana resident will expire July 1. The fiscal body, which is the council in Lake County, would then be required to appoint a new member to finish out the member's term.
The bill maintains Indiana's current PTABOA law that states a member has to be at least 18 years old and be 'knowledgeable in the valuation of property.' The bill also maintains that a majority of the members must have the certification of a level two or level three assessor-appraiser.
'This is an important piece of legislation that directly affects my district,' Dernulc said in a statement when the bill passed out of the Senate Feb. 4.
Dernulc, R-Highland, said he drafted the bill after learning Steele was arrested for allegedly driving under the influence in Chicago late last year.
'Members of an Indiana PTABOA should be Indiana residents to ensure we have equal and fair property tax assessments for those who have chosen to call themselves Hoosiers. I look forward to seeing how this will change how people look at these boards and who serves on them,' Dernulc said.
The bill was amended in the Senate Local Government Committee to include language proposed by State Sen. Greg Taylor, D-Indianapolis, to ensure that the PTABOA member lives in Indiana throughout their four-year term.
Lake County Councilman Ted Bilski, D-Hobart, previously said conceptually the PTABOA bill makes sense, and he supports it. The members of the board should live in the community they are serving, he said.
But Bilski said he hopes the bill doesn't make it more difficult to find PTABOA members because it's not always easy to find level two or level three assessor-appraisers.
'(The bill) makes sense. I have no issues with it. I hope it doesn't impede our ability to fill the board,' Bilski said.
Lake County Council President Christine Cid, D-East Chicago, previously said she told Dernulc she supports the bill. Cid said the county uses a state website to find level two and level three assessors, so it would be easy to find qualified people who live in the county or state that could serve on the PTABOA.
'I believe there are plenty of qualified people here, not just in Lake County but in Indiana, that could serve,' Cid said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Axios
4 hours ago
- Axios
Indiana GOP mum on redistricting after VP visit
Gov. Mike Braun didn't say whether he'd call lawmakers in for a special session to draw new congressional maps after Vice President JD Vance's visit to Indiana yesterday. Why it matters: If Democrat-controlled states retaliate against Texas' redistricting plan, national Republicans will be looking at other GOP-controlled states, like Indiana, to pick up another seat or two. Driving the news: Vance met with Braun, House Speaker Todd Huston and Senate President Pro Tem Rodric Bray for about an hour at the Statehouse. What they're saying: Braun told reporters the meeting was "pretty good" and said, "we listened." Vance did not take questions from reporters when he walked by. The intrigue: Bray and Huston released statements afterward, but neither mentioned redistricting. "We had a meaningful discussion, heard the vice president's perspective on a number of topics, and will continue conversations as we work to advance Indiana and deliver results for Hoosiers," Huston said. "I appreciated the opportunity to hear from the Vice President on a variety of issues, which we will continue to talk through in the days ahead," Bray said. The other side: U.S. Reps. André Carson and Frank Mrvan — Indiana's two Democratic congressmen — joined protestors at the Statehouse to criticize the redistricting effort.
Indianapolis Star
10 hours ago
- Indianapolis Star
Pride flag in Zionsville classroom sparks backlash on social media, legality concerns unclear
A social media post making its way around X and Facebook shows a pride flag hanging inside Zionsville middle school classroom, with the poster calling the display 'PridePaganda.' The account labeled 'HoosierTruth' is run by a conservative radio talk show host Bud Wirey, who said in the post: 'Our children's schools should not have PridePaganda in the classrooms.' Along with the photos, Wirey tagged Indiana Attorney General Todd Rokita, Sen. Todd Young and Lt. Gov. Micah Beckwith. One photo in the post appears to show the classroom of Rachel Beier, an art teacher at Zionsville West Middle School, who has a sign hanging outside her door with rainbow coloring with the words 'safe zone' on it. There is also a second photo in the post that shows a pride flag hanging in a classroom, although it is not clear if that is also Beier's classroom. Beier could not be reached for comment by the time of publication. Wirey told IndyStar via another of his Facebook accounts dubbed "The Shop" that the pictures were sent to him from a parent who wishes to remain anonymous for "fear of repercussions towards their child." He declined a phone interview on the topic. Zionsville Superintendent Rebecca Coffman told IndyStar that the district has a goal to make sure everyone in their community feels welcomed at school. 'For nearly a decade, we have collaborated with families in our community to ensure that the students in our schools are striving to be Strong in Every Way,' Coffman said in an email. 'As part of that district focus, our students created a statement to be reflected in our schools and in our community. In ZCS, everyone belongs.' When asked by IndyStar if the attorney general's office plans to pursue any legal or disciplinary action against the district, school or teacher, a representative said those questions would be better suited for Zionsville's school board and the Indiana Department of Education. A spokesperson at the Indiana Department of Education said it encourages local school districts to deal with these kinds of situations whenever possible. "The Indiana Department of Education (IDOE) maintains statutory authority over teacher licensing and discipline matters, investigates complaints received, and files appropriate proceedings seeking teacher discipline when permitted under Indiana law," said Courtney Crown, deputy director of communications for the department. "While those matters vary in subject matter and content, IDOE seeks to substantiate all complaints it receives and assure state and federal laws are followed." The Zionsville School board had not responded to IndyStar's questions by the time of publication. Rokita's office did point to his "Eyes on Education" portal, which allows anyone to send in posts or materials found in schools or about curriculum that they find "objectionable." The portal is meant to help Hoosiers become aware of what is taught in schools and to inform voters, said Josh DeFonce, the communications director for the attorney general's office. "The Eyes on Education portal is not intended to trigger legal action against local schools and the Attorney