Hollywood Drops The Hammer On AI, Midjourney And Stable Diffusion
BURBANK, CALIFORNIA - OCTOBER 16: A sign refers to A.I. as striking SAG-AFTRA members and supporters ... More picket outside Disney Studios on day 95 of their strike against the Hollywood studios on October 16, 2023 in Burbank, California. Contract negotiations between the actors union and the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers (AMPTP) broke down last week in the strike which began July 14. (Photo by)
The simmering tensions between creative industries and artificial intelligence companies erupted into open legal warfare this week, as Disney and Universal filed a landmark copyright lawsuit against AI image generator Midjourney, while Getty Images' high-profile case against Stability AI began in London.
Mickey Mouse et Minnie Mouse présentant la maquette d'Euro Disneyland. (Photo by Yves ... More Forestier/Sygma via Getty Images)
On June 12, Disney and Universal filed a 110-page complaint in Los Angeles federal court, accusing Midjourney of 'systematic, ongoing, and willful' copyright infringement. The studios allege that Midjourney trained its AI on 'countless' copyrighted images, then enabled users to generate unauthorized reproductions of beloved characters like Darth Vader, Shrek, and Homer Simpson with a simple text prompt. The complaint includes side-by-side comparisons of original movie stills and AI-generated images, and language characterizing the image generators as a 'bottomless pit of plagiarism.'
AUSTIN, TX - MARCH 09: David Holz, now CEO of Midjourney, speaks onstage at the Leap Motion & the ... More Disappearing User Interface panel during the 2013 SXSW Music, Film + Interactive Festival at Austin Convention Center on March 9, 2013 in Austin, Texas. (Photo byfor SXSW)
Midjourney, which reportedly generated $300 million in revenue last year and boasts over 20 million users, did not comment on the lawsuit. In a previous interview, founder David Holz has described his popular AI model in ways I'm sure he wishes he could take back. 'It's just a big scrape of the internet,' he said. 'We weren't picky.'
NEW YORK - JUNE 15: Cast of "The Lion King" perform on stage during the 62nd Annual Tony Awards at ... More Radio City Music Hall on June 15, 2008 in New York City. (Photo by Theo Wargo/WireImage) *** Local Caption ***
'Piracy remains piracy, and the fact that it is perpetrated by an AI company does not diminish its infringement,' said Horacio Gutierrez, Disney's chief legal and compliance officer, in a statement. 'Our world-class intellectual property is built on decades of financial investment, creativity, and innovation, investments that are only viable due to the incentives enshrined in copyright law.' Kim Harris, general counsel for NBCUniversal, echoed the sentiment: 'We are initiating this action today to safeguard the hard work of all the artists whose creations entertain and inspire us, as well as to protect the significant investments we make in our content.'
Legal experts say the case will hinge on whether Midjourney's outputs are 'transformative' enough to avoid infringement, and whether scraping content from the internet without consent crosses a legal line. 'The similarity is so strong there,' said Dustin Taylor, an IP attorney at Husch Blackwell. 'If the courts agree, this could set a precedent that fundamentally changes how AI companies train their models.'
Canadian filmmaker James Cameron joined the board of directors for Stability AI, in September, 2024. ... More (Photo by JOEL SAGET / AFP) (Photo by JOEL SAGET/AFP via Getty Images)
While Stable Diffusion's influence has waned, Midjourney remains among the most popular image generators. One of the reasons behind its popularity is that it creates ultra realistic cinematic images that look like they are from big movies. There are dozens of other companies that do this, too, including Runway, Ideogram, Freepik, ChatGPT, Grok, and Leonardo (owned by Canva), to name just a few. These lawsuits will have a chilling effect on their use, creating a new hierarchy in Generative AI, with companies like Google's Veo, which indemnifies its users, as do others like Adobe. Moonvalley's new AI model, Marey, is trained on fully licensed content. Small shops like Invisible Universe and Toonstar train their own models without external data. Runway has a deal with Lions Gate to do their same thing with their IP.
DANA POINT, CALIFORNIA - SEPTEMBER 27: Craig Peters, CEO of Getty Images speaks onstage during Vox ... More Media's 2023 Code Conference at The Ritz-Carlton, Laguna Niguel on September 27, 2023 in Dana Point, California. (Photo byfor Vox Media)
Across the Atlantic, Getty Images' lawsuit against Stability AI began in London's High Court. Getty accuses Stability AI of scraping millions of its copyrighted photos to train Stable Diffusion. Getty CEO Craig Peters told CNBC, 'We're spending millions and millions of dollars in one court case… AI companies are making the argument that paying for access to creative works would 'kill innovation' by raising costs, but taking copyrighted work without permission or compensation is really stealing.'
Stability AI has admitted to using some Getty images for training but claims its practices fall under 'fair use' and that its models do not reproduce original works directly. 'Artists utilizing our tools are creating works that build upon collective human knowledge, which is fundamental to fair use and freedom of expression,' a Stability AI spokesperson said. Getty is bringing a parallel lawsuit against Stability AI in the United States.
NEW YORK, NEW YORK - MAY 29: Bryn Mooser speaks onstage during WSJ's Future of Everything 2025 at ... More The Glasshouse on May 29, 2025 in New York City. (Photo by)
Bryn Mooser, head of new, AI-focused Asteria Studios, partnered with Moonvally to create an AI video generator trained exclusively on licensed content, Marey. 'There's no question to me that the studios are right. AI models must have consent,' he said on the AI/XR Podcast last week. Disney and Universal are seeking up to $150,000 per infringed work, but this is not about the money as much as it is defeating the fair use argument, which will set the legal and ethical boundaries for how AI companies use copyrighted material in the years to come.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Los Angeles Times
36 minutes ago
- Los Angeles Times
‘How to Train Your Dragon' remake soars at the box office as family films dominate
Universal Pictures' 'How To Train Your Dragon' soared over the competition this weekend, as family-friendly films continued their dominance at the box office. The live-action adaptation of the animated franchise from DreamWorks Animation grossed $83.7 million in its opening weekend in the U.S. and Canada, according to studio estimates. It beat out fellow live-action remake 'Lilo & Stitch' from Walt Disney Co., which hauled in $15 million over the weekend for a cumulative total of $366 million so far after 24 days. Expectations were high for Universal film, which revives a profitable franchise for the studio. The original animated movie was released in 2010 and grossed nearly $495 million in global box office revenue. A sequel soon followed in 2014 and brought in more than $621 million worldwide. The most recent film in the trilogy, 'How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World' came out in 2019 and made almost $540 million globally. 'How to Train Your Dragon' comes at an opportune time for family films. After a lackluster first quarter at the box office, theater attendance has been turbocharged, at least in part by the success of kid-friendly movies such as Warner Bros. Pictures 'A Minecraft Movie' and Disney's 'Lilo & Stitch.' Though family audiences were initially slow to return after the pandemic, movies that appeal to those theatergoers have proven to be box office juggernauts. Last summer, Disney and Pixar's 'Inside Out 2' and Universal and Illumination Entertainment's 'Despicable Me 4' drove theater revenues at a time when the industry was collectively wringing its hands after a slow Memorial Day weekend. This summer, 'How to Train Your Dragon' and 'Lilo & Stitch' are demonstrating the power of the hybrid film, which combines live actors with computer-animated creatures — a strategy that has proved valuable, said David A. Gross, who writes movie industry newsletter FranchiseRe. The trend began back in 1988 with Robert Zemeckis' 'Who Framed Roger Rabbit,' but has seen recent success with films like Paramount's 'Sonic the Hedgehog' franchise and StudioCanal's 'Paddington' movies. 'It's just a logical step in computer filmmaking,' Gross said. 'It's a very powerful storytelling tool.'
Fox News
36 minutes ago
- Fox News
American Culture Quiz: Test yourself on famous fathers and starry skies
The American Culture Quiz is a weekly test of our unique national traits, trends, history and people, including current events and the sights and sounds of the United States. This week's quiz highlights famous fathers, starry skies — and more. Can you get all 8 questions right? To try your hand at more quizzes from Fox News Digital, click here. Also, to take our latest News Quiz — published every Friday — click here.