General's Office does not evaluate submissions for possible legal violations," DeFonce told IndyStar. However, at the top of the submissions page for the Eyes on Education portal, it says, "The Office of the Attorney General will follow up on materials submitted to the portal that may violate Indiana law using our investigative tools, including public records requests, and publish findings on the portal as well." No Indiana law has explicitly outlawed the hanging of certain flags or other classroom decorations, but laws passed in recent years were meant to have more of a chilling effect on what is taught and said in schools. In Rokita's own 'Parents' Bill of Rights,' which explains various topics of Indiana's education policy, it does not mention anything about hanging pride flags or signs for LGBTQ youth being against Indiana law. This year, the Indiana General Assembly approved SB 289, which prohibits diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives in publicly-funded schools or government entities, opening the door for anyone to sue them if they are found in violation. Other bills, like HB 1608, passed in 2023, require school administrators to tell parents if their child requests a change of their name, title, or pronoun. Many dubbed it the 'don't say gay' bill and caused an uproar among many Hoosier families, who called it an unnecessary bill that could endanger LGBTQ youth. Zionsville's certified employee and central office staff handbook also does not mention any policy prohibiting pride flags or any other flags from being hung up in classrooms. This also isn't the first time Zionsville schools has come under pressure from Rokita's office. Rokita posted on his office's Facebook page a photo that allegedly shows the entryway of a Zionsville classroom that displays a pride flag with the words 'You are welcome here.' The post caption says, 'Is this what Hoosier taxpayers expect in their middle school math class? Parents in Zionsville are tired of the woke propaganda.' There are also multiple comments in that Facebook post claiming they are Zionsville parents or alumni who are praising the school for being a safe place for LGBTQ youth. Other Indiana schools have faced similar flag scandals. In 2021 Pendleton Heights High School students protested a move by their principal who enacted a policy to remove pride flags from classrooms. In April 2025, a parent of a Decatur Township student was facing charges after showing up to school with a firearm and sending threatening messages to a teacher after accusing the teacher of pushing LGBTQ topics onto their child.
Indianapolis Star
14 hours ago
- Indianapolis Star
Indiana's war on 'useless' degrees hurts all students
Indiana's elimination of over 400 university degree programs represent an unprecedented attack on academic freedom. A new state law threatens the existence of an overwhelming number of degrees. Public universities are cutting or consolidating about 20% of the degree options available in Indiana. This troublesome legislation limits access to the types of degrees and majors Hoosiers are able to pursue. Gov. Mike Braun said these changes will help students make wiser decisions about degrees that will lead to better career prospects. Bachelor's degree programs are safe if they produce an average of 15 graduates over a three-year period. The threshold is seven for master's degrees. In Indiana, it now seems like a degree is only as good as its potential to land you a high-paying corporate job. Career-readiness and professional development are undoubtedly important aspects of a college education, but they aren't the only types of growth and learning that matter. Mia Behringer, a rising senior at Indiana University-Bloomington, rejects the notion that the only goal of a college degree is to find a job. "Higher education is more than looking for a way to make money," Behringer said. "You go to school to expand on your lifelong learning." Behringer, who majors in art history and environmental sustainability, wasn't surprised when her art history degree was targeted. But the Ph.D program for art history at IU has been impacted by the legislation, too. Hicks: Indiana's college crisis has nothing to do with woke campuses or high costs 'It would have been nice to be able to have the option to go to higher education in my home state, but that's just kind of disheartening to see that cut off,' Behringer said. 'My plans now are to probably go study in Spain. I'd like to continue and probably do something abroad after kind of seeing the attack on academic freedom in the United States. And we don't really hold importance in sustainability programs or art history programs, and I can feel that.' The cuts make it increasingly difficult for humanities students to pursue higher education in their fields, overlooking academic careers that require these specialized programs. "To equate education with job readiness and making money is misguided," recent IU graduate Lilly Luse said. "The market will always change." Luse graduated this year from IU with degrees in comparative literature and film studies. The comparative literature major is on track to be suspended and merged due to the legislation. Luse hopes to use their degree to become a professor of cinema studies and plans on pursuing higher education to reach that goal. They find that pursuing a less popular degree has its perks, including smaller class sizes, more attention from teachers and increased collaboration with other students. Opinion: Indiana should cap out-of-state student enrollment to solve brain drain The success of a particular degree should not exclusively be defined by how many graduates it produces. Some advanced degrees are meant for academics and professionals within a field of study that might be far more niche than others. 'If we lose critical thinking skills, we're going to fall victim to certain messages,' Luse said. Luse is right. Stifling academic freedom restricts freedom of thought — part of a broader anti-intellectual trend Indiana lawmakers have embraced. 'People are so afraid to have challenging conversations about things like stifling queer life in Indiana (or) like the book bans,' Luse said. "We're going back to these really outdated modes of thinking that certain things are to be feared or not to be talked about." Opinion: Indiana should cap out-of-state student enrollment to solve brain drain Indiana is continuing down a path that diminishes the role and impact of a college education and learning as a whole, putting not just students, but all Hoosiers, at risk. This legislation claims to prepare students for the workforce, and it's clear that academia doesn't make the cut. There is always value in learning something new. Exposure to new perspectives and ideas helps us become well-rounded people. Learning for the sake of learning is important, too.