Yahoo
38 minutes ago
- Yahoo
'How to Train Your Dragon' director explains why he was a 'little reluctant' to announce sequel
The live-action remake of How to Train Your Dragon has only just soared into theaters, and a sequel is already underway. In fact, it was announced back in April at CinemaCon 2025, well before the film, which hails from writer-director and alum of the original animated series Dean DeBlois, was even released. The news came as a bit of a surprise to the audience of theater owners and exhibitors — usually, the modus operandi for studios is to wait and at least see how something performs at the box office before asking for more. Which is exactly what DeBlois told Entertainment Weekly when we asked him about it in May, a few weeks before the film's June 13 bow. "I think once [Universal Pictures] saw a pretty finished version of the movie that we tested with an audience, they felt really confident. And so they wanted to let it be known especially at CinemaCon, because there's so many factors that go into planning for a movie, even two years out, getting screens and premium large format screens, and just getting movie theater exhibitors excited," he says, but, "I was a little reluctant." He continues, "I'm like, maybe we should just release the movie first and see if people like it before you go and announce another one? But I understood that that was the audience where you want to get them excited about what's coming." DeBlois and stars Gerard Butler and Nico Parker were on hand to make the announcement, which took place during Universal's studio presentation after the film made its world premiere at the conference earlier that same morning. And according to Parker, DeBlois wasn't the only one hesitant to announce the sequel, which is slated for release on June 11, 2027. "I remember me and Gerry [Butler] being like, this is going to be so embarrassing if everyone hated the film, because we're going to have to go out there and be like, 'What did you think? Aw good. Well, guess what? More where that came from!' And everyone would just be booing," Parker says, laughing at the memory. "We were both kind of terrified that it would just go horribly. But it went well." It went well indeed. Both the announcement and the debut of How to Train Your Dragon received strong applause from the CinemaCon crowd, and the film received positive reviews and even better box office tracking ahead of its release. Based on the 2010 animated film of the same name, which itself was the first of a trilogy, the live-action remake is also set on the fictional isle of Berk. It follows outcast teen Hiccup (Mason Thames), whose inability to kill dragons like the rest of his Viking comrades leads to him accidentally befriending one — a Night Fury named Toothless. Now, DeBlois sets his sights on the sequel, which he's paused efforts on to conduct this interview with EW. "Now it's tackling the story, and that's a weird thing for me, because I wrote the story for How to Train Your Dragon 2 the animated movie, and I'm proud of these movies, and so I have to be really objective and stand back and say, what could be done better?" he says. "So I'm in that process now. Literally, today, when I get off the call with you, I'll go back to my keyboard and start tapping away." DeBlois doesn't want to get specific about the process just yet. Still, he does tease that, like this first live-action film, the sequel will be a faithful recreation of its animated predecessor, something that Universal encouraged from the beginning. "I think they saw great value in playing to the nostalgia of people who grew up with these movies and then also presenting something new and fresh for a whole new audience who might not be familiar with them," DeBlois explains. "So I think by choosing that lane and going down that lane and trying to be additive in every way that we did, in terms of deepening mythology and deepening character relationships and going even more immersive with action, that's where we felt we could bring more without reinventing. And if it goes out into the world and people receive it well, then we'll continue that path of how do we do then movie 2 in a similar way, where we tell a story that people will know and have a nostalgia for, but has surprises, too."Speaking of nostalgia, we know of at least one person who's chomping at the bit for the sequel: admitted Dragon superfan and Hiccup himself. "I'm so thrilled," Thames says, with a giant grin. "Of the animated movies, the second one is probably my favorite — it hits the feels every time. So if we get the chance to do that, I'm looking forward to it." How to Train Your Dragon, which also stars Nick Frost, Gabriel Howell, Julian Dennison, Bronwyn James, Harry Trevaldwyn, and Peter Serafinowicz, is now playing in theaters. Read the original article on Entertainment Weekly
